map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

CNN: RFE/RL is "World Changing Radio"

CNN International reports on RFE/RL's role in Czechoslovakia's Velvet Revolution, and its continuing mission to spread free media More
More Articles

Features

No End Of Frozen Conflict In Moldova's Transdniester

The administrative building on Tiraspol's central square sports a banner reading: ''Our strength is in unity with Russia.''

August 18, 2009
By Gregory Feifer
TIRASPOL -- Forlorn concrete apartment blocks greet visitors just across the heavily guarded border of this lush sliver of land along the Dniester River. Elderly men push baby carriages through the half-abandoned streets: it's mostly the very young and old who remain in breakaway Transdniester.

This region split from Moldova soon after the Soviet collapse in 1991, following a brutal war that killed around 1,500 people and ended with the intervention of Russian peacekeepers.

It's been locked in a frozen conflict and seemingly stuck in time ever since, but some believe an opposition victory in Moldova earlier this month could provide a chance to finally settle Transdniester's status.

So little has changed in the region, it could be a museum of the Soviet Union, right down to the hammer-and-sickle insignia adorning official buildings.

Near an outdoor market in the border town of Bendery, some new cafes and shops show relative signs of life. But pensioner Larissa Kilmichenka, who sells inexpensive clothes to help make ends meet, says life is indescribably tough.

"I can't support my family on a pension of 400 rubles," she says. "You can't survive on that. It's simply impossible."

Looking To Moscow

Transdniester once produced most of Moldova's industrial output. But now factories stand idle, hit hard by sanctions from Chisinau, which insists Transdniester is part of its sovereign territory. Since last year, the global financial crisis has further wiped out 60 percent of metals and other exports.

A sleepy day on the beach in Tiraspol
Today, only financial aid from Russia props up an economy that would otherwise collapse. Crime may also help: the unregulated region is reputed to be a center for traffickers of drugs, arms, and women forced into prostitution.

The median income is around $150 a month. Asked how life here could possibly improve for Transdniester's 400,000 residents, Kilmichenka cites only one option. She says the region must join Russia.

"There's no alternative," she says, "because we won't survive without Russia."

But even ardent Moscow loyalists admit joining Russia requires a stretch of the imagination: the two allies, which don't share a border, are separated by more than 600 kilometers of Ukrainian territory.

Transdniester used to belong to Ukraine until 1939, when it was merged with part of Romania to create Moldova in the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact between the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany. The agreement is 70 years old this week.

No Compromise

After the Soviet Union collapsed, Transdniestrians backed secession for fear Moldova would rejoin Romania.

Vladimir Pasyutin
Local legislator Vladimir Pasyutin, who owns furniture and agriculture businesses, says Moldova is an artificial state that should be allowed to split apart, and blames the Moldovan authorities for Transdniester's problems.

"We've tried to come to an agreement with Moldova from the very beginning, ever since 1989," he says. "We first began talking about a confederation, and we've always tried to compromise."

But that spirit of compromise can be hard to detect. Most people in Transdniester voted to join Russia in a referendum three years ago, and many were heartened when Moscow recognized two Georgian separatist regions last year.

A statue of Lenin still lords over the barren central square of the capital, Tiraspol. Across a shaky bridge over the Dniester River, teenagers jump into pea-green water on a lazy summer day.

They appear no different from their counterparts elsewhere -- except for the fact that they live in a self-proclaimed republic not recognized by any country. Seventeen-year-old Alyona Timurzina says Transdniester will never again be part of Moldova.

"We don't want to have anything to do with Moldova," she says. "We may have been small during the war, but we remember everything that happened. How our fathers died, for example -- including mine."

Caught In A Trap


But a small handful of residents is deeply pained by Transdniester's refusal to engage with Chisinau. Among them are members of the opposition Social Democratic Party, housed in two rooms of a crumbling one-story residential building near Tiraspol's main square.

Aleksandr Radchenko
White-haired and weary-looking, party head Aleksandr Radchenko says President Igor Smirnov and his allies split from Moldova in 1992 not because of their political convictions, but because they refused to give up communist-era control of the region's lucrative industry.

He says the separatist leaders are still holding Transdniester hostage to their desire to enrich themselves.

"Nonrecognition is a golden paradise," Radchenko says. "The longer it goes on, the better it is for them, even though the people suffer because of it."

Russia maintains hundreds of troops in Transdniester. Many here speak Russian, and the Kremlin has issued Russian passports to thousands of residents.

Radchenko says Moscow's main interest in the region is for maintaining influence over Moldova. He says Transdniester is a pawn in a geopolitical competition with the West.

"Whatever anyone tells you here, Transdniester is the front line of Russia's interests [to the West]," he says. "That's why it appears the conflict in Transdniester will remain frozen for a long time."

New Government To Bring Change?


On-again-off-again talks between Transdniester and Moldova, mediated by international organizations, broke down last year. But the opposition victory in Moldova's parliamentary elections this month appears set to end eight years of Communist Party rule. Some believe Transdniester's leaders will be more willing to talk to a new liberal coalition.

But a change of regime in Chisinau also promises to put Moldova on a path toward European integration, and away from Russian influence -- which others believe may harden the Kremlin's support for Transdniester's separatists.

Back in the town of Bendery, human rights activist Grigory Valovoi says President Smirnov welcomes a large governing coalition in Moldova only because it will be easier to manipulate than the current Communist leaders.

Grigory Valovoi
"The situation in Moldova's parliament will allow Transdniester's authorities only to further drag out the negotiation process," he says.

Valovoi publishes an opposition newspaper and runs Transdniester's only independent radio station from a small apartment on the eighth floor of a decrepit building whose elevator broke down years ago.

He says most people in Transdniester are weary of their isolation and impoverishment. But he doesn't believe change is coming for a population that's fallen by half since 1992, chiefly from migration to other former Soviet republics.

"I don't see a future for this strip of land," Valovoi says. "Most young people want to leave and those who remain don't even remember there was a war in 1992. All they know are the official cliches drilled into them."

Transdniester's frozen conflict will end, Valovoi says, only when Moscow wants it to.
This forum has been closed.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 4
by: Prince Igor
September 06, 2009 09:06
If such sources did their homework, they'd know that the arms smuggling bit from Transdniester is played out propaganda which hasn't been evident for a good few years and perhaps beforehand as well.

The suggestion that Westerm mass media doesn't put out incorrect information is absurd.

Organized crime and corruption is evident in Moldova and many other parts of the world including Kosovo.

Meantime, there's no sound basis to second guess that Transdniester's government is more representative of that territory than Moldova's government.

So much for the propaganda being dished out at this thread.

by: Brazilian Man from: São Paulo - SP, Brazil
September 03, 2009 16:13
Eurasia Daily Monitor said:

“Russia’s military and administrative control of Transnistria is rapidly being endowed with a “democratic” façade, intended to legitimize permanent Russian control of this distant exclave. The contours of a Kaliningrad-on-the-Dniester will continue to take shape if the West tolerates this until it becomes irreversible.”

http://www.jamestown.org/single/?no_cache=1&tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=31970

BBC says:

“The region is plagued by corruption, organised crime and smuggling. It has been accused of conducting illegal arms sales and of money laundering. Poverty is widespread.”

“The separatist authorities exercise tight control over the media. Many outlets are owned either directly by the region's government or by business groups with close links to the authorities.”

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/country_profiles/3641826.stm

If someomne after all those links and comments and texts posted here didn’t provide anything real against Smirnov’s Transnistria… well, (s)he must be a real “Greater Russia” and/or “Soviet Union was great, nice country” true-believer!

by: Prince Igor
August 30, 2009 18:57
Actually, Western media seems to agree that there's no great ethnic tension in Transdniester.

As noted at this thread, the above article references a political party in Transdniester, which supports that disputed territory's affiliation with Moldova. Show me how that party is being persecuted. It's not so influential on account of the lack of popularity for its platform in Transdniester.

Concerning Transdniester and Moldova, Brazilan Man has yet to successfully refute the views expressed at this thread by Johann and yours truly.

by: Brazilian Man from: São Paulo - SP, Brazil
August 28, 2009 22:35
http://www.brettforrest.com/articles/communist-gonzo/

We have to ask why all the Western media would be “wrong” and only the Moscow and Tiraspol would be “right” about what really happens in the lands between the Dniester and Ukraine…

by: Prince Igor
August 27, 2009 16:37
Over the years, Freedom House has stated a series of inaccurate assertions.

Rehashing dubious claims that aren't specified with detail is flat out propaganda.

In Transdniester, there're something like 10-11 registered political parties. Despite their differences on issues like the economy, just about all of them agree on not being part of Molsova. The above article by Greg Feiefer gives credence to this view. People leaving Transdniester are overwhelimngly motivated by the matter of seeking better socioeconomic conditions elsewhere. This desire doesn't see them going to Moldova (at least in the overwhelming number of instances).

by: Brazilian Man from: São Paulo - SP, Brazil
August 27, 2009 00:08
Freedo House says:

“Residents of Transnistria cannot elect their leaders democratically, and they are unable to participate freely in Moldovan elections. While the PMR maintains its own legislative, executive, and judicial branches of government, no country recognizes its independence. Both the president and the 43-seat, unicameral Supreme Council are elected to five-year terms. Having won reelection in December 2006 with 82 percent of the vote, Igor Smirnov is now serving his fourth term as president, and he has said that he will not step down until Transnistria is independent. The international community has generally considered the presidential and parliamentary elections held since 1992 to be neither free nor fair, although they have not been monitored.

Opposition presidential candidates have often been barred from participating on technical grounds.”

http://freedomhouse.org/modules/mod_call_dsp_country-fiw.cfm?year=2009&country=7750

by: Prince Igor
August 26, 2009 12:33
It's easier to get Moldovan from Moldova print media in Transdniester than it is to get Transdniester's print media in Moldova.

As previously noted, Transdniester has three officially recognized languages unlike Moldova, where Russian and Ukrainian are formally given some secondary consideration, while not being acknowledged as official languages.

Smirnov was born in the same country that the territory of Transdniester was part of. As noted, there's no evidence suggesting that Moldova's government is more popular in Transdniester than Transdniester's government. If this wasn't so, journalists like Feifer, Lucas and de Waal would be indicating such. Transdniester isn't a closed North Korea like situation.

The human rights situation in Transdniester is better than what's found in Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan and Azerbaijan.

by: Brazilian Man from: São Paulo - SP, Brazil
August 26, 2009 08:02
You can buy Russian newspapers and newspapers in Russian language in Chisinau. But can you buy Romanian, Moldovan or Romanian-language newspapers in Tiraspol?

And about the Kamchatka-born Igor Smirnov… he has been the only and incontested president in Transnistria since 1992, in a similar manner that Kazakhstan has been under control of president Nursutan Narzabayev since 1992, Uzbekistan has been under control of president Islam Karimov since 1992, Azerbaijan had been under control of Heidar Aliyev from 1993 until his death in 2003 and Turkmenistan had been under the control of Saparmurat Niyazov from 1992 until his death in 2006… if these aren’t presidencies-for-life, I really don’t know what it would be!

by: Prince Igor
August 25, 2009 08:25
Brazilian Man, if Moldova's president was more popular in Transdniester than Smirnov, the Western media going over there would pick up on that point. Where do you get this "president-for-life" bit with Smirnov? Is this not your own editorializing?

The above article makes mention of an opposition party in Transdniester. It's in the minority on account of its lack of appeal.

Once again, the Moldovan language with the Cyrillic script is available and recognized as an offical language in Transdniester, along with Russian and Ukrainian. Of the three languages, Russian is the most popular. Once again, note how in Moldova, the Moldovan language with the Cyrillic script isn't officially used. In Transdniester, the Moldovan language with the Latin script is no more banned than French in the US.

Johann

I wonder how soon Moldova can expect to get full EU membership? Meantime, life goes on with decisions to be made, which IMO are ideally based on the present and likely projected future conditions. The last point is often not so easy to assess.

by: Brazilian Man from: São Paulo - SP, Brazil
August 24, 2009 17:52
I think it’s the other way round: the Russian troops support the president-for-life Igor Smirnov Tiraspol regime, which as far as I know bans any kind of Romanian-language media in its controlled territory…
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 4
TEXT SIZE - +

Editors' Picks

'Religious Hatred'

Russia Buries Slain Priest Photogallery

President Van Rompuy

'How's That Again?!' Audio

Photos Of The Week

Arresting Images Photogallery

Follow Us On Twitter

Keep up-to-date on all the latest news from RFE/RL's broadcast region by following us on Twitter:
~ You can find our instant news feed at @RFE_RLNEWS.
~ An obsessive Kremlin watcher? Follow our blog at @PowerVertical.
~ Human rights abuses chronicled at @RightsWatchdog.
~ News, comment, and the odd silly dictator story at @TransmissionRFE.

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile