Saturday, May 26, 2012


Features

Russian Maestro Brings Orchestra To Yerevan From Baku, Transcending Politics

The CIS Youth Symphony Orchestra gives a concert in Yerevan on September 24.
TEXT SIZE - +
By Gayane Danielian, Hrach Melkumian
YEREVAN -- Renowned Russian conductor Vladimir Spivakov has arrived in Yerevan with a group of musicians on an unprecedented direct flight from Baku after giving a concert to mark the anniversary of a prominent Azerbaijani composer.

The concert by the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) Youth Symphony Orchestra was in honor of Uzeyir Hacibeyli and attended by former culture ministers of Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Russia. They gave a concert in Yerevan on September 24.

The press office of Armenian President Serzh Sarkisian said Sarkisian personally welcomed Spivakov to Yerevan and told him: "Your visits turn into big events in the cultural life of our country. Full concert halls and the warm welcomes you receive are evidence of this.. People in Armenia have great affection for you and consider you a friend of Armenia."

Cultural Diplomacy

The orchestra was formed with the support of the Council on Humanitarian Cooperation and the Interstate Foundation for Humanitarian Cooperation of CIS member countries.

The foundation's executive director is Armenia's former ambassador to Russia, Armen Smbatian, who took the post in January, after eight years in Moscow.

Smbatian, who served as Armenia's culture minister in 1996-98, was in Baku this week to hear the orchestra perform at a music festival dedicated to mark the 125th anniversary of the birth of Azerbaijani composer Uzeyir Hacibeyli.

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev's special representative for international cultural cooperation, Mikhail Shvydkoi, also attended the concert, along with Azerbaijan's current ambassador to Russia, Polad Bulbuloglu.

At a September 23 press conference in Yerevan, Shvydkoi said the future could hold more opportunities for cooperation among musicians from the region.

"Now we are thinking about what we can do. A funny idea came up: We will try to create a Caucasus quartet with an Armenian, Azerbaijani, Georgian, and Russian [musicians] in it that could play together. There are plenty of ideas and initiatives," Shvydkoi said.

"We want to introduce the Armenian-Azerbaijani component in a series of formats and events like the Baku Forum [and] the forum of translators in Yerevan. This will require the goodwill of presidents, the goodwill of the leadership."

Visiting Karabakh

The Yerevan visit wasn't the first joint trip by the three former culture ministers. Smbatian, Bulbuloglu, and Shvydkoi also visited Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia together in July 2009 as part of a Russian-backed initiative to rebuild bridges between the two estranged peoples.

During that visit they held a series of meetings with the leaders of Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia, and visited Shushi, a town close to the Karabakh capital of Stepanakert, where Bulbuloglu's late father owned a house.

The town had a strategic military importance during the 1991-94 war between ethnic Armenians in Karabakh and Azerbaijan, and had a predominantly Azeri population before being captured by Karabakh forces in 1992.

In 2009, Smbatian and several other prominent Armenians joined the visiting delegation to travel to Baku, where they were received by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev.

Armenia and Azerbaijan fought a three-year war over Nagorno-Karabakh in the early 1990s after the mostly Armenian-populated region of Soviet Azerbaijan broke free of Baku's control as the Soviet Union collapsed.

A Russia-brokered cease-fire put an end to fighting in 1994 but internationally supported attempts to find a peaceful settlement have not yet found success.

As a result, visits by Armenian journalists, public figures, athletes, and government officials to neighboring Azerbaijan -- and vice versa -- have been extremely rare in the past two decades.

An exception took place in April this year when the supreme head of the Armenian Apostolic Church, Catholicos Karekin II, visited Baku to take part in a summit of world religious leaders.

'An Example To Politicians'

But Smbatian's visit to Baku and Bulbuloglu's visit to Yerevan are unique because they are the first high-level visits to take place since this summer's escalation of tensions along the line of contact between Armenian and Azerbaijani armed forces in Karabakh.

At least three major cease-fire violations in as many months have resulted in more than a dozen reported casualties on both sides. Skirmishes and sniper activity that occasionally result in losses of life continue almost on a daily basis.

It is against this fraught backdrop that Shvydkoi, Bulbuloglu, and Smbatian have arrived in Yerevan to hear classical music.

At a meeting with journalists on September 23, Spivakov said the concert in Baku was part of the CIS Youth Symphony Orchestra's practice of always performing a work by a prominent local composer in whatever country they appear in.

In Yerevan the orchestra was to perform Aleksandr Harutiunian's "Overtures," and dedicate the performance to the 90th anniversary of the Armenian composer's birth.

Spivakov, whose wife is Armenian, said he hadn't been in Baku "since the [1988 pogroms of Armenians] in Sumgait."

Shvydkoi, who advises the Russian president on cultural cooperation matters, said the orchestra served "as an example for politicians, who often cannot come to terms, to agree on different issues."

He added: "We simply wanted to show that representatives of different nationalities, cultures, and countries can create a wonderful structure that is amazing by its harmony. Now we intend to set up a quartet where either Armenian and Azerbaijani, or Georgian and Russian musicians will perform."

After the concert in Armenia, the CIS Youth Symphony Orchestra heads to Kyiv.
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Zoltan from: Hungary
September 25, 2010 14:42
I'm fully support these kind of reconciliation moves between the people of Armenia and Azerbaijan.

After all they are neighbours therefore they should live in peace and harmony.

Both Armenians and Azeris can have a look at the example of my homeland Hungary.
We try to overcome of our grievances with our neigbours of Romania or Slovakia with whom Hungary had bitter conflicts after the WW I.

Moreover you can pay attention to the engagement of Serbia and Croatia, or Kosovo.

Life goes on. One should step further including Azerbaijan and Armenia.
In Response

by: Artavazd from: Armenia
October 07, 2010 05:56
Dear Zoltan, it is nice to see your continual and fervent participation in these exchange of ideas about issues around Armenians and Azeri-turks. Unfortunately, reconciliation is unattainable, unless the Azeri-turks admit all the magnitude of atrocities they carried out against Armenians, at least of the latest history. I am talking about the genocide of Armenians starting from 1920 in Shushi, Baku and other regions of eastern Trans-Caucasus, where Armenians lived from the beginning of times; the violent massacres of Armenians of Sumgait, Baku, Gandzak, Shahumyan, Martuni and other regions of Karabakh starting from 1988. Not speaking of the ongoing genocide of Armenians during the whole Soviet era, when Azeri-turks, were driving Armenians from their houses in those regions, which were given to Azerbaijan by the heavy hand of Stalin.

The examples of heavy conflicts between your European neighbours during WWI, or even recent Serbian and Croat conflicts, or even so-called ethnic cleansings in Kosovo or elsewhere in Croatia are incomparable to the genocide of Armenians by Ottoman-turks starting from 1915 to 1920, and Azeri-turks in Transcaucasa from 1920 on.

by: Taxpayer from: USA
September 25, 2010 17:23

"During that visit they held a series of meetings with the leaders of Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia, and visited Shushi, a town close to the Karabakh capital of Stepanakert, where Bulbuloglu's late father owned a house."

Mr. Polad Murtuza-ougly Mamedov, a former opera singer, whose stage name is "Polad Bulbuloglu", was born in Baku, not in Artsakh. Where his father, also a singer, was born remains a big secret of nomadic travels. What we know for sure is that his father did "own" a house in the ancient Armenian city of Shushi. He is actually buried there and his grave as all the other Azeri graves is intact, unlike bulldozed Armenian graves in the territories under Azeri control.

How did these nomadic Azeri-Turks end up in a cold Armenian city high up in the mountains? We'll have to look in the history, but don't worry, the history of these occupiers in Artsakh is very short.

On August 7-16, 1905, this Armenian town was attacked by Turkic nomads (later they were told to call themselves Azerbaijanis) and thousands of Armenians were killed, 400 houses were burned down. On March 23, 1920, during their holiday of "Bayram" the Turkic Musavatist army succeeded in capturing this city. The Armenian population was subjected to Genocide - 20,000 Armenian inhabitants were killed on that day and their houses were taken by the invaders. So, when did Polad's dad "purchase" his house in Shushi again?

According to the official Azerbaijani Census, in 1921 Shushi had a population of 9,223 (4,374 men and 4,849 women). Among these were 8,894 Azeri Turks, 289 Armenians and 40 people of other ethnic groups. Mind you, that was a year after Azeris came to an Armenian town of 60,000!!

During the Soviet times this ancient Armenian capital of Artsakh remained under Azeri Turk control with a population of 16,000 according to the 1989 Census.

Starting from November 1991, Azeri army installed artillery positions inside Shushi and subjected Armenian city of Stepanakert situated directly down the mountain to day and night shelling killing thousands of civilians.
On May 9, 1992, Artsakh army liberated Shushi. Azeri population that was kept hostage by Azeri nationalists there was allowed to leave the city via a humanitarian corridor.

Armenian liberators found a completely destroyed Armenian cemetery there and a half destroyed Armenian cathedral filled with rockets. Azeri army used this ancient church to stockpile their ammunition knowing that Armenians will never aim at a church.

by: Teymur from: Baku
September 27, 2010 10:10
This a good thing - as in fact we do have to live together.

So for once, Mr. Taxpayer-yan, why don't you relax and listen to the beautiful music )
In Response

by: Taxpayer from: USA
September 28, 2010 20:20
Every time Tolysh, Lezgi, Tsakhur, Armenian and other native peoples of these lands "relaxed" they had their throats slit by the invading nomadic Azeri-Turks.

Many of native Transcaucasia people now realize that they actually don't have to live together with these representatives of an alien to the area genocidal civilization.

Azeri Turks' native Ergenekon is thousands miles away from Baku near the Altay mountains where they can live together with their Tuvin, Khakas, Kazakh and Mongolian neighbors.

by: Donovan from: PA
September 29, 2010 00:27
>region of Soviet Azerbaijan broke free of Baku's control as the Soviet Union collapsed.
Before the Soviet Union collapsed, not 'as'

by: Artavazd from: Armenia
October 07, 2010 05:32
“Shushi, a town close to the Karabakh capital of Stepanakert, where Bulbuloglu's late father owned a house.” So... At least Bulbuloglu was not massacred during the Karabakh conflict like many Armenians were. Unlike Bulbuloglu, those Armenians owned houses in their native towns and villages. While Bulbuloglu owned a house in the ancient capital of the Armenian province of Artsax – Shushi, after the genocide of almost all Armenians of the city in 1920 (as a matter of fact, of the genocide of Armenians in Baku and other regions of eastern Trans-Caucasus, where Armenians lived from the beginning of times). Apparently, Gayane Danielyan and Hrach Melkumyan are too young to remember at least the latest history of massacres of Armenians of Sumgait, Baku, Gandzak, Shahumyan, Martuni and other regions of Karabakh starting from 1988. Otherwise they would not “naively” believe that a concert, or even a series of concerts, or a joint Quartet would somehow “rebuild bridges.” What bridges? Could there be any bridges between Armenians and Azeri-turks, who had massacred Armenians in 1920, and under the protection of the Soviet era Aliev/Brejnev regime were driving Armenians from their houses in those regions, which were given to Azerbaijan by the heavy hand of Stalin (Nakhichevan ASSR is the most vivid example)? Not speaking of sneaky penetration of Azeri-turks and their proliferation in the Armenian SSR territory, again, under the same Aliev/Brejnev rule. So, what rebuilding and what bridges are we talking about? There were no bridges. There was only an ongoing genocide of Armenians during the whole Soviet era. The 1988 movement of Karabakh Armenians was only an attempt to stop that genocide. It is disappointing to see two Armenian journalists, together in the same group of those so ignorant of the underlying issues, who view the Karabakh movement as a fire, which supposedly burnt some “bridges.”

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

No Saturday Night Fever, As Armenia Mulls Eurovision Blackout

Latest Comment (23 total)

greg: Rafi. you go through round after round accusing me of raping and killing ... More

Loophole Offers Legal Out For Doctor Convicted In Bin Laden Case

Latest Comment (3 total)

khan: i think everyone in the paki gov should be hanged the traiters suking ... More

Putin Wants To Party Like It's 2007

Latest Comment (3 total)

nirvichara: It is so boring to hear all this crap about Putin's "old KGB ... More