map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

'Berlin Wall's Lessons For Today'

In an op-ed for "USA Today," Jeffrey Gedmin discusses RFE and the role of free media in societies living under repressive regimes. More
More Articles

Features

Half-Abkhaz, Half-Georgian -- One Woman Fights To Preserve Ethnic Heritage

June 25, 2009
By Brian Whitmore

Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.



Lela Avidzba reads the poem "The Knight In The Panther's Skin" by Shota Rustaveli (in the original Georgian, Russian, and Abkhaz).


TBILISI -- Lela Avidzba is a rarity -- an Abkhaz who is fluent in the Abkhaz language.

According to most estimates, up to one-third of Abkhaz cannot speak their language, even on a basic level. Even fewer can read or write it. The dominant language in Abkhazia -- which broke from Georgian rule after a bitter war in the early 1990s, and saw its de facto independence recognized by Moscow last August -- is Russian.

Avidzba's mastery of her intricate native tongue -- with its bewildering, 64-letter alphabet and complex phonetics, is remarkable. Making it all the more remarkable is the fact that she is actually half-Georgian, and lives not in Abkhazia, but the Georgian capital, Tbilisi.

Hers was one of the thousands of families torn apart by the 1992-93 war between Georgian forces and Abkhaz nationalists looking to break free from Tbilisi's control. About 15,000 people were killed, and hundreds of thousands of ethnic Georgians were expelled from Abkhaz territory.

Avidzba, an effusive 32-year-old with light brown hair, was born to a Georgian mother and an Abkhaz father, was a teenager living in the Abkhaz capital Sukhumi when the war broke out. Her parents sent her to Tbilisi for safety, but remained in Abkhazia themselves.

Avidzba's father, Sergei, died in 2006. Her mother, Luisa, still lives in Sukhumi, but Avidzba, who is no longer welcome in her homeland, is unable to see her.

Avidzba was detained and interrogated for several days while visiting her ailing father in Sukhumi. Since her father's death, Abkhaz authorities have denied Avidzba permission to visit her relatives in the territory altogether.

Torn Between Nations

Avidzba says that the walls that have been erected between the Abkhaz and Georgian peoples are as artificial as those separating her family.

Lela Avidzba doesn't know when she'll see her mother again.
"We lived together our whole lives. Abkhaz and Georgian cultures are indivisible," Avidzba says.

"There are common traditions and mixed families. My mother is Georgian and my father was Abkhaz. This is the worst possible situation for a family to be in. Both sides are a part of me."

Easily conversant in Georgian and Abkhaz -- as well as in Russian -- Avidzba has worked tirelessly to bridge the gaps between her two nations.

She is raising her son Nikolas to speak both Georgian and Abkhaz. As a spokeswoman for the Georgian government, she is one of the most prominent Abkhaz in Tbilisi, and even hosts a talk show in the Abkhaz language on Georgian television.

Inching Toward Reconciliation


In 2004, together with her mother, Avidzba helped organize a visit to Georgia for Abkhaz children who lost parents in the 1992-93 war. She said the children relaxed at a spa, toured Tbilisi, and met Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili.

"When the children left -- and they were little children -- they wrote letters saying, 'Georgia, we love you and want to come back,'" Avidzba says. "But unfortunately, [in Abkhazia] they hear something completely different [about Georgians]."

Avidzba says she harbors no illusions that such gestures of reconciliation can overcome the deep animosity Abkhaz feel for Georgians, but she is nevertheless determined to persevere.

"I don't know whether it was due to a lack of strength, or euphoria [over independence], but nobody was able to stand up and prevent what has happened," Avidzba says.

"Time is not on our side. A new generation is growing up [in Abkhazia] that has never seen a Georgian and doesn't know what they're really like. For them, a Georgian is simply an enemy."
This forum has been closed.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 4
by: Soxumeli from: San Francisco
July 19, 2009 16:21
Dear Metin,
Arguments used by you are copy cats of those I have heard for years. When you know something based on what you have heard or read is one thing, but when you know something because you witnessed it all, it is totally different. This is where you and I differ from each-other. I was in Sokhumi in July 1989, as well as August 1992. I lost members of my family, aunt and grandmother, after Abkhazian forces (with great help of Russian armed forces) occupied Sokhumi in September 1992. So, please, let's not try to bring facts, when you probably don't know most of them, and/or how they occurred.
I think what people in Abkhazia don't seem to understand is that from the start, the path chosen was the wrong one. One thing is to gain de-facto independence from Georgia, but more important is to first be able to maintain it and then to be recognized as such. When world leaders look at Abkhazia, all they see is a pawn in the hand of Russia, ready to sell everything and anything. Whether you like it or not, Abkhazia has made significant mistakes in the process, which is justified with the outcome. With no independence, discredited, impoverished, and no prospects for the future, your people achieved the worst result it could have in a given situation. Time will help you understand what I am saying here, if you don't know it yet.

by: Zviad Kavteli from: Ann Arbor, MI, USA
July 18, 2009 23:20
Abkhazians will soon realize that their deal with the Evil Empire (Russia) does not benefit them. Russia is not interested in Abkhazian independence, Russia is interested in domination of entire Georgia (including Abkhazia).

Russia has succeeded in turning Abkhazians and Georgians against each other. But Russia will collapse itself, just like USSR did.

by: Metin from: Ankara
July 16, 2009 11:26
An useful quote for Soxumeli:

Contrary to various misinformed reports, Abkhazia did not declare independence from Georgia either before, during, or upon its victory in, the war. Throughout years of negotiations, Abkhazia was willing to contemplate making a concession and to enter confederal relations with Georgia. And let it not be forgotten that for most of the 1990s, especially when Shevardnadze-protegé Andrej Kozyrev served as Boris Yeltsin’s Foreign Minister, Russia’s policy was by no means pro-Abkhazian, a CIS-blockade being imposed along Abkhazia’s River Psou border with Russia. But let us see what I had to say on this matter in my earlier review: ‘Abkhazia did not formally declare independence until 12 October 1999. And this was in large measure the result of frustration at continuing bad faith on the part of Tbilisi in post-war negotiations. Pace Cornell (p.192), it has not been the Abkhazians who have refused to compromise — one might say that after their military victory, they were fully entitled to declare independence at once (September 1993), and yet they continued to pursue federative possibilities, whilst all that Georgia has offered is a return to the status quo ante bellum (some compromise from Georgia!). After protracted talks and constant last-minute revisions by Georgia a Protocol was ready for presidential signing in summer 1997, and yet at the last minute Tbilisi (not Sukhum) refused (Abkhazian Foreign Ministry Document 325, 25 Dec 1997). Such petty obstructionism continues, for in February 2001 Georgia's UN Ambassador, P’et’re Chkheidze, refused to sign two draft-documents, claiming them “unacceptable for the government of Georgia” — as the respected commentator, Liz Fuller, noted in her Radio Liberty report (4.5, 2 Feb 2001): “Chkheidze's criticism is surprising as the versions of both drafts currently under discussion were proposed by the Georgian side”.’

http://circassianworld.blogspot.com/2009/06/reply-to-svante-cornells-daily.html

by: Metin from: Ankara
July 16, 2009 11:24
Dear Soxumeli,

I would like to answer with Stanislav Lakoba's speach in 1993.

Well, almost - for such news-agencies as Reuters, AP, the BBC, whenever they refer to us, our standard epithets are ‘separatists’ and ‘rebels’... How is it that we are separatists when we are actually not separating from anybody or attacking anybody? Are there any resolutions of the Abkhazian Parliament adopted before August 14 1992 (or even several months afterwards) which have declared secession from Georgia? There is not one! In fact, it was the Abkhazian side that suggested building our relations with Georgia on an agreed, federative basis. Therefore, it was the Abkhazian side which came out with proposals that would preserve the unity of Georgia. The response was the despatch to Abkhazia of tanks, fighter-bombers and guardsmen armed to the teeth...

We are being forced into a separatist-position by the actual separatists reigning in Tbilisi who are busy destroying their own country. They have cast their country, the unity of which was supported by the bayonets of the Stalinist Soviet Empire, back to the feudal division of the Middle Ages. The so-called separatists from Adjaria, Mingrelia, Kakhetia (not to mention Abkhazia and Ossetia) are taking up an all-round defensive position against the central power in Tbilisi. The question is: «Why are there so many ‘separatists’ in Georgia?»
(Abkhazia is Abkhazia by S. Lakoba)

There is constant misrepresentation in the West or pro-Georgia propaganda that Abkhazia is led by a gang of separatists. I would reccommend those people to tell a fable to their kids: "There is separatis country ruled by separatist government and there are separatist children drinking separatist milk and separatist old people in the streets and they drive separatist car. Everything could be Ok with them and they could look like us but there is one thing that distinguish them from us - they are separatists, they are not people so we have to kill them all"

Refugees is always a big problem and it was NOT Abkhazia who bare responsibility for them - it is Georgia that STARTED the war and created huge humanitarian catastrophy. By the way Georgian population fled before Abkhaz Army entered the occupied territories. (See UNPO 1993 Report) [THE MAJORITY OF GEORGIANS, HOWEVER, FLED BEFORE ABKHAZIAN AND NORTHERN CAUCASUS TROOPS ARRIVED.]

And as i said before, some of them fought in Georgian side against to Abkhazians.

According to the 1951 UN Convention on Refugees, those who use arms in an armed struggle and then flee do not fall under the international definition of refugees. The responsibility for these people fell and falls solely on the Georgian authorities. It is important to note here that a great many of those who fled from Abkhazia were recent immigrants. They were partly victims of the compulsory resettlement organized by Stalin and his Abkhazian-born Mingrelian lieutenant Lavrenti Beria.

You lost Abkhazia forever. Abkhazia is NOT Georgia - Abkhazia is Abkhazia.

This is a reality and you should understand this reality. Other wise - sweet dreams...

by: Soxumeli from: San Francisco
July 15, 2009 19:01
Dear Abkhazian,

When a separatist government, such as the one that of Ardzinba, achieves it's goal to secede using internationally condemned and prohibited act of ethnic cleansing, Abkhazians have discredited themselves to a degree which is not reparable and no one in the world can do more damage to the legitimacy of your claim for independence than you yourself had done already. Even if you claim for independence was based on valid arguments, by committing an ethnic cleansing of Georgian population, Abkhazians made kind of mistake, consequences and shadow of which will never be forgiven and/or forgotten.
I understand that Abkhazians were given assurances from Russia, that it was OK to do this and that Abkhazia would, eventually be independent, but oblivious and inexperienced to the current world order, Abkhazians walked into carefully set up trap through which not only you will not be recognized by anyone but Russia, but time will come when Abkhazia will be begging Russia to accept it as a part of its territory.

Unfortunately, current reality is grim, and even worse that will follow that grim reality will only get grimmer. Embracing it fully now, will help you leave the fantasy world and come back to reality on time, while it's not too late!

by: Abkhazian from: Cener of Sukhum
July 08, 2009 08:40
REPRESENTATIVES OF ABKHAZIA NOT GRANTED VISAS TO GERMANY TO “PEACE CAMP” ORGANIZED BY COUNCIL OF EUROPE

From July 5 till July 12 in Germany the Council of Europe has organized Youth “Peace Camp” on conflicts settlement and transformation. Young men and women from Abkhazia could not go to the camp because of difficulties with visas.
According to the co-director of the Sukhum house of youth Aida Ladariya, two months ago for the first time Abkhazia was offered to take part in a meeting organized by the Council of Europe in cooperation with the German "Europa Park". Representatives from Palestine, Cyprus, Northern Cyprus, Georgia, Abkhazia and South Ossetia should have taken part in this camp.
“We were glad to be invited as it gave a chance to the Abkhaz youth to be heard by the international community. Unfortunately, the world hears only one side of the conflict, namely Georgia”, Aida Ladariya said.
http://www.abkhaziagov.org/en/news/detail.php?ID=20370


by: Abkhazian from: Sukhum
July 08, 2009 07:57
The Abkhaz young people and from South Ossetia were denied to get visas by teh Coucil of Eirope
Congratulations to teh minister Iakobashvili , let Ilona convet=y it to him , He is succeeding in dicsrimination of the right to move , or the human rights declaration is written just for the rest of the world and not for the Abkhaz or Ossetians ?

by: Abkhazia from: Sukhum
July 06, 2009 08:13
TO ALAVERDI
It is better for you to see at reality with open and not dreaming eyes
I understand that you , I mean Georgians lost such a paradise which once you were “invited “ and implanted ono the blessed Abkhaz soil , and just you could not appreciate living here together , quietly and in respect.
Because you could not understand it , this land , which is mine not yours .
You brought just suffer , just death to many of us , just destruction . Now your words are just words , empty and meaningless as yet you have not realized what have you done , and it seems you do not stop. These beautiful words as “ jewels “ and peace , you are uttering are so blasphemous so I have just nothing to say to you more.


by: Alaverdi
July 04, 2009 21:47
Kartvelians do not exist.
The collective word for all Georgians is -GEORGIAN.
The Kartlelians (v is missing) are a small Georgian tribe , Migrelians are also small Georgian tribe.
Abkhazians are similar to Megrelians & a little to Svanian.
Horrors that happen are too numerous & neither side is free of the guilt.
We all have personal tragedies that involves us into this conflict.

But the issue of Abkhazia is far more then my personal grief, grief for the people who are my family.

To those that want to suggest otherwise - these people I know never held fire arms in their hands,they lived in Sokhumi & Gali for generations after generations, but they had to suffer death of the loved ones & eviction from their homes. They had to run under the immediate threat of the death or/and the rape. The remaining Georgians is Gali & Ochamchire region are isolated, unprotected living & suffering in their historical Samurzakano.
Civilians do not carry firearms (crime by law) in the part of the Georgia that is governed by the state Government. However rebels are all armed. This is why they are not allowed past the check points - they are dangerous to the peaceful civilians.
But enough about details - they are too many, too personal & all sides have their own experience, their own complains & their own grief because their neighbors brought to Abkhazia laws of the serial killers. It is our shared pain , shared history & shared SHAME. Even if I never been less liberal then I am today, I share the guilt with Abkhazians because they are my country men, & share the guilt with other Gerogian Tribes involved in these atrocities because they are my country men.
Great thing about the life is all will end, even most horrible experiences have to end somehow & peace should emerge. I wish, hope & actively promote PEACE to all people who are willing to listen because I love my country not in bits of pieces, but I love my Georgia as whole, I cherish every part of her, i enjoy diversity of the gifts & talents of our People. When Georgia is well we can all prosper, when she is wounded we all suffer her wounds.
You claim you love Abkhazia then you should understand my undying love for my Country that includes Abkhazia.



by: Metin from: Ankara
July 04, 2009 10:20
We know very well that many Georgians fought against to Abkhazians in Georgian side. According to the 1951 UN Convention on Refugees, those who use arms in an armed struggle and then flee do not fall under the international definition of refugees. The responsibility for these people fell and falls solely on the Georgian authorities. It is important to note here that a great many of those who fled from Abkhazia were recent immigrants. They were partly victims of the compulsory resettlement organized by Stalin and his Abkhazian-born Mingrelian lieutenant Lavrenti Beria.

Another important fact to consider on the question of Kartvelian displaced persons is that their number is regularly exaggerated by the Georgian authorities. Some of them have never left Abkhazia and others never lived there. The Georgian authorities have engineered a home-aspect to the conflict in Abkhazia by establishing a so-called "government in exile of the Autonomous Republic of Abkhazia”. Through the deliberate exaggeration of the number of IDPs, Georgia is able to win support and money from international humanitarian organizations. [According to the 1989 census there were only 239,872 "Georgians" living in Abkhazia]

Abkhazian society can allow the return ONLY of those Kartvelians who did NOT FIGHT on the Georgian side and only after they RECOGNIZE Abkhazia as an independent state. And the same right for return should be given also to descendants of Abkhazian refugees from the Caucasian War of the XIX century, who live mostly in Turkey.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 4
TEXT SIZE - +

Follow Us On Twitter

Keep up-to-date on all the latest news from RFE/RL's broadcast region by following us on Twitter:
~ You can find our instant news feed at @RFE_RLNEWS.
~ An obsessive Kremlin watcher? Follow our blog at @PowerVertical.
~ Human rights abuses chronicled at @RightsWatchdog.
~ News, comment, and the odd silly dictator story at @TransmissionRFE.

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile