map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

'Berlin Wall's Lessons For Today'

In an op-ed for "USA Today," Jeffrey Gedmin discusses RFE and the role of free media in societies living under repressive regimes. More
More Articles

Features

Kosovo Fights Serbia -- As Serbia Fights Everybody

Tens of thousands marched in Pristina.

November 20, 2008
By Daisy Sindelar
Thousands of angry Kosovars demonstrated in central Pristina on November 19. Carrying banners and chanting "No division -- we want to be sovereign," the crowd protested recent steps by the United Nations to weaken the mandate of the incoming European Union mission.

The 2,000-strong mission -- comprising police, judicial, and customs officials -- was envisioned to take over from UNMIK, the United Nations mission that has helped govern Kosovo as a Serbian province since 1999. It is still tentatively due to begin operating in December.

Kosovo, which emerged from years of Serbian control with an independence declaration in February, has eagerly awaited the deployment of the EU mission, known as EULEX, as a sign that its long journey toward statehood was in the final lap.

Last week, however, the United Nations -- which still maintains the UN Mission in Kosovo -- upended those expectations, putting forward a six-point plan amending the EULEX role.

The plan, presented by UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, proposes two separate chains of command for ethnic-Albanian and ethnic-Serbian police officers in Kosovo. In Albanian-majority areas, police would serve under the EU umbrella. In northern Kosovo, which is mainly Serbian, law enforcement would fall under UN administration.

Such a plan would also require EULEX, like UNMIK before it, to act as a "status-neutral" mission -- that is, not formally aligned with Kosovo's self-designation as an independent state.

Kosovars reject the plan outright, saying it amounts to a de facto partition of their territory. Activist Albin Kurti, addressing the Pristina protesters, said the people of Kosovo will never accept the plan.

"They claim that EULEX will be neutral in regard to status," Kurti shouted to loud calls from the crowd. "This neutrality means being unbiased toward two sides. In terms of the Kosovo issue, this implies that there are two sides -- Kosovo and Serbia."

Bad Neighbors

The plan appears to be a sop to Belgrade, which continues to reject Kosovo statehood and defend the rights of its Serbian brethren in Kosovo.

The UN is under pressure to accommodate Security Council member Russia, a Belgrade ally. And Brussels, which appeared to tentatively back the UN plan, is eager to keep restive Serbia on a slow-but-steady path toward EU membership.

The terms of the six-point plan do not appear to be final. U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Daniel Fried this week said Washington supports the deployment of EULEX "as soon as possible" and in a way that would overcome the objections of Kosovo's leadership.

EU foreign-policy chief Javier Solana and UN chief Ban are due to meet on November 21 to discuss the EULEX deployment, and Kosovar leaders are in London with hopes of persuading British Prime Minister Gordon Brown to tip the negotiations in their favor.

Serbia, however, appears confident. Foreign Minister Vuk Jeremic says Belgrade has received guarantees the six-point plan will not be changed, and that a Security Council session on Kosovo may take place as early as November 24 or 25.

If true, it's a lone bright spot in what is proving a time of troubles for Serbia, whose ties with its Balkan neighbors are growing increasingly fractious.

Belgrade recently expelled the ambassadors from Macedonia and Montenegro after those countries opted to recognize Kosovo's statehood. And the UN's main judicial body, the International Court of Justice (ICJ), announced this week it would hear a genocide case filed by Croatia against Serbia stemming back to the Balkan wars of the early 1990s.

The announcement has reopened old wounds, with many Serbian officials and commentators expressing outrage at what they see as Croatian hypocrisy.

Speaking on Serbian state television, Jeremic lashed out at Croatia, saying Belgrade will file a countersuit with the ICJ to bring Zagreb to account for its own military actions targeting ethnic Serbs.

"I'm very sorry that Croatia didn't accept our offer to make peace -- an offer that Serbia has made more than once," Jeremic said. "They have refused to face the fact that 250,000 Serbs were themselves victims of ethnic cleansing, and now they will have to face it in front of the International Court of Justice."

Fractious Union

The rift appears to underscore Serbia's reputation as the scrappy black sheep of the Balkan neighborhood, and comes at a time when the international community is largely distracted by the global economic crisis and the pending political transition in the United States.

Kosovo Serbs hold pictures of people who went missing or were killed in Kosovo.
But Serbia's troubles with its neighbors, including the intractable standoff with Kosovo, are also in part the result of a fractured EU policy that has failed to settle on a unified stance in Brussels' dealing with the Balkans.

Although 22 of the 27 EU states have recognized Kosovo independence -- Cyprus, Spain, Romania, Greece, and Slovakia being the holdouts -- the lack of unanimity has made it difficult for the EU to stay firm on Balkan policy.

This includes the original EULEX mandate, which was based on the plan for Kosovo's internationally monitored independence drafted in 2007 by the UN's special envoy for Kosovo, Martti Ahtisaari, this year's Nobel Peace Prize laureate.

That plan envisioned a complete transfer of mission responsibilities from UNMIK to EULEX, and was based on Kosovo independence and territorial integrity.

This month, however, Pierre Mirel, the head of the European Commission's western Balkans division, said the EU had "accepted" that EULEX would not be related to the Ahtisaari plan, and would not proceed without Security Council approval.

Pieter Feith, the EU's current Kosovo representative, shot back that Mirel's comments "are not the EU's official position."

James Lyon, a Balkans expert with the Democratization Policy Council, says trying to get Brussels to come together on any Kosovo issue "is always very difficult."

"There's a great deal of confusion on this, because the EU representatives here in Serbia were coming out and saying that this plans is acceptable, whereas we had Pieter Feith saying it's not acceptable and it isn't the EU's position," Lyon says.

"So obviously the EU bureaucrats are not singing off the same sheet of music. As far as whether the plan is acceptable or not, there's the sense that the EU is floundering on this."

Such "floundering" can be felt in protracted administrative and legal chaos throughout Kosovo, with Albanian and Serbian institutions often working in parallel, or not at all. "The international community has wasted almost a year in terms of establishing an effective mission there," Lyon says.

Brussels may also face difficulties in factoring its tenuous relationship with Russia into the balance. The EU recently resumed partnership talks with Moscow after a chilly spell brought on by Russia's war with Georgia in August. Now, with ties growing warmer, some observers worry that Kosovo may prove a casualty of the EU's zeal to appease Moscow and its Serbian ally.

Richard Giragosian, an analyst specializing in security and military issues based in Yerevan, says the EU should not allow recent events in the South Caucasus to reshape its stance on Kosovo.

"We see an attempt by the European Union to try to perhaps move closer to the Serbian position," he says. "I would also say, from a U.S. military point of view in terms of on-the-ground security, that we're entering a dangerous phase now for guaranteeing the security and viability for the infant institutions of Kosovo."

"The real burden for the West and for the European Union," Giragosian adds, "is to support those infant institutions."

RFE/RL's South Slavic and Albanian Languages Service contributed to this report
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 3
by: Drazen
December 17, 2008 22:10
What Genocide? Who and how many were exactly killed in Kosovo to call it a genocide?
What happened in Kosovo and is still happening is called ethnic cleansing. Both sides contributed to it. Today Serbs are the ones being cleansed out of Kosovo.
It seems like a lot of Albanians don`t like to mention what happened after 1999, and all of you probably know too well what happened.
@ Matija. We or Tito did give Kosovo freedom (Autonomy and voice in Yugoslav affairs) but Milosevic took it away this is what triggered all those riots in Pristina. Albanians were being kicked out of their jobs and they were discriminated against. Serb police, under Milosevic at that time, beat the rioters and made sure no one herd about the riots. Serbs complained to Milosevic that they were being oppressed by the Albanians. All that Bull mostly Albanians mention of how they were good friends with their Serb neighbor is obviously for the most part no true.
After 1999, when the Serbs had no one to protect them (since NATO and UN soldiers didn`t really care) returning Albanians started to attack Serbs and Serb sites(Graves, churches, monasteries, homes etc.). I didn't mention the KLA since they were a minor pest for the JNA. They only started getting somewhat better when the Americans started to train them.
Countless other atrocities happened such as organ selling, rape etc.
So watch Who you call Hitler and Nazis. Your technics are no better then German when they decided not to teach about WWII after it happened.
As for the "Danubian Pirates", which fairy tail is this from?

by: Naim from: Prishtina
December 09, 2008 11:30
This message is to you all not living in Kosova. I have gone through some comments, and I would ask: What you have done to contribute peace? Or what do you know about reallity in Kosovo war? You might forget about what you heard on the news on 1998-1999 ? But we Albanians will never forget!!! Kosova is and will remain indipendent as long as we live!!! If all of us die it will be different for sure but as long as we survive the serbian rule has ended in 1999!!! And It is strange that even after 10 years of war and 9 years after it seems that serbs had no enough bloodshed? Their propaganda is focused on hate, and war, even the serbian orthodox church contributing in that hate? while we call for peace. We still have araound 7000 missing persons, where are they? Even despite that we offer them peace, rights, but they dont want them we have continues provocative behaviour in every occasion they can get even they are minority of 4%, and we continue to hope for peace. I would say to all of you who are supporters to the serbian genocide.... Kosova is a state that will try to contribute to the peace on the region and to reoccupy Kosova it is only a dream for you my enemies. It is end now the real world knows who you are your face in the surface now and it will remain there. The modern world does not like your aggresion. As far as crime export to you miss whatsoever, lookk at your country back home and your serbian pirats in Danub river (just like in somalia), let us live in peace and look kyour own bussiness there!!!

by: Ivo
November 29, 2008 16:13
'Thousands of angry Kosovars demonstrated in central Pristina on November 19. Carrying banners and chanting "No division -- we want to be sovereign,"[...]'

Nothing new on the hypocrisy front: It's perfectly acceptable to let the Albanians in Kosovo secede from Serbian rule, but it's a major no-no to give the Serbs in Kosovo the same right.

Somehow we totally forgot about territorial integrity just to let Kosovo part and now again territorial integrity is a holy principle.

The Serbs should grow the hell up once and for all, and give up their 'cradle' and maybe also realize they don't need a whole province full of people who can't stand them and vice versa. The divorce of the forced marriage between Serbs and Albanians has been only partially implemented and it needs to be taken to the end.

by: shqiptar from: united kingdom
November 25, 2008 22:21
Hello everyone.Very interesting to read all this comments even most of them are full with hate and sadness.Well..Big fish eat the small fish and when you are small fish you need to be lucky to survive.Serbs thinks that kosova is theirs and albanians think kosova is theirs.The truth can be find by reading independent historians that have wrote the truth and only the truth.If you read serbian historians you get a very different story then reading other historians.The simple fact is that we live in this era and we must accept the game how is played between big powers.At the moment the big player is USA.They take decisions and they change laws, break them, replace them therefore they do anything they want.In kosova's case they helped to liberate them from the serbian murder,millosevic but this it comes with price.Nothing is free, especially if you are a very small fish like kosova and especially you have a very strategic location in balkan which can help to supervise many contries around and in long term. Politics are always dirty and always are innocent people that die.It is time for serbs and kosovan to leave in peace.Another war does not help neither of them and will not be winners either.Kosova has gone from serbian's hand forever and they should accept it.Kosova is moving towards europe and in years to come will be more stronger and secure and protected by europe becouse it is on their own interest.Russia is not a superpower anymore as it liked to be therefore serb's allie is not too strong to help them.Maybe in years to come things will change and we do not know what will happen.In mean time let leave in peace.

by: Matija from: Tbilisi
November 24, 2008 19:51
@Ariana -
sorry for mispelling your name.
With all due respect, I urge you to check on the facts. UN was deployed in Croatia, BiH and eventually Kososvo. They were the so called 'tampon zones' during the nineties. Nothing to do with Belgrade.

Despite the fact that all the actual self-governing standards were given to your people in my country it seems it's been way too little. Freedom to Pakistanis of Bradford, then!

As far as having nothing to do with Serbia is concerned, I accept that. Firstly,too much blood and hatred's been shed.Secondly, despite everything said by official Belgrade, I find it hard to believe that Serbia, would actually wish to once again govern an ethnically cleansed region with over 40% unemployment rate. The only export of Kososvo nowadays is crime.

Serbia might want its natural resources and industry back and I guess this is the only reason why we're still paying your (Kososvo's) external debt, but I don't think we shall ever (or for that matter, should ever) live together. Too much crap to overcome.
This is the exact reason why the Serbs who are left in Kosovo will never accept Albanian rule. And why we'll probably surge into another war if your government decides to claim 'sovereignty' on Serbian enclaves.

Whatever happens, I hope that common sense will prevail. States built on violence are doomed. We've proved it. Try to be more tolerant and smarter than us.

Well, as my first conatct with a Kosovo Albanian (had a few of Albanian friends but they were all born and living in Belgrade), I have a pledge.
Please, don't burn our churches.
They've been there for a long time and are a part of UNESCOs world heritage.
One more thing. Leave the peonies. The legend may say they're rooted in the hearts of fallen Serbian knights, but that's hardly a reason to pluck them Leave'em be, and they'll make the vales of 'Independent Kosovo' nicer.


Kind Regards.

by: blbysrb from: Juhoslavia, magic kingdom
November 24, 2008 19:47
Yes, NATO invaded Serbia and stole Kosovo and planted their spies there, because it is all big conspiracy against Serbs, and because of battle in 1389, when we lost, is biggest battle in Serbian minds! We are biggest victims, so our Hit... Milosevic led us to glory and our Lebensraum, hurah! It is NATO and Albright and Muslims and Croats and Albanians, never us!! We will get back Kosovo, just like Germany got back Prussia and the Sudetenland!! Forever!!!!

by: Ariana from: Independent Kosovo
November 24, 2008 13:51
@Matija
My name is Ariana and I don't mind paying the price as long as we're independent and have nothing to do with Serbia. We paid such a high price, it is Serbia's turn now. As for the UN...it may have been deployed in Belgrade, ex Yu never really took anything into consideration when Kosovo was in question.

by: Matija from: Georgia
November 24, 2008 06:02
@adriana
UN has been all over ex Yu ever since the 90ies. SO it is possible.
As far as I'm concerned we've overpaid the price. And as far as 'Independent Kosovo' is concerned, you''l be paying the price to your own leaders in years to come I'm afraid.

by: Max from: Sydney
November 23, 2008 23:27
Ahhhh Daisy daisy daisy. What a neat little article, nice to see you know how to cut an paste. BBC? CNN? Fox news perhaps?? Im sorry, but this is the year 2008, and people are much more informed about the truth and what really happened in the Balkans, specifically Kosovo. The myth of innocent Albanians being slaughtered by evil Serbs has long been exposed. The western experiment in Kosovo has failed, and we will see the return of Kosovo to its rightful owners . . . the Serbs

by: Ariana from: Independent Kosovo
November 23, 2008 17:52
I can not believe some of the comments I red. People, wake up...you're talking about a group of Albanians beating some porr Serb guy. What about a state machinery killing sleeping children, just a reminder, a massacre in Drenica, Likosan, Qirez, Qyshk..shall I go on? And while the machinery "worked" (butchered), Serb pople just stood by and took advantage of privileges offered to them. Why lashing out on Serbia? Because, Serba started the wars in Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia and Kosovo...My God, when are you people going to wake up? An aggressor needs to pay a price, Serbia if you're reading this, February 17th was a price YOU paid.

P.S. Oh, I almost forgot, Mr.Whatever is your name that you claim worked for UN..You could not have worked for almost ten years, the UN is in Kosovo for almost nine years. And its time it goes home.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 3
TEXT SIZE - +

Editors' Picks

President Van Rompuy

'How's That Again?!' Audio

Karzai Inauguration

The Anticipation Of Change Video

Follow Us On Twitter

Keep up-to-date on all the latest news from RFE/RL's broadcast region by following us on Twitter:
~ You can find our instant news feed at @RFE_RLNEWS.
~ An obsessive Kremlin watcher? Follow our blog at @PowerVertical.
~ Human rights abuses chronicled at @RightsWatchdog.
~ News, comment, and the odd silly dictator story at @TransmissionRFE.

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile