Thursday, May 24, 2012


Transmission

Ahmadinejad Jewish? Wouldn't Matter If He Were

TEXT SIZE - +
With recent debate in the Western media over claims that Iran’s President Mahmud Ahmadinejad might have Jewish ancestry, in Iran several reformists, journalists, and bloggers have responded by saying that even if true, it wouldn't matter anyway. 

What matters, they say, is that Ahmadinejad violates the rights and will of the Iranian people.

In an article published on the “Rahesabz” website, journalist Yadollah Eslami writes that “our [concern] about Ahmadinejad and his friends is not about their family record but about their respect of human rights."

In a similar vein, journalist Babak Dad writes in his blog that it doesn't matter whether Ahmadinejad is Muslim, has Jewish roots, or is an atheist. Dad argues that Ahmadinejad certainly isn't a follower of any heavenly religion because if he was truly religious he wouldn’t “lie” and become “a tool of repression.”

And blogger "Inja va anja" ("Here and there") argues that talk about whether Ahmadinejad is Jewish or not is unproductive because it might encourage people to channel their negative feelings about Ahmadinejad  toward the Jews. The blogger adds: “Ahmadinejad is himself and his father, or the religion of his father, cannot be blamed for his deeds.”

Meanwhile, the "Tehran Times" speculates as to provenance of the story. It quoted an unnamed analyst who said that the “Daily Telegraph” report about Ahmadinejad’s family background was “undoubtedly “ published after a request from the Israeli leadership.

In light of the Goldstone report, such reports are obviously designed to divert world attention from Israeli crimes against Palestinians and the use of weapons of mass destruction in the three-week attack on the Gaza Strip.

-- Golnaz Esfandiari
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: cyrus from: glasgow
October 08, 2009 16:18
i see British when things go wrong
a wink at his fellow British and don't worry we will get it together.
I see a British and tells me buy a Range rover because it is British
i tell him but it brakes down all the time
the replays keep spending money on it because It is British.
You lot make me sick, how can darkness understand light
how can i explain to you to think and be like British or westerns.
You could never be like Western people and Iran will never be safe in your kind of peoples hand. You are a traitor, selfish and your version of freedom is go to disco, drink lager or .. and sleep around.
that's the bottom 10% of European and American do not the better ones. Never ever i call you people Iranians.
Cyrus an Iranian.
ps try to learn from Westerns by living amongst the top 10 and not the bottoms 30/40.


by: B1222
October 08, 2009 17:32
The sly author hints at R.Goldstone` origin,whose report was condemned as pro-Israel`.THe author knows well that Goldstones report was called anti-Israel`s. The simple hint about Jewish origins which"means nothing".

by: ragged soul
October 09, 2009 14:41
Pffft. It is precisely because Ahmadinejad follows a 'religion' that he supports repression. And don't for a miniute tell me that if he was truly religious he would be 'good.' Look at Israel - the fools there eat sleep and drink God and see how they treat those who really own the land they steal. Religion is the root of all evil, whether you're christian muslim or jew.

by: John
October 11, 2009 17:45
Thank you for this. Ahmadinejad is a ruthless dictator, what difference does it make if he is a Jew or not?! There were similar rumors about Hitler.

About This Blog

Written by RFE/RL editors and correspondents, Transmission serves up news, comment, and the odd silly dictator story. While our primary concern is with foreign policy, Transmission is also a place for the ideas -- some serious, some irreverent -- that bubble up from our bureaus. The name recognizes RFE/RL's role as a surrogate broadcaster to places without free media. You can write us at transmission+rferl.org

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Macedonia's Latest Contentious Statue

Latest Comment (19 total)

Ancient Greek=Albanian: Afërditë in Albanian means "Near Day" in Modern Greek Aphrodite has no meaning.

THE ... More

Obama Says G8 Summit To Discuss 'Strong Growth Agenda'

Latest Comment (2 total)

Konstantin: PS:
Today a man and a women made commentaries on a street, mocking:

- "O ... More

No Saturday Night Fever, As Armenia Mulls Eurovision Blackout

Latest Comment (10 total)

Jason: It is disingenuous to suggest that Armenian music, played by the German DJ, ... More