Monday, February 13, 2012


News

'Moral Outrage' As Iranian Court Upholds Student's Death Sentence

A protester holds stones as he faces off against security forces in Tehran during antigovernment protests on December 27. Mohammad Amin Valian has been sentenced to death for similar behavior during the rallies.
TEXT SIZE - +
By Golnaz Esfandiari
Twenty-year-old Mohammad Amin Valian, a student at Iran's Damghan University, could be executed at any time.

Several opposition websites have reported that an appeals court has upheld the death sentence against Valian in connection with a December antigovernment protest. He is among at least 11 people sentenced to death in trials following the protests that erupted after last year's disputed presidential election.

Aaron Rhodes, a spokesman with the International Campaign for Human Rights In Iran, tells RFE/RL that Valian has been convicted of "moharebeh" or "waging war against God," based on a photo taken during a protest on the December 27 religious holiday of Ashura.

"He was charged with moharebeh, which is just about the most serious charge that anybody in Iran can be charged with," Rhodes says. "And what this guy did -- he is a bright young student who was politically active -- he took part in several demonstrations, not as a leader but he was photographed throwing some rocks. And on the basis of those photographs he's received those charges."

During the Ashura holiday, opposition members launched fresh antigovernment protests in Tehran and several other cities. Bloody clashes were reported and dozens of protesters were arrested; at least eight were killed.

Religious Family

The opposition website "Iran Green Voice" reports that the judge who issued the initial moharebeh verdict referred to a speech by a senior cleric, Ayatollah Makarem Shirazi, who had reportedly said that "desecrators of Ashura" are "mohareb," or enemies of God.

Any number of others could be similarly accused, convicted, and face being hung.
The website, which has called for a campaign to save Valian from death, says that the student comes from a religious family and that his activities have always been within the framework of the law. According to the website, there have been no proven links whatsoever between Valian and groups and organizations outlawed in Iran.

Valian is a member of the reformist Islamic Association at his university in the northern town of Damghan. He reportedly campaigned for opposition leader and defeated presidential candidate Mir Hossein Musavi, who has said that last June's presidential vote was massively rigged in favor of President Mahmud Ahmadinejad.

It is not clear when he was arrested, but he went on trial in early February.

'Moral Outrage'


Rhodes describes the death sentence against Valian as a "complete moral outrage."

"It's an attempt to intimidate other students, other young people like him, who just want to exercise their basic human rights and their political rights," Rhodes says. "Any number of others could be similarly accused, convicted, and face being hung." Rhodes says the "grossly disproportionate sentence" devalues the life of a promising young man.

A prominent human rights lawyer, Abdol Fatah Soltani, tells RFE/RL's Radio Farda that the charge of moharebeh is being misused by Iranian judicial authorities. "None of those who are being arrested in protest demonstrations can be charged with moharebeh because they participate in peaceful protests and they're after their civil rights," Soltani says. "The essential condition for moharebeh is when someone has taken up arms and attacked people and created riots."

Soltani believes that throwing stones does not rise to the charge of moharebeh. The Iranian authorities have said that five arrested in connection with the Ashura unrest have been charged with moharebeh.

Iran has so far executed two people sentenced in trials following the postelection unrest that has plunged the Islamic republic into its worse crisis since the revolution. Mohammad Reza Ali Zamani and Arash Rahmani Pour were hanged on January 28 after being charged with moharebeh over their membership in an exiled monarchist group that aims at overthrowing the Islamic regime. The two had been reportedly arrested before the presidential vote.

Radio Farda broadcaster Elahe Ravanshad contributed to this report
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Hamik C Gregory from: Reno, NV USA
March 03, 2010 20:57
Instead of being inspired by the divine Islamic verses and prayers which begin with these sublime words “ In the name of God the Compassionate, the Merciful”, the Islamic judge in Iran has decided to be inspired by Ayatollah Mokarram-e Shirazi who is an imperfect human being! God being Compassionate and Merciful has repeatedly forgiven those who have waged war against him but the judiciary in Iran can not! Something is wrong with this picture!

by: Me from: here
March 04, 2010 04:03
How can we as logical, compassionate human beings not comment on this insanity? This young mans life can be so easily and dispassionately be snuffed out because he threw some stones? What are the so called authorities so afraid of? The audacity of their disproportionate sentence speaks volumes about their fear of losing their stranglehold on the Iranian people. There is evil in charge in Iran.

by: Teymur from: Baku
March 04, 2010 08:02
Don't they understand that by condemning this innocent guy to death they only further enrage the millions of young people all over Iran ?

by: sirivanhoe98 from: Sydney Australia
March 04, 2010 11:55
A weak regime, under public pressure to reform itself will only react with more draconian measures to remain in power.

At a public meeting in a village, the local residents pressed Ahmedinajad for not completing delivering better basic services such as water and power to rural communities, he responds by playing the USA and Israel card to deflect attention from his own failures.

"Poor? I will tell you who is poor. There are 40 mil people in USA who do not have insurance, and live below the poverty line. Do we want Satan to tell us what to do? "No" the crowd respond. Israel...etc etc.

This is the only way they remain in power.

Meanwhile, the ruling class has enriched itself beyond belief with secret Swiss bank accounts. The central bank even doctors up the financial accounts to conceal the exodus of tens of billions of dollars from its coffers.

They will have to be thrown out the same way they came to power. The same way Marcos was deposed. People power.



by: Bill Webb from: Phoenix, AZ, U.S.A.
March 04, 2010 14:27
The iranian government cannot claim any democratic principles at all. That wasn't an election. They claim Islam "allows" them to manipulate the election results. Now they claim it "compels" them to develope a nuclear arsenal. They just read whatever they want into the Kuran.They are just tyrants and the cow jumped over the moon.

by: Abdulmajid
March 05, 2010 00:52
Justice murder with the intent to intimidate and silence those who would stand up to a clerical-fascist dictatorship! Which the people have all the right in the world to get rid of, for the Islamic republic of Iran has done NOTHING to better the living of its people. Nobody in his right mind would deny that teh Iranian regime is evil, but from there do conclusde that Islam, that Muslims are inherently evil, that is unacceptable. So, bombing or even nuking them would be just as despicable, and if the Americans imposed another dictatorship on them, this time a US-friendly one this would not help a bit. See Iraq and Afghanistan. Complete, utter chaos. You want more of that? Unfortunately the Americans only got it right in Germany and in Japan. The Iranian people stand alone. Between a rock and a hard place. This is absolutely the nadir. It tarnishes the image of Islam. Nobody should want this type of dictatorship. Compared to what the Ayatollahs are, even Hassan II of Morocco was a nice old fellow. Nobody should say that that is Islam. They misuse Islam much in the same way the Inquisition misused Catholicism. Yet, nobody should say this can only happen in Muslim countries. Corrupt and repressive regimes exist in Christian Latin America, in many non-Muslim African countries, and nobody would say China or Russia are Muslim countries. Or that Japan up to 1945 was one, now would they? All "anti-imperialists", including many who post here, praise Sandinista Nicaragua or Chavez Venezuela for standing up to the USA in the 1980s and they forgot that although the people may have been in the right, the regime was (and indeed is) just exactly as repressive and corrupt, or even more so, as the previous ones. Sadly, it seems unlikely that in Iran it can be overthrown. This was their Tiananmen.
And I am surprised at how someone (you know who I mean) can make quite reasonable and plausible statements here, but on another issue that same person can be so completely obtuse and medieval, it certainly shows me what he is like. I first wanted to dismiss his constant rant as immature teenage prattle, now I realize that he is up to par with the very most cunning of "them", and that while his statements on that particular theme may seem obtuse and moronic, he certainly isn't. Which makes it all only worse. But what I don't understand is how here he can intercede for a Muslim people and in other circumstances he wants another Muslim people wasted. In any case, nobody should even think that the clerics and politicians in his mother country are one bit better than the clerical-fascist regime in Iran. But just so you know, I am not interested in entering a discussion with someone who is a declared and avowed enemy of people who have my sympathy.

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

U.S. Hearing On Balochistan Raises Hackles, Awareness In Pakistan

Latest Comment (1 total)

akram: It shows why pakistanis mistrust americans,US has plan for balkanization of pakistan and ... More

Jolie Earns Serbian Scorn For War Film

Latest Comment (86 total)

Abdulmajid: Well said, e.t., and I appreciate very much your qualifying 1992-95 as the ... More

Iran To Make Nuclear Announcement

Latest Comment (13 total)

Ivan: @ Jack from Upper Siberia, he only Official connection is Russia=Syria=Iran=Hamas=Hizbolla More