map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

'Berlin Wall's Lessons For Today'

In an op-ed for "USA Today," Jeffrey Gedmin discusses RFE and the role of free media in societies living under repressive regimes. More
More Articles

Transmission

Kremlin Guide To America's Top Dissidents

Dmitry Medvedev has less than a week to track down U.S. dissidents.

September 16, 2009
The Kremlin fumed when U.S. President Barack Obama included a meeting with Russian opposition leaders on his Moscow itinerary back in July. At the time, Obama's administration was responding to criticism over its perceived abdication of the moral high ground by downplaying the role of human rights in the formulation of U.S. foreign policy.

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev's critics could hardly accuse him of abandoning Kremlin commitments to human rights, since those commitments have been dubious at best. But he's gone on the offensive anyway.

Russia's de facto No. 2 plans to use a visit this month to the United States for a UN General Assembly and a G-20 summit to turn the tables, according to Itar-Tass:

"I think I should speak to dissidents. Let them tell me what problems the United States has," he told members of the Valdai international debate club on [September 15]. "That won't be bad, considering the Soviet experience."

With less than a week to go before the September 22-25 visit, Medvedev's planning team must be in overdrive.

So we'd like to do our part and suggest a few American dissidents who might fit the Kremlin's bill as the payback date approaches. (Note to Medvedev handlers: American regime-bashers come from both wings of the political spectrum, although they often sound indistinguishable.)

Noam Chomsky -- iconic linguist, lecturer, and voice of the left for decades
For: instant cachet among the beard-stroking intellectual elite of any nation
Against: makes Marx look like a reactionary; kind of stingy with his Facebook friendships

Rush Limbaugh -- combative radio talk show host of the right
For: millions of fawning American listeners every day
Against: you can't get a word in edgewise

Michael Moore -- documentary filmmaker whose enormous success at Cannes earned him powerful enemies in the U.S.
For: revered in many circles
Against: reviled in nearly all the others

Kanye West -- rapper and record producer
For: influential with the young set; feuding with current U.S. president
Against: tends to go off-message

Sarah Palin -- former vice presidential candidate and Alaska governor
For: close neighbor of Russia's; got on great with Pakistan's president; sees America on the verge of slipping into terminal communism
Against: see McCain/Palin '08; sees America on the verge of slipping into terminal communism

Reverend Jeremiah Wright -- former pastor of the Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago who famously inveighed "God damn America!" from the pulpit
For: friends in high places
Against: out of step with said friends

Gus Hall -- American Communist Party leader who stuck with it through years of persecution and the Soviet collapse
For: though now dead, Hall, too, regarded Mikhail Gorbachev and Boris Yeltsin as "a wrecking crew"
Against: symbolic visits to monuments to dead Communists are no longer the preferred Russian photo op

Sean Penn -- Oscar-winning actor/director and political activist
For: lots of showbiz friends and a cozy relationship with the Huffington Post
Against: less disgruntled since January

Christopher Hitchens -- former flame-breathing Trotskyite turned neocon booster
For: dual nationality lends him trans-Atlantic heft
Against: hard to tell whose side he's on; interventionist bent and outspoken atheism could backfire on the Russian leader; he laid waste to Mother Teresa, for goodness sake

Eric Cartman -- vitriolic "South Park" fourth-grader
For: global recognition and an enemy of political correctness
Against: has variously advocated or committed tyranny, piracy, genocide, pedophilia, murder, misogyny, blackmail, hate crimes, rape, and terrorism

Medvedev's handlers might welcome more suggestions. Got any?

-- Andy Heil
This forum has been closed.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 3
by: Justin K from: Windsor, Canada
September 23, 2009 22:23
If Mr. Medvedev would like to speak to REAL American dissidents, not the media's whitewashed version of dissidents. Than NONE of these would be a real perspective from American dissidents. Real dissidents are the ones that are located in Homeland Security's Lexicon document. The political 'extremists' are as follows: 'Ron Paul Supporters', 'Pro-Second Amendment Supporters', '9/11 Truther's', 'Disgruntled Veterans', 'Tax Protesters', 'The Patriot Movement', and 'Militia's'.

So if Mr. Medvedev really does his homework, he will talk to individuals from those specific groups I mentioned above, not as I like to call 'soft' dissidents. I will be writing to Mr. Medvedev tonight explaining to him that he should not be pulled astray to false soft-dissidents, and if he really means well, he should locate and meet LEGITIMATE dissidents, or those who are labelled 'terrorists' though the Patriot Act, and the other Homeland Security/FBI documents.

by: Andy from: Glasgow
September 22, 2009 15:56
Well unlike Russia, our dissidents are free, get published, get big fat salleries and no one pasters them. In fac, they are alive, which is what Russia can't claim for tons of dissidents who end up being killed in daylight because they dissagree with Putin! Russia's hypocricy is as old as the country itself!
Democracy and freedom are built on convinctions not lies!

by: Isoruku from: chicago
September 21, 2009 16:17
Noam Chomsky has "cachet," not "cache." This is a common error made by reporters and others who haven't quite mastered English. "Cachet" rhymes with with "sashay" and means elevated status or style, while "cache" rhymes with "flash" and means a place where something is stored (and in verb form means to store something, such as weapons or gold). CNN goofs on this all the time. Maybe RFE should try harder.

by: Moderator
September 21, 2009 16:17
We're trying, I swear. Thanks for the catch.

by: Hryhoriy from: New York
September 20, 2009 17:16
...although Medvedev will never reveal the 42,153 russians which have been successfully exterminated by both Chechens and Ukrainians on mockal federation territory. Slave Heroyam Chechniyi!

by: Michael Bielawski from: Seoul, S Korea
September 18, 2009 18:11
I wouldn't trust any of these puppets to represent the real opposition to the elite in America. Chomsky??? Michael Moore??? There was a time I followed these people, until I learned that they follow a tight script and give you just enough criticism of government to keep you following them, but they keep you in the left/right illusion, and off course from the real culprits like the Federal Reserve. I would say Webster Tarpley or Alex Jones, both whom are on Russia Today all the time anyway, would be a good start.

by: nader paul kucinich gravel from: the states
September 18, 2009 15:45
Pays the price, works the seasons through
Frozen days, he thinks of you
Cold as ice but he burns for you
Mother Russia, can’t you hear him too?

Mother’s son, freedom’s overdue
Lonely man, he thinks of you
He isn’t done, only lives for you
Mother Russia, can’t you hear him too?

Punished for his written thoughts
Starving for his fame
Working blindly, building blocks
Number for a name, his blood flows frozen to the snow

Red blood, white snow
He knows frozen rivers wont flow
So cold, so true
Mother Russia…he cries for you

by: Michael Udel from: Guangzhou, China
September 18, 2009 14:15
Alex Jones is the loudest voice in the alternative media and a leading documentary filmmaker exposing the lies of the US Govt as well as other world leaders. He also strongly defended Russia's response to the US/Israeli led Georgian attacks on 8/8/08.

by: Annwas from: Cincy
September 18, 2009 13:36
I am one such dissident, and I would like to speak to the Russian President when he comes to the united states.

by: Nick from: Denver
September 18, 2009 05:34
Why the hell are you all putting up these celebrities and talk show hosts?! When I though dissidents, I thought automaticly of the American people. Us in the trenches!!! What the hell are you people thinking! THEY SURE AS HELL DONT SPEAK FOR ME, DO THEY SPEAK FOR YOU???!!!
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 3
TEXT SIZE - +
About This Blog
Written by RFE/RL editors and correspondents, Transmission serves up news, comment, and the odd silly dictator story. While our primary concern is with foreign policy, Transmission is also a place for the ideas -- some serious, some irreverent -- that bubble up from our bureaus. The name recognizes RFE/RL's role as a surrogate broadcaster to places without free media. You can write us at transmission+rferl.org

Follow Us On Twitter

Transmission is now on Twitter. Meet like-minds and join the conversation at @TransmissionRFE:
~ You can also find our instant news feed at @RFE_RLNEWS.
 

 

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile