Friday, May 25, 2012


Features

Kremlin, With Kyiv's Help, Ups Pressure Over Transdniester

One of 150 signs set up by Ukraine along its border with Moldova's breakaway region of Transdniester in 2006
TEXT SIZE - +
By Gregory Feifer
After five years of bitter estrangement, Russia and Ukraine are taking part in what can only be described as a lovefest.

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev was in Kyiv on May 17, laughing over mutual words of admiration with Ukrainian counterpart Viktor Yanukovych. It was Medvedev's seventh meeting with Yanukovych in just under three months -- a far cry from the state of affairs under his predecessor, Viktor Yushchenko, with whom Moscow cut off all dialogue.

That's because Yanukovych has reversed Yushchenko's pro-Western policies in spectacular fashion since taking office in February, dimming Kyiv's drive to join NATO and extending the Russian navy's controversial lease of the Black Sea port of Sevastopol in return for cheaper Russian natural gas.

But beyond the bilateral deals, there are signs that Moscow's new cooperation with Kyiv is adding muscle to Kremlin policy toward its other neighbors. Russia appears to be using its newfound friendship with Ukraine to reassert its influence over another former Soviet republic, Moldova.

On May 17, Medvedev and Yanukovych issued a joint statement over Moldova's breakaway pro-Moscow region Transdniester, urging that the territory be granted "special status." In a break from usual practice, the statement refers to Transdniester and Moldova as separate entities, which some suggest may represent a form of creeping recognition of the separatist region.

Transdniester split from Moldova soon after the Soviet collapse in 1991, following a brutal war that ended with the intervention of Russian peacekeepers. The region has been locked in a frozen conflict ever since, host to hundreds of Russian troops who remain despite Moscow's repeated promises to withdraw them. The Kremlin has propped up the separatist government with financial aid and issued Russian passports to Transdniester's residents.

Moscow Muscle

Russia and Ukraine are both members of the so-called five-plus-two conflict mediation group, together with the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), the European Union, and the United States. But Moscow and Kyiv apparently announced their new initiative on Transdniester without informing either their five-plus-two partners or the Moldovan government.

Vlad Spanu, of the Washington-based Moldova Foundation, told RFE/RL's Moldovan Service the move was meant as a show of strength.

"Russia is flexing its muscle over the Transdniester issue, showing Moldova -- but also the United States and European Union -- that it's they who will decide how the Transdniester question will be solved," Spanu said.

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev (left) and Ukraine's Viktor Yanukovych think Transdniester should be granted "special status."
Although the Russo-Ukrainian statement is vaguely written to appear neutral by continuing to back the five-plus-two format, Spanu says it's actually directed against the Moldovan government.

Other analysts agree. Anneli Ute Gabanyi of the German Institute for International and Security Issues in Berlin told RFE/RL's Moldovan Service that Moscow wants to use Transdniester to meddle in Moldova's internal affairs and maintain its military presence there.

"The ball is now in the court of the EU, but especially of the United States," Gabanyi said. "We'll see if they'll be able to crystallize a firm position, and how Russia will react to it."

Moldova and the EU have responded in statements couched in diplomatic niceties while making their displeasure clear. Moldovan Prime Minister Vlad Filat said his country welcomed "all active participation" by mediators, but he asked Russia to help resolve the conflict by withdrawing its troops from Transdniester.

The EU's foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton issued her own statement backing Moldova's "fundamental principles of sovereignty and territorial integrity" and praising Filat for confirming "readiness to further engage with all [Moldova's] partners."

Divide And...

But experts say there's a deepening sense among Moldovans the West is more interested in improving relations with energy-rich Russia than risking Moscow's ire by acting to protect common values in former Soviet republics.

Pro-Western Moldovans have reason to worry. They see this week's statement by Moscow and Kyiv as an attempt to exploit political uncertainty in their country. The government, which is pushing EU integration, took power last year after voters ousted the old Kremlin-friendly Communist administration following street protests over an earlier rigged presidential election. But the Communists have managed to keep the weak governing coalition paralyzed by obstruction in parliament.

Meanwhile, Moscow is moving on economic fronts as well. The state monopoly Gazprom has sued Moldova in a Moscow arbitration court to recover $280 million in unpaid gas debts, the bulk of which is said to be for gas sent to Transdniester, outside of Chisinau's control. Russia's "Izvestia" newspaper also reported that Moscow and Kyiv may soon withdraw from agreed economic sanctions against Transdniester.

The Transdniestrian separatist government appears to be signaling its own indifference to Western pressure by arresting an independent local journalist on charges of espionage. The U.S. Embassy in Chisinau, the EU, and the OSCE have all called on Tiraspol to release Ernest Vardanean from detention and ensure he receives a fair trial, but they have met with little response.

All sides are looking to the next five-plus-two meeting next week in Kazakhstan, which currently chairs the OSCE. But few in Moldova believe this week's Russian-Ukrainian statement bodes well for hopes of progress over the two-decade-long Transdniester conflict.

RFE/RL's Moldovan Service contributed to this report
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Mamuka
May 20, 2010 14:13
The appeasement-based policies of the EU and the US have certainly emboldened Moscow to move in this direction. They no doubt have concluded that there will be no cost to such quasi-recognition of Smirnovistan.
In Response

by: BS Buster
May 23, 2010 01:30
Denouncing Molotov-Ribbentrop while supporting the boundaries of the 1940 created Moldavian Soviet Socialist Republic is contradictory.

In Pridnestrovie, the Moldovan government isn't more popular than Pridnestrovie's government.

by: Johann from: Usa
May 20, 2010 15:19
It is just common seance that The Pridnestrovian Moldavian Republic, will have special status inside Moldova. There are 600.000 people, including 400.000 Russian speaking people living there. There are also 200.000 Turkish Muslim people living in south Moldova.
Moldova is not like Finland or Greece, where 99 out of every 100 persons are speaking the native language of that country.
There are 200.000 Moldavian/Romanian people living in the breakaway east part of Moldova. the borders are wide open, so all this people could move to Moldova, or Romania, if they wanted.
But they don't want, because Moldova is too poor capitalist country for this people. The new government in Moldova, doesn't know how to run
a capitalist country effectively. ( They have no business education).
In Response

by: Vitalie S from: rio
May 20, 2010 16:35
Johann, I suggest you get an education yourself. 200,000 muslim turkish living in Moldova? Where did you read that? Next time you have a layover in Amsterdam, just stay at the airport, do not go smoking. In fact, there are turkish moldovans who speak either russian or romanian and most of them are not muslim. In terms of Transnistria, all foreign troops should leave and a OSCE joint task force should be set up. No more handing out passports, as well. The whole thing is a scam by Russia which, like in 1948, si trying to redraw the map of Europe. very sad.........
In Response

by: Johann from: USA
May 21, 2010 16:16
Vitalie !!!
I have never and will never use any illigal drugs. I came to Amsterdam with my Jewis father about 50 years ago, and there wee NO drugs there.
I was 10 years old. Drugdealing is TERRORISM against humanity and should be purnisable with deathpenality. If I were the president, I would call out the Military ( I was Goast Guard member) and declare war on drugs, like the Mexican president has done. The Great State of Arizona has decleared war on illigal immigrants. I think they should have instead, declered
war on drugdealing. Terrorist groups in South America finance their actvity by hiring terrerists to sell drugs to American Kids on the streats of American cities Shame on them !!!
In Response

by: BS Buster
May 22, 2010 06:25
Vitalie

The USSR (not "Russia") redrew the map by creating the Moldavian Soviet Socialist Republic in 1940, years after the Soviet Union's inception.
In Response

by: CH from: Sweden
May 21, 2010 11:03
There are no significant numbers of Turkish muslim people living in Moldova. The 150.000 turkic Gagauz people whom you probably thought of and who live in Southern Moldova are orthodox christians, and have been this for many centuries... . Also, Finland is actually a bilingual country !
In Response

by: Johann from: USA
May 21, 2010 16:28
To CH
I came to Finland and Sweden many years ago. I know that in Finland they have a Swedish minority and even a Swedish language newspaper
( I learned Swedish for 2 years at The Unuversity of Minnesota). That I was meaning is , everybody learns Finnish and Swedish is optical, like French is optical in Canada. But people in Finland have the same culture, same passport and most of them are blond. I also know about the
semai-independant islands AAland, in-beatween Finland and Sweaden. They speak Swedish, but have their own post stamps and Flag.
Maby that is the resulation for Moldova and Transnistra.
In Response

by: Asehpe from: Netherlands
May 21, 2010 15:46
President Filat and his new government in Chisinau would appear to disagree with your statements. Have a look at his website (it's in Romanian, but there's also a Russian version should you need it). Your stats are wrong (as others pointed out). And frankly, in what way can you claim that Smirnov is any good at governing a capitalist country? Transnistria is not exactly a success, you know.
In Response

by: BS Buster
May 22, 2010 06:23
Scotland isn't part of England with both being part of the UK.

Moldova's historical calim to Pridnestrovie (Transnistria) is weak.

by: Natalia from: London
May 21, 2010 08:59
This developmet is sad for pro-western moldovans who hoped that one day the country will join the progressive economies in Europe. It is also a poor and desperate step for Russia/Ukraine that shows complete disregard of the priniples of International law and UN Conventions.

I agree with Vitalie that Russia is reverting to practicies used by the Soviets half a century ago. The West must stund up to Russia and protest in order to protect its values and priniples, otherwise it looks like a policy of appeasement. WE certainly (all Moldovans) will fight against it, but we need the support of the FREE WORLD against Soviet aggression.
In Response

by: Vlad from: Moldova - US
May 21, 2010 13:16
I am Moldovan but I am not going to fight against or for anything. We had a war and do not need another. Let people in Transnistria vote. If they choose to be independent, let them be independent.

Transnistria almost never was part of Moldova. Majority there are Ukrainians and Russians and Russian citizens. We can not force them into Moldova. Moldova is without them for 20 years. We do not need Transnistria. Let them go. Many Moldovans do not care about it.

Moldova is abandoned by the West. It will not be in EU soon. There might be no EU itself. Disillusionment is the next stage for Moldovans. More immigration then. West does not care about it.

You have no idea how many Moldovans (Romanian speaking too) are working now in Russia. How many have Moldovan + Russian citizenship. There is nowhere else to go. Trains to Moscow are full. Back are empty. EU does not need them. It is sad though.

I do not believe into EU. EU itself has no future. Moldovans in Russia and EU are treated the same. Humiliated, discriminated... EU is not better.

Move to Australia, Canada, New Zealand or US ... somewhere far, far away from EU and Russia. People there will not look at you as if you were sick just because you are a Moldovan and treat you as a human.
In Response

by: Asehpe from: Netherlands
May 21, 2010 15:51
I will agree with you in one thing -- it is a pity that the EU did not adopt a more clearly pro-Moldova (and pro-Ukraine and pro-Georgia) policy when it was easier. Now that might still work, but it's quite iffy; and there doesn't seem to be any political will to do that.

A historical chance to undo the division of Europe that had resulted from WWII and was continued by the Soviet Empire. But Europe couldn't think as one -- and maybe it never will -- so I suppose Europe will not really become what it could. Like the Greeks at the end of the Persian War, the Europeans failed to actually form a common front. Apparently the EU will go the way of the League of Nations.

Pacat, cum zic în România (si în Moldova). E un pacat adevarat.
In Response

by: Natalia from: Chisinau- London
May 21, 2010 18:22
Vlad ,
1. When I say "fight" I do not advocate violence, but peaceful resistence to a Unilateral Action contemplated by Russia/Ukraine that is contrary to International Law and Conventions.
2. There is a big difference between Russia and the West. In some respects Russia is still more than 50 years behind the times with no respect for democratic values and human rights.Therefore, you cannot compare life in the West with life in Russia. Moldovans that become economic immigrants in Russia, they do it out of necessity. Because they are accepted on the grounds that we/they were once members of the Soviet Union, whereas immigration to countries in the West is very restricted , particularly now with the economic recession.
3. If Moldova is to survive it needs financial help to develop its economies , so that its young people see a future for themeselves in the country and do not immigrate. A country that exports its best people, is bleeding and can never go forward. Only the West can provide such financial assistance as the Russian economy is still underdeveloped. Without the natural gas and oil Russia would be a bankrupt country, because it does not produce any goods or services that are competitive in the modern world.
4. Anyone who is expecting help from Russia is ignoring the reality of Russian economy.
5. Transnistria should stay at home Vlad , where it belongs to Moldova- a sovereign state does not give up its territory ... just because a powerful neighbour decide to intimidate a small state.
In Response

by: BS Buster
May 22, 2010 06:30
In Pridnestrovie, there doesn't seem to be any evidence of the Moldovan government being more popular than Pridnestrovie's.

Pridnestrovie had a referendum in 2006 in support of being independent of Moldova.

One can argue over the %. Realistically, it's bogus to question the overall consensus there.
In Response

by: BSBuster-Buster
May 24, 2010 13:09
It's bogus to expect that the Transdniestrian govt can be attributed any democratic legitimacy. It's a Central Asian-style dictatorship.

That said, a more rational demarcation of the border would make sense. Most of it should just be part of Ukraine. Maybe Russia can find well-paid positions at Gazprom for Smirnov and his coterie. Always room for more ex-KGBniks!
In Response

by: Mike2 from: Ukraine
May 21, 2010 13:29
Natalia from... London :-)

by: James McVerry from: Rose Hill, Virginia
May 21, 2010 21:48
Any modern and reasonable person would respond to these conflicts by simply saying LET THEM VOTE, let them determine their own status and which country they want to belong to. And let them decide for themselves which associations and/or clubs they want to attach their state or country to. In other words, the natural trend has surely been towards valuing self-determination of nations above outdated territorial integrity concept. This is natural evolution of human race and history. How many countries were out there in 200 bc? A handful. How many were there in 1900? Less than 70. What about 1985? Less than 140. Currently? Over 200. We’ll inevitably have more and more independent nations, get used to the obvious. Now, let these smaller nations decide which club or values they want to belong to. Some choose NATO, others EU only, a few CSTO, etc.
People of Transdniester are no different than Kosovo or Nagorno Karabakh. If the majority of legal residents of these states choose independence, I don’t see why they are not entitled to it. Try to explain to a Karabakhi person that his liberties and freedom is less valuable than those of his Azeri neighbors. Each of these conflicts has its merits, causes and consequences. There must be an effort to differentiate between them. For example, Abkhazia is a very different conflict because Georgians were its pre-conflict majority population. No one wants to allow 20% Abkhazian minority population to decide the fate of the whole territory, which is rightfully Georgian. The case in Nagorno Karabakh is totally different. Local Karabakhi Armenians were the overwhelming majority of the population (I think 85% or so) and they were facing imminent annihilation by Soviet Army and Soviet Azerbaijan troops who had managed to kill and depopulate about the half of the civilian population of Karabakh before locals figured out that the only way to protect themselves is to take arms and defend their homes. These people deserve the right to determine their own fate very much like our founding fathers fought for our liberty and independence. Let them vote, let them decide for themselves.

by: Zimbroo
May 22, 2010 11:02
What is this article actually trying to say? It is confused and full of inaccuracies.
For instance, the author is not in control of the chronology of the area, and is pretty unsure of the what he is talking about. Transnistria declared independence in September 1990, and broke away effectively after that date. The "brutal war" (are there any gentle wars, Mr. Pfeifer?) broke out in the spring of 1992 and was not quelled by the Russians, it was fought outright by the Russian army which intervened on the side of the separatists. The Russian army committed atrocities against Moldovan civilians in some villages.
To speak about renewed Russian influence in Transnistria is superfluous, since Transnistria IS RUN by Moscow and has always been run by Moscow.
Such childish pieces are just putting RFERL in an embarassing position.

How much longer are you going to beat around the bush and not touch the real sore spot, which is the absence of Romania from the so-called 5+2 format, in spite of the fact that 70 percent of Moldova's population and most of its territory is Romanian?

Don't you have any real experts in this area? You keep interviewing the two former OSCE representatives to Moldova who act like experts, although their tenures were marred by lack of any success in pushing the process forward.
In Response

by: BS Buster
May 23, 2010 01:25
The attack came from Moldova. At this thread, reference was made about "all Moldovans" being against a certain erroneously depicted image.

The attack from Moldova on Pridnestrovie was sucessfully repelled by a multiethnic group including Moldovans. The Russian 14th Army played a constructive role. It's not honest to make no mention of pan-Romanian extremists and softer versions of them.

In Moldova, there're Moldovans who're willing to see Pridnestrovie go its own separate way.

FYI, in an earlier period of history, the independent principality of Moldova included parts of modern day Romania. It didn't include the territory of Pridnestrovie. (The only exception possibly being a very small sliver of it).


by: Johann from: USA
May 23, 2010 14:14
In the great depression a "say" developed in my country
"Go west young man"
So to flee the difficulties of most of America, people moved to states like Montana, Colorado and California (California has more than 30.000.000 people and is the most populous state in the Union ).
California is one of few states, that I have not visited, but I have been in some where 20 to 30 American States.
In The Great West a lot of people started farms or found means to support their families.
I am wondering about why all this Moldovians go to Russia for work, but they don't go to the west ( Maby The EU doesn't care about Moldavians)
About Transnistra ! In Iceland, where I was born, we were a county in Denmark until 1918. Over the WII 1944 we became a republic with our own president.
Faroe Islands, and Greenland, ( and Virgin Islands, bought by USA)
have steadily been gaining more independence from county, to semi-independence to more. A day has been set for Greenland's full independence from Denmark. Faroe Islands have their independent
Coast Guard with 3 ships, even they are still part of Kingdom of Denmark.
So why can't Moldova do the same thing and Denmark, or let the people of
Transnistra decide their own fate.
In Response

by: BS Buster
May 24, 2010 01:20
They already have.

Unfortunately for them, there're major powers influencing how the global community should respond.
In Response

by: Vlad from: Modlova - US
May 24, 2010 13:34
Moldovans moved in all directions, east, west... Russia almost the only place which does not require visas for Moldovans. Coming the other wave of immigration of Moldovans. Now the youngsters who grew up through last 20 years without parents.

Moldova looks to be th same failed state as Triansnistria. A solution is let Transnistria join Ukraine or Russia, while let Moldova join Romania. Many Moldovans want to join EU or Romania fast. They realize that Transnitria conflict would be on the way. So they do not mind let Transnistria go in exchange for joining EU.

Remember independence vote in Quebec, Canada. If a majority voted for independence Canada would let them go. It is better than a war or animosity.

It is true that big powers decide fate of places like Moldova. Near future of Moldova might be already agreed between Washington, Moscow, Berlin, Brussels. Unfortunately Romania or Poland have no heavy say in it. There are anti Romanian sentiments in Italy and anti Polish in Britain. Romanians and Poles immigrate themselves. Germans pay the bill and they are tired of all.
In Response

by: BS Buster
May 24, 2010 20:27
At last glance, the linking with Romania sentiment in Moldova is at about 15%; although it has the potential to become more popular.

In comparison: in Pridnestrovie, the mood to become part of Russia is greater.

Beware of divide and conquer neocons and non-neocon Russia haters, with their adventuristic idiocy.

by: ugg uk from: http://ugg-uk.us
May 24, 2010 01:20
great post!

by: Konstantin from: Los Angeles
June 14, 2010 05:11
To "Be aS bust...":

Molotov Robentrop pact never devided territories,
Just postponded WW2, USSR - being not ready,
The rest is lie by Russia-UK-Bechtel pact, fonny,
Based on Molotov danceling with imperial candy.

Not unlike Ivanov, offering NATO Secretary a toy,
Grabbing Globe to devide - for Rushkis evil ploy.
East Moldova was not Russia - don't lie and sin!
It was Authonomy, Moldova refugees in Ukraine!

To the "Be As Bust..." and Johnatan, Vitaliy right!
Again, USSR wasn't redrowing maps badly - lie,
Ethnic Russia was Government Army and spies
Invading to destroy republics was Russian stile.

As for Johnatan, many Jews were leaving USSR
Being selected by Bolshevics for Russian Tzars
Slender against non-Russians, Russia to prize.
I refused them - assassinations were my price!

Moldova claim for Pridnestrovie is not so weak,
Because it wasn't their claim, return to Moldova
In exchange with Ukraine exits to the Black Sea
And Russia occupiers-breeders be in Ukraina!

Moldovian Vlad? So, return Tiraspol to Ukraine!
Give back to Moldova Black Sea exit to prosper,
As new Switherland - between Romanian Kins
And Kins of Ukraine. Play occupiers percenter?

To Asehpe:
EUROPE WAITS FOR FORMER USSR NATIONS
BE DECISIVE ON FREEDOM, NOT KISS TO RUSSIA!
NOT NECESSERELY DEVIDE NATO-RUSSIA-PRUSSIA,
AS RUSSIANS OCCUPIERS STILL FORCE THEM AS LAGA.
FIRST WE MUST STAND UP TO ENCROACHING ABOMINATION!

Konstantin.

(will continue)

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

No Saturday Night Fever, As Armenia Mulls Eurovision Blackout

Latest Comment (23 total)

greg: Rafi. you go through round after round accusing me of raping and killing ... More

Loophole Offers Legal Out For Doctor Convicted In Bin Laden Case

Latest Comment (3 total)

khan: i think everyone in the paki gov should be hanged the traiters suking ... More

Putin Wants To Party Like It's 2007

Latest Comment (3 total)

nirvichara: It is so boring to hear all this crap about Putin's "old KGB ... More