Monday, February 13, 2012


Commentary

Looking Beyond Georgia's Political Crisis

Georgian riot police clash with opposition protesters in Tbilisi in mid-June.
TEXT SIZE - +
By Nino Burjanadze
Last August, the world watched in horror as Georgia was invaded. But this year, far fewer people are paying attention to what may prove to be an even more tragic situation -- the very real risk that Georgia may disappear from the map of the democratic world as a result of the actions of a man who cloaks his authoritarian approach with democratic verbiage.

Mikheil Saakashvili's attempts to blur the distinction between himself and the country of which he is president have led Georgia down a dead end for democracy. We are fighting for our freedom and for the western orientation to which we as a nation have been faithful for the last 20 years.

It is all the more frustrating that all the misdeeds of this government have been perpetrated in the name of meeting Western standards for democratic reform. That approach has undermined the Georgian population's faith in the West.

It should be up to the Georgian people to choose its preferred leaders at the ballot box, however, when the possibility of bringing about democratic change through free and fair elections is ruled out and Georgia is disqualified from the list of "electoral democracies," our only remaining alternative is street demonstrations.

Dual Threats

Today, many friends of Georgia believe that the danger from outside the country is greater than that from the inside. There is indeed a very real threat from the north, and we Georgians, at least those of us in opposition, are fully aware of that threat. We were alarmed at this danger even prior to August 2008, unlike the present government, which still claims to have won last year's war.

In addition, it is the Russian factor that President Saakashvili prefers to use for the purpose of undermining his political opponents, trying to demonstrate that everyone who dares to raise his voice against his misdeeds has covert links with, and receives funding and assistance from, Russia. I would like to assure all friends of Georgia that the threat from Russia would be incomparably smaller were it not for Saakashvili's unhealthy ambitions to defeat the Russian army.

It is common knowledge that the chances of revising geography to give us more congenial neighbors are nil. It is equally clear that few observers expect that Russia will abandon in the near future its ambitions to impose its influence over the South Caucasus.

For that reason, our Western friends are wrong to argue that domestic politics should be put on hold until relations with Russia improve, as this moment will never come.

History shows that the Russian threat increases in proportion to Georgia's weakness.

And the present leadership has done everything in its power to weaken Georgia in every respect: geo-politically, economically, and socially. The contradiction between accusing the opposition of maintaining close ties with Russian financial circles and at the same time selling most of Georgia's economic assets to Moscow in the most non-transparent and unclear circumstances demands international attention.

'Serving Russian Interests'?

At present, despite his empty pledges of loyalty to Western values, President Saakashvili, whether deliberately or inadvertently, is serving Russian interests better than anyone.

Or take our leaders' latest decision. Two weeks ago, the Georgian Interior Ministry ordered the Georgian border guards deployed in the Mamisoni Pass on the border with the Russian Federation to pull back 20 kilometers, thereby effectively "ceding" that swathe of Georgian territory to the Russian army without any valid reason. Even though dozens of eyewitnesses and local residents have confirmed the withdrawal, the ministry continues to deny it shamelessly.

It is unfortunate that the ongoing political crisis is compounded by a profound economic crisis that impacts the vital interests of every Georgian citizen. In addition to the global financial crisis, we have to contend with a total absence of accountability, the nonexistence of democratic checks and balances, and extravagant budget spending, all of which severely undermine the prospects for steady economic growth in the next few years.

It is of vital importance that the international community, committed as it is to democratic principles and values, should listen to the voice of hundreds of thousands of Georgians who are resolutely defending their rights and freedoms in the streets of Tbilisi.

We are fighting to change realities where there are prospects neither for democracy nor stability. We are fighting for freedom and democracy, for control over the fate of our country and our lives.

We have already lost 20 percent of our territory; three new Russian military bases have been established on our soil; our defense and economic infrastructure has been seriously damaged; last year's war resulted in hundreds of thousands of new displaced persons; the prospects for Euro-Atlantic integrations have been put back for decades; our economic assets are being sold off to Russia. We simply cannot wait for another, even worse disaster to happen.

It is not our politicians who deserve international attention, but the Georgian people. All true friends of Georgia should take a closer look at the disastrous situation in my country and the devastating rule of President Saakashvili.

Georgia and the Georgian people need their help.

Nino Burjanadze served as Georgian parliament speaker from November 2001 to 2008. Last fall she founded the opposition Democratic Movement-United Georgia. The views expressed in this commentary are her own, and do not necessarily reflect those of RFE/RL
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Alex from: Tbilisi
June 30, 2009 11:44
I believe Ms. Burjanadze would be a bit more credible if she divested herself of her house (paid for by the citizens of Georgia), advised her husband and son not distribute baseball bats at opposition rallies and put Georgia ahead of her own ambition.
Her machinations are more about power than democracy. Her party and other parties have consistently ignored the will of the people (re: numerous independent surveys) that the people want the current administration to improve upon itself but do not want political squabbles to be settled in the streets. Especially when the people on the streets (referring to those in cells) are paid to protest.

by: Alexander from: NYC
June 30, 2009 18:35
Are you serious? The president of the country allows protest, such protests that block the main streets of Tbilisi, this articles show how lack of evidence anyone around the world has on the topic of "Georgia". This President was democratically elected twice to be the president of Georgia. In both elections both the United States and the European Union sent envoys to make sure the elections were not rigged. I worked under the UN from the years 2000-2007 and went to Georgia on diplomatic missions and humanitarian missions. Under those years this president has gotten ridden of Corruption in his Government and the countries GDP over the path of 5 years rose by 12%, a record number in world economics. Russia's involvement in the war from what the world knows was because of the "defense of it's Citizens", in South Ossetia, a territory in which the entire Globe recognized as a sovereign part of Georgia. Russia's number one mission is to keep its former satellite states under it's sphere of influence. This comes with the collision of a Georgia pro western politics and Georgia, located on a key strategic location can not afford to loose Georgia to the west. So it plays political games and military power to try and hold on to the country. After all Putin's statement was "The biggest mistake or Fall Russia ever had was the collapse of the Soviet Union". The facts are this, Georgia has every intention to go into South Ossetia, it is by far its own territory. There are no records of any genocide after a year of inspection and it's recorded that Russian soldiers killed more civilians in the whole operation. Another fact, Georgia is a new democracy, it takes time to mold and become like the states of the west. The president by far has allowed all kind of political disagreement and protests, which have been going on since march and "Nino Burjanadze", a corrupted official, there have been video tapes and recordings that show her accepting bribes and laundering money in the Parliament. The only reason she is in the opposition is because she lost her seat due to lack of popularity and votes, and now she is trying re modify the government in spite that the Georgian public doesn't have a majority interest in her or her party.

by: Tinatin from: Tbilisi
June 30, 2009 22:39
Burjanadze,

You do not have a right to speak for Georgian people because they do not support you! Georgian people are intelligent enough not to vote for you. You are more concerned for the fortunes of your corrupt family then the fate of Georgia. You, the members of your corrupt family and circle of friends have been blocking the main thoroughfare in the capital for over a month, inflicting further economic damage on the already struggling Georgian population.

Enough! Go home Burjanadze, do something useful, grow vegetables!

by: George
July 01, 2009 01:06
Ha-ha. Ms Burjanadze (and her Soviet-time clan) is grasping at straws. The truth is, this is her last chance to remain in Georgian politics and she is ready to accuse anybody of anything.

But the true wish of the Georgian people is clear - the ridiculous street and TV performances by Ms Burjanadze and her colleagues are damaging the country and should seize.

Serious political dialog with the current government is what will benefit Georgia. Unfortunately for Ms Burjanadze she has taken herself out of this process.

by: kavkasiologe from: EU
July 01, 2009 08:55
Ms.Burjanadze has many personal qualities but unfortunately with a shameful biography.
This is pity, but we can not use this qualities.

by: people
July 01, 2009 09:03
Nino from Soviet Kutaisi? It'S Trush!!!

by: Tarik from: US
July 10, 2009 18:27
she writes that

"..our Western friends are wrong to argue that domestic politics should be put on hold until relations with Russia improve.."

and in the next paragraph

"History shows that the Russian threat increases in proportion to Georgia's weakness"

But again, when all you care about is personal power and wealth, that's the twisted logic you have

Latest Commentary

No records found for this widget:963

More Commentary

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Iran To Make Nuclear Announcement

Latest Comment (13 total)

Ivan: @ Jack from Upper Siberia, he only Official connection is Russia=Syria=Iran=Hamas=Hizbolla More

In Armenia, Radio Azatutyun Brings Water Controversy To Public Light

Latest Comment (1 total)

Art SF: My hear hurts for Armenia. I hate to see people leaving the country. ... More

Putin Won't Meet Election Monitors

Latest Comment (6 total)

Jennifer Ciotta: The Western press does seem to take an anti-Putin stance, but if their ... More