Tuesday, February 14, 2012


Features

German Murder Trial Is Focus Of Anger In Islamic World

Women carry a symbolic coffin with a picture of Marwa al-Shirbiny during a protest in Istanbul.
TEXT SIZE - +
(RFE/RL) -- It is a story that has gripped both the Muslim and Western worlds.

It began in 2008, in the German city of Dresden, when an Egyptian-born woman, Marwa al-Shirbiny, asked a man to make room for her 3-year-old son on a children's playground swing.

The man, Alexander Wiens, responded by calling al-Shirbiny -- who was wearing an Islamic headscarf at the time -- a "terrorist" and a "slut."

Al-Shirbiny summoned the police, and Wiens was subsequently fined the equivalent of $480 on charges of verbal abuse.

When Wiens attempted to appeal the conviction this July, al-Shirbiny, then pregnant, attended the hearing. As she was leaving the courtroom, the court records charge, Wiens leapt at her and stabbed her 18 times with a kitchen knife.

Her husband, Elwi Ali Okaz, tried to protect her, and also suffered multiple stab wounds.

To make matters worse, in the melee a policeman shot Okaz in the leg, apparently assuming that the Egyptian man was the attacker, rather than the German defendant.

The murder trial of Wiens, a 29-year-old ethnic German born in Russia, began in Dresden October 26 in the same courtroom where the murder took place. The dead woman's husband, Okaz, attended on a pair of crutches.

Ayyub Axel Koehler, the head of Germany's Central Muslim Council, told Reuters before the trial started that Muslims everywhere are intensely interested in this case.

"This trial is getting huge attention in the Muslim world,” Koehler said. “There were riots in some Islamic countries because of this murder. So it's up to us Germans to defend our reputation."

Koehler, a convert to Islam, was referring to demonstrations in Egypt and Iran, and Tehran's request for the United Nations to become involved.

He also said that Germany's Muslim community -- the biggest in Europe after France -- has been badly shaken by the affair.

"We're looking at this trial with great anticipation, because our women and girls are obviously scared,” he said. “They are already being discriminated against in public and looked down on."

Koehler said Germany's reputation has suffered badly, and that politicians have ignored Islamophobia and its consequences in society.

State prosecutor Christian Avenarius said in the course of the trial that it was clear the accused was motivated by a fanatic hatred of foreigners.

A top aide to German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Commissioner for Minorities Maria Boehmer, called on October 26 for calm, saying she knew that this "terrible deed" caused horror both in Germany and Egypt, as well as many parts of the Arab world.

She said it showed that Germans must "engage daily" to fight against racism, and work for peaceful coexistence.

Security is reported to be tight at the Dresden courthouse, with some 200 policemen surrounding the building. The accused has his hands and feet chained together, and is sitting behind bulletproof glass.

Egypt's ambassador to Berlin, Ramzy Ezzeldin, attended the opening of the trial, telling journalists as he arrived that he has "great trust" in German justice.
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: GeoffP from: San Bernadino, US
October 28, 2009 15:09
Curious: have there been any demonstrations for any of the women murdered in the West or the Middle East - or, anywhere, really - because they REFUSED to wear the hijab? Why is the outrage about this so...selective, shall we say? It's almost as though it has some elements of religious supremacism or intolerance from the rioters and protesters. But I'm sure that couldn't be the case, could it?

by: Alex Sterling
October 29, 2009 18:15
@Sergey

Islamists are not extremists like Nazis. The group you mention, Islamists, is made up of extremists, but also every other member of islam. Some are quite nice, some are nasty, some are fakers, some are believers. Just like any religion, do no treat it like a monolithic death cult. Remember, the sunnis and the shiites are fighting EACH OTHER and they're both adherents of Islam. This is a case of miseducation.

by: Mike Rooks
October 30, 2009 19:31
I think you're right Alex, i lived in the middle east for a while and believe me they're not all extremists and what is really surprising is that these are the minorities , anyway the media gives attention to these groups thats why we thinks thats all what muslims stand for, take the kkk for example if they generalize it, we'll be in a similar condition

by: sam from: usa
November 02, 2009 15:03
He should not have been charged with verbal abuse !! no free speach over there ? no wonder he flipped out. Of course he should not have attacked her, how evil .

by: Raj Singh from: London
November 12, 2009 11:35
German govt just stupid.we don't know who is the person behind burka.they should ban burka all over the west.how can we come to know who's behind that clothes.i humbly request to west plz don't allow that burkas.muslim are not from germany.so why dutch peoples have to pay for muslims.i don't care.muslim go back to arab and wear burka

by: Omar from: Singapore
November 18, 2009 17:46
Hi Sam.

If you talk about free speech, can you explain me what is Freedome of speech?
If verbal abuse is same as frees speech why there in dictionary have ABUSE word and FREEDOM word?

did abusing other by means of hatred means freespeech?
For your information, Freedom speech means it's the speech which should not harm anyone in any way. Its your right, your right must not effect to other people's right.

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

U.S. Hearing On Balochistan Raises Hackles, Awareness In Pakistan

Latest Comment (7 total)

Baluch Na Tavar: @Saleem, what are you talking about ?? Dividing Baluchistan in to four provinces. ... More

Gaza Hamas Leader Arrives In Iran

Latest Comment (2 total)

Ben: Masks are thrown off.After the "Arab spring" the so called "peaceful talks" are ... More

UN Rights Chief Scathing On Syria

Latest Comment (4 total)

Rick: Yes , but it is insignificant

a pier

some sheds

and nothing more More