Friday, May 25, 2012


Commentary

Georgia Coming Back In From The Cold

President Mikheil Saakashvili (left) welcomes U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to Tbilisi on July 5. Suddenly, Georgia's not feeling so isolated.
TEXT SIZE - +
By Ghia Nodia
Over the last few weeks there has been a parade of high-level visitors to Tbilisi and Batumi.

It began with U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, followed by the foreign ministers of Poland, France, and Luxembourg. It also included the head of the newly created European Union foreign-policy service, a deputy prime minister of Ukraine, and, finally, the president of Azerbaijan.

During the same period, Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili managed to hold unofficial talks with his Ukrainian and Belarusian counterparts in Crimea. About a month earlier, he traveled to summits with the presidents of Romania and France.

It has been a long time since anything of this sort has happened. Compared to the last two years, when the number of official visits to Tbilisi fell sharply, we can consider the latest events a sort of "diplomatic breakthrough."

Most of the guests not only visited Tbilisi, but also stopped by other countries among those that Russia considers its "near abroad." From this one can conclude that Western countries are trying -- at least on the level of symbolic gestures -- to stress that relations with Moscow are not being improved at the expense of Russia's neighbors.

The meetings of the Ukrainian, Belarusian, and Azerbaijani presidents with Saakashvili -- the embodiment of disobedience toward Russia -- indicate that these leaders are trying to balance their relations with Russia with other political vectors.

Saakashvili Here To Stay

But the uptick in diplomatic activity is particularly significant for Georgia. The fact that in recent times Saakashvili has rarely been invited to summits and that Tbilisi has ceased to be a popular site for high-level meetings stems not only from the fact that the West did not approve of Saakashvili's behavior in August 2008. The problem was that it was unclear whether he would be able to survive politically following the country's military defeat. Or, if he could, would he be able to do it without resorting to political repression and the restriction of democratic liberties.

So the West decided to wait and see what would happen with Georgia....

But the results of the local elections in May finally cleared things up. Saakashvili and his party really strengthened their position. As a result, for the next few years everyone is going to have to deal with him.

Moreover, Saakashvili not only survived but he did so without any radical shifts. Clearly you can't compare democracy in Georgia with the standards of the European Union, but despite domestic political tensions and the existential threat from the north, the general dynamic has been more toward the expansion of democratic liberties than toward their contraction.

This was confirmed by the quality of the elections -- Western observers unanimously noted clear progress compared to the previous polls, although they always added (and justly so) that the consolidation of democratic institutions is still a long way off.

While it seems Saakashvili will never regain the star status that he had in the wake of the Rose Revolution, the West is now convinced that he is a serious leader who must be taken into account and dealt with and that Georgia -- despite its shortcomings -- remains a regional leader in terms of democratic development.

Isolated No More

But what can these visits give Georgia, beside a few pleasant words? It is obvious that Russia is not going to withdraw from Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Georgia will not be accepted into NATO or the European Union. The West is not going to fight with Russia over Georgia's sovereignty or even impose economic sanctions on Moscow.

But what is really important is the new dynamic. Lately the United States has begun consistently describing the Russian military presence in Abkhazia and South Ossetia as "occupation" -- that is, Washington is using the harshest word there is in the diplomatic lexicon. Perhaps this is connected with the upcoming elections in the United States and is a response to criticism from the Republicans. But so what? The word "occupation" is not a bell that can be easily unrung.

Georgia recently signed an agreement with the European Union on the easing of visa restrictions and the beginning of talks on an association agreement has been announced. "So what?" the critics will say. "Nothing will come of it." Maybe so, but nonetheless the dynamic of Georgia's relations with the EU is positive.

It can all be summed up like this: Georgia's opponents (or the opponents of the current government) have been fond of saying that the country is isolated and the West no longer supports us. Either Georgia must throw itself on the mercy of the victor or Saakashvili must leave immediately. After the diplomatic parade this month, it is much harder to make this argument.

Ghia Nodia is professor of politics at Ilia State University. The views expressed in this commentary are his own, and do not necessarily reflect those of RFE/RL
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Ash
July 22, 2010 13:01
This site is becoming more and more like a soviet style propaganda site, as constant good news about people like Saakashvili and not a single negative piece. Where as the opposite is true for Russian news - "they never do anything good". Shame on you RFE/RL.
In Response

by: Andrew from: Auckland/Tbilisi
July 23, 2010 05:16
Lets see Ash, maybe it is because Saakashvili is trying to turn his country into a place with a fully functioning democracy, rule of law, he fights against corruption with great success, and is trying to modernise the economy.

Compared with this Russia is a dictatorship, controlled by the secret police who act with impunity against the Russian people, corruption is massively increasing, Russia wages wars on its neighbor Georgia in support of separatist terrorists who commit ethnic cleansing, while conducting a genocidal campaign against its own north Caucasian subjects who desire to be free of the yoke of Russian tyranny.

In Russia anyone who criticises the government is liable to be shot in the back of the head (Politkovskaya, Estimirova, Markelov etc) or die after torture in prison (Magnitsky).

So yes, Russia NEVER does anything good. What do you want RFE/RL to do? Invent some happy stories about what is still very much the evil empire?

by: KONSTANTIN from: LOS ANGELES
July 22, 2010 18:22
It simce that ambers of Russian flames of war
Never dying, hide under "Ash" that hide under "capi"
Bashing "comi". What "opposite is true", Ash, a new door
For Georgia postpond another invasion of your Russian pappy?

Konstantin.

by: Peter Wilson from: San Diego
July 22, 2010 20:33
You are right Ash. As for Saakashvili, he will be gone in a couple of years unless he pulls a Putin like switch with prime-minister.

by: rick from: MILAN
July 22, 2010 21:45
today we know that "occupation" of kosovo
by NATO/USA is legal for UN .

Well , where is the difference with abkazia , south ossetia , Transnistria ?

Only that this 3 republic have a differen friend !

by: Konstantin from: Los Angeles
July 23, 2010 08:29
Wilson from San Diego and Rick from Milan,
Howe big is stolen oil and gas Russia's "karman"?
Moscow, Stolitca, can afford many like you - 100-s talkers.
Your "Stolitca" - 100 faced, your "Gerb" is double faced vaulcher.

I am just one man, but truth is strongers than 100 "Stolitca" liers.
Saakashvili may gone or move to premier job, smear-shin?
Yushenko could loose elections, so can many in CIS?
So what? Long live all non-Russian CIS nations!

NATO and USA not much better and missguided
By your Russia! Russia told Iraq to invade Kuveit,
Create precedent and invade CIS, USA was used
Through Ambassador Cohen - by Russia bribes!

NATO was bombinmg "Ugo" and Serbia borders
From San Diego Germans - staffed with Rashkis
And demanded help Folswagen bombing orders,
While British friends of Rashkis helping Prashkis.

Another precident forged for Germany and Russia
To devide Eastern Europe by Russia and Prussia!

Konstantin.
In Response

by: Dominik from: San Diego
July 23, 2010 13:15
Konstantin......you're dumber then a dump truck. First of all, LEARN how to write in english properly. Second, if you don't like USA go back to the filthy hole from which you crawled out of in Eastern Europe you fool!
In Response

by: Konstantin from: Los Angeles
July 24, 2010 08:17
Where is my reply?
Censoring for filthy mouth Dominik from San Diego?
Or more properly, for Russia-Prussia-Levite 1949 Tiraspol zone conspiracy?
Back to Pridnestrov'e, along with usurping-seting-up USA Lerner and alike!

Konstantin.

by: Konstantin from: Los Angeles
July 23, 2010 17:45
Dominic from San Diego, of Russian, Austrian, and Livite plote?
Crawled from Eastern Europe or Russia - as Shwarzenegger,
Or Shwarzkopf, that sabotage USA as pseudo-patriotic boat?
Make behind my back quiet funkel - using your verbal filther?

I was betrayed in 1947 by Russia, Britain and US plagiarists.
Moscow government sentenced me and my mother to death,
Incited by Moscow Germans - encroaching again, lying twist.
As in USA, as in Russia the "Sacramento noh ain mal" hate.

As plagio-"Shwartckopf Vietnam" USA Germans on TV news,
You posing as patriot against me that saved USA few times,
While Shwarzkopf and Shwarzenegger, help by the Rashkis,
Plagiarizing my Ideas as military-fuhrers "leaders-Prashkis".

Go crawl back to Russian children summer camp - to 1949,
Where your Russian, German and Levites conspired again
To resurect Russian and Prussian Empires evil "Heavens"!
Wars staged by the plot of 1949 against Freedom your gain!

My English is more creative than English itself and your boll,
And of one of you, Lerner - trained to Germanize-usurp USA,
And of Shwarzenegger, with his "Sacramento noh ain mal"!
Go home to "Dnester republic" 1949 nazi camp all the way!

Konstantin.

Latest Commentary

No records found for this widget:963

More Commentary

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Ukraine Activists Protest Language Law

Latest Comment (1 total)

Eugenio: Ukrainian MPs are really taking their work much more seriously than those of ... More

Beaten Ukrainian Gay Activist Unbowed

Latest Comment (3 total)

David: Beating any minority social group only strengthens their resolve and moral high ground. ... More

Dolphin Deaths Alarm Black Sea Ecologists

Latest Comment (1 total)

John Harduny: Marine mammals often die in places with new geophysical exploration activity tied to ... More