map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

CNN: RFE/RL is "World Changing Radio"

CNN International reports on RFE/RL's role in Czechoslovakia's Velvet Revolution, and its continuing mission to spread free media More
More Articles

Transmission

How We Used Facebook To Try To Free Azerbaijan's 'Donkey Bloggers' 

Youth activists Emin Milli and Adnan Hajizade behind bars during their trial in October

November 19, 2009

The following is a guest post from Ali S. Novruzov, an Azerbaijani who blogs over at "In Mutatione Fortitudo." He describes how the arrests and convictions of Azerbaijan's "donkey bloggers" have pushed the country's youth activists into finding creative ways to get their message out using new technologies.

Back on July 8, late at night, I received an alarming text message. Emin Milli and Adnan Hajizade, two prominent Azerbaijani bloggers and youth leaders had been assaulted that evening and were still at the police station.

To get the latest updates, I immediately logged in to Facebook. There, at first still in shock, a handful of Azerbaijani youth activists were just beginning to pass on the news and spread the word.

During the four months that Emin and Adnan spent in confinement before and during their trial, their friends turned Facebook into a modern telegraph; their status updates were news dispatches, rather than answers to what-are-you-doing questions.

Chanting "Freedom" outside the court and waiting painstakingly for the first footage to be uploaded to YouTube became equally sacred rituals. And since the assault on the bloggers and their detention, countless text messages, phone calls, Facebook status updates, instant messages, emails, tweets, and blogposts were flying around.

It is not because we live in such a sophisticated high-tech society that we spread and read the news through such innovative ways, but rather it is the lack of media freedom that drives Azerbaijan's youth to turn to more creative forms of news distribution.

After years of pressure and media crackdowns, the avenues of free speech in Azerbaijan have become narrow backstreets. Local television channels completely ignored the detained-bloggers story; a whole staff of a popular youth newspaper resigned en mass, after sponsors blocked the publication of the bloggers' photos.

Opposition media wasn't of much help either -- one of the leading outlets published the worst smear article on Emin and Adnan in the best traditions of Soviet "Pravda."

Having been failed by traditional media, we were compelled to become our own citizen journalists -- for if we weren’t, no one would ever care.

News itself has become the most valuable asset to guard and pass on. Each time Twitter users managed to enter into the courtroom and live-tweet a session, it would not be a show of any particular craftsmanship, but it was a vital response to the judge's decision not to allow any filming or recording of the proceedings.

Emin and Adnan's case is not just another cause, or an attempt by a bunch of people to get their blogger friends out of jail. It is a struggle taking places in the trenches of freedom of expression. It is a manifestation of Repression 2.0, which is increasingly strangling the nascent online community in our country.

The "Free Adnan Hajizade & Emin Milli" website


Now, after the court has sentenced Emin and Adnan to 2 and 1/2 and 2 years respectively, despite the huge internal and international pressure, one question is being frequently asked: How do Azerbaijani youth activists and citizen journalists feel? Are they scared? Will this verdict cause them to be less outspoken and critical in the future?

The results of this trial are as unpredictable as the trial was itself. From what we have witnessed, those youth activists and citizen journalists have become more politically conscious, outspoken, and organized.

They are small in number, but they are all as motivated as Emin Milli, who declared at the court that it was an honor for him to be imprisoned for his ideals.

And Emin’s last tweet before his arrest still has that prophetic quote from a late Azerbaijani president: "Without sacrifices there isn't any freedom. Therefore, today myself and people like me have to be arrested."

-- Ali S. Novruzov


The Rundown - November 19 

November 19, 2009

News & views on RFE/RL's broadcast region

Af/Pak
#
Pasthoon Atif says Afghans want Karzai to be held accountable
# Spencer Ackerman on the logistics of the (potential) surge
# The new Obama strategy will probably come next week
# Afghanistan's Attorney General is rolling out corruption charges
# Hillary Clinton is in Afghanistan
# The "NYT" ed board on the task ahead in Afghanistan

Russia
#
Fyodor Lukyanov on Gorbachev's Wilsonian credentials
# The "WSJ" ed board on the death of Sergei Magnitsky
# The "FT" ed board on Russia in the WTO

Iran
#
Mark Bowden on how the 1979 revolution was hijacked
# Obama set out a new line on Iran's nuke program

U.S. Politics/Foreign Policy
#
Timothy Garton Ash on Obama's Asia trip
# Al Kamen's "In the Loop"
# Embassy Row - the "Washington Times"

Of Interest
# Louise Arbour on Kosovo's continuing divide
# Michael Bociurkiw on Ukrainian swine flu politics
# Kishore Mahbubani on U.S. involvement in the Islamic world


For Russian Opposition, Three’s A Crowd Photogallery

Aleksandr Ryklin is joined by two "extremist demonstrators."

November 18, 2009

Several Russian opposition leaders were detained briefly on November 16 for protesting against the detention of Eduard Limonov, a leader of the Other Russia coalition.

RFE/RL reported on their protest here. But it turns out that their detentions were not a simple matter; in fact, they required a little assistance from a pair of agents provocateurs, RFE/RL's Russian Service reports.

Each of the opposition leaders began his protest standing alone. Under Russian law, that’s not a punishable offense; an individual needs no prior permission to hold a sign in a public place. But when the one-man protest turns into a crowd of three, the police can charge the participants with holding an unsanctioned demonstration.

And that’s exactly what happened as a pair of men in hoods joined opposition leader Boris Nemtsov on his solitary protest. After the police detained Nemtsov for leading the mass action, Vladimir Milov stepped up to take his place -- and again, two hooded men boosted the demonstration’s numbers to three. He was also detained, as were two more opposition leaders who began individual protests only to find themselves leading a crowd.

See a slide show of the four consecutive three-man protests.

-- Margot Buff


The Rundown - November 18 

November 18, 2009

News & views on RFE/RL's broadcast region

Af/Pak
#
Steve Coll on a Taliban-controlled caliphate
# A scrapbook from SWAT
# H.D.S Greenway on Afghans acting like Americans
# Afghanistan's mineral chief took a $30 million bribe
# Michael Innis on media leaks as a part of war
# Pakistan's offensive may influence U.S. strategy in Afghanistan

Iran
#
Neda Sultan's grave site has been desecrated
# Meir Javendafar on Tehran learning from Ankara
# The "WSJ" ed board on hostages held by Iran

Russia
#
Suspects were arrested for the murder of a Russian activist
# Yulia Latynina on Putin's "Vertical of corruption"
# Lilia Svetsova on Medvedev's modernisation push
# Vladimir Putin gives a "big up" to Russian rappers

Obama in China
#
The Newshour on human rights in China
# Peter Beinart thinks China is less likely to listen to the U.S.
# Martin Wolf on what Obama should have said in China

9/11 Terrorist Trials
#
Steve Simon thinks the trial is a great idea
# Jeff Jacoby calls the trial "reckless"
# Andrew Cohen channels the Timothy McVeigh trial

U.S. Politics
#
The Senate is at odds with the White House on foreign aid
# Al Kamen's "In the Loop"
# Embassy Row - the "Washington Times"


Website Claims Missing Iranian Deputy Minister Held In Israel 

November 17, 2009

A conservative Iranian website, "Alef," has claimed that a former deputy defense minister who has been missing for three years was abducted by Israel's secret services with the collaboration of German and British intelligence services and is now being held by Israel.

Ali Reza Asghari
"On the basis of a two-year investigation carried out by relevant bodies, [Ali Reza] Asghari was abducted by foreign intelligence services and is being held in a Zionist prison," "Alef" said.

Asghari, a retired general who served in the Revolutionary Guards, disappeared after arriving in Turkey in early February 2007. Iranian officials suggested that he had been kidnapped by Western intelligence services because of his background. Other sources said that Asghari, who is being referred to by some sources as the father of Hizballah, defected to the West.

The Associated Press reported that Hans Ruehle, a former chief of the planning staff of the German Defense Ministry, wrote in a Swiss newspaper in March that Asghari told the West that Iran was financing North Korean efforts to transform Syria into a nuclear power, leading to an Israeli air strike that targeted a site in Syria in September 2007.

The Israeli website ynetnews.com quoted analyst Ron Ben Yishai as saying that the "Alef" report could be a test to get a response out of Israel or the United States and further investigate where Asghari is being held.

The report adds that another possibility is that the Iranian claim is meant to counter Israeli claims that soldier Ron Arad is being held in Iran.

"Alef" is close to conservative lawmaker Ahmad Tavakoli.


Tehran Detention Center Doctor's Death Arouses Suspicions 

Mehdi Karrubi (center) has led calls for the complaints of the rape of prisoners detained in the demonstrations following the election to be investigated.

November 16, 2009

"Tagheer," the website of reformist cleric Mehdi Karrubi's Etemad Melli party, reported over the weekend that a physician resident at the Kahrizak detention center has committed suicide. "Tagheer" identified the physician as Ramin Purazdjani, but another reformist website, norooznews.ir, gave his name as Ramin Pourandarjani.

"Tagheer" said that 26-year-old Purazdjani committed suicide following the revelation of events at the detention center that is being described by the opposition as "Iran's Guantanamo."

Several people who have been arrested since the June presidential election who were held at Kahrizak have reportedly said that they were tortured and raped. At least two detainees, including the son of a conservative official, Mohsen Ruholamini, are reported to have died as a result of abuse there.

Norooznews.ir, which is close to the reformist Mosharekat party, whose senior members have been jailed in the postelection crackdown, reported that the physician examined Ruholamini two days before his death.

According to the report, Dr. Pourandarjani died on November 10 in his room at a police clinic in Tehran.

"Norooz" said that Pourandarjani was arrested following Ruholamini's death and pressured to announce that he died of meningitis. Following the issuing of the coroner's report that Ruholamini died from repeated blows to the head, he was released on bail.

"Norooz" also reported that Pourandarjani was threatened on a number of occasions by "unknown persons " not to reveal the truth about the involvement of "senior military and judiciary officials" at Kahrizak.

The reports adds that Pourandarjani recounted the events at Kahrizak to a few of his friends and expressed concern for his own safety. Shortly afterward, his sudden death was announced.

Officials have reportedly said that he died from a heart attack. But "Norooz" reported that the authorities did not allow the family to perform an autopsy and that his funeral was held under tight security measures.

The father of the dead physician told RFE/RL's Radio Farda that his son did not suffer from any disease. He said the authorities have yet to notify him of the cause of his son's death.

The "Mowj" website has posted a video of Pourandarjani speaking at his graduation ceremony.

Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, ordered Kahrizak, which is in southern Tehran, to be shut down in late July following growing criticism and anger over reported abuses there.

The authorities have said that those officials who violated the law at Kahrizak will be put on trial.

The spokesman of the Supreme National Security Council committee in charge of investigating the postelection events, Parviz Soruri, was quoted in October as saying that most of the suspects arrested for the abuses at the Kahrizak detention center have been released on bail.

-- Golnaz Esfandiari


Russian Free-Press Advocate Moves To Georgia 

Oleg Panfilov

November 13, 2009

The prominent Russian journalist and free-press advocate Oleg Panfilov has moved to Tbilisi.

"The main reason for my moving to Georgia is the situation in Russia. It's impossible to live in a country where the authorities lie to you, where media lies to you, and people are afraid of them," Panfilov, who previously ran the Moscow-based Center for Journalism in Extreme Situations, told reporters.

Panfilov, a longtime critic of the Russian authorities, said he had been receiving death threats.

He took Georgian citizenship last year.

In Tbilisi, Panfilov will host a program on a new Russian-language television channel called "Kavkaz Kanal." He will also teach journalism at Tbilisi's Ilia Chavchavadze University.

Panfilov also says he hopes to found a journalism school and write a book on the August 2008 Russia-Georgia war.

-- Brian Whitmore


TEXT SIZE - +
About This Blog
Written by RFE/RL editors and correspondents, Transmission serves up news, comment, and the odd silly dictator story. While our primary concern is with foreign policy, Transmission is also a place for the ideas -- some serious, some irreverent -- that bubble up from our bureaus. The name recognizes RFE/RL's role as a surrogate broadcaster to places without free media. You can write us at transmission+rferl.org

Follow Us On Twitter

Transmission is now on Twitter. Meet like-minds and join the conversation at @TransmissionRFE:
~ You can also find our instant news feed at @RFE_RLNEWS.
 

 

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile