Monday, February 13, 2012


Features

Disgust And Mistrust In Western Ukraine

A campaign poster for Yulia Tymoshenko on the streets of Lviv. She'll need to carry this Orange stronghold if she has any hope of winning the election, but many say they're not even going to vote.
TEXT SIZE - +
By Gregory Feifer
LVIV -- Oleh Bodnov studies at a high school in Lviv's Soviet-era concrete-slab outskirts. His mother moved to Italy when he was 4, leaving him to live with his grandmother. Now 16 years old, the sensitive, curly mopped student says it's been extremely difficult to cope.

"At first my grandmother told me she'd gone to town just for a few days." He says. "But after a month, I began to realize my mother wasn't coming back. I was hysterical."

This city in western Ukraine feels the most European in the country, but it's largely impoverished. Many of its residents have left to find work abroad.

Marta Horbach
Bodnov says he's come to accept his mother's decision to take up the housekeeping work she said would provide for his future. But soft-spoken 13-year-old Marta Horbach is less accepting. Her mother left to work in the United States when Marta was only 2.

"She tries to stay involved, and she sends presents," Horbach says. "We speak once a week, but we have nothing really to talk about because she doesn’t know what interests me."

Western Ukraine was a stronghold of the Orange Revolution. But those who took to the streets five years ago are deeply disillusioned by their leaders' failure to deliver on their promises of tackling endemic corruption and enacting desperately needed economic reforms.

The Orange Revolution's heroine, Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko, is one of two candidates in this weekend's presidential election. If she stands any chance of winning, she'll have to rally support from people here. But some say they're not even going to the polls this time.

Seat Of National Culture

Some Lviv residents have returned home after losing their jobs abroad in the financial crisis. But remittances from migrants who remain in the West are a lifeline for family members weathering the devastating effects of the economic crisis at home, where prices for basic goods have more than tripled.

In one grade school, teachers of children left behind say they try to act as surrogate parents as best they can. But there's another issue even more important to people here than financial troubles.

In a country split between its largely Russian-speaking east and European-looking west, people here feel they're the keepers of Ukrainian identity.

Anna Ruditskaya
"It's the most important issue in our lives: our language, our national heroes," says school deputy director Anna Ruditskaya. "Ours is the only school in the district to teach children about their national traditions from first grade."

Not long ago, just saying those words would have been dangerous. Until the collapse of communism in 1991, Ukrainians were sent to prison for promoting their native culture.

One teacher says her parents were denied promotions at work after she sang a Ukrainian nationalist song as a young schoolgirl. Such memories will play a key part in the election: Geographic location is the best indicator of which of the two candidates -- Tymoshenko or her rival, pro-Moscow Viktor Yanukovych -- people will support.

Split History

Much of the reason is a difference in history. Unlike Yanukovych's base of eastern Ukraine -- which was a part of Russian Empire since the 18th century -- western Ukraine was ruled largely by Poland and the Austro-Hungarian Empire until the Red Army invaded in 1939. Moscow then spent decades putting down an insurgent army based here.

On a late snowy afternoon in central Lviv, Ukrainian Catholic clergy chant inside a Baroque chapel as mostly elderly worshippers hunch over in prayer. The ornately gilded interior looks decidedly Western, unlike many Orthodox churches in eastern Ukraine.

Lviv's historic city center is badly in need of renovation. But it's a stunning collection of Polish- and Austrian-influenced Renaissance and Baroque architecture. Perhaps nowhere is the division between east and west felt more keenly than here.

The new statue of Stepan Bandera in Lviv
In a large square across town, a new statue bears a striking resemblance to typical Soviet-era figures of Lenin. In fact, it's of a Ukrainian insurgent army leader, and it's highly controversial. Stepan Bandera, who fought against the Soviets before leading a Ukrainian government in exile, was assassinated by the KGB in Munich in 1959.

Last month, outgoing President Viktor Yushchenko stirred controversy by naming Bandera a Hero of Ukraine. Many in eastern Ukraine denounce him for collaborating with the Nazis during World War II. The Simon Wiesenthal Center, a U.S. Jewish human rights group, also criticized Yushchenko, saying Bandera's followers were linked to the deaths of thousands of Jews.

The statue is guarded by a platoon of security service officers in fatigues, their numbers doubled ahead of the election amid rumors of bomb plots.

Broken Promises

Some here say honoring Bandera -- a sensitive issue that required public debate -- was the last of Yushchenko's many mistakes. But people strolling in the statue's square believe the partisan leader's opposition to Soviet rule was vital for preserving Ukrainian culture. Maria Kots says the criticism against Bandera is led by Moscow, which is still seeking to undermine his legacy.

"Yushchenko's decision was historic," she says. "Bandera is our hero."

Yushchenko has rehabilitated other nationalist figures, saying Ukrainians can build their nation only by looking back to their roots. He's focused his presidency on promoting Ukrainian language and history, often antagonizing Moscow. But many here who strongly supported Yushchenko during the Orange Revolution say he's done nothing to improve the lives of ordinary Ukrainians suffering from the economic crisis.

People in Lviv say the president and his former Orange ally Tymoshenko wasted their opportunity for reform by fighting each other instead. Yushchenko's decision on February 4 to back a controversial election-law amendment spearheaded by Yanukovych and opposed by Tymoshenko has further cemented the conviction shared by many that personal rivalries have trumped public welfare in the contest for Ukraine's future.

Disgust And Mistrust

In downtown Lviv, cars slide dangerously over icy streets piled with snow. Despite a record snowfall this year, there's not a single snowplow in sight -- proof, people say, that politicians are absconding with public money. They say some of it is being spent on the black Mercedes and Porsche Cayennes that speed through town bearing government license plates.

As the February 7 election approaches, there's deep cynicism about the country's future. People say they've lost all trust in politicians, especially the two candidates. Tymoshenko and Yanukovych have fought a bitter campaign, hurling insults and accusing each other of preparing to falsify the election. Tymoshenko upped the ante on February 4, calling for a second Orange Revolution if there's evidence Yanukovych rigs the polls.

Like many in Lviv, Bohdan Horetsky says he'll vote for Tymoshenko only because she's the lesser of two evils. Horetsky says she's no less corrupt than stout Yanukovych, who spent time in jail in his youth and lost the presidency five years ago after vote-rigging then sparked the Orange Revolution.

"Tymoshenko makes promises and delivers nothing," Horetsky says. "But how can a former convict head a state? It's clear to anyone Yanukovych is the wrong person."

Others say they're too disgusted by politics to vote.

Myroslav Marynovych
Ukraine Fatigue


Scholar Myroslav Marynovych of Lviv's Ukrainian Catholic University was a Soviet-era dissident who spent years as a political prisoner and later led students to Kyiv to take part in the Orange Revolution. He says there's no real choice in the election.

"This historical moment is very shameful for Ukraine," he says. "Because there's a clear difference between the speed of society's inner development and the slowness of the political elite's development."

Marynovych says people across Ukraine have come to understand their country's problems -- and, crucially, how democracy should work -- while their leaders have fanned antagonisms between eastern and western Ukraine for their own advantage.

Marynovych says ordinary Ukrainians are ready for a dramatic, grassroots change. But real reform would be difficult without outside support. And Western interest in Ukraine, he fears, is dwindling.

"What I'm most afraid of is that the West will say, "We don't understand what's going on there," he says, "and we're not interested in understanding it. Let Russia take care of that country!'"

What Ukraine needs, Marynovych says, is a new Marshall Plan -- to give Ukrainians the opportunity to reform their county, and less reason to leave their children for migrant work in the West.
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: elmer
February 06, 2010 16:08
There is one hugely sad, very striking thing in this article - children left behind while parents seek work outside of the country. In that respect, Ukraine looks exactly like Mexico, which has a hugely corrupt government, a downtrodden population, and many, many children left behind while their parents seek work in the US and in other countries. It has a devastating effect not only on the families, but also on the country. Do Ukrainian oligarchs care? No - they are too busy using and abusing the government for their own personal wealth, complete with offshore accounts and mansions in Switzerland and elsewhere, and Ukraine be damned. Not a good thing.

by: Jonny
February 07, 2010 04:36
It is unquestionable that the suggested new Marshall Plan would not work at all without involvement of Poland, Ukraine's biggest western neighbour, in the project. A similar but financially smaller scaled project was in fact introduced years ago with Poles, not political leaders or social activists who shouted among the Ukrainian public during the Orange Revolution but economical and social professionals who soon later proved the stunning economic stability home during the world financial crisis, staying Ukraine as advisors along with their peers of the other Western countries. Few Ukrainians seem to know the fact and even the Ukrainians who know it tend to attribute its ineffectiveness to its relatively small scale in terms of money. The Ukrainian policymakers did not really accept what those experts from Poland advised, which is rather the real reason why Ukraine’s social and economic reform did not even start. All in all, Ukrainians were and still are, and will for long, suspicious of Poles' motive to help them. They have the centuries-long illusion that Poles were trying to snuff the Ukrainian culture including religion – very sadly. Now most of the Poles, even their hastily energetic part who explicitly supported the Orange Revolution, have apparently got tired of the neighbours' hopelessness. If I were a Pole I would rather build a Great Wall on the river Bug, but luck to Ukraine Poles are not that hasty.

That is exclusively of Ukrainian's own fault in interpretation of history with hatred and wariness that have long been preventing the people from coping with Poles. It is their own social tendency to attribute their faults to either Poles or Russians. I am not going to talk about the Russian aspect here, but at least in the Polish aspect Ukrainians are solely to blame for what has happened to them. After all, a substantial and thorough historical revisionism is needed for Ukrainians, especially all the events since Bohdan Khmelnitsky's rebellion, or the society of Ukraine will remain hopeless for ever. Ukrainians' stubborn attempt to maintain the infallibility of their anti-Polish sentiment comes largely from their misinterpretation of the historical event that began in 1648. The recent fuss over Stepan Bandera is part of all this issue. The issue is this deep and grave and never easy to solve.

The last straw, whether illusionary or not, of a deeply impoverished thus disintegrated nation is always exclusionist ethnocentrism. Outsiders could do something to the status quo of the troubled nation but could not, and should not even try as much as to, change its troubled mentality itself. Consequently, the Ukraine Question will certainly last very long – even longer than decades. The West including Poland, therefore, should not be in a hurry about the neighbour.

by: Daniel D Martin from: Florida ,USA
February 07, 2010 20:25
yes Ukrainebneeds a new Marshall plan led by USA ,France ,UK,Germany ,EU in order to develop its agriculture and new clean energy sources
This plan should be also extended to Armenia ,Georgia and Azerbaijan in order to make them ready to join the European Union soon

by: Ashish from: India
February 08, 2010 06:01
Why should aid from the West be the cure to all ills Ukraine faces? Why can't it be Russian aid? It's inherent to the people from the west to attribute nothing but evil intentions to Russia's actions.

As someone who's not part of either camp, and looking at it from an unbiased platform - it's quite obvious how well the western propaganda machine works.

Giving aid to Armenia, Georgia and Azerbaijan so that they may join the EU (and eventually NATO) is a blatant violation of the agreements set up at the end of the cold war. The euphoria that prevailed at the end of the Cold war is dead. People there no longer trust their governments - they look to the one country in that region which has made the tough decisions and has actually prospered - Russia.

For every fault Russia has committed in the past, it's possible to name one committed by America. It's not a clean game folks - and there's no use wrapping up blatant expansionism with noble words and lofty ideals, it fools only those willing to be fooled.

Ukraine and Russia are the same entity - it is an aberration for them to be two separate countries (I would include Belarus in this too). Vote grubbing politicians (read: leaders of the Orange Revolution) have trumped up the spectre of an "Evil" Russia and continue to do so, to be able to nurture and exploit that fear for their own ends. Let results speak - and 4 years after the Orange Revolution, lets just say there is much to be modest about.

I've always felt Russia lacks an obedient "free" press and a good PR department. The Americans excel at both.

by: rkka from: rkka@arvgk.com
February 09, 2010 00:33
"Some here say honoring Bandera -- a sensitive issue that required public debate -- was the last of Yushchenko's many mistakes. But people strolling in the statue's square believe the partisan leader's opposition to Soviet rule was vital for preserving Ukrainian culture."

In 1941, Bandera came to Ukraine in the train of the Wehrmacht, whose mission was the extermination of "subhuman" Slavs, a category that very much included Ukrainians. That is what Bandera fought for, the extermination of Ukrainians so that Germans could have that land.

The fact that Ukraine is now populated by Ukrainians not Germans was Stalin's doing, far more than Bandera.

by: Wolodymyr from: ASA
February 09, 2010 06:22
All that negative sophisticated talke about Ukrainian election and peoples faults is easy to point out but one must understand how much force and brutality was imposed on Ukrainian people for centuries from thair neigbours especcialy from Moscow rulers. They milked Ukrain dry they led Ukrain to HELL and now they are blocking the way to freedom. To the WEST I can say one thing " FORGE THE STEEL WHILE IT IS HOT" when it cool then it is to late.To the EAST (RUSSIAN PEOPLE) I can say PLEASE HAVE CONTROL OVER YOUR MOSCOW LEADERS. For every one concern please help UKRAINE to be a free and INDEPENDENT NATION. THANK YOU ALL.

by: me from: EU
February 11, 2010 18:52
Ukraine is NOT one country/nation, it is two peoples forced to live together although they hate each other. The best and simplest solution is to divide the area called Ukraine approximately down the river Dniepr. That way both east and west will get what they want and everybody will be happy!

by: pruk from: Keiv
March 05, 2010 01:37
Yanukovych will come and go, others will follow, the name of Bandera will continue to live on. The Bolshevik dogs have tried for decades to irradicate the source of their guilt, they've failed and will continue to fail. Long live the name of Badera!!!!
Slava Ukraini!!!

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Turkey Strikes PKK Targets In Iraq

Latest Comment (2 total)

Anonymous: hey jack-UssR :) Kurdish militants are not "freedom fighters". they are "captivate fighters", ... More

Putin Won't Meet Election Monitors

Latest Comment (5 total)

Vakhtang: Mr. Putin is not up to European observers, his head is crammed with ... More

Jolie Earns Serbian Scorn For War Film

Latest Comment (84 total)

e.t: Oh, stop with the 9/11 rhetoric. Even a child knows that the war ... More