Thursday, May 24, 2012


Features

Foul Play Alleged In Armenia Eurovision Voting

TEXT SIZE - +

 

Music fans in Armenia are up in arms about what they claim was a rigged vote to nominate a singer for this year's Eurovision Song Contest.

Nine of Armenia's top musical acts were in full voice on February 14, with Eva Rivas being named Armenia's 2010 entry to Eurovision, the annual pan-European singing competition.

But many fans have alleged that foul play was involved as thousands of text message votes for Rivas's top competitor never went through.

Born Valeria Tsaturyan, the Russian-Armenian songstress Rivas won the competition for the prized spot with her English-language song "Apricot Stone."

The 22-year-old native of Rostov-na-Donu in southern Russia beat out her closest competitors, pop-rap duo Emmy & Mihran.

That, at least, is what officials are saying.

But even before the results of the competition were announced, fans of Emmy & Mihran were claiming that their text message votes for the pair had failed to go through.

Vartan Grigorian, a representative of the PR group representing Emmy & Mihran, claimed that 5,000 SMS votes had already been registered for Rivas just 30 seconds after the announcement that voting was open to the public.

At that point, he told RFE/RL's Armenian Service, the server promptly went down -- with Emmy & Mihran holding just 1,400 votes.

Armenian public television, which organized the contest, followed up on pledges to investigate. It acknowledged late on February 15 that over 30,000 texted votes had not been counted -- but said that even so, Eva Rivas still came out on top by a wide margin. They said Emmy & Mirhan came in third, behind another singer, Razmik Amyan.

The Emmy & Mirhan camp says they do not believe the figures and will mount a challenge in court.

Some fans have alleged that Rivas's win was a foregone conclusion, given the heavy support that she enjoyed from a powerful diaspora-led production team in Moscow.

"The problem is not with Eva Rivas's persona, but with people who stand behind her," said one disgruntled voter.

Emmy and her partner Mihran, who has formerly worked as a backup dancer for Madonna, sang an English-language song entitled "Hey."

When Rivas was declared the winner, the duo quickly bowed and left the stage.

Ties In High Places

At a press conference following the competition at Yerevan's Opera Theater, Rivas's Moscow-based producer, Valery Saharian, brushed aside the allegations of foul play.

"One should also be able to accept a defeat in a dignified manner," the producer told RFE/RL's Armenian Service from Moscow.

A jury vote was held alongside the telephone-based public voting for Armenia's Eurovision nominee. The members of the jury were appointed by Armenia's Culture Ministry.

Each of the votes was given equal weight in determining the winner.

Armenian public television said that the jury had given the edge to Emmy & Mihran, but maintained that the public portion of the vote sealed Rivas's victory.

Rivas, an Angelina Jolie lookalike with waist-length hair, is sponsored by Samuel Karapetyan, an influential businessman. He is the brother of Karen Karapetyan, the chief of staff of the Armenian president.

Rivas is not the only Armenian Eurovision representative with ties to high places.

The female singer Sirusho, who was announced as the country's Eurovision representative in 2008 without a selection competition, has since married the son of Armenia's former president, Robert Kocharian.

And the Armenian controversies come alongside other recent Eurovision-related controversies in the region.

Last year, Azerbaijani citizens who had voted for the Armenian song in the Eurovision contest held were called to the Security Ministry to explain their vote after the national telecommunications company offered its phone records to the authorities.

That led to an investigation by Eurovision officials and eventual rule changes concerning telephone records.

This year's Eurovision competition will be held in Oslo, Norway in May. This year will be the fifth time that Armenia is participating.

Written by RFE/RL's Armenian Service and correspondent Richard Solash

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments page of 3
    Next 
by: Mher from: Armenia
February 16, 2010 18:29
Who cares?? :) the winner is Eva Rivas and she deserved it, because the song is meaningful not only yelling and screaming like the others.
and there isn't any injustice, I personally voted for Eva and my sms didn't reach, still pending.
please stop hatred and accept others victory, I'm sure if Emmy and Mihran won that competition the whole Armenia will begin to talk that her mother organized everything.
my hope to see the next euro vision to be held in Armenia that's our goal, not fighting to be recognized globally.

by: Stepan from: Yerevan
February 16, 2010 19:41
Yes, Mher is right. Eva is by far the best singer ever in Armenia's history and this election was even more fair and transparent than the last presidential elections in Armenia. Definitely, Armenians should stop complaining all the time and accept their destiny. Armenia is a democracy. Why can't Armenians just come to term with it?!

by: Armenian from: USA
February 16, 2010 20:38
I don't know what happened there. But this song was my favorite too.

by: gago hopar from: USA
February 16, 2010 20:43
i was expecting much more from emmy and mihran but there song was noting treditional and had noting to do wit armeniansm and it was not even a nice song so y did idiotic fans have to open there mouth even if it was riged im glad it was cuz wtf there song sucked! eva got my vote! i tink even tho mihran mentiond he will not do this stuf again if he loses or wont go to armeanin watever the hek he sayed i tink he should try again wit a more ethnical song next time he is a talented person this song was not maching to his standerds sorry...

by: John Harduny from: Reston, VA
February 16, 2010 20:51
Eva Rivas has the best song by far, and she does deserve the nomination. The entire SMS thing was not a good idea to begin with. Give it a rest.

by: Violet from: Armenia
February 16, 2010 21:53
Me and my friends voted for Eva Rivas and our sms didn't reach, we tried again and again, but we couldn't give our vote, and now I'm happy that without paying money my and my friends choice become reality.

by: Ara from: Armenia
February 16, 2010 23:37
I can say that it was clear to me that Eva was going to win, but because she was good, but because someone had decided this before the contest. I was at all the rehearsals and can say that the director of the show, Mr. Keshishyan gave her the most time on stage (over 90 minutes on Saturday) where everyone was to get 30 minutes to practice, but most were rushed off stage by the director within 15 minutes. I too was unable to get one one vote in, which I got a message to tell me that my sms was not delivered. Sad reality is that this song as "meaningful" as it is to Armenians will not got very far in an international arena. Of course if her sponsor, Mr. $300 million a year can buy her votes in Europe, then just maybe we will place in the top 10.

by: Aratta
February 16, 2010 23:38
"When Rivas was declared the winner, the duo quickly bowed and left the stage."

Why??? Why did Emmy and Mihran leave the stage just seconds after Eva Rivas was delared a winner? Did Emmy know at tht time that there was a problem with voting? Emmy got most of the votes because of Mihran. It's not the first time Emmy participates in the contest, and loses.

by: Anahit Bagdasarian from: US
February 17, 2010 07:17
I agree with Mihran from Yerevan, first in show buisness loosing and winning are like sisters, one in show business has to be prepared for both. Second Eva's song truely is a beautiful song, has a meanning, sweet liricks and she sings it amazingly well. The third we all must have one goal to bring next Eurovision to Armenia. I think Ammy shoud go and congratulate Eva, because if she wins, Ammy is not going to be in a very nice spot. We have to be proud to bring one more Armenian back to us, she easly could of represent Russia, but she chose Armenia. I wish her all the luck.

by: Armen from: USA
February 17, 2010 07:42
As everything else in Armenia, the spot on Eurovision is for sale, and nobody cares about who sings well or who has the best song. But the question I would like to post is this, what she has to do with Armenia, nobody heard about her, or her Armenian heritage ever, and all of a sudden she is Armenian and is going to represent Armenia. She has nothing to do with Armenia, except the fact that she has "good" Armenian friends, who does not know where to invest his money, so he is having fun, buy sending his girlfriend to Eurovision. Pretty expensive project. He better spend that money on books and send it to Artsakh. People will appreciate that more. BTW the song has no chance to compete in Europe.
Comments page of 3
    Next 

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Macedonia's Latest Contentious Statue

Latest Comment (19 total)

Ancient Greek=Albanian: Afërditë in Albanian means "Near Day" in Modern Greek Aphrodite has no meaning.

THE ... More

Obama Says G8 Summit To Discuss 'Strong Growth Agenda'

Latest Comment (2 total)

Konstantin: PS:
Today a man and a women made commentaries on a street, mocking:

- "O ... More

No Saturday Night Fever, As Armenia Mulls Eurovision Blackout

Latest Comment (10 total)

Jason: It is disingenuous to suggest that Armenian music, played by the German DJ, ... More