Our Affiliates
 
 
RFE/RL Radio
 
 
 

RFE/RL Iran Coverage Cited Around the World 

RFE/RL's coverage of the post-election crisis in Iran has been cited by a variety of media outlets around the world. More
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Commentary

Nothing Simple About Disbanding Of Iranian Rebel Camp In Iraq

Female militants of the Mujahedin-e Khalq Organization (MKO) at Camp Ashraf in 2006.

December 29, 2008
By Abbas Djavadi

Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki, who has found himself sandwiched between the demands of an influential neighbor, Iran, and the presence of a large occupation force of mostly U.S. soldiers, assured Iranian leaders during a recent visit to Tehran that a "solution acceptable to all parties" was imminent to the contentious issue of an Iranian rebel camp on Iraqi soil.

Camp Ashraf, located north of Baghdad and close to the Iranian border, houses some 3,500 rebels belonging to the Mujahedin-e Khalq Organization (MKO), an Iranian opposition group.

On December 21, an Iraqi government representative traveled to the camp to tell its residents that the camp will be disbanded and that they "may go to any country of their choice."

Iraq "is responsible for their security, and it continues to implement its plans to shut down the camp and to either deport its population to their own country or to a third country," according to a statement issued by Iraqi national security adviser Muwaffaq al-Rubay'i after that visit. "Remaining in Iraq is not an option for them."

Founded in 1965 to fight the shah's regime with terrorist attacks, the MKO soon turned against the Islamic regime of Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini in the 1980s and its members were expelled from Iran after a crackdown. They settled in Iraq, mostly in Camp Ashraf, and were supported and used by former Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein in his 1980-88 war against Iran.

 

That controversial alliance with Hussein made the rebel group extremely unpopular with other Iranian opposition groups. The MKO has been listed by both the United States and the European Union as a terrorist organization.
 
After the overthrow of Hussein in 2003, U.S. forces disarmed the MKO rebels but stopped short of disbanding the camp, putting it instead under military protection. Some analysts have suggested that Washington views the MKO as a source of intelligence and leverage against Iran.

 

When U.S. troops start gradually withdrawing from the country in accordance with a security pact signed between Washington and Baghdad, the protection of Camp Ashraf will be turned over to Iraq. News agencies have reported that the Bulgarian mission charged with guarding the camp will end on March 31. 

 

Tehran has been pressuring the Iraqi government to extradite the rebels, but organizations such as Amnesty International have urged Baghdad against any forcible returns, believing the rebels could face execution or torture.

 

The White House said last week that it has received written assurances from the Iraqi government that "no one will be forcibly transferred to a country where they fear persecution."

Concerned About Consequences

In November, UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon asked the U.S. and Iraqi governments not to extradite the camp's residents to Iran. Dorothy Krimitsas, a spokeswoman for the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), told RFE/RL's Radio Farda last week that ICRC representatives visit the camp regularly.

 

Krimitsas said camp residents are concerned about the possible consequences of the security takeover by Iraq, adding that the United States and Iraq are responsible for the lives of those living in Camp Ashraf. 

Nobody doubts that the decision to disband the camp will be implemented, probably by the end of March.  Some camp residents may voluntarily decide to return to Iran, but most of them are expected to seek political asylum in Western countries.

 

Third countries are hardly likely to grant asylum to more than 3,000 former members of a terrorist organization within the space of three months, however. There have been no reports of any serious efforts to accommodate them temporarily until their asylum requests are processed.

 

Tehran might welcome that failure as a pretext to "welcome" more former fighters back home.

In any event, Tehran would prefer to see the camp closed and its 3,500 rebels stamped as terrorists removed from its immediate neighborhood.

 

Either way, the dispersal of its members across the globe will be a devastating blow to the MKO, which once claimed to be Iran's "best-organized armed opposition" group, but which will now have more marginal leverage.

Abbas Djavadi is associate director of broadcasting for RFE/RL. The views expressed in this commentary are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect those of RFE/RL

 
 
Would you like to post to this forum?
Name *
Location
E-mail
Comment *
Disclaimer
Reader comments in no way reflect the views or opinions of RFE/RL correspondents, contributors, or staff.
Before you post a comment, please read the forum rules
 
 
  Send  
 
 
 
Comments 1-10 (of 12)
by: Meno from: London
January 05, 2009 19:56
Camp Ashraf won't be closed as the Iranian Resistance (MEK/PMOI) has never been involved in Terrorism. According to UN conventions you are allowed to fight a suppressive regime and this regime has been condemned by UN 55 times, for one of the highest violations of HR in the world.
The PMOI is a respectful and honourable organisation that represents the voice of the people of Iran.
Mandela was also named/marked as a terrorist, but all of a sudden when the Iranian people rise up against the fanatical mullahs' regime, they are terrorists..

Any way, Maliki works under Abdel Aziz Al-Hakim, who is the son-in-law of Khamenei the Iranian supreme leader, they are doing what the mullahs want nothing more.. He came into power because the mullahs put him into power with rigged elections.. And now they are focusing to get rid of the PMOI/MEK..

The PMOI/MEK has been in Iraq for more than 20 years and they haven't done anything wrong to the Iraqi people, not only that but they have supported the Iraqi in the area the whole time.

Under the international law of 4th Geneve Convention and Non-Refulement they are not allowed to extradite them nor move them. They all have protected person status.

To put everyhing aside..

After 120.000 executed members of the PMOI and the Iranian people, no one can stand before them any more, because they have nothing to lose. All they want is too replace a dictatoral fundamentalistic regime with a democratic and secular government, so with these words they do represent the people of Iran.

In response to the terror label: After so many won courts, you can imagine that if there were any evidence on them that they did act in Terrorism the court would rule different.

With any accusation the PMOI has the right to defend so they are more than happy to reply.

As a Teacher I believe we need them for a good and peaceful society so respect to all their work.

by: Steve from: London
January 02, 2009 10:53
You all seem so caught up in your pet issue that you didn't even read the article very well. It says the group has been listed as a terorist group by the EU and U.S. The recent news stories about the reprieve they won at Ashraf say the same. Just because that listing is being challenged doesn't really change what is a minor point in the article. They're also the ones who supplied the latest info on the Iranian nuclear program, so I doubt the U.S. is too eager to dump them.

by: Sven from: Stockholm
January 01, 2009 17:50
Answer to Kiumars: You talk about other people "denying facts". But it seems you are yourself denying the fact that the "terrorist" designation of the MKO/PMOI has been declared illegal by European courts five times during the last two years. The courts have found that the PMOI is not concerned in terrorism. Those are facts.

by: Kiumars from: UK
December 31, 2008 22:23
I see that some people here trying to question the terrorist state of the MKO, these guys either are ill informed or are members of MKO denying facts.
Guys take a look at Wikipedia and see the list of terrorist acts that MKO confirmed at the time when they did it! These are what MOK has admitted to, add to that the treason and working with Sadam, et, etc.

I am really amazed that USA did not prosecuted the MKO like other Sadam’s armed forces! After all they were in Sadams armed force.

I also like to see which country dares to give them refuge. I am sure they end up in Israel and Saudi Arabia; who have been financing them so far.

by: Sven from: Stockholm
December 31, 2008 16:22
I agree with Bahman Irani: it is strange that the PMOI terror listning scandal has been ignored by the media for so long. The shameful actions of those responsible for the EU Council of Ministers' decisions should be exposed. If people knew what has happened, I think those persons responsible would never be allowed to work in politics again.

Journalists should jump at the opportunity to report about something like this. It is really strange that no one seems to care. Unfortunately, as long as people don't know what is going on the illegal actions can continue. The fact that all this happens because it is the wish of the Iranian regime makes it even more disgusting.

Christopher Booker seems to be one of very few established journalist who understand what is going on:
"Tehran's wish is law to Brussels"
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/columnists/christopherbooker/3883542/Tehrans-wish-is-law-to-Brussels.html

/ Sven

by: Bahman Irani from: London
December 30, 2008 16:14
Bravo Sven and the author of that article, Elias Rudberg. I hope that RFE/RL will assign someone competent to read those rulings to report factually about this whole bizarre affair. I think RFE/RL owes it to its readers. It is high time that the appeasement of an illegitimate, undemocratic and tyrannical religious fascism in Iran be stopped and all those who are lured by commercial ties tainted with blood, or intimidated by Tehran's terrorist threats, learn to stand up to the mullahs by example of the brave people in Ashraf who have stood up steadfastly to the mullahs against all odds and continue to do so, to the end, as they vow. Let brave souls around the world gain inspiration from them and support them.

by: Sven from: Stockholm
December 30, 2008 13:57
Regarding the "terrorist" designation of the MKO/PMOI, see this article on NewsBlaze:
"The EU Council of Ministers - Criminals or just sadly incompetent?"
http://newsblaze.com/story/20081224161357zzzz.nb/topstory.html

by: Bahman Irani from: London
December 30, 2008 08:32
Of course the despots that rule Iran and plunder its wealth and suppress its students, women, and workers, would love all PMOI members to surrender and live "ordinary" lives of misery under such an evil ideology and regime. But too bad for the mullahs that theese courageous patriots have openly and freely elected to say NO to that duplicitous offer and have chosen to RESIST the rule of tyranny in their country. Jounes' regime, (what a funny name for a mullah supporter), has slaughtered young children, pregnant women, and very recently steadfast PMOI prisoners held in their dungeons. His cruel and hate-filled regime cannot delay the cries of freedom from Iranians for much longer. The regime tries futilely to fool the world by presenting itself as the victim of its oppposition which it has slaughtered mercilessly throughout. But no intelligent person will fall for that. Everyone knows that this regime is on its last legs so forget about offering pardons for Resistance and start thinking about your appearances in front of war crimes tribunals. The Iranian nation will hold you to account in fair trials.

by: jounes from: iran
December 30, 2008 06:12
MKO,PMO,NCRI,NLA..and many othr names it has is a terrorist group which has killed over 16000 innocent people in just 2 or 3 years in Iran . in iran it's been wiped taotally off peoples' memories. but i know that they are the same terrorist group which killed Iranian president prime minister and many MPs not to mention their alliance with former Iraqi wampire Saddam hussein in fighting against their own compatriots. i m so hapy to hear they are about to be expelled from Iraq . bbut i have to remind you of the fact that Iranian govrnment has offered amnesty to those repenting members who wish to come back to Iran and live with their families after many years of being isolated from their families. During last year over 500 members of MKO who managed to escape Ashraf and return to Ian. they are now leading ordinary lives like all other Iranians with no prosecutions or tortures. As a matter of fact only 150 high ranking members of this cult , as Iranian government claims, would be arrested in Iran.

by: Marsh Haddington from: Berlin
December 29, 2008 22:58
I think Mr. Djavadi has closed his eyes to the through, dear Mr. Djavadi, you are gambling on the dead horse, Iranian regime was tried well to demonize their resistance, they were failed, you came late to do this, I am so sorry. All of your info providing in this article only helped Mullahs in Iran!
I suggest you to have a look the 4December judgment of European Court of Justice. It is clearly opposed your article!!
Comments 1-10 (of 12)
TEXT SIZE