Thursday, February 23, 2012


Features

Fear And Loathing: Russian Attitudes Help Fuel Instability In The North Caucasus

Rasul Magomedov's daughter blew herself up in the Moscow subway in March 2010 killing 40 people
TEXT SIZE - +
By Gregory Feifer
BALAKHANI, Russia -- The tiny village of Balakhani clings to a mountainside at the end of a rough dirt road winding high into the Caucasus Mountains in Russia's region of Daghestan. 
 
This was the home of a 28-year-old schoolteacher who came to national attention last year as one of two suicide bombers who killed 40 people in the Moscow subway. Chechen militant leader Doku Umarov claimed credit for ordering the attacks.
 
Inside the modest house where Mariam Sharipova lived with her parents, her father sits on the floor. A devout, bearded teacher who works in the same school, Rasul Magomedov refuses to speculate about why his daughter blew herself up. But he says the Kremlin encourages such actions by using the threat of terrorism to consolidate its power. 

In Focus: Radicalization Splitting Society In Russia's North Caucasus
 
"The Caucasus is where Moscow pours all its blame for everything wrong," he says, "to justify its actions and failures before average working people."
 
Displaying metal shards he says is shrapnel from a military rocket that recently landed near his house, Magomedov says security forces chasing militants in the mountains are killing innocent civilians, victimizing Muslims on "Muslim land." His daughter was a hard worker who had planned to study for a doctorate, he says, but he understands why she would want to take revenge. And he predicts there will be more attacks like hers in the future.
 
This region may lie on the fringes of the country's vast landmass, but the culture of violence here is an important trope in the Russian consciousness. If once seen as a romantic, if dangerous, part of the tsarist empire, however, the Caucasus are now viewed as little more than a seat of terrorism and poverty, and the negative attitudes are seriously dampening hopes for stability.
 
Neither Amusing Nor Romantic
 
The poet Mikhail Lermontov immortalized the mountainous region on the southern edge of Russia's expanding empire in the 1840s. The Muslim clans battling tsarist troops in the North Caucasus may have been seen as ruthless, but the region was lionized as a romantic, beautiful object of Russian manifest destiny. A century later, popular Soviet comedy films depicted the Caucasus as an exotic tourist destination where communism was modernizing an amusingly backward people. But there's little Russians find funny about the Caucasus today.

Download
​​(WATCH: RFE/RL's Gregory Feifer speaks to Rasul Magomedov)
 
Mention the Caucasus today and many Russians say they think of television news images of strewn corpses, smoke and bleeding victims such as those seen by millions of viewers after the subway attacks last year. And it's helping fuel deep suspicion and hatred.
 
This year, protesters in Moscow began rallying under the banner "Stop Feeding the Caucasus," demanding the government stop funding a region many see as hopelessly corrupt.

Among the supporters, Sergei, a Muscovite who wouldn’t give his last name, echoes the views of many who say they also believe too many migrants from the North Caucasus are responsible for growing crime in the capital. "They get together in groups and attack people," he says, "mostly women after dark, for no reason."
 
Spreading Violence
 
Still, such fears haven't convinced most Russians the government should give up rule in the Caucasus, even though the current state of affairs is chiefly the result of the Kremlin's drive to maintain its grip on the region.

Prime Minister Vladimir Putin first came to power in 2000 launching an invasion of breakaway Chechnya, vowing to kill Chechen terrorists wherever they were hiding.

"If we find them in the toilet," Putin said, "we'll exterminate them in their outhouses."

His slang-inflected promise helped make him the country's most popular politician. Putin has since exploited the threat of terrorism to consolidate power by abolishing the election of regional governors in favor of Kremlin appointments and cracking down on civil society and press freedom. 
The village of Balakhani is nestled in the mountains of Daghestan
​​
Chechnya, once bombed into ruins, was rebuilt under its feared, Moscow-appointed leader Ramzan Kadyrov. But violence has since spread to other previously stable neighbors such as Ingushetia and Daghestan, where militant attacks now take place virtually every week. And there are no signs they'll abate any time soon.
 
In Ingushetia, several hours away from Daghestan by car, the popular leader, President Yunus-Bek Yevkurov, is trying to forestall such attacks by prevailing on the security services to reduce the number of house searches and arrests in his region. But he says relations between people from the Caucasus and others are complicated by the hatred incited by public figures elsewhere in Russia who associate entire nationalities with criminality.
 
"Our young people tell me matters have reached a point where 'We avoid other groups of people on the street, not because we're afraid but because they'd pick a fight and we'd be blamed,'" he says. Yevkurov calls on the government to help break down stereotypes by regulating the media and punishing public figures who incite hatred.
 
Ingush President Yunus-Bek Yevkurov
​​But others say the problem lies deeper. Alexander Verkhovsky of Moscow's Sova Center for Information and Analysis says Russians in private speak far more negatively about the Caucasus than in public, and that they're steadily embracing nationalism.

"Nationalists demand there be a common enemy," he says. "And the post-Soviet history of the Caucasus has led to the fact that that common enemy is the North Caucasus."
 
Back in Daghestan's village of Balakhani, Magomedov -- father of suicide bomber Mariam Sharipova -- says his daughter's act should have provided the authorities a huge wake-up call.

"Change your attitude toward us Dagestanis," he says. "Don’t think we're stupid people."
 
But as Putin prepares to return to the presidency for at least another six years, Magomedov is deeply pessimistic about the future. A recent poll showed most Russians believe the authorities should undertake even harsher measures to fight militants in the Caucasus, such as reviving the death penalty and punishing their relatives.

Many in the Caucasus fear that bodes badly for the entire country's stability.
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Camel Anaturk from: Kurdistan
November 07, 2011 13:06
aah,right honorable mr.Feifer,you are quite right,we all know how bad the russkies are ...however `the culture` of violence here dates centuries before the russians tried to colonize the region,just as the west now tries unsuccessfully of course to control the neighboring -stan countries.The local clans have been fighting and mass murdering each other for centuries,but that is all right,its part of their `culture` And the west is doing its best to exploit the situation to its own ego maniacal interests pouring millions of $$$ into the hands of terrorists ,posing as heroes,because they `fight `the russians-they can only kill children and civilians with american taxpayers` money provided by the langley virgins with the help of Feifer type brain washers.Yes,Tovarish Putin is very very bad,worse even than western stooge Mad dog an,who says about the Kurds:`We shall drown them in their own blood`-with the help of Us millitary & more billions of $$$$.Mad dog an however wont be ever cited on this on RFR/RL as a faithful american stooge.American policy today is a standard for double standard self serving ego megalomaniacal hypocrisy the world has never known.Even the nazis and the stalinists were better than today`s langley virgins.
In Response

by: Conservative from: USA
November 07, 2011 13:59
Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) is recognized by the USA as a terrorist organization and the leader of PKK is in Moscow. I understand your love for Russia.
In Response

by: Camel Anaturk from: Kurdistan
November 07, 2011 20:05
Dear conservative sis from the Jew S of A.You have never understood anything ,you dont and you will never ever understand anything in your life.PKK`s chief is in a wild turkey prison and you are talking turkey in your cold turkey state of mind of your stooge territory in the region.So the PKK is recognized as a terrorist by the high and mighty might is right corporate puppets posing as politicians and we all must accept their holier than thou attitude???Well the native indians recognize you as a `nation`of terrorists,mass murderers and two faced double standard hypocrites.Moscow is full of american businessmen,bribing everyone they can to get a good deal and helping themselves to the local talent Natashas.And you dear conservative bro or sis or most probably something in between should do what every real conservative should do-join the democrats.
In Response

by: Vainakh from: CZE
November 09, 2011 12:42
The culture of violence??? You are funny...MARXIST from PKK has a lecture about culture of violence. We call it culture of honor under the law of God. But I am sure that you saw Koran last time during your studies...

by: Anonymous
November 07, 2011 13:21
And so can anyone please explain why the Russians still wish to rule over the North Caucasus? Why dont the Russians just do the right thing and pack-up and leave? Russia doesnt need the North Caucasus, and the North Caucasus doesnt need Russia. Best to part-ways once and for all.
In Response

by: Conservative from: USA
November 07, 2011 13:56
Because Russians do not like the idea that the Caucasus will become one of the pro-Western territories, may be even a NATO member at the Southern border of Mother Russia.

by: Jack from: US
November 07, 2011 13:22
RFE/RL cannot discredit itself more than it already did. Everyone knows RFERL is CIA-operated mouthpiece of US government which justifies Muslim terrorism, also deliberate killing of Christians in Kosovo, organ trafficing by Albanian "freedom fighters". RFE/RL even justified attacks on Danish newspaper which published Mohamed cartoons. No surpise RFE/RL is championing the father of a suicide bomber. US government propaganda at its best, even as thousands of American soldiers being kiiled by Muslim allies of US government
In Response

by: Conservative from: USA
November 07, 2011 13:54
Jack you are a GRU-FSB-Pravda mouthpiece.
In Response

by: Andrew from: Auckland
November 08, 2011 04:49
He also seems to be an Armenian.

Armenian men have always been Russian lapdogs.....

by: Russian barbarian from: Russian Mongol Empire
November 07, 2011 13:39
"""If we find them in the toilet," Putin said, "we'll exterminate them in their outhouses.""
Wrong interpretation RFERL. Russians are criminals so they do not use normal language instead they use prison language. He didn't say exterminate ("unichtozhim") he said "zamochim" which is analogous to F words in English. Surprised? During the war in Georgia the head of the Russian Ministry for Foreign Affairs Sergey Lavrov said to his British counterpart David Miliband "Who the F are you to lecture me?". These are Russian diplomats. What do you expect from simple Russian people if the government supports Russian crime the Russian mafia worldwide?
P.S. God bless the Caucasus. They are doing our job, the one we were suppose to finish 20 years ago.
P.P.S. "I have never seen in any army at any time, including the German Imperial Army of 1912, as severe discipline as exists in the Russian army. The officers, with few exceptions, give the appearance of recently civilized Mongolian bandits.", "Everything they (the Russians) did impressed one with the idea of virility and cruelty." US general during WWII George Patton.
In Response

by: God Almighty Mossad from: Jew S of A
November 07, 2011 20:26
Deeyuh russian barbarian,can ya tell the enlightened RFE/RL audience how gen.Patton lost his life and why???And yes dear free speecher,`russians are criminals` as ya say,ya just had to add `all of them are.Maybe you should ask yer mossads after they bomb Iran to bomb them too on their way back.There is no other way to show the world your humanism and civilization.God bless Israel,pardon,America.
In Response

by: Ghost
November 07, 2011 21:47
Camel "Ivan" Anaturk from Russiastan, why do you Russians hate Jews so much? I am not Jewish anyway but I want to understand it. Can you also explain why "Russia issues stark warning against attack on Iran"?
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/45187774/ns/world_news-mideast_n_africa/#.TrhQ13KwV-8

by: Conservative from: USA
November 07, 2011 13:52
"the popular leader, President Yunus-Bek Yevkurov, is trying to forestall such attacks by prevailing on the security services to reduce the number of house searches and arrests in his region."

Yevkurov is a very "popular" Russian version of CIA GRU-lieutenant-colonel who survived the assassination plot from his "beloved" Ingush people in 2009. He feared his own people so he immediately started to blame "the United States, Britain and Israel of seeking to destabilize the situation in the North Caucasus". Like it was stable for the past 400 years of Russian occupation.
http://en.rian.ru/russia/20090817/155832917.html
"I am miles from believing that Arabs are behind this. There are other, more serious forces there... We understand whose interests these are: the United States, Britain, and Israel too," President Yunus-Bek Yevkurov said in an interview with the Russian News Service (RSN) radio.
"The West will keep seeking to prevent Russia from reviving the former Soviet might," he added."

by: Ingush
November 07, 2011 18:11
It is better for Caucasus peoples to separate from Russia because Russians blame us for everything wrong happening in Russia. If we leave Russia Russians will understand that we are not the ones who steal their money.
In Response

by: wiseman from: USA
November 07, 2011 21:37
Don't you see the truth? Russians do not want to give you any independence. Read it yourself in Russian at the Voice of America:
"The slogan: "Stop feeding the Caucasus!"
“As one of the psychological reversals of nationalism” - says Yakov Krotov – “and anti-corruption rhetoric did not change anything here: Hitler preached against corruption, which the Weimar democracy had. So there is the same way: they do not say, "Let the Caucasus go!" No. They want the Caucasus, they want to simply kill everybody in the Caucasus - that there will be no one to feed. We should not think that these people want someone to give freedom, they want take the Caucasus lives away"
http://www.voanews.com/russian/news/russia/russian-nationals-2011-11-04-133268058.html
In Response

by: Marko from: USA
November 08, 2011 13:08
Not a real balanced article. Overall, violence in the North Cs is down this year, not up. Dagestan is a lagging indicator in some respects, probably because of its complex mix of ethnicities, but the violence there is nowhere close to a level that would be required for Russia to seriously consider "getting out." Back in the 90s and early 2000s the violence was at a far higher level and Russia cracked down hard and has made progress ( albeit uneven at times) since. Iraq and Afghanistan are far more violent than the North Cs , and we in the US have hung on there-- and these aren't places within our sovereign territory.

As far as the moral issue is concerned, these sorts of wars are always pretty ugly (but that applies to insurgents as well as conventional military forces). If the reporter, had gone to Afghanistan and interviewed the families of Taliban suicide bombers, what do you think that he would have heard? This kind of stuff just makes us look hypocritical (RFE is a US-government-affiliated site). Honestly, these days, we need all the friends we can get. Don't think chiding the Russians continuously for stuff that we do ourselves is a great way to go...

by: Sergey from: Chicago, USA
November 13, 2011 00:16
"Rasul Magomedov refuses to speculate about why his daughter blew herself up. But he says the Kremlin encourages such actions by using the threat of terrorism to consolidate its power. "

OK, according to RFE/RL, Islamic terror in Russia, including suicide bombing, is caused mostly by Kremlin.

Then, Mr Feifer, how would you explain the causes of Islamic terror all over the world ? If we take a look at the geography of Islamic terror in the decade since 9/11, it spans the entire globe. Is it all also Kremlin fault ?

Or maybe there is a problem within Islam that causes its most ardent adherents to commit terror acts and atrocities over and over again with remarkable persistence ? Maybe it is certain interpretations of Quran and other Islamic holy texts that motivates Islamic terrorists ? Otherwise, why would Kosovo Albanian Muslim attacks US servicemen in Germany notwithstanding the fact that the US spearheaded the effort and fought the war in Balkans to create independent Muslim Kosovo ? Why would British Muslim citizens blew themselves up in the London Subway (Tube) in 2005 ? Does Britain oppresses its Muslims on British territory ?

Do you want to say that Islamic indiscriminate terror, such as suicide bombing in subway, maybe somewhat justified if it targets countries with unsavory regimes ?

Anyway, this is another example of pointless attempts to divide Islamic terrorists into "good" (or somewhat justified) and "bad". When you commit horrific atrocities, such as suicide bombings, you loose any right to be understood in a sane world. Otherwise we might as well declare an Islamic Khalifate worldwide and forget about such things, as human rights, freedom of religion, press, women rights and so on.

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

'Nearly 50 Killed' In Iraq Attacks

Latest Comment (2 total)

Jack: all terror attackes are perpetrated by Sunnis - sponsored and supported by Saudi ... More

'Uniformed' Afghan Turns Gun On Foreign Troops

Latest Comment (2 total)

Jack: brave NATO has its tail between the legs and is begging Taliban for ... More

Abkhaz Leader Survives Yet Another Assassination Attempt

Latest Comment (2 total)

Bill Webb: I don't often wish that I was young again because I realize how ... More