map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

'Berlin Wall's Lessons For Today'

In an op-ed for "USA Today," Jeffrey Gedmin discusses RFE and the role of free media in societies living under repressive regimes. More
More Articles

The Power Vertical

Putin's Russia Reaches Out

The Russia Today television channel reporting on events in Georgia on August 11.

December 23, 2008
This month's "The Atlantic" has a little essay of interest by Washington-based journalist Joshua Kucera. He tells of a few encounters he had with a Russian Embassy "official" who offered him a few hundred dollars every now and again to publish stories about "what we are doing in the Russian government."

 

And it wasn't even one of those spooky Deep Throat situations -- no 3 a.m. parking garages, no surreptitious notes stuck between the pages of "The New York Times." All Kucera had to do in order to find out "what we are doing in the Russian government" (and now The Power Vertical readers will also know the secret!) was to check out two websites that, to be honest, I'd never heard of before. Kucera's Russian friend, whom he calls "Vladimir," said he'd pay Kucera to take stories off those sites and republish them as his own.
 

And where do you go to find out what is going on in the Russian government? Here and here. The first is russianpeacekeeper.com (motto: Where we are, there is peace.), which publishes essays on themes like how the CIA is funding international terrorists and how Georgia is to blame for the war in South Ossetia and Abkhazia this summer. Here's a taste of the latter:
 

Besides Georgia performed operations to discredit Abkhazia and South Ossetia. To this end, Georgian raiders made acts of sabotage and terror against the Georgian population in the areas adjacent to the Georgian border (murders and assaults related to robbery). Georgian raiders kidnapped people and tortured them to make them to confess to “committed crimes”. They slipped arms, drugs, radioactive materials and counterfeit money . All these actions were broadly highlighted by the Georgian and international mass media. Thus, Georgia created a criminal enclave image of Abkhazia and South Ossetia that make threat to Georgia, and prepared bulk information to justify its future military aggression.

The other website is inforos.com, which doesn't seem to be updated as often as the peacekeepers, but covers many of the same themes -- Ukraine, Georgia, various U.S. machinations around the world. Interestingly, in its "personalities" section there is only one personality worth mentioning: Vladimir Putin. What would President Dmitry Medvedev think?
 

So, there you have it, Vladimir, a plug for your websites with links and all, and it didn't cost you a ruble. We do it as a public service.
 

-- Robert Coalson

     
Comments
by: Steve J. Nelson from: USA
December 28, 2008 18:23
Robert,
Please don't link to La Russophobe. The site regularly publishes lies about select individuals and attacks their credentials on Russia while offering absolutely zero of their own. It is most definitely someone's black PR project, maybe linked to the pro-Saakashvili Orion Strategies PR firm.

While you might not post this comment here and Kim Zigfeld blocks my comments at her site, over at Pajamas Media everyone gets to read the truth with every post she puts up.

by: Anton from: Auckland
December 28, 2008 03:39
Was sincerely laughing, Steve, while reading. Sure, there is no visible rationality - but imagine yourself, taking your lawyer for a duckhunt and shooting him instead of a duck! Is there a rationality?

Not that I mean shooting the ducks is immoral - I do think so, as these are the very intelligent and smart beings, but this is only my personal evaluation - but how dumb a human being must be to solicit a buckshot into a lawyer instead of a duck? How about a nuke into a wrong target? However you are encountering the foreign policies, inspired by this very duck expert, so what can be done to challenge this? Them are just willing to shoot a duck, or to shoot an ayatollah, or else - do you have any personal leverage to amend their goals? Thar's what you call "democracy" - 25% of population elects a loony, and then 75% has to duck avoiding the results.

US should ideally care a rat's buttocks about what Russia does to some miserable Georgia and why, and Russia must respond similar fashion, as what US does to its neighbours is not Russia's business at all, same vice versa.

If American "human rights standards" were in first instance shoven up theirs, then there would be no many wars in the modern world! Enjoy the democracy? - just have it for yourself! To the wailing of the planet, though, any canniball tribe on earth is now feeling threatened with some delirious mormonic-style human rights standards, emitted by dealy sick US, which can not even let their women to make free abortion choice. Sorta you've been screwed, u must become a Mom. How can a country like that promote any values?

You are surely right about the sneaky press reports on Georgia war - but who really cares? These were only for internal US consumption, while outside US everything is pretty clear anyway! US were training Georgian army for 10 years - and their snouts were kicked out in only a week. What did US show to Russia as a result? That US troops would also run after the first day of assault? Ridiculous! Surely it is wiser to remain silent sometimes!

by: Steve J. Nelson from: USA
December 27, 2008 18:26
Robert,

This Russian Embassy guy must have assumed that journalists pay to play over here just like they do in his homeland, but it's a little bit more quid pro quo in the U.S. rather than tacky direct cash payments. I mean, look at the Washington Post's ridiculous Russia coverage for God's sake, in particular their phantom mercury poisoning story about some Russian lawyer in France that Mark Ames documented at The Nation as being completely made up by Fred Hiatt. I think you'll see how embarassing it ought to be to be a sock puppet for those in power, particularly when they get caught lying about minor issues like who attacked in South Ossetia first.

Propaganda is as propaganda does, but what I want to know is why my taxpayer dollars pay for your Kremlinology pontifications, and why the American taxpayers are doling out $300 million for Saakashvili's salary, and why the hell we had Marines, advisors and contractors in Georgia in the first place. Is it because Saakashvili went to Columbia? Can I get my federal bailout too?

I'm sorry, but some NGOs got the boot in Russia because they were being used as "legends" for intel types, and a lot of nice people's visas ended up as the collateral damage. Even if Saakashvili is a saint and our policy is entirely justified, I can't figure out is what freakin' idiot in the White House or deep in the bowels of the State Department actually thought that the Russians would sit idly by and do nothing while their client state got pummeled by our client state.

by: Anton from: Auckland
December 26, 2008 06:45
Russia most certainly works on its image abroad, and I fully believe that they may pay the reporters for them to use Russian sources. This is not surprising at all, as many governments hire PR companies for public presentation purposes.

As for the actual story of the genocide of South Ossetians, of course it sounds ridiculously - but in my view this is said not to point out the vicious nature of Georgian government, but to provide a parody on the way how the Kosovo war was motivated. After watching Christine Amanpour for a couple of weeks, I was expecting that hundreds of thousand Albanian bodies would be somehow presented to the public - but... Whoops! By calling a small-scale ethnic conflict "genocide" and starting a war because of this Russia simply stated that US is not alone and it can also start wars without an apparent reason.

Now I can meet in Russian media occasional hints that US "endorsed" Ukraine becoming a nuclear power - perhaps they are going to search for nuclear weapons in it shortly, like US was searching for Saddam's chemical weapons.

by: Fay
December 25, 2008 18:29
Since the events of August 2008 in Georgia, I have noticed many "professional" looking sites like the ones mentioned, mostly with anti-Georgia articles and disinformation and written with poor English and grammar.
I have also noticed an increase in LiveJournal blogs with anti-Georgia content.
========
http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5ho7UIbSW5URR7SkNC4KjN7IAHNbg
Russian media firm SUP buys US blogging company LiveJournal

Dec 3, 2007

SAN FRANCISCO (AFP) — Moscow-based SUP announced Monday it has bought blog-hosting firm LiveJournal as part of a plan to cultivate an international community of people that author such online diaries.

The Russian media company said it acquired LiveJournal from Six Apart Ltd. in San Francisco and that it will operate the blogging firm from this California city.

A party celebrating the deal is planned for Monday night in a chic San Francisco restaurant and the guest list includes the Six Apart mascot, a live goat.

Financial terms of the deal were not disclosed.

SUP began licensing LiveJournal blog-managing software from Six Apart slightly more than a year ago.

The Russian component of LiveJournal nearly doubled in users during that time period and now represents 28 percent of LiveJournal's more than 18 million monthly visitors, according to SUP.

"Having gotten to know LiveJournal in Russia over the past year we see enormous potential in developing the business worldwide," said SUP chief executive Andrew Paulson.

"We believe this is a great opportunity."

Along with a new management team, SUP promises "significant new investment" in LiveJournal.

Brad Fitzpatrick started LiveJournal in 1999 as a way to let his high school friends stay abreast of his life. Six Apart bought the company that operated LiveJournal in 2005.

Fitzpatrick recently left Six Apart for a job with Northern California Internet colossus Google but will remain on a LiveJournal advisory board created to oversee the firm's transition to SUP.

Online media company SUP was founded in 2006 with Russian capital and an international management team.

SUP operates popular Russian social networking website LiveJournal.ru; sports and entertainment website Championat.ru, and online advertising operations +SOL and Victory S.A.
=====

by: Ed
December 25, 2008 18:10
I have noticed other sites similar to the ones mentioned, often with poor English.
One such site is: http://www.tinavssaaka.com/.
It also makes use of popular blog services such as LiveJournal to disseminate its agendas.
(http://digg.com/tech_news/LiveJournal_bought_by_Russian_company), (http://blogs.techrepublic.com.com/tech-news/?p=1680).

by: Fred
December 25, 2008 17:36
http://civil.ge/eng/article.php?id=20174
Saakashvili: Multi-Million Anti-Georgian Campaign Ongoing
Civil Georgia, Tbilisi / 22 Dec.'08 / 19:34
President Saakashvili said on December 22, that “hundreds of millions are being spent on anti-Georgian propaganda.”

“Only in recent days in western media, western journalists have broken out several scandals on how Russian security services are financing the campaign against Georgia with the hands of western PR-companies and with the hands of some western journalists and some western newspapers,” Saakashvili said.

He was apparently referring to The Associated Press report about head of the Tskhinvali-based non-governmental organization Lira Tskhovrebova’s alleged links to the South Ossetian and Russian security services. The report came amid Tskhovrebova’s visit to the United States, which was organized and planned by U.S.-based public-relations firm, Saylor Company.

While saying that attempts are made to engage “some western journalists and some western newspapers” in “anti-Georgian campaign,” Saakashvili was apparently referring to a story, which was recently published by the Atlantic magazine, in which a Washington-based journalist describes how Russian embassy employee tried to convince him on cooperation.

“But we should not get afraid of [this campaign]. The West is a democratic society. There are various newspapers there. There is this type of PR-companies, but there is other type of PR-companies as well and there are more civilized, cultural and normal persons. Therefore, under conditions of democracy and freedom, they will fail to prevail over us. The truth will eventually find its way,” Saakashvili said.
     
TEXT SIZE - +

About This Blog

The Power Vertical is a blog written especially for Russia wonks and obsessive Kremlin watchers by RFE/RL staffers Brian Whitmore and Robert Coalson. It covers emerging and developing trends in Russian politics, shining a spotlight on the high-stakes power struggles, machinations, and clashing interests that shape Kremlin policy today. Follow their latest posts on Twitter at @PowerVertical.

Brian Whitmore
Brian Whitmore
Robert Coalson
Robert Coalson

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile