map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

'Berlin Wall's Lessons For Today'

In an op-ed for "USA Today," Jeffrey Gedmin discusses RFE and the role of free media in societies living under repressive regimes. More
More Articles

Commentary

Bosnia On The Verge Of Dissolution?

The seat of the Bosnian Presidency

September 17, 2009
By Nenad Pejic
This summer I spent a few days in the Bosnia-Herzegovinian town of Medjugorje, which has been visited by millions of pilgrims since apparitions of the Virgin Mary were reported there in 1981. The region is also known across Bosnia for its aspiration to become part of Croatia.

That dream hasn't come true, but this summer locals there told me how happy they were to be paying a special surtax for the construction of a motorway from Hungary through Sarajevo to the Adriatic coast. "We see this as a great opportunity for Medjugorje and the region," I was told. "This will make Poland two hours closer to us -- imagine how many Polish pilgrims will come then!"

An optimist might see this as a chance for economic development and strengthening Bosnia. A pessimist might wonder whether the deeply divided Bosnia could pull off such a project. In this case, as we will see, the pessimist is correct.

Senior Cynicism

But first, a bit of a digression.

A few days ago, Nebojsa Radmanovic, the ethnic Serbian member of Bosnia's tripartite presidency, said in an interview with the Belgrade-based daily "Evening News" that Bosnia is one step closer to dissolution than it is to being a functioning state. That is a harsh statement to be coming from one of the three men in Bosnia most responsible for seeing to it that Bosnia functions as a state. If Bosnia is not "working," he and the other two presidency members are the first ones to be blamed.

But that doesn't bother Radmanovic, for whom the dissolution of Bosnia would be just fine.

About 10 days ago, Serbian President Boris Tadic visited Bosnia. He participated in the opening of a school called "Serbia" in Pale, about 15 kilometers from Sarajevo. Addressing the crowd, he said Serbia "bears responsibility wherever our people live."

"Serbia is responsible for all the people who bear our name," he said.

This was a provocative thing to say, given the name of the school.

But it wasn't Tadic's only provocation.

He visited Bosnia without being invited by the authorities of that country or attempting to meet with its leaders. His motorcade passed by the building of the Bosnian Presidency without slowing down. Instead, he met only with leaders of the ethnic Serbian community. The visit was a replay of a similar visit he made to Banja Luka, the capital of Republika Srpska (the ethnic Serbian entity within Bosnia), in June. Both trips sent the same message and served to incrementally weaken the Bosnian state.

Gestures like Tadic's and statements like Radmanovic's have encouraged leaders in Banja Luka. Recently, for instance, Republika Srpska Prime Minister Milorad Dodik denied the crimes against humanity committed in Tuzla in 1995, even though the war crimes tribunal at The Hague has established the incident and sentenced the responsible general to 20 years in prison for causing the deaths of 71 civilians. Dodik knows these facts, but his statement was intended to stir up enmity and foster ethnic tensions.

About a month ago, Bosnian Deputy Foreign Minister Ana Trisic-Babic said she might step down because she could not work with Foreign Minister Sven Alkalaj. Alkalaj then confirmed the two had not spoken directly for months, maybe even years. Is this a functioning state?

My Way Or The Highway

Getting back to Medjugorje: The people there will not see an influx of Polish pilgrims, and who knows if the motorway will ever be built. The parliament of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Muslim-majority entity of Bosnia, adopted a law on the highway and introduced the surtax, which people were happy to pay.

But the entity's executive branch -- led by representatives of the Muslim community -- unilaterally changed the law. As a result, the Croat representatives in the government walked out of a government session.

Clearly, when an executive branch rewrites laws passed by a legislature, the country is weakened. It's another step toward dissolution, and in this case, the Muslim representatives are to blame.

On September 17, their party, the Party of Democratic Action (SDA), was expected to announce whether it would suspend participation in the entity's government because the others oppose its nominee for the government's top security post.

Such "my-way-or-the-highway" behavior, again, weakens the state, and pushes it closer to dissolution. In Sarajevo it is a widely held perception that Muslim representatives often exploit their majority position to push their own agenda at the expense of other ethnic groups. More steps down the path toward dissolution.

And what about the international community?

An intellectual in Sarajevo told me last week that Bosnia is like a sick patient who needs hospital treatment, but who is told he must recover before he can be admitted. The world -- particularly the EU -- has been slow to respond to developments in Bosnia, usually reacting slowly rather than acting decisively. And that, too, is pushing the country toward dissolution.

Nenad Pejic is associate director of broadcasting for RFE/RL. The views expressed in this commentary are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect those of RFE/RL
This forum has been closed.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 4
by: Antifascist
October 14, 2009 21:41
What do you know, pau, and who are you to decide on that, why don't you rather ask soem people in the country, as I did? Soem say to fragment Yugoslavia was wrong, but to fragment Bosnia-Herzegovian is all right?
Say, if it was the size of Australia then one could maybe do it, but to create a new Gaza Strip and West Bank, right here on Europe's doorastep? To make the Bosniaks into the Palesrtinians of Europe, do you think that's all right? Then I don't want ANYTHING with people like you!

by: Pau from: Barcelona
October 11, 2009 17:08
The current Bosnia is an artificial state who simply can not survive without western economical and military suport. It is just a fact. The only reasonable solution is to create instead three smaller states, one for every ethnic group (Croat, Serb, Muslim). Integrated all of them in the EU there is not reason for them not to be prosperous, and live in peaceful terms for a long time. Where is the reason to mantain a state against the opinion of most of their citizens?

by: Abdul Majid
October 06, 2009 10:53
Why, of course, I am not the only one to subscribe to that point of view, Alain, after all, do you know how many millions of Muslims are out there? Yes, indeed, the Cross will NOT Chase teh CRESCENT out of BOSNIA! Which means, the SERBS will NOT EXPEL or EXTERMINATE teh Bosniaks! To deny the Bosniaks their homeland or to preetend to keep them subdued as you do is INHUMAN! So do not wonder why it is so that me and Antifascist and milloins of Muslims have NO SYMAPTHY whatsoever for the wretched and accursed Serb nation!

And, by the way you talk, despitze your saying you're from Paris I suspect you'r Michael Averko!

by: Alain from: Paris
October 05, 2009 07:59
Looks like Abdulmajid and Antifascist are one and the same... "the Cross will NEVER, understand that NEVER chase the Crescent from Bosnia"
I've already read that somewhere...

by: Abdulmajid
October 04, 2009 14:13
Since rthere are only two alternatives, either the Bosniaks are completely subdued, ghettoized, decimated and made into the Palestinians of Europe - a peoplel without land and without rights - or they prevail over their enemies and make their country safe for themselves to live in peace within its internationally recognized borders, I prefer the latter. And cut out that crap about that Serbs will not be ruled by Muslims - the other way round seems to be4 all right for you, you hypüocrites! Also cut out that crap that you condemn violence. Talk is cheap. You don't condemn the outcome of that violence. Indeed in hos last postz the Russo-Serbo-DFascist Sergey said that he wanted Bosnia to be shattered. So if I ever have uttered something they preceive as as a threat against such people who insult me in person by saying that all Muslims are evil barbarians and who would want to see me put down as a traitor, then I feel justified, and the Cross will NEVER, understand that NEVER chase the Crescent from Bosnia or Albania or Kosova! And let all those who would try to rechristianize these countries by force and by violent means find a very sticky end!

by: Antifascist
October 01, 2009 17:04
To all the hypocrite Serbofascists and Islamophobes out there:
Bah, and you Alain and Sergey say Muslims are evil and Islam is evil. By that you are insulting ME personally. And you say you condemn violence against Bosniaks. Ha ha ha! Talk is cheap. You support the Serb side. Else you wouldn't have said that "thousands of Arab jihadists" came to Bosnia "to slit Christians' throats" Ha ha ha! And what about the Greek, Russian, Ukrainian and Orthodox thugs who came to murder Bosniaks and to rape Bosniak girls? And all of what you say is just pure Islamophobia. All that drivel about the "worldwide Islamic Caliphate" and "Sharia Law" only serves as a justification top thiose who would want to WASTE all Muslims, and who say "War against Islam = war against Muslims" And I have NO sympathy wahtsoever for such people. They are the new Nazis and the new Ku Klux Klan, and in their eyes, I and the Bosniaks and the Kosovo Albanians, and the Palestinains are nothing but their "niggers" and their "yids".
But the Bosniaks and the Kosovo Albanians are NOT returning under Serb rule, and the Bosnian Serbs would be very well advised to seek their forgiveness. And as for all Bosnian Serbs who still hate Bosnia and teh Bosniaks yes they should QUIT Bosnia! Nobody is holding them back. But then NOBODY is forcing them out. You attribute to the Bosniaks all evil the Serbs did in a typical and futile attempt to portray the victim as the criminal.
And it is downright shameful that the comments of these new racists, fascists and xenophobes are allowed here on this site that is supposed to oppose totalitarianism, and to suppress what the potential or true victims of this new totalitarianism have to say. How about not letting the Islamophobes have the last say here?

by: Antifascist
September 30, 2009 16:11
Ah, c'mon, whom are you trying to kid, if you constly say that the Bosniaks aer guilty of the war then what else can be expected of you. You say that the Americans and Europeans foufgh the wrong side in Bosnia. So you mean they should have ghelped the Serbs slaughter the Bosniaks and "transfer the survivorse elsewhere. And then you have the nerve to say that you are against violence. Do you tale me for stupid?
You say "NOT for Bosniaks only, not for Muslims only", and what have you said before, that Bosnia "of course" belongs to Serbia. And I have CLEARLY said that all those who REJECT Bosnia are FREE to move out, NOT that they should forcibly be expelled. But for who has blood of Bosniaks his hands -no quarter and no mercy. And you would allow Muslims in Bosnia just the same freedom and dignity as Jean-Marie Le Pen would allow the Muslims in France if he came to power. And THAT is unacceptable. Besides that, the notion that there is a worldwide conspiracy to install a worldwide Islamist toalitarian state is a LIE exactly the same as the "Protocol of the Elders of Zion!" Such unbelievable crap is used as a justification by those who want to exterminate the Bosniaks. And if you say you never said that, still you want to see them subdued. Or else you would not blame them for the war. Or say that they are All jihadists. From your words I gather that just because I happen to profess the Muslim faith you would immediately pigeonhole me as a jihadist. Who has to be held under close check. And I profess the Muslim faith from revulsion against those you call "secular and Christian" who in 1992-1995 stood by and let the Bosniaks at the mercy of their enemies and denied them their right to self-defense, with the same arguments you are using. So, am I to you a traitor and a jihadist? Then try to get me back to Christianity! So far I haven't done anybody any harm and - luckily -none has doen anything to me. But should I wait to be attacked or stabbed or shot down by some idiot racist xenophobe? Of course it does not say on my forehead what I am and I do Not stand for Osdama Bin Laden's trademark of blind rage and visceral hatred, which is no better than the Serbofascits', nor for Ahmadinejad who is no better than Milosevic, nor for the Taleban's Stone-age islamism. And neither do the Bosniaks, so it is slander and insult to say they are jihadists and must be put down. The slander that thousands and thousands of bloodthirsty jihadists came to Bosnia fromall Arab countries to kill poor innocent Serbs and to make it a bridgehead for the invasion of Europe is nothing but malicious and evil-intentioned prtopaganda of the worst sort, as a justification to kill them. And some people still take it seriously. A few weeks ago some imbecile Islamophobe attacked an Egyptian woman in a courtroom in Dresden and stabbed her to death and cried "You don't have a right to live" just because she was Muslim. I for one, if somebody thinks I have no right to live I will say "After you!" And mark my words, nobody will force the Bosniaks or the Kosovo Albanians back under Serb rule. And nobody will fob the Bosnioaks off with just a few tiny bits of unconnected territory, a Balkan Gaza Strip and West Bank as you would like them to. You will have to accept that Bosnia will be a majority-Bosniak country, because in 20 years the Bosniaks will be over 67% of the total people there, and what do you want to do, fob them off with 25% of the land in two or three small enclaves! NEVER!
And even Russia will not step in to decimate them. Their love of their Serb "brethren" does not go so far.

by: Alain from: Paris
September 30, 2009 14:02
To Antifascist:

Nobody is saying that the Bosnian Muslims should go to the Middle East. But you are clearly saying that Serbs and Croats should leave Bosnia and move (permanently) to Serbia and Croatia.

Nobody is saying that Bosnia isn’t also the homeland of the Bosnian Muslims. But you are clearly saying that Bosnia is ONLY a homeland for the Muslims.

Nobody is saying that Bosnia should be only Christian. But you are clearly saying that only the Muslim Crescent is Bosnia.

Nobody is saying that killing Muslims is OK. Quite the contrary – I condemned violence in my previous point. But you make repeated implicit and explicit violent threats against Sergey and me…

So… if your comments are representative of the Bosnian Muslims and mine are representative of the Christian and secular non-Muslims… then this conversation only proves what we have been witnessing on the ground for the past 20 years, since Alia Izetbegovic’s first declarations that Bosnia should be Muslim and ONLY Muslim land… and that’s aggressive Islamic imperialism in the Balkans.

by: Antifascist
September 29, 2009 16:10
Dear Sergei, I don't care whether that's your real name or not. In any case I 'm nont giving you mine nor any other details which might allow some goons to come to my house to rough me up.)
Firstly, the Bosniaks are my brothers and sisters. Their struggle is my struggle.
Second, there IS no such things as a World Caliphate. Tehre is no such thing as an Islamist Bloc which would want to take over the whole world as teh Soviet Union would have done (but even they opposed tha West more out of fear of being overtakebn themselves, than out of ideological conviction.) The Muslim countries, in disarray and impoverished, are also dependent on the West and dont have the military means to oppose it anyway.
Thirdly, the Bosniaks were only DEFENDING themselves, nobody among them ever said 'let's round up and slaughter all Christians we can lay hands on'.
In conclusion, all you offer me is Islamophobia and hatred of Mulsims. You can say as ofteh as yo want that you don't justify mass murder against teh Bsbniaksd but you never once have condemned it, for you it must be all right.
And I'm telling you, you will NOT put me and my brethern down just because you don't happen to like our religuion. If you don't like Islam or Muslims, nobody is forcing you to join in. You will NOT chase the Bosniaks away from their homeland, nor make them as guilty as the ones who attacked them. And if any of you has the feeling that for my having become a Muslim myself I am a traitor and do not deserve to live, I say to all those who are thinking that as they read this, it would be my pleasure to do to them exactly what they wish for me!

by: ntifascist
September 29, 2009 10:57
I don't care what you think about Islam or that you andthse of yur ilk ake it out to be the new Bolshevism, but your argumentation plays directly into the hands of those wo like Raovan Karadzic would murder and expel people just for heir being muslims, ndinto the hands of those who wuld make ME a second-vlas citizen in MY own country. Even if you say you don't approve of any anti-Muslim policies or genocide, fact is yo would welcome them because thn the posiotion of those you see asy our enemies wouldf be weakened. Never mid that they haven't done anything to anybody, nor that most of them do not stand behind stone-age Islamists. But what you do is to deny the Bosniaks' right to exist in their own homeland, or that in Europemuslimsd can only be second-calss citizens and many of what you say sounds exactly like what Julius Streicher said about the Jews in Nazi Germay, or what Geert ilders is saying, and I do NOT care for what any Islamophobes out there might say about Muslms being inferior. Which means stiop suggestimng to me to lok up Isamophbic websites and try to see uslims as HUMAN BEINGS, not just as "trerrorists, jihadfists, troublemakers or inferior human beings", or else you can't expect of me to take you serious,ly, and I vastly prtefer the iperialism of my own to the Russian one!
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 4
TEXT SIZE - +

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile