Saturday, February 18, 2012


Features

200th Anniversary Of Darwin's Birth Won't Be Marked In Kabul Or Tehran

English naturalist Charles Darwin's "On the Origin of Species" was published in 1859.
TEXT SIZE - +
By Farangis Najibullah
For many, 19th-century English naturalist Charles Darwin is the man whose groundbreaking theory of evolution and natural selection changed our understanding of the world.

According to Darwin, all species of life descended over time from a common ancestor through the process of natural selection.

Despite being vehemently contested by religious opponents, Darwin’s theory -- published 150 years ago in his book "On the Origin of Species" -- is largely accepted by the scientific community and taught in schools and universities worldwide.

And events are planned worldwide this week to mark the 200th anniversary of Darwin's birth on February 12.

Not in Afghanistan and Iran, however.

Iran has left Darwin's theory out of textbooks as a teaching that contradicts Islam's version of the creation of mankind.

In Afghanistan, Darwin's ideas are viewed as an extremely sensitive and controversial issue that could lead to condemnations and even violence if it finds its way into school programs. 

'It Has Been Decided'

Mohammad Sabir, a German-educated biologist, is part of a team of experts set up by Afghanistan's Ministry of Education to prepare the national curriculum for Afghan schools. Sabir says it was mostly a political decision to exclude Darwin's theories from Afghanistan's education programs.

It has been decided that...it would be to the Afghan education system's benefit if Darwin’s theories are not taught in schools, [otherwise] it would provide a pretext for opponents to incite against [the education system]."
"Afghanistan is a religious country, and there are other theories about the creation of mankind than Darwin's theory," Sabir says. "It has been decided that under current circumstances it would be to the Afghan education system's benefit if Darwin's theories are not taught in schools, because [otherwise] it would provide a pretext for [political] opponents to incite against [the education system]."

Many Afghans believe their deeply conservative society is not ready to even consider Darwin's concept of humans' evolution from animals.

According to Sabir, Afghan schools teach that mankind was created by God and that there is no such thing as evolution. Any other teaching would be seen as a challenge to religion. 

The Education Ministry fears that the inclusion of Darwin's teachings into the school curriculum would provoke severe condemnation by religious leaders and incite anger and outrage among ordinary people.

And the ministry's apprehension is not baseless.

Some of the country's conservative leaders have shown little tolerance for anything that contradicts their interpretation of Islamic values and Afghan traditions.

'Islam Doesn't Allow It'

Wahid Mozhda, a Kabul-based expert on political and social affairs, says the inclusion of any subject in the national curriculum that could be seen as a challenge to Islamic teachings would likely provoke a strong reaction.

"A supplementary textbook was published here recently, and it had stories where animals were given human names. For instance, a mouse was called Ahmed," Mozhda says. "It caused many reactions. Articles were published in newspapers. It was viewed as an insult to Islamic names.  For instance, they wrote: 'Amin is a name to describe the Prophet's eminence. When you give it to an animal, you are be offending the Prophet’s name, and Islam doesn’t allow it.'"

While Afghanistan's school curriculum largely ignores Darwin's theories, Iranian textbooks briefly mention the English scientist's teachings as among many theories of creation.

According to Shirin Hosseini, a Tehran University student, there are books available in libraries for those who want more extensive material about Darwin and his scientific works. But students must seek those books out on their own.

"Everything I read about Darwin, I read privately," Hosseini says. "In Iran, they mention Darwin. They say he studied the creation of humans.  However, religious teachings put pressure on Darwin's theory, saying Adam was created as the first human being and that mankind originated from Adam. That is how creation is explained here."

Hosseini says that personally, she was curious to know the English naturalist's controversial hypothesis. However, the 20-year-old student says Darwin is not an "everyday issue" for her friends and classmates in Iran and that she has never heard anyone showing any particular interest in Darwin's concept of evolution.

Likewise, Mohammad Sabir in Kabul is convinced that "there is not a dire need at the moment to take worthless risks to include Darwin's theory of evolution into the Afghan curriculum and suffer the consequences."

"We will do it when the time is right," Sabir concludes.
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: reader
February 12, 2009 08:35
I myself don't believe in Darwin's theory. Everyone has right to claim his or her ancestry in Adam, not in some greasy ape from Ethiopia. It is an ultimate human right to be human, not ape.

by: Julie
February 12, 2009 18:41
Although I respect your right to disbelieve anything you choose, we do not come from greasy apes, we are descended from the same ancestors. I usually try to get the facts straight about something before I decide to denounce it, but that's just me.

by: Saba from: USA
February 12, 2009 18:54
Science always proves it's theories. It might take some time but it does. It is science who landed the man on the moon. Not any religon. Religious versions are just believes that's all. And everyone has the right to their own without harming others.

by: Cletus
February 12, 2009 23:55
Teaching evolution to all students is not important. Schools should offer the science courses to the scientifically inclined students, and let the religious students study other things.

by: toosinbeymen from: nyc
February 13, 2009 09:23
And I thought Christian fundamentalists were bonkers. On the other hand, I'm sure that the crazier ones would do the same as in Iran and Afghanistan if they could.

If people want to practice this among themselves, have at it hoss. Just don't tell me what to think, study, wear, eat, do, believe, and so on.

by: michal from: warsaw
February 13, 2009 10:31
willful ignorance is not a human right.

Shake off all the fears of servile prejudices, under which weak minds are serviley crouched. Fix reason firmly in her seat, and call on her tribunal for every fact, every opinion. Question with boldness even the existence of a God, because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason than that of blind faith.
-- Thomas Jefferson

by: DENNIS JUNIOR from: NYS/USA
February 14, 2009 06:55
willful ignorance in some countries of the world....

by: reader
February 14, 2009 14:53
Darwinism has no monopoly on truth

by: reader
February 14, 2009 15:24
By calling someone ignorant only because he\she don't want to trust Darwin's theory is a discrimination. And it has nothing to do with knowledge. I met hundreds of people who were atheist\darwinist and had little idea of biology, history, anthropology. I'm myself a muslim and many people around me noted that I'm more knowledgeful and generally smarter than most of young men and women today (at least in my region). 70 years of darwinism teaching in USSR didn't do anything good to my country, it only made people more ignorant in such important subjects as history and even mathematics. And about "blind faith" let me get it straight. If you want to prove God's existence you just have to look around and think. By calling other people ignorant only because they don't share your point of view is an action of degrading person's knowledge and dignity. Whoever does this is an ignorant one himself.
You know, there was a story when a group philosophers came to imam Abu Hanifa and they asked him to bring proof of God's existence, because they didn't believe in God. Abu Hanifa agreed to do it and arranged a meeting on a river. When group arrived at the arranged point they couldn't find him but later saw him swimming on a river. He was in a some-kind of raft and when they met up one of them asked him "What took you so long?". He answered: "while I was thinking on how to cross the river I saw how two pieces of wood fell down and got tied by a rope (or web), (all this became a one good raft by itself) I used it to cross the river. Then all of them replied: "It can't be!", and he said to them after it: "How can you ask me to bring proof to you when you don't believe in this?". That's what I remember. The meanings are two in this story, 1: no matter what proof or evidence you bring to atheists, they won't believe it, and 2: this story shows that one little raft can't be made all by itself, without external interference, atheists would agree on this, then why do they believe that a whole planet, all living beings and could be made all by itself with all it's diversity?
That's all I want to say.

by: Paul Griffin from: Bishkek
February 18, 2009 10:14
Perhaps if those who propound the theory of evolution were intellectually honest enough to both admit some shortcomings in the various theories of evolution AND to allow that the opposing viewpoints may have merit, then they would be accorded more credibility and find acceptance in the schools in Afghanistan.

Intellectual progress occurs when - among other things - the opposing viewpoints are weighed and discussed and decided upon, instead of merely censoring viewpoints contrary to one's own...

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Tymoshenko: 'I Fear For My Mother's Life'

Latest Comment (3 total)

C. M. Greene: It is inspiring to see a strong woman like Yevhenia Tymoshenko speak out ... More

Russia Sets Weapons Export Record

Latest Comment (10 total)

Dog Bar: Jzack You for got to say That the Taliban beat Russia in the ... More

Israel Alleges Network Of Bomb Plotters

Latest Comment (6 total)

Dog Bar: Isreal is most at fault. For what happened to them by the hands ... More