map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

CNN: RFE/RL is "World Changing Radio"

CNN International reports on RFE/RL's role in Czechoslovakia's Velvet Revolution, and its continuing mission to spread free media More
More Articles

Features

Teachers In Abkhazia's Gali District Under Pressure To Give Up Georgian Language

Children attend class at a high school in the Shashikvara village, close to Gali

March 22, 2009
By Eka Kevanishvili
TBILISI, March 20, 2009 (RFE/RL) -- Schoolteachers in the southern Gali district of Abkhazia have long been accustomed to operating on a shoestring.

For them, the free delivery of brand-new textbooks should be cause for elation. Unless, that is, the textbooks are in Russian.

Teachers in Gali, the one district in breakaway Abkhazia where at least 40,000 ethnic Georgians are believed to be living, say they are coming under pressure from local officials to drop all Georgian-language instruction and give up their standard textbooks.

Recent reports by Georgia's Rustavi-2 and Imedi television networks showed new Russian-language schoolbooks being delivered to schools in Gali. The Russian-language texts teach sensitive subjects like geography and history from an Abkhaz point of view.

In Georgia proper, such reports are feeding fears that Abkhaz officials are subjecting Gali's 40,000-plus ethnic Georgians to a forced assimilation campaign.

Inga, a teacher in the Gali village of Pichori, told RFE/RL's Georgian Service in a telephone interview that she and her colleagues have been warned by Abkhaz authorities that teaching in Georgian will soon be banned in their school.

"While we're teaching in Georgian, there are Abkhaz standing on the other side of the classroom door, spying on us. We can't convey over the phone what we're actually feeling. We've managed to survive so far, though," Inga said.

Neither Inga nor a second Gali teacher, Karina Ekhvaia, was able to confirm that new textbooks had been brought to their schools.

Steady Pressure

But both attested to mounting pressure being placed on teachers and school administrators to give up the Georgian language in favor of Russian-language instruction -- and a curriculum dominated by a decidedly Abkhaz view of local history and geography.

Ekhvaia, an instructor at Gali's public school No. 13, expressed concern about the fate of her pupils, for whom school is a critical link to their Georgian identity.

"I can confirm that Georgian schoolteachers are indeed being put under pressure. I can't say whether new textbooks are being provided," Ekhvaia said.

"But Georgian teachers are frequently visited by Abkhaz authorities for inspections. Of course it's a very hard time for us. We want to bring up our children in the Georgian language."
While we're teaching in Georgian, there are Abkhaz standing on the other side of the classroom door, spying on us


Pressure on Georgian schools is nothing new in Abkhazia. But last year's war between Georgia and Russia over a second breakaway region, South Ossetia, has emboldened separatist authorities in both territories.

With backing from Moscow, de facto officials in Tskhinvali and Sukhumi have applied steady pressure on the few remaining Georgians on their territory, laying claim to their land, imposing a Russian passport regime, and -- in the case of Gali -- saying no to Georgian-language instruction.

The Abkhaz constitution offers nominal protection to ethnic minorities to receive education in their native languages. But Sukhumi has also passed laws placing formal limits on school hours spent in non-Russian instruction.

Outrage In Tbilisi

That law has been exercised unevenly. The approximately 40 Armenian-language schools that have been established in the republic to serve the needs of ethnic Armenians have largely been allowed to function without interference from local officials. Georgian schools have been less fortunate.

The school crackdown has been a rallying cry for Tbilisi, which was deeply wounded by the perceived loss of South Ossetia and Abkhazia when Moscow moved to recognize their independence bids last autumn.

Georgian media frequently reports on the plight of ethnic Georgians inside Gali -- sometimes to an extent the residents themselves find uncomfortable as they attempt to maintain a formal peace with their Abkhaz neighbors.

In one recent incident, Georgian media reported that children crossing from the Gali village of Saberio were robbed and came under fire when Abkhaz border authorities attacked the bus transporting them to their school in the Georgian village of Tskoushi.

The headmaster of the Tskoushi school, however, downplayed the incident, saying the bus showed no sign of damage and that the pupils were studying normally.

Speaking to RFE/RL's Georgian Service, Ruslan Kishmaria, the Abkhaz head of the Gali local administration, accused Georgia of fabricating the story in order to stir resentment against Abkhazia:

"Don't believe [the reports]. The Georgian Education Ministry is lying," Kishmaria said. "[The students] have studied, are studying, and will continue to study, just as before. There are no problems. Nothing [the Georgian side is saying] is true. They're studying the same way they always have."

Most teachers in the Gali district receive two salaries -- one from Georgia, and the other from Abkhazia. The Georgian salary, the equivalent of approximately $330, is currently almost three times larger than the Abkhaz contribution.

But some Gali teachers, including Inga from Pichori, have reported hearing rumors that their Abkhaz salaries would be increased in return for pledges to drop Georgian-language instruction.

"There was talk about increasing the salaries. But no one has explained the reasoning behind it," Inga said.

International Concerns

Rising fears of an assimilation campaign have drawn the attention of the international community.

Norway's former Foreign Minister Knut Vollebaek, who currently serves as the OSCE's high commissioner on national minorities, traveled to Abkhazia in January and said he found the situation "difficult" for Georgian parents eager for their children to be educated in their mother tongue. 

Vollebaek says one rationale frequently cited by Abkhaz authorities for the all-Russian education campaign is that they see there is a shortage of Georgian textbooks but lack the funding to buy new supplies. 

The OSCE is attempting to address the situation by funding translations of existing texts from Russian into Georgian. There's just one catch -- the books to be translated are geography and history texts, written from a distinctly Abkhaz perspective.

Even in Georgian, such books are unlikely to be welcome among ethnic Georgians. Vollebaek says with regret the OSCE is "not in the situation where we can choose the ideal situation in Gali district."

Nor is the government in Tbilisi. The Georgian Foreign Ministry has amplified its complaints in recent weeks of attempts by Sukhumi and its Russian supporters to ratchet up the pressure on Abkhazia's Georgian population.

In a briefing this week, Foreign Ministry official Sergi Kapanadze said Georgians in Gali had been given until March 20 to renounce their Georgian citizenship and receive new passports. Those who refuse have reportedly been threatened with fines, arrest, or possible deportation.

A Georgian news report earlier this month claimed Abkhaz authorities had rejected 3,000 Russian passports set to be distributed in Gali because they stated the residents' place of birth as Georgia.

Vollebaek says the pressure could lead to a fresh humanitarian crisis if Georgians begin to flee Abkhazia.

"It's important for us to address the situation for the Georgians, both with respect to education but also with respect to the other fundamental rights, like property rights and freedom of movement," Vollebaek said.

"There is also the question of passportization, which we see as a problem if it is forced on people. All these pressures together may create a situation that makes it unbearable for Georgians to live in Gali."

Daisy Sindelar contributed to this report
This forum has been closed.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 2
by: Stephan
March 26, 2009 17:08
RUSSIA GUILTY OF GENOCIDE!

In september 1993 Russia organised an ethnic cleansing of Georgians in Abkhazia. Thousands of civilians were murdered by Abkhaz militias. The majority of the population, about 300,000 Georgians, were driven out of their homes. In august 2008 Russia organised Ethnic Cleansing in Georgia!
Russia was preparing to wage war in Georgia several years ago, when the Russian authorities began to hand out Russian passports to the residents of Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Russia has always stuck to one principle: 'divide and rule'. What's happening in South Ossetia and Georgia today is a continuation of the imperial policy of enslaving peoples at the hands of their neighbours. By suppoting separatists remiges in Georgia, Russia has unleashed a strong insurgence movement inside its own territory. No doing in this world goes unpunished!
Russian propaganda says one thing, while the Kremlin and the military leadership do another. It was Moscow that led the provocations by South Ossetia against Georgia, and when Tbilisi was forced to launch a military operation, Moscow immediately sent its troops onto the territory of another state and began to bomb and shell Georgian cities. Russian media will now do its best to create an image of Georgians as enemies of Russia, a mass zombification of the public at large, the preparing of public opinion, perhaps one or two bloody terrorist attacks with a lot of human victims, which will of course be carried out by "persons of Georgian nationality"..
Russia has exposed South Ossetia to a very crude and cynical aggression. People have died. Georgian citizens have died, including local residents and Georgian peacekeepers. The actions of the Russian side cannot be described as anything else but genocide.
What Russia has done in Georgia is an open challenge to the entire international community!
That's real international terrorism!

by: abgeo from: http://www.abgeo.blogspot.com/
March 25, 2009 20:27
very sad! :(

by: 08001 from: London
March 24, 2009 21:08
Tom Klan - 'They have axed the Russian Language sector within this institutions, leaving thousands of Russian speaking pupils unable to continue their studies and pursue their rightful development. Only because they spoke Russian! The prospect of Russian speaker attending any university or college was swiftly removed with a stroke of a pen'.

I must mention that 'fact' to my Georgian friend in Tbilisi who recently completed her Master's degree in Russian.

You clowns just make this stuff up don't you. Who knows where the agenda driven deception begins and the plain bone headed ignorance ends.

by: Andrew from: Auckland
March 24, 2009 16:01
Tom,
Obviously you are a bit of a bigoted idiot.

The war in Abkhazia in the 90's was started when SEPARATISTS attacked the Regional government buildings in Sukhumi.

The Abkhaz separatists comitted the majority of war crimes during the war, and comitted the worst crimes, including mass executions/murders, rapes & ethnic cleansing of the majority of the provinces population.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_in_Abkhazia_(1992%E2%80%931993)

http://www.hrw.org/legacy/reports/1995/Georgia2.htm#P117_4464

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_cleansing_of_Georgians_in_Abkhazia

You really need to get an education, as you are showing yourself to be a bit (severely) misinformed.

By the way, there has been no axing of the Russian language faculties in Georgian universities, or in primary & secondary schools for that matter, where it is compulsory for Georgian students to learn Russian as a second or third language.

So either you are misinformed, or a malignant spreader of Russian agitprop.

by: sealine
March 24, 2009 15:09
to Rasto

I just have checked the references in your message below and actually they can not be considered as unappealable and in general i had a feeling that it is a sort of propaganda... frшvolous,roughly one-sided and perverted presentation of facts... Fortunately, there are a lot of sourses available to check actual state of matters in this respect.

by: Tom Klan from: London, UK
March 24, 2009 08:14
Thank you for your posted links,

Sadly though, I have to dismiss them as a totally worthless propaganda tools, intended for naive and uneducated masses, made in 70’s distasteful Soviet style. And since I’m not one nor the other, let’s move on shall we? Instead, let me offer you one of mine, have a look at what highly respected diplomat and NATO’s spokesmen (Mr James Appathurai) has to say about Georgian News reporting, I hope you will agree with me, If Government’s can’t be trusted with fairly simple digestion’s of the facts, can we actually trust our Sate been truthful and impartial on such a highly sensitive issue such as War and History reporting? I very much doubt it.

Perhaps the main difference between you and I is that , you are watching too many clips on YouTube and I was there in both S. Ossetia and Abkhazia in person. And just to clear some air, I’m not Abkhazian or the Russian just in case you ask me that question.

Here is the link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zsLQj6thzYI

Enjoy

by: John Smith from: London
March 23, 2009 21:07
The present de facto government of Abkhazia refers to the existence of the Soviet Socialist Republic that was created in 1925.
This republic was created by the greatest dictator of all time, Stalin, and his helpers. In the 30s Nestor Lakoba (an Abkhazian communist/nationalist) organized the assimilation of the Georgian peasant population. People who agreed to register as Abkhazian were freed from military service, received cattle and other privileges. Tens of thousands of Georgians were happy to accept such an offer because in their opinion they were already Abkhazians (i.e. inhabitants of the province of Abkhazia). But the real purpose was to increase the (registered) number of Apsua (a Northern Caucasus people that moved to the (attractive) Black Sea shores.
In the 70s such assimilation programs were repeated, now with promise of cars, houses and university access.
In 1993 hundreds of thousands of Georgians were driven from Abkhazia, tens of thousands were brutally murdered and abused. Participants in these murders now hold posts in the Abkhazian government.
Most other ethnic groups have meanwhile also left Abkhazia. The result is a mono-ethnic "republic". In this so-called republic the Georgian language is officially forbidden as well as Georgian schools and education in the Georgian language. Georgian refugees are not allowed to return to their homes. In the Gali district a young child played with a Georgian flag. Because of this it was brutally hit in the face by Abkhazian police-officers.
Some Georgians dared to return to this Gali district, the part of Abkhazia closest to Georgia. They are forbidden to harvest any fruit from their gardens.
This criminal government is financed by Russia, the Russian government knows this and takes part in it. They provide weapons and military instructions.
Fake tourism programs are launched to promote Abkhazia as a tourist destination.
The country is full of hidden mass-graves of Georgian inhabitants (including many women and children), their families are still looking for them.

Solution: 300.000 Georgian refugees return to their homes, democratic elections are held and a referendum to decide the future status of Abkhazia. Those who participated in war crimes and genocide have to be brought to justice.
Until this happens the Abkhazian republic is a fake.

by: John Smith from: London
March 23, 2009 21:02
to Tom Klan:
Abkhazia is NOT Independent Republik!
In september 1993 Russia organised an ethnic cleansing of Georgians in Abkhazia. Thousands of civilians were murdered by Abkhaz militias. The majority of the population, about 300,000 Georgians, were driven out of their homes. In august 2008 Russia organised Ethnic Cleansing in Georgia!
Solution: 300.000 Georgian refugees return to their homes, democratic elections are held and a referendum to decide the future status of Abkhazia. Those who participated in war crimes and genocide have to be brought to justice.
Until this happens the Abkhazian republic is a fake.

by: Tom Klan from: London, UK
March 23, 2009 17:54
Dear Rasto

Thank you for your posted links,

Sadly though, I have to dismiss them as a totally worthless propaganda tools, intended for naive and uneducated masses, made in 70’s Soviet style.
Since I’m not one nor the other, let’s move on. You may be able to convince some ignorant foreigner, but not me, thank’s.

Perhaps the main difference between you and I is that , you are watching too many clips on YouTube and I was there in both S. Ossetia and Abkhazia in person. And just to clear some air, I’m not Abkhazian or the Russian just in case you ask that question.

Good Luck


by: Rasto from: London
March 23, 2009 14:26
to Tom Klan

please view these first and than comment on who has done what:

On Ossetia with English subtitles:

http://www.youtube.com/view_play_list?p=4970B5D01AC9E8AB


On Abkhasia from Otar Ioseliani only Russian..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-ZVqfxWb3U&feature=related
.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6E8RIvPuvX4&feature=related
-
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 2
TEXT SIZE - +

Editors' Picks

'Religious Hatred'

Russia Buries Slain Priest Photogallery

President Van Rompuy

'How's That Again?!' Audio

Photos Of The Week

Arresting Images Photogallery

Follow Us On Twitter

Keep up-to-date on all the latest news from RFE/RL's broadcast region by following us on Twitter:
~ You can find our instant news feed at @RFE_RLNEWS.
~ An obsessive Kremlin watcher? Follow our blog at @PowerVertical.
~ Human rights abuses chronicled at @RightsWatchdog.
~ News, comment, and the odd silly dictator story at @TransmissionRFE.

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile