Friday, May 25, 2012


Commentary

Georgia Gets A Timely -- And Welcome -- Phone Call

Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili (left) with U.S. President Barack Obama at the Nuclear Security Summit in Washington on April 12
TEXT SIZE - +
By Ghia Nodia
U.S. President Barak Obama's phone call last week to Georgian counterpart Mikheil Saakashvili came with Georgia's pro-Western political regime increasingly isolated in the post-Soviet space. Russia is on the offensive to restore its dominating influence, and the West has insufficient resources or will to curb this trend.

Recent changes in the region are not encouraging for Georgia. After pro-Russian Viktor Yanukovych was elected president of Ukraine, Georgia became "decoupled" from Ukraine as a candidate country for NATO membership. It is now alone in its neighborhood in this respect. A coup in Kyrgyzstan has brought to power a government whose first steps suggest it will be more pro-Russian than its predecessor, and some speculate that it may try to squeeze the U.S. military from its soil.

Kyrgyzstan is much less important for Georgia than Ukraine is, but the symbolism is very negative. The results of two out of the three "color revolutions" that shook the region in 2003-05 now appear to have been reversed. Some radical Georgian opposition leaders immediately vowed to repeat the Bishkek scenario soon in Tbilisi. Coincidentally, they are the very political figures who recently changed their views, withdrawing support for Georgia's NATO aspirations and instead engaging in friendship with Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin.

The Turkish-Armenian rapprochement that could create positive dynamics toward Europeanizing the region is now stalled. So far, the most unpleasant by-product of this effort is the further alienation of Azerbaijan from both Turkey and the United States. This by default strengthens Russia's hand in the region.

Dependable Ally

All this leaves Georgia pretty much the West's only dependable ally in the region. Despite the misfortunes of the recent past, the Georgian leadership sees no alternative to developing as close a partnership with the U.S. and the EU as it can, and there is solid public support for that stance. The major and better organized factions within the opposition -- the Christian-Democratic Movement and the Alliance for Georgia -- also support such a policy. Georgia is frequently criticized for its democracy deficit, but it still looks much better on this account than almost any of its neighbors, and the assumption that Western-style democracy constitutes the only role model for Georgia's political development is never questioned.

Georgia stressed its allegiance to NATO by sending a battalion of 750 Georgian servicemen to Afghanistan on April 7, raising the number of Georgians serving in Afghanistan to 950. Georgia thus became the largest per capita contributor to NATO's Afghan operation. The first thing President Obama did in his talk with his Georgian counterpart was to thank Georgia for this. Georgia has also helped Obama by accepting three former inmates of the notorious Guantanamo prison on its territory.

All this cannot fail to annoy Russia. Many Georgians expect it to step up its efforts to bring about regime change in the only country of its "near abroad" where it has not made any headway in terms of political influence (except of course for consolidating military control over 20 percent of its territory that Russia now considers the independent states of Abkhazia and South Ossetia).

...And Valuable Partner

A controversial fake report aired by Imedi TV that depicted a hypothetical Russian takeover of Georgia in the wake of internal turmoil was almost universally criticized, and with good reason. However, it reflected real fears that exist within Georgian society, and some Georgians would say that recent images from Bishkek have reminded them of the Imedi story. The main way to prevent a repeat of the Bishkek events in Tbilisi is to maintain internal stability by democratic means -- and the internal situation appears fairly stable of late. Western support remains indispensable nonetheless.

By making a much-publicized call to President Saakashvili just before signing the new START arms-control deal with the Russians (obviously the greatest achievement of the "reset" policy so far), Obama sent the message that Georgia continues to be a valuable partner in the region. This runs counter to messages sent by Russian politicians and experts, mostly through informal channels, that the Obama administration does not really care about Georgia, and so the latter should deal with Russia on its own.

A gesture of encouragement from the U.S. was something Georgia badly needed at this juncture. But it was also a smart move on the part of the Obama administration, which cannot afford to abandon the only regime in the region that despite all difficulties, internal or external, continues to pursue the course of integration with the world of western institutions and values, and is popular among its own population for that.

Ghia Nodia is professor of politics at Ilia State University. The views expressed in this commentary are his own, and do not necessarily reflect those of RFE/RL
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: xiongnu
April 13, 2010 14:17
//Georgia stressed its allegiance to NATO by sending a battalion of 750 Georgian servicemen to Afghanistan on April 7, raising the number of Georgians serving in Afghanistan to 950. Georgia thus became the largest per capita contributor to NATO's Afghan operation. //

The Afghans should be happy to know that their sons and daughters are killed with the help of the Georgians, who are doing it to "stress their allegiance" to NATO.

Nice values!


In Response

by: Giorgi from: USA
April 13, 2010 15:36
Dear xiongnu, before you start accusing Georgians of a murder, please check your facts and than make your comments.
Georgian forces are not involved in fighting; we are helping with evacuations, refugees and rebuilding of infrastructure as well as securing the villages that are under threat of been wiped out by the Taliban just because they allow girls to go to school.
So before making any accusations, please educate your self on the topic first..
Thank you
In Response

by: liquid from: Ukraine
April 13, 2010 20:23
Giorgi: You should probably educate yourself first before you go off spouting misinformation. Fact: Georgian troops have been deployed to Helmand Province to engage in combat.

On 12.14.2009, Saakashvili stated Georgian troops deployed to Afghanistan would be involved in fighting.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/georgia/6809222/Why-Georgia-sends-troops-to-Afghanistan.html

And on 4.8.2010, he stated the "deployment in Afghanistan is also aimed at giving Georgian troops much-needed combat experience".

http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=georgia-deploying-750-soldiers-to-afghanistan-2010-04-08

So before YOU start misstating facts about the deployment of Georgian troops to Afghanistan, then you should educate yourself on the actual facts.

Thank You.
In Response

by: Koba from: Washington, DC
April 16, 2010 14:08
TO: liquid from: Ukraine

So what?
Yes, we are fighting alongside the Americans for the just cause of creating a sustainable Afghanistan. So what? We are proud to be on the right side. What side are you on? On the dark side of the Taliban regime? The USA is doing the whole world a favor by turning Afghanistan into a working democracy. Instead of spewing anti-American hatred, be freaking supportive for a change.
In Response

by: Ulysses
April 13, 2010 18:21
And RFERL should feel happy for having such a bright-minded user on its forums :D .
In Response

by: Eugenio from: Vienna
April 13, 2010 22:45
Hey, xiongnu, nice comment, not bad!
At the same time, let's not forget that these very same Georgians will also be getting killed in Afghanistan. And for what? Of course, so that their American friends could take a couple of extra years in order to successfully lose this war.
Cheers, Eugenio
In Response

by: Katy from: London
April 16, 2010 09:44
Chechens might have fought Russians but that also brought their nation close to annihilation. This is precisely what Russians wanted to do in Georgia - to turn the country into another Chechnya, thankfully Russians were not allowed to materialise their sinister designs in Georgia.

You mocking of all Georgians as “drinkers and womanisers” and referring to the Georgian nation with misspelt Russian moniker “groozi” shows that you are nothing more than a bigot who simply has a personal beef with the Georgians in general.

Imbecile.
In Response

by: Koba from: Washington, DC
April 16, 2010 14:00
Yes, 'the Afghans should be happy to know that their sons and daughters are' DEFENDED FROM the bloodthirsty Talibans by the Georgians.

Go back to your cave! And stay there!

by: komrad Borz from: London
April 13, 2010 15:06
Highly ironic that this puffed up little paper tiger can't defend itself against Russian aggression. Georgians are drinkers, womanisers and far from a Warrior nation. 5 million couldn't hold out more than a few days against Russian invasion, yet 1 million Chechens tied Russians down for nearly a decade...
A thousand troops in Afghan could have been used to defend their own country- BECAUSE NOBODY ELSE IS GOING to defend them, let alone 'stress their allegiance' to Georgias well-being. Wake up and smell khachapuri Groozi...!

by: 2kija from: Cardiff
April 13, 2010 15:16
Georgian people's sons and daughters are also dying because of agressive politics of Russian Empire. And those people are innocent and non-agressive towards anyone.

Therefore "Afgan" is quite not right notion. These are terrorist against whom these people fight against. There might be a death becasue of irresponsibility or unreasonable acts but it could not be said about Georgians who are helping keep peace in quite dangerous areas. Youv got anything against peacekeeping?

by: max
April 13, 2010 16:47
xiongnu

It seems to me, you'd rather live (or perhaps see others living) under Taliban than (see others) fight against it with the help of Nato member states whose whose sons and daughters also get killed in this war. Mindset of people like you are the safest heaven for terrorists like Taliban.

by: Karon von Gerhke-Thompson from: Alexandria, VA
April 13, 2010 18:03
Ghia Nadia: Jackson Diehl, Washington Post, disagrees with you. Today's artilce entitled "At Nuclear Summit, Obama Snubbs an Ally." Indeed, Mikheil Saakashvili poses the greatest threat bar none to stability in the Caucasus, North and South. In the entire region, it could be said. I encourage you to try again, however. On one rare day, RFERL may get it right!
http://voices.washingtonpost.com/postpartisan/2010/04/at_nuclear_summit_obama_snubs.html

In Response

by: Andrew from: Tbilisi
April 14, 2010 06:19
Well Karon,

The threat to stability in the entire region comes from Russia, pure and simple.

Russia sponsored ethnic cleansing in Georgia, Azerbaijan, and commits massive crimes against humanity in the north Caucasus.

Russia sponsors separatism in neighboring nations in order to destabalise their governments and destroy their drive for independance, while ruthlessly crushing the people of the north Caucasus who wish to be rid of the Russians permanently, and for good reason.

Unfortunately for "useful idiots" such as yourself, history shows quite clearly why the majority of the peoples of the Caucasus want little to do with Russia.

over 200 years of Russian ethnic cleansing, oppression, and outright genocide are more than enough.

In Response

by: RPH from: USA
April 14, 2010 19:33
Useful idiots? How mature of you. Stay classy.
In Response

by: Andrew from: Tbilis
April 15, 2010 11:00
Well RPH, that is what the Russian intelligence service the KGB used to call those "intellectuals" from the western universities and poilitical parties that viewed the Russian communist empire through rose tinted glasses and believed Russian propaganda.

Not much has changed unfortunately.

If the sock fits.....
In Response

by: Koba from: Washington, DC
April 16, 2010 14:22
What are you talking about? Do you really believe that Saakashvili is the greatest threat to 'stability in the Caucasus?' Do you really believe in this crap or this is some type of a botched joke? In any case, I am sorry for you.

Russia is the number one threat to stability in the world! And you know it!

by: Kate
April 14, 2010 17:17
Karon,

With all nukes and gaspipelines in Putin's pockets along with newly purchased 1/2 bn warship from Sarkozy, Saakashvili is a threat to Caucasus?
You must be kidding, eh?
Have you any idea about Caucasus?

by: Konstantin from: Los Angeles
April 15, 2010 04:15
"Free Europe" tends to look more pro-Russian lately,
Maybe just because networks of Russian propaganda,
A strange mix of hiding shape-shifters, "oborotny-pistolety"
And bluntly throwing into our faces simbols of their "banda":

Is "X.i-on-gnu (I bend shl....s)" say Georgian crimes on civilians?
Georgia is helping Afghan people, gaining experience too under fire!
Is "liquid (Juden-like innuendo)" inforces Xiongnu by meaningless stants?
Georgians will gain experience in global and field conflicts, "pseudo-frier"!

Ulysses encourages in coded messages, like a foreman of hiden "banda".
"Eugenio (Genka-culturized)" cheers Xiongnu, promisses Georgians killed
And Americans loosing in couple years the Afghan War. Great propaganda!
Wasn't it Russia in Afghanistan? Bestially tortured and killed millions at will?

USA saved Afghan people from total genocide! Mislead unwise democracy
In USA, run by race of greedy, that allowed Russian instigators, since Lenin
Staffed USA brain, twisting Socialist-Capitalist ideological mess idiocy,
With British and German Imperial help impersonate its own faulting.

Is "Komrad Borz (Komrad Russian balanda)" name of old enemy,
A lecturer of University that tried deny me Construction Diploma
In 1979 for protesting of USSR tabu non-Russian languages?
Sure, a lying race hate of an inferrior Russian KGB "gnoma"!

Nowbody defends nowbody "russian balanda", but God see!
Your own Russian survival depends on the World Good Will!
Repent! Return all to Georgia and CIS! Russia might not be,
If we bring all Einshteins and Kartvelis! Russia will be Billed!

Provoking Georgia and Caucasus "Russian Balanda" again?
Coward Russia always betray and hipnotize victim before kill,
CIS nations created A-bombs that Russia would use, to gain.
Enveing real Gentlmen? Rape-child of Russian drunk "filler"?

The only terrorists are Russian "oborotens". Unfortunetly USA,
Ideolog-brainwash by Russia and other imperio-provocateurs,
Antoganizing many in Third World, like Pushtun, to Russian joy
And expansion of would be Empire through the Euro-Asia door.

Konstantin.




by: Giorgi from: Tbilisi
April 15, 2010 08:07
I read here that Georgians stood against Russian troops only for several days. I doubt that any of your countries could stand more in same circumstances. Some European Countries even didnt fight against Hitler's Nazi regime until Americans and Brits didnt start to fight them.

As for Georgian troops in Afganistan, I better fight talibs and terrorists, rather than support them and their propaganda. I think that Georgian troops are on a very important mission in Afganistan and when somebody is talking about murders of innocent people, please mention that Russia and their puppet separatists killed thousands of innocent wemwn, children and old ones in Georgia and i realy want to know, what were you posting that time.

by: j from: uk
April 18, 2010 01:23
your called radio FREE europe means that u dont take sides but just tell the truth cause that what you stand for but its seems you favour georgia even though its a regime has no democracy and is a puppet state of usa and that russia is once the good guys but you just cant help but to turn it around and make out that there not, you seem to forget they killed innocent people and Mikheil Saakashvili should be put on trial oh wait the americans wont allow that coz he nows to much and might point the finger!
In Response

by: Andrew from: Tbilisi
April 28, 2010 12:46
Well J,

Guess you forgot about all those Russian troops and Ossetian and Abkhazian militia committing ethnic cleansing boyo.

In what way exactly were the Russians "the good guys"?

When they supplied separatist terrorists with tanks, helicopter gunships, and missile launchers?

When they refused to act as a neutral peacekeeper in the years leading up to this conflict, and particularly in the final months when they turned a blind eye to increasingly violent attacks against Georgians and pro Georgian Ossetians in the Georgian controlled areas, using mortars and artillery, not to mention roadside bombs and sniper fire?

When the Russians bombed civilian targets in Georgia, including but not limited to cement works, schools, hospitals, apartment blocks and so on.

When Ossetian militia, frequently led by Russians, destroyed Georgian villages, murdered civilians, cut down orchards, killed livestock, and burnt crops, not only in ethnically Georgian parts of South Ossetia, but in Gori, Akhalgori (which Russian troops still occupy one might add), Surami, and in concert with the Abkhaz separtists, in Zugdidi, Samtredia etc.

Then there is the looting of schools, banks, and private homes by rampaging hordes of Russian, Ossetian, and Abkhaz militia, the stealing of cars on the Gori Tbilisi highway etc.

Also interesting to note that just as many Ossetians live in Tbilisi and Gori, as in South Ossetia, however in Georgia they can learn Ossetian at public schools if they so desire, and are fully integrated into society.

Compare this with South Ossetia (which until the late 19th century was called Shvida Karlti and was populated mainly by ethnic Georgians, the city of Tshkinvali was majority ethnic Georgian until the 1960's), where Georgian is banned, where Georgian villages such as Tamarasheni are now destroyed.

Seriously J, you need to learn a bit more about what goes on in the Caucasus before you post comments/
In Response

by: Anonymous
May 02, 2010 18:20
Andrew from Tbilisi, no need to be over-apologetic to the J.pa,
It is just a propaganda from all over the World and from Europa,
Inserted there by the expanding teams from the Russian side
To smear their victims - it includes, also, "Free Europe" site.

By the way, it's often misstake of Georgia over-hospitality,
Like Russian Zaric that brought a million Monghol army,
Repaying fortune of gifts to Zaric by genocidal brutality,
Or Irakli's faith in gratitude from Varangian dammies.

Shevarnadze also believed frendship of "Artek" elite,
Where USSR elite and their kids were brothering
And Gorbachev friendship of new "Himikal Ali",
And Anen-Pushkin with Russia in Abkhazia.

Russians used to say you are too consious,
While they are not. They hit you - you forgive.
Knew he that Russia crusified kids like me?
That in "Artek's" they would be so malicious -
Spoiling air and destroying us for God's gifts?

Konstantin.

PS:
But you are OK,
your patient rebattle is necessary,
not too many and not too often, thought...

Latest Commentary

No records found for this widget:963

More Commentary

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Ukraine Activists Protest Language Law

Latest Comment (1 total)

Eugenio: Ukrainian MPs are really taking their work much more seriously than those of ... More

Beaten Ukrainian Gay Activist Unbowed

Latest Comment (3 total)

David: Beating any minority social group only strengthens their resolve and moral high ground. ... More

Dolphin Deaths Alarm Black Sea Ecologists

Latest Comment (1 total)

John Harduny: Marine mammals often die in places with new geophysical exploration activity tied to ... More