Wednesday, June 19, 2013


Persian Letters

Behnoud Shojaie Was Executed In Front Of My Eyes

Behnoud Shojaie
Behnoud Shojaie
TEXT SIZE - +
Blogger Mohammad Mostafaei is an Iranian lawyer who represents offenders on death row who committed crimes when they were younger than 18. Mostafaei writes about the October 11 hanging of his client, Behnoud Shojaie, who was executed for stabbing to death a teenager when he was 17.

About 2.00 a.m., rights activists and a number of Iran's mourning mothers were [outside Tehran's Evin Prison]. We were waiting for the parents to arrive at the prison. After about an hour, Ehsan's [the victim] parents appeared along with his siblings. The crowd moved towards them to try to convince them with their pleas to reconsider the execution of Behnoud.

Some time passed and his parents agreed to forgive.

All of a sudden the surroundings changed, the prison gates opened up, and the parents…and I went in. We stayed for some time in the waiting room. I thought the parents would forgive and Behnoud would not be executed.

Some more time passed and the voices of the activists praying were audible from outside. After a couple of minutes we entered into another lounge. Behnoud and some prison officials were present. As soon as he saw the parents he got down at their feet and begged them for his life….

Some of the prison officials, Mr. Oliyaifar, and myself went to the parents and begged them once more to reconsider Behnoud's execution and forgive him.

The mother said that she was incapable of thinking right: I just have to see the rope around his neck, she said. The sound of the azan [the Islamic call to prayer] could be heard.

Behnoud went into another room to offer his last prayers and ask God for forgiveness. After he completed his prayers we all went into the prison again.

I was overcome by fear, I was shivering. I did not know what would be the fate of this orphan child.

When Behnoud was begging the parents of the victim, he told the mother that he never had a mother of his own and asked her to be a mother for him and forgive him. We went to another lounge, hall number 4, comprising a rectangular stage with a rope hanging from the top.

Behnoud had wished to see the blue sky one last time before he died but instead he was face-to-face with a blue rope. The parents entered the hall and Behnoud was brought in afterwards.

The hall of executions.... It was more surprising for me that Behnoud was the only one to be executed. Probably this was bad luck as well, to leave on his own, all alone.

All of those present there asked for the victim's parents once more and said they wouldn't regret it if they left it in the hands of God. But the mother said once more that she just had to see the rope around Behnoud's neck.

He went onto the stage and the rope was placed around his neck. Within seconds, the parents of the victim approached him and pulled away the stool on which he was standing. Behnoud left this world....

Everything around me turned dark. Behnoud is no longer in the prison and among his friends. He will be missed.

I did everything in my power to try and stop this from happening. I still believe that he did not deserve what he got.

He shouldn't have been executed. But he was. He was executed.

Tags: Iran

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments page of 2
    Next 
by: Cleitus the Black
October 12, 2009 14:26
It seems to me that Behnoud Shojaie got just about what he deserved, and perhaps better.

Did the boy he stabbed to death get repeated attempts to plead with Behnoud's family to save his life before their son ended it?

The fact that the family had the chance, both to pardon the condemned, and to execute the state's sentence is to me the really interesting story here, showing that the Iranian justice system may, at least in this regard, more "just" than some in the Western world, where sentences, if they are commuted at the last minute, are done by an uninvolved governor, miles away - and where the family, even if they forgive the criminal, have no say as to whether the state's sentence is carried out...


by: Cleitus the Black
October 12, 2009 15:33
An interesting postscript to my previous note; the BBC has just reported that 4 Sudanese men accused of murdering a U.S. envoy and his driver will be executed - because the mother of the U.S. victim, John Granville, refused to forgive the accused killers (which would have pardoned them under Sudan's Sharia Law) and instead officially demanded that they be executed, to "safeguard the lives of others from those who killed her beloved son"... And although the family of the other victim, Mr. Granville's driver had already forgive the accused murders, this means the four men will presently face the noose.

Full text of the BBC report is here:http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8302410.stm

Perhaps Mr. Mostafaei should head to the Sudan for some pro-bono work...

by: Issa Ibrahim from: Peshawar
October 12, 2009 17:29
We get from God the same kind of forgiveness as we show others. After all, the ways that others injure or offend us are insignificant compared to our offenses before him.
I fear for the parents who could not forgive.

by: Conover from: Kennard
October 12, 2009 20:53
This is in regards to Issa Ibrahim's comment. Oddly enough, I just said the very same thing, almost word for word to a close friend. I hope the parents get the forgiveness they will desperately need one day. We all need to be forgiven for something.

by: Nomoredespots
October 13, 2009 04:14
These barbaric and medieval execution laws should have been stamped out a long time ago. A country which rules by these archaic ways should not be allowed to be part of any united nations until they decide to grow up and get with the times.

by: mahshid from: Tehran
October 13, 2009 08:30
my name is mahshid , I have a son named behnoud I havent seen for 8 years since he is living in netherland under psycological teratment in in clinic in Netherland , I dont have any relative or some one to help me to se him ,He did a mistake 4 years ago and now he is in this medical center which is also a jail too since He cant get out.
I was following Behnoud case every time I could I wish I had a chance to go to him to tell him ur without mother and I am without my behnoud ,God knows how I feel these last 2 days since Behnoud is excuted why a child who has done a mistake in his early younghood should have same punishment which is serial killer dooes what kind of law is this who punishes all people same with different stages of crimes is this our religious to just hate and kill '
Behound is not a murderer Ehasan parents are , he did not knew he is going to kill some one in fight but they knew well what they are going to do
with love to myboth Behnouds
one in jail in a foreign country alone anfd the other in acold grave

by: Chaudhry from: Washington DC
October 13, 2009 12:28
Well He was a Killer, this is what he deserved.

by: Chaudhry from: Washington DC
October 13, 2009 12:31
This is what he deserved no matter what. hustice was served upon him.

by: A
October 13, 2009 20:25
He didn't deserve to die for a crime he committed when he was only 17. He was a child. These are barbaric laws. Forgiveness is the key, not more blood.

by: mike black from: Washington DC
October 14, 2009 00:07
I agree with the comment that he may not have meant to kill the other child and that he had suffered as an orphan...but I also understand the mother of the victim's feeling - correct or not - that seeing him hanged would somehow make her feel better or give her some sense of "closure". There's no "good" side to this story.

Also: I have seen or heard multiple stories of families here in the States that want the killer(s) of their family members pardoned from execution. I doubt those wishes are granted more than half the time. You can berate the laws in Iran and elsewhere as "primitive", but at least there the wishes of the victims' families matter for squat.

As for executing those who were minors at the time of their crime, several states in our own country are in a huge glass house. The minimum age in many states is 16; 17 in others.
Comments page of 2
    Next 

About This Blog

Persian Letters is a blog that offers a window into Iranian politics and society. Written primarily by Golnaz Esfandiari, Persian Letters brings you under-reported stories, insight and analysis, as well as guest Iranian bloggers -- from clerics, anarchists, feminists, Basij members, to bus drivers.

Guerrilla Translators

Seen anything in the Iranian blogosphere that you think Persian Letters should cover? If so, contact Golnaz Esfandiari at esfandiarig@rferl.org
Partner Media