Saturday, May 26, 2012


Features

Obama, Turkish PM Agree To Tackle Iran

The two leaders met at the White House
TEXT SIZE - +
By Andrew Tully
U.S. President Barack Obama says he and Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan have agreed that one of the most important issues the two NATO allies need to resolve is Iran's nuclear program.

The two leaders met at the White House on December 7 to discuss a wide variety of issues, from Iran's nuclear program and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict to Turkey's warming relations with Armenia.

Obama said that he indicated to Erdogan "how important it is to resolve the issue of Iran's nuclear capacity in a way that allows Iran to pursue peaceful nuclear energy but provides assurances that it will abide by international rules and norms."

He said he believed that Turkey could be an important player in trying to move Iran in that direction."

For his part, Erdogan said his country and the United States have taken joint steps on a variety of regional issues, including Iran's nuclear program, and he emphasized that he wants to ensure a diplomatic resolution to the problem.

But he added, "We do not want to see a country in our region possessing nuclear weapons and we want the countries in our region who have nuclear weapons to be rid of them."

The United States and other Western countries fear Iran's goal is to make nuclear weapons. Erdogan has said he believes Iran when it says it merely wants civil nuclear power.

Only last month, Erdogan visited Tehran to sign gas and trade deals, and he hosted Iranian President Mahmud Ahmadinejad -- whom he called his "good friend" -- at a summit of Muslim countries in Istanbul.

Erdogan also has dismissed as "arrogant" UN sanctions against Iran for defying the world body by pressing forward with the nuclear program.

Obama praised Ankara for what he called its "outstanding" contribution to the NATO effort in Afghanistan. In November, Turkey -- the only majority Muslim country in the military alliance -- took command of peacekeeping operations in Kabul. Some 1,700 noncombat troops are now serving there.

Now that Washington is committing 30,000 more U.S. troops to Afghanistan, it has asked NATO allies to add a total of 10,000 of their own forces. So far, Ankara has not offered to add to its force.

Karabakh Deadlock

Armenia was also on the two leaders' agenda. The country signed a historic deal with Turkey in October that could lead to the opening of their common border after nearly a century of hostility.

But Armenia is still locked in negotiations with neighboring Azerbaijan on resolving the status of Nagorno-Karabakh, an Armenian enclave inside Azerbaijan.

Any problems with the Nagorno-Karabakh talks could interfere with normalization of relations between Armenia and Turkey.

Obama praised Turkey for the diplomatic breakthrough for the "courageous steps that he has taken around the issue of normalizing Turkish-Armenian relations, and encouraged him to move forward along this path."

Obama offered the Turkish leader U.S. condolences for the slayings of five Turkish soldiers on December 7 in central Turkey, where members of the separatist Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) are known to be active. No one has claimed responsibility for the attack.

Obama said he and Erdogan discussed better ways to coordinate their efforts coordination against the PKK, which for more than 30 years has been fighting Turkey in the country's southeast, near the border with Iraq.

"We have stated before, and I have reaffirmed since I came into office, that the United States considers PKK a terrorist organization, and that the threat that it poses -- not only in Turkey but also in Iraq -- is one that is of deep concern," Obama said.

"And as NATO allies, we are bound to help each other defend our territories."

As for the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, Turkey has served as a mediator of sorts in the Middle East, especially with Israel's Arab neighbors. But Erdogan has been publicly outspoken about his disagreements with Israeli policy, especially its military response a year ago to repeated Palestinian rocket attacks against nearby Israeli villages.

In the past, Ankara occasionally has been an effective mediator between the West and Muslim countries because of Turkey's unique geographical position and its status as a predominantly Muslim country in a Western alliance.

But Erdogan has ended all that, according to James Phillips, who studies Middle Eastern security issues at the Heritage Foundation, a private policy research center in Washington.

"Erdogan has seriously eroded Turkey's traditional role as a bridge between East and West, in part because his own rhetoric essentially is anti-Western," Phillips said.

"Moreover, he has stepped up criticism not only of the U.S. but of Israel, and that's cast doubt on Turkey's traditional role as an intermediary."

The reason, Phillips tells RFE/RL, is that Erdogan is a member of the Justice and Development Party, an Islamist faction of Turkish politics. He recalls that there were concerns about Erdogan and the party when it won a majority of seats in the Turkish parliament in 2003.

Phillips says those concerns have now become reality. He says he believes that Turkey can no longer be seen as the honest broker that it once was either for the Middle East peace process or Iran and its nuclear program as long as Erdogan's party remains in power.
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments page of 2
    Next 
by: Jaff Sassani from: Tehran/Iran
December 08, 2009 10:25
President Obama’s administrations have to pay for any favor they get from PM of Turkey to help them in Afghanistan and Iran. He is not going to serve the USA interest for free.

Turkey committed Genocide against Armenian people and continues with Kurdish people Genocide now. The price is too high for USA to pay for Turkey’s help in Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Iran is not going to give up on its Atomic Bomb making unless Israel is giving up its Atomic Bombs.

The USA interest is best served when the USA have mission in the region to do something good for people in the region. Playing games and continues with wars without hope for people in the region will be the formula of defeat for the USA.

The US Governments should convince the Turkish Government to have peace with Kurds and admit the Genocide crime against Armenian people plus pushing to rebuild the region and have EU type for them to defeat Islamic Republic of Iran and Islamic terrorist in the region.

The strong President will make decisions during hard time to save the nation. The US Economy will go down by continue with the war without change of old policy. Mr. President you should convince your country and your own administrations first to do well job for them by solving others problems.

You must have visions for future not going along with failed policy of past.

by: Zareh Sahakian from: Canada
December 08, 2009 14:35
"Turkey's warming relations with Armenia". Does the author know something that we don't ? The reality is there is no such thing as "warming relations". The whole issue of signing protocols between Turkey and Armenia has proven to be a piece of political theatrics that has in mind only the appearance of "goodwill" on Turkey's part. Turkey approaches Armenia as an enemy and is there to simply help Azerbaijan in destroying Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh. President's Obama's insistence on supporting Turkish-Armenian relations WITHOUT preconditions, directly contradicts Prime Minister Erdogan's statements. Soon we'll find out who is right, and most importantly who will prevail.

by: captain_marlow from: twitter/captain_marlow
December 08, 2009 14:38
Why the misleading title? "Obama, Turkish PM Agree To Tackle Iran"
Erdogan said NO to everything Obama asked. Now that the US is perceived as weak and fumbling, Turkey is clearly looking east and wants to be friends with Iran.

by: Orhan Ertugruloglu from: the Netherlands
December 08, 2009 14:51
Iran rejected Turkish role in nuclear talks on 8 November and said there would be no need for the mediation of third parties in the nuclear dispute. The Iranian Foreign Ministry Spokesman Mihmanperest also shrugged off threats of sanctions. He said that such threats and deadlines were not new for Iran and they would not work.

by: Abdullah E. from: dublin
December 08, 2009 16:36
james philips speaks exact words as secular elit in turkey who are against the democraci and they want bureaucracy and army to run the country as before. TIMES ARE CHANGED mr phillips now nation decides who wil be in power....

Mr sassani. Turkey workin hard for a peacufull region. you will agree no place deserves more peace than our region considering all the sufferings over the years.lets not always look for secret agenda,just peace....

by: Farzin from: California
December 08, 2009 16:57
And Iran should cease its ongoing cultural genocide against the ethnic minorities, including the denial of identity to Azeri Turks and Kurds. Turkish government is taking courageous steps to embrace the country's citizens, to normalize relations with Armenia, in the midst of the latter's illegal occupation of North Azarbaijan, to build and strengthen the only functioning democracy in Muslim world. And what do Iranians do, they get beaten up with batons or shot for their right to even speak or vote.

So Jaff, let's first look for sores in our own eyes, instead of reasserting our persistent historical Turkophobia or anti-Semitism, reciting the theories of brutal Islamic regime or even worse, the racist Aryan traits of preceding Persian nationalism. Instead of advising U.S. President, let's think what we can do better to liberate our own people from the prison they live in.

by: Bruce Hodgkins from: Seattle, WA
December 08, 2009 16:58
Re Turkish-Armenian normalization and the linkage with the Nagorno-Karabakh issue: the directionality of this linkage by Erdogan appears to be in the wrong direction, and is likely specious at best. It is not Armenian concessions on Karabakh that would be preconditions for normalization of Turkish-Armenian relations, but quite the opposite: Turkish-Armenian reconciliation would mitigate Armenians' perceptions of physical insecurity and the threat that stems, arguably reasonably, from their near extinction in the region in the recent past. An unrepentant Turkey will always be an existential threat to Armenians. This is the essence of the issue. The most effective action that Turkey could take to facilitate settlement of the Karabakh problem , if it were sincere, are those that would address the perception of vulnerability and physical insecurity of the remaining Armenians in the region, namely diplomatic relations, border opening, and genuine repentance re what the US Ambassador of the time termed 'race extermination'. It should be plain that these actions are the true preconditions to regularization of the region's conflicts, and not the other way around.

by: Orhan Ertugruloglu from: the Netherlands
December 09, 2009 06:23
The Washington meeting between Erdogan and Obama produced nothing new. But ıt was presented by the media friendly to the AKP government in Turkey as a success. Turkey is not sending more combat troops to Afghanistan.The US and Turkey will continue to pretend as if they are cooperating closely in the Middle East i.e., Iraq, Palestine and Iran. .Ankara will remain opposing Iran sanctions.To cut the long story short, at the end of the meeting, both parties were not better of than while entering the meeting.

by: Ghazal from: Tehran
December 09, 2009 07:19
Dear Farzin,

it seems your ability to view the matter impartially has been impaired. The Turks in Iran do have their own identity and culture to the extent that most of the residents of our Azari provinces are not able to coverse in Farsi, the official language of our country, fluently. I will not get into the Kurds' problem because their situation is very different. The Kurds not only in Iran but also in all three other coutries that they mainly inhabit face a great deal of discrimination. this is mostly due to the British meddling in the post WWII "country division" that they did, something that absolutely was not their business and they did what they do best. Their whether ignorant or deliberate division of tribes with imaginary lines called "borders" has caused enough pain and loss of life eversince.

Regarding the Iranian's right to vote or speak, i suggest you look at the African-American's situation even now in any Western country. The images of that 14 years old black kid being beaten up by the cops in the gas station are not easy to forget for many fo us. Freedome of speech per se as you wish to call it does not exist anywhere. I do not think you can go to Hyde Park and start cursing our the Royal family, either.

by: RD
December 10, 2009 18:59
I guess what Erdogan does not seem to phatom is if Turkey genuinely wants good relations with its neighbours, it should establish good diplomatic ties with its neighbours without pre-conditions. The first act of goodwill, which is doubtful from Turkey, will create an atmosphere of benevolence and trust. Conflicts and issues may become easier to resolve or positively move forward under a climate of co-operation. Instead, Erdogan is making an ass out of hiself and his country with his comments that may make him and his AK Party popular in his Turkey but overall do not improve Turkey's image internationally.
Comments page of 2
    Next 

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

No Saturday Night Fever, As Armenia Mulls Eurovision Blackout

Latest Comment (23 total)

greg: Rafi. you go through round after round accusing me of raping and killing ... More

Loophole Offers Legal Out For Doctor Convicted In Bin Laden Case

Latest Comment (3 total)

khan: i think everyone in the paki gov should be hanged the traiters suking ... More

Putin Wants To Party Like It's 2007

Latest Comment (3 total)

nirvichara: It is so boring to hear all this crap about Putin's "old KGB ... More