map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

'Berlin Wall's Lessons For Today'

In an op-ed for "USA Today," Jeffrey Gedmin discusses RFE and the role of free media in societies living under repressive regimes. More
More Articles

Features

What's In A Name? You Wouldn't Ask That Question If You Lived In Macedonia

Visitors to the Macedonian capital, Skopje, now fly into Alexander the Great Airport.

January 30, 2009
By Blagoje Kuzmanovski
SKOPJE -- In searching for the perfect ancient hero to arouse a sense of national identity in their modern-day citizens, Macedonian officials have settled on a provocative spokesperson -- Alexander the Great.

The image of the ancient Greek king and warrior, who at the time of his death in 323 BC had conquered most of the known world, beams intently down on residents from billboards with the message "You are Macedonia."

A lengthy television ad depicts him on the eve of a crucial battle, calling on his fighters -- in the fluent South Slavic strains of contemporary Macedonian -- to be decisive and unafraid of the challenges ahead.

Even Skopje's tiny international airport is in on the act. Until recently, the hub of national carrier Macedonian Airlines' two-plane fleet was called Petrovec Airport. Now it is the Alexander the Great Airport.

Travelers at the airport walking past a massive bust of the ancient conqueror appear indifferent to the encroaching hellenization. But the rebranding frenzy is raising tempers in Greece.

'Expression Of Our Identity'

Athens has spent the past 17 years in a standoff with its northern neighbor over the right to claim the king -- and the name Macedonia -- as its own. Greece has blocked Skopje's NATO entry over the bitter row, and has threatened to scupper its EU bid, as well.

Greek sculptures inside a government building in Skopje
But Sefik Duraki, a Macedonian government spokesperson, appears unrepentant.

"We see this [revival of our ancient Greek past] as an expression of our identity, a kind of nation-building exercise, and a confirmation of our statehood," Duraki says. "It’s not our intention to be provocative."

Officials in Athens might disagree. Buildings, roads, and squares in Macedonia are renamed on an increasingly frequent basis to honor the ancient king and his forebears.

Duraki himself this month announced at least two such rechristenings. A major north-south trans-European highway was to be renamed Alexander of Macedon highway. And a Skopje football stadium will now be called the Philip II football arena -- in honor of Alexander’s father.

Alexander the Great was born in Pella, the capital of the ancient kingdom of Macedonia. That heritage, Skopje says, gives it the right to claim the warrior's image as its own. But Pella is located in what is now Greek Macedonia, and Athens argues that the only country with the right to Alexander's legacy is Greece.

Powerful Lever

The issue has divided the two countries since the early 1990s, when the Socialist Republic of Macedonia split from Yugoslavia and constitutionally anointed itself the Republic of Macedonia.

By focusing the public’s attention on the glories of the past, [the government has] found the perfect way to provide an escape from reality.
Greece objected, and insists on using the provisional reference of the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia in its official dealings with Skopje.

It has also exercised a far more powerful lever in blocking Macedonia's NATO and EU bids unless Skopje adopts a name that is acceptable to the Greek leadership.

Officials in Macedonia announced in November it would take Greece to the International Court of Justice in The Hague for blocking the NATO invite, which it says contravenes a 1995 interim accord between the two countries.

In the meantime, Skopje continues to keep its ties with the military alliance warm, with the commander of NATO's allied joint force command, Admiral Mark Fitzgerald, arriving in Macedonia on January 30 for a two-day visit.

Many Macedonians say they are tired of their government's grandstanding, which has only grown more pronounced as the country approaches presidential and local elections on March 22.

Biljana Vankovska, a political science professor at Skopje University, says she worries the dispute with Greece is doing their country irreparable harm by blocking the path toward Western integration.

"By focusing the public’s attention on the glories of the past, [the government has] found the perfect way to provide an escape from reality,” Vankovska says.

The unremitting dispute between Macedonia and Greece has also proved a mounting source of irritation to the international community.

The United Nations has appointed a special mediator in the quarrel, and is urging Skopje to accept the "Republic of Northern Macedonia" for international purposes -- and pressing Athens to drop its veto threats at NATO and the EU if Skopje does.

The EU, which is struggling to slowly herd the Balkan countries onto a membership track, has appeared almost exasperated with the dispute, and signaled particular frustration after Skopje's decision on the Alexander of Macedon highway.

Hellenization Campaign

The International Crisis Group (ICG) think tank this month issued a report warning the name dispute may undermine efforts to stabilize the western Balkans, and called on both Athens and Skopje to take steps toward repairing the relationship.

The ICG called on Macedonian officials to accept the UN's name proposal, and to reverse its hellenization campaign and restore the original names to the Skopje airport and other buildings and roads rechristened in recent years.

It also urged other NATO and EU members to "actively encourage" Greece to drop its NATO and EU objections and to "respond positively" to any concessions by Skopje on the name issue.

Some Macedonians say they would welcome an opportunity to strip their country of some of the government's overreaching attempts to co-opt Alexander the Great.

After all, says Todor Cepreganov, the director of the National History Institute at Skopje's Saints Cyril and Methodius University, there is more to Macedonian history than ancient history.

“I don’t agree that in our search for identity Macedonia should only look back to ancient times," he says. "Yes, we have our roots in ancient times, but we shouldn’t abandon our Slavic roots, either."
This forum has been closed.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 11
by: Jim from: Toronto
February 27, 2009 22:02
How soon the fickle hate filled mob has forgotten the words of FYROM's first President.

"We are Slavs who came to this area in the sixth century (AD)... we are not descendants of the ancient Macedonians. "

And least anyone forget... aside from FYROM nationals... the Nazis also claimed to be related to ancient Greeks too (as did the fascists in Bulgaria and Italy). Even Turkey is obsessed with Greece. It seems everyone is Greek except the people that that can actually show they've been indigenous to the region for thousands of years, use Greek toponyms, and you know do minor things... like actually speak a language that can trace its roots back through 40 centuries.

What do FYROM nationals have in common with my ancestors other than spray painting "We are Macedonian" and "Gay-reeks" everywhere over the Internet? Where is there mention of a "Macedonian" demographic a hundred years ago?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_Macedonia#Statistical_data

I wonder if FYROM nationals had decided to call themselves ethnic Romans... would anyone have objected? Or how about if the Turks had decided to rename themselves ethnic Athenians? Would that be fine? How about if Syria renamed itself Greater Tel Aviv? Would that be kosher? How about if Mexicans renamed themselves "ethnic Texans" would Americans object?

What happened to international laws protecting state symbols... exactly so things like this don't happen? And to fellow Nato members... what good is Nato if some of its members openly aid non-member nations trying to erase a member from history? You honestly think you can't be next in line?

I never knew what bigotry felt like until the FYROM government and public started its campaign of trying to extinguish my ethnic identity to forge their own (along with all all the supremists around the world that feed off this stuff).

The problem here is not that anyone actually believes that the former Yugoslav state has anything to do with ancient Macedonians. The problem is that people expect Greeks to be Gods because of the some of the successes of our ancestors. That expectation is not our fault.

I am suddenly now expected to forget my ethnic identify that can trace its roots across millineia for a 17 year old country that only shows hate towards me? Is this what "human rights" means in the world today? Tolerate the hateful?

"Had I not greatly at heart the Common welfare of Greece I should not have come to tell you; but I am myself Greek by descent, and I would not willingly see Greece exchange freedom for slavery" - Alexander the Great (Herodotus 9.45)

by: Pella from: Virgina GR.
February 21, 2009 04:53
The Slavs Have no clue of what the heck they are talking about. I can tell they have no clue about the Macedonian History, and they sound idiotic when it comes to Macedonian History.
They still in the TITTO Communistic Era. As you can read they are using propaganda and falls information to fool the reader. Only an Idiot will believe them. An educated person will ignor them because the truth History of the Macedonians is written in Greek every were in North Greece Macedonia. I am Greek Macedonian and I can communicate with the Macedonian writting. A Slav will NOT!

by: risto from: macedonia
February 21, 2009 01:40
If greek would know their history they would not be histeric about Macedonia. Dear alexandra If someone in mexico naimed airport George Washington im sure americans will be glad.that means that mexicans onor George Washington.
Only selfegozentric and ignorant people like greeks are angry.But they are angry to anyone to turks,to macedonians to albanians even to bulgarians there is no good neibors to greeks.
Nowadays im hereing that arheologist from athens refuse to put statue of alexander in athens,to them he is qonqueror wich is true,because they know the history,and politicians(politicans) in greece refuse to hear..Everyone knows only greeks do not know.You (greeks) can not understand the free soul of MACEDONIANS there is why you do not understand the mision of alexander.
Dear alexander olympias was from epir she was epyrian woman,philip was macedonian and aristotel was from halkidiki and he was always stranger to athenians and never was admited like greek .You todays greek admit it because it is ok with present politics , but in history NO!
Read carefuly!

by: alexandra from: usa
February 19, 2009 21:21
how it will feel to the Americans if Mexico call their Country Washington DC, and their Airport George Washington? I am shocked that many International Governments are so ignorant of recognizing Vardarska Banovina a Slavic State of Yugoslavia as Macedonia. No wanted why there is such a big mass in this world. Records indicate that Vardarska Banovina had changed its name several times, and now looking to become glorious country by calling them selvs as Macedonians, and yet its Government ignoring in serving its poeple who starving, and the governement is bussy stilling Greek History and herritage.

by: Alexander from: the True Macedonia
February 19, 2009 13:22
Macedonia was, is and will always be Greek. FYROM is just putting up a front and trying to cover up the truth, but history never forgets. When Macedonia, purely a Greek name, meaning Tall People/High Lands, is translated to Makedonski, then you know it just cant be. Alexanders mother was Olympias, a Greek princess, alexanders father was Philip, a Greek king. Alexanders teacher was Aristotle, purely Greek. Macedonians took part in the ancient Olympics, where only Greeks could compete. How are they not Greeks now and all of a sudden you are descendants when greeks have forever called that province of northern greece Macedonia? You are fakes and the world will discover the truth soon enough. No matter what you build or say, its only a cover, the truth lies within and the more you push, the more you prove the case that you're fakes. Macedonia will be Greek forever!

by: Gandetto from: Ohrid
February 18, 2009 15:35
That's right. Macedonia for Macedonians. Bulgarians, Greeks and Albanians will NEVER overcome us. They are nothing. Great Macedonia is near.

by: Risto Stefov from: Skopje
February 17, 2009 18:10
To albanians, greeks and bulgarians on here. There is no such thing as being albanian, greek and bulgarian. There is only Macedonian. Once we take the name officially worldwide, we will begin our attempts to take back land. The albanians in my country are scum and think they have power, but we control and subdue them. The bulgarians are nothing to worry about either, they just complain but have no power. Greeks? well they hant done anything to us since the embargo, and even then it didnt bother us much. They wont win this as my country will always be called macedonia. Neighbor countries are all part of a Great Macedonia in the future.

by: Bulgar the Great from: Inland Empire, CA, USA
February 17, 2009 08:14
Alexander the Great was Bulgarian. Macedonian language is essentially Bulgarian. Yogurt is Bulgarian. Even the computer was invented by a Bulgarian (save your ignorance and look it up - John Atanasoff).

The tragic thing is that even though Bulgarians are a great nation, they don't support each other and let themselves be dominated by unscrupulous, sly and greedy foreigners. They were the best Soviet pawn, now they are an American puppet. Bulgarians, Russians and Serbs are slavic brothers, but you gotta know how to pick your friends, because brothers stab you in the back.

So here's a solution to the Macedonian problem. Let the West choose the rules of the game (it will anyway). Once your country gets accepted into the EU and you hold that shiny little passport in your trembling hands - go for it. Run for your life. The West will get flooded with Macedonians, Croats, Montenegrans, Bosnians, Muslims, Arabs, Gypsies, but guess what - the Western powers brought it upon themselves. They will own Macedonia. You will always be their problem, until you learn to live by their rules of "democracy" or simply assimilate into their nations. Infiltrate them. Take them over from within. Then Macedonia will be yours again. Peace!

by: reemo from: amsterdam
February 15, 2009 19:15
i think that if either party wishes to use the name of alexander the Great and therefore wishes to connect to the past again. They should make it obligatory for men to walk around in skirts again. LOL come on wake up you proud Balkan Boys this the 21st ! nationalism does not work anymore in combination with progress, just choose become a museum or a modern state .

by: Boris from: Tirana
February 14, 2009 21:07
Macedonia for Albanians!
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 11

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile