Tuesday, February 14, 2012


News

Western Nations, Institutions Praise Kyrgyz Referendum, As Russia Expresses Doubts

Members of a local electoral commission empty a ballot box at a polling station in Bishkek on June 27.
TEXT SIZE - +
By RFE/RL
The United States, United Nations, European Union, and Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) have all praised Kyrgyzstan for having conducted a peaceful constitutional referendum.

In Washington, State Department spokesman Philip Crowley praised “the peaceful conduct of ordinary citizens who voted without incident.” He added that the White House hoped the referendum is the first step toward peace and stability after what has been a volatile few months.

"The United States calls on the provincial government and all of the citizens of Kyrgyzstan to use this opportunity to advance the process of reconciliation and accountability to ensure future interethnic harmony and move Kyrgyzstan forward on a path to security, stability, democracy, and prosperity for all citizens of the republic,” he said.

Voters in Osh use a mobile ballot box during the June 27 referendum.
UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said the outcome of the referendum demonstrates that the Kyrgyz people are aspiring for peace and stability after weeks of violence and disorder.

"The adoption of a new constitution is an important step towards promoting the rule of law and establishing a legitimate, democratically elected government," Ban said. "The United Nations will continue to support Kyrgyzstan and its people as they prepare for parliamentary elections later this year."

The UN has provided technical support to the referendum process and constitutional reform. It will continue to advise the government on constitutional reform, building of democratic institutions, and organization of the general election planned for the fall of this year.

Maja Kocijancic, a spokeswoman for EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton, told RFE/RL's Kyrgyz Service that the June 27 vote marks an "important step toward a re-establishment of the constitutional order and democratic process" in the country.

The OSCE praised Kyrgyzstan for holding a "largely transparent" referendum on a new constitution.

Kyrgyz officials say some 90 percent of participants approved the constitution, paving the way for the first parliamentary democracy in Central Asia and allowing parliamentary elections planned for October.

According to election officials, nearly 70 percent of 2.7 million eligible voters took part in the referendum, only two weeks after deadly ethnic violence in southern provinces killed at least 270 people and forced some 400,000 – mostly ethnic Uzbeks -- from their homes.

In a statement on June 28, the OSCE noted the challenging circumstances, including what it called the "pervasive atmosphere of fear and intimidation in parts of the south," which may have kept some potential voters home.

The OSCE and local observers also noted some shortcomings during the process, including incorrect ballot counting. In some polling stations, voters were not checked to prevent possible cases of multiple voting, observers say.

The OSCE's Boris Frlec in Bishkek: "The provisional government and other authorities should be commended..."
But the OSCE said "efforts were made to enfranchise internally displaced voters who often had no identification papers."

"Considering the extremely difficult environment in which this referendum took place, only weeks after the violence in Osh and Jalal-Abad," said Boris Frlec, the head of the observer team from the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, "the provisional government and other authorities should be commended for organizing a remarkable, peaceful process."

The referendum also gave legitimacy to the interim government, which came to power in April in the aftermath of public protests that toppled President Kurmanbek Bakiev.

Roza Otunbaeva, the head of the interim government, outlined her intentions at a news conference shortly after polls closed.

"After a very modest inauguration ceremony, I will be granted presidential powers according to the constitution of 2007," she said. "Then I will begin forming a new government -- a government that will not be called provisional, but it will be a technical government. In English, they say 'a caretaker government.'"

The new constitution considerably reduces presidential powers, the first move of its kind in Central Asia, a region notorious for autocratic presidents.

Roza Otunbaeva: "In English, they say 'a caretaker government.'"
Otunbaeva said voters had chosen to put an end to the era of "authoritarian rule by one family under two previous presidents" -- a reference to Bakiev and his predecessor Askar Akaev, both overthrown by public uprisings amid widespread allegations of corruption and nepotism. 

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, however, expressed doubts about the viability of the political system that would be ushered in under the new constitution.

"I don't really understand how a parliamentary republic would work in Kyrgyzstan," he said. "Will this not lead to a chain of endless problems, to reshuffles in parliament, to certain political groups gaining power, to uncontrollable shifts of power from one person to another, and, finally, will this not help extremist-minded forces come to power?"

In a separate statement, Russia's Foreign Ministry offered measured praise for the vote, expressing hope that the referendum will "facilitate political stability" in Kyrgyzstan.

Neighboring Tajikistan welcomed Kyrgyzstan's referendum results, with the Foreign Ministry saying Dushanbe would work with any government the people of Kyrgyzstan choose for themselves.

Other neighboring Central Asian states have yet to give official reactions to the Kyrgyz referendum.

Final results of the referendum will be available later in the week.

written by Farangis Najibullah, with agency reports

Clashes In Kyrgyzstan

Full RFE/RL coverage of the ethnically charged violence that has shaken southern Kyrgyzstan since June 10. More

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Bill Webb from: Phoenix, AZ, U.S.A.
June 28, 2010 14:36
Congratulation to the government and people of Kyrgyzstan for having pulled off this referendum so quickly, ending the violence and chaos, no doubt due in large part to the support and backing of the OSCE, Russia and the USA, no doubt due in large part to the large military bases in the country, no doubt due in large part to the Taliban and Al Queda trying to force their will upon the people of Afghanistan and Pakistan. Maybe they could take a lesson from Kyrgyzstan in how countries are ruled, by governments chosen by the people, not by gangs of armed marauders terrorising the country. Power to the people.

by: Mike from: Norfolk, Va
June 28, 2010 20:06
I fail to see how "Al Queda" and the Taliban fit into this picture. This was part of the great game, don't fool yourself into believing that its original.
In Response

by: Richard from: tashkent
June 29, 2010 16:55
Well, Mike, perhaps you fail to see how Al Queda and the Taliban don't fit into this picture because they weren't really involved. Perhaps you're stupid, or just uninformed, or have never been to this region. Perhaps all of those things.

by: Selim Karadagli from: Ankara
June 29, 2010 09:25
My friends in Kyrgyzstan told me that people were enthusiastic in voting, even Russians, Meskhet Turks, Uygurs, Koreans, Uzbeks, etc. This is understandable. I congratulate our brothers in Kyrgyzstan for this transparent plebiscite.
World needs to evaluate the events in Kyrgyzstan by unbiased way. London has to show a political will by extraditing Maksim Bakiev. It is not good to blame the whole nation for the crimes committed from both sides.
We remember the bloodshed against Ahiska Turks in Uzbekistan in June 1989, but we don't blame all the Uzbeks for those atrocities against the ethnic minority in Ferghana valley. The same stance should be for the Osh events.

by: Brazilian Man from: São Paulo - SP - Brazil
June 29, 2010 18:07
Russia does not like, nor believe in, European-style parliamentary democracy. And that’s why it did not like the Kyrgyzstan referendum.

by: John from: London
July 01, 2010 11:12
what Russian president had to say could equally refer to a presidential rule in Central Asia, because that is what exactly was happening under the ousted governments. It is with bitterness that we should state that government does reflect the people's mentality - only what is in the bowl will come into spoon. Some analysts from inside Kyrgyzstan say that the real motive of the mobs who were the doers of "revolutions" and violence in Kyrgyzstan is dire poverty and the tendency of its people to loot and to take away from others what they do not have themselves. Those who from outside keep admiring the spirit of the people there - beware of supporting fascism in a small Kyrgyz nation. In the region of Central Asia with so many enclaves and exclaves it is vital for neighbouring governments to be friendly with each other, turn borders into symbolic lines only, provide security to all of the many many ethnicities living in the countries instead of declaring primacy of one ethnicity on top of others living in the same country. Since none of these are in place even potentially - this area is only a large promise of continued disaster. Total evacuation of people of the disputed areas to the third countries is not a solution at all, however.

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Azerbaijani Aviation Engineer Seeks Niche In Civilian Drone Market

Latest Comment (4 total)

Ben: Secular Muslim coutry`s intellectual peaceful product-the weak hope for the future. More

Cold Threatens Russian Fruit Crop

Latest Comment (9 total)

Konstantin: It is what I said, Vakhtang:

[CIS nations once agreed don'tclaim back Sochi ... More

UN Rights Chief Scathing On Syria

Latest Comment (3 total)

Eugenio: Actually, the Russian naval base in the Syrian port of Tartus is still ... More