Tuesday, February 14, 2012


Transmission

The 'U.S. Caused The Haiti Earthquake' Meme

TEXT SIZE - +


Sometimes earthquakes just happen. But sometimes, if you believe the conspiracy theorists out there, they are made to happen -- usually by secret U.S. military weapons.

It isn’t surprising that the idea that the U.S. military caused the tragic January 12 earthquake in Haiti is making the rounds. But the way that it is making the rounds is interesting.

Figuring out exactly where to pick up the thread is hard, but it appears a story appeared on January 18 on the website of Venezuela’s ViVe TV that Russia’s Northern Fleet had reported that a “flawed” U.S. Navy weapons test had caused the horrific events in Haiti.

For the sake of veracity, apparently, the ViVe TV report claimed the U.S. Navy was also behind a January 9 earthquake near the northern California town of Eureka, which fortunately caused no casualties.

The report added that the weapon was being developed and tested for use against Iran.

Shortly thereafter, Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez went on television to repeat the report. Chavez’s analysis was picked up by RT (formerly Russia Today, the Kremlin’s English-language television channel) on January 20.

The RT report does not mention that Russia's Northern Fleet was supposedly the original source of the Chavez sensation.

RT has been pushing various anti-American themes in its Haiti coverage, including the notion that Washington is using the crisis to "occupy" the country.

Where there is this much smoke, there must be fire, so Iran's Press TV jumped all over the story on January 23. The report picks up on some earlier reports that Lieutenant General Ken Keen of U.S. Southern Command, who is now heading U.S. military relief efforts in Haiti, was in the country at the time of the earthquake and concludes that he had been "prepositioned" in the country because Washington knew the horrible damage its super weapon could inflict.

Press TV also notes that the story got "special attention" in some U.S. and Russian media outlets, including Fox News and Russia Today. The Fox News report is limited to a mocking account that compares Chavez to a goat and spends most of its time discussing whether he is crazy.

All of the other references in the Press TV story can be easily assembled by typing HAARP into Google. HAARP stands for the U.S. High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program, which the U.S. government claims is a research program to study the ionosphere in order to improve communications technology.

Some of the conspiracy buffs out there note that Russia and the EU have similar projects and suspect that all of them could be used in tandem to create devastating effect.

An Internet search for "Haiti" and "HAARP" reveals that the "story" is all over the blogosphere with embellishments of the most fantastic kinds.

In fairness, the RT story does admit that the use of "tectonic weapons" is a favorite theme of conspiracy theorists. But as an example of this, it dismissively cites only a 2002 Georgian claim that Russia caused an earthquake in the South Caucasus country.

What none of them seem to have noticed is that on January 20, the very same day that RT pushed this snowball down the mountainside, Interfax ran this story in which a spokesman for Russia's Northern Fleet categorically denied the Russian Navy had anything to do with the original report, which he dismissed as "science fiction."

"The vessels of the Northern Fleet in the North Atlantic are occupied with completely different tasks and have nothing to do with the investigation of natural disasters in conjunction with the tests of the weapons of any country," the spokesman said.

But who is going to let that get in the way of a good conspiracy story, especially one that seems to be doing so much to bolster the growing ties between Venezuela, Russia, and Iran?

-- Robert Coalson

Tags: earthquake , haiti

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments page of 2
    Next 
by: xiongnu from: Moscow
January 25, 2010 14:50
//Shortly thereafter, Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez went on television to repeat the report. //

Where is the link to the original video of Chavez repeating the report? What is the actual quote? Have you checked your story, Robert Coalson, or are you just _repeating_ somebody else's report?





In Response

by: RFE/RL Editors
January 25, 2010 16:33
We're not sure why a link of Chavez actually reading the text by Venezuela's official news agency in Spanish is needed, but if you insist, there is this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ul8q8XxI8SM

by: bandidito from: europe
January 26, 2010 03:39
No, no, no...

The Youtube link you provide ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ul8q8XxI8SM ) goes to a short newsclip from a Colombian TV station (MITV). There is no original Chávez sound (just some video background from his recent Sunday TV program, where he didn't make any such statement).
The official Venezuelan news agency is Agencia Bolivariana - http://www.abn.info.ve/ . Try and find the alleged statement there - good luck!

The story on Russia Today quotes as its source the Spanish tabloid "ABC" - http://www.abc.es/hemeroteca/historico-24-01-2010/sevilla/Opinion/un-terremoto-made-in-usa_1133277403786.html . But "ABC" only claimed that Chávez "accused the US intelligence services of the earthquake". All other details are courtesy Russia Today.
"ABC" itself provides no link to any original Chávez soundbite or official text.
Youtube is already full of links to this "Chávez" story, but they all either link to the RT program, or to other (e.g. Brazilian) news stories referring to RT.
If Hugo Chávez actually had made such a statement, don't you think there would be a link to the original on Youtube by now? But there is nothing, nada.

by: CentraCarib from: CentraCarib
January 26, 2010 06:57
Nothing conspiracy, just do your professional journalistic work. The atromic bomb was also unbeleivable conspiracy theory?
It is known that HAARP can be used as a weapon of possible greather forc than nuclear bombs.
Nearby Puerto Rica has a HAARP fascility run by US Air Force,while for half a year strange many daily quakes occur near Puerto Rico.
Chekc the graphs of HAARP before the earthquake; for a few days there was a hig voltage signal of 2,1 Hz shaking the earth.

Chavez fantasizes this? He works daily with the Russian Northern Fleet. Most likely its true. And the report itself is secret and owned by the Russians that might have their own dirty HAARP work to keep secret.

by: Irene from: Eastern Europe
January 26, 2010 09:30
This RT video looks like just one more Russian informational attack in its Psychological War against the West - of course using a false identity. This time of Chavez....

by: allan from: new york
January 26, 2010 12:34
I like this story...its quite intriguing. and another reason for people to continue learning about technology and its downsides. Not everything man develop has a positive outcome. Great example: the invention of the nuclear bomb.

This story makes a lot of sense from the scientific perspective [hence: HAARP]

Of course sooner or later we will start hearing reports from those "paid to" claim this facts are false. Same as when MDs that get paid to certify false products work. Is seen on TV everyday. Then once private groups do actual testing and research on the product they show there is no evidence to show those claims made by companies are true.

Ignorance is not bliss.

by: Ze from: Brasil
January 26, 2010 13:13
Nope, this link provided doesn't show Chávez saying that... I doub he said

by: xiongnu
January 26, 2010 15:07
We are not sure why the RFE/RL Editors are not sure why we insist that a link of Chavez actually reading the text by Venezuela's official news agency in Spanish is needed. Didn't the Editors want to watch that video?

There are 11 links in Robert Coalson's transmission, and so it's not as if "providing links" goes against your policy!

Also, we are not sure why the RFE/RL Editors answered our comment by providing us with a link to a video clip that doesn't answer our request at all! Have they watched it?
In Response

by: RFE/RL Editors
January 26, 2010 16:50
This is true, that link is not of Chavez himself. Our mistake.

But the point is also not that we reported that Hugo Chavez said this, but that it was reported by Russian and Iranian sources. That's part of what makes it such a strange story -- the indirect citations. The report RT cites, for example, is here: http://www.abc.es/20100119/internacional-/chavez-acusa-provocar-seismo-201001191332.html

Yes, we would be curious to see Chavez say it, but again, that is not the focus of the item. Do you think the Russian and Iranian agencies would put words in Chavez's mouth? Has he denied saying it? If anyone can provide a link to Chavez actually making this claim, we'd like to see it.

by: Brian from: Colorado
January 26, 2010 19:11
Its not as if Hugo Chavez has completely lost touch with reality. Its not as if one could never believe that Chavez would make this kind of crazy assertion. Chavez loves to blame the Great Satan for everything that happens, and unfortunately, the majority of his followers are relatively naive, unsophisticated and uneducated.

This claim and those who seem to be defending it remind of the reports that blamed Bush for causing Hurricane Katrina. I find it laughable that there are readers on this website who actually buy into this kind of nonsense. What's wrong? Did you actually finish your copy of the National Enquirer, or Star. Maybe the illegitimate love child of Michael Jackson and space aliens will descend from the heavens and deliver the cure to cancer.

by: xiongnu
January 27, 2010 10:47
//Do you think the Russian and Iranian agencies would put words in Chavez's mouth?//

I think that many people have put words in Chavez's mouth. Google "Chavez denies" and you'll see interesting results. I saw nothing about Chavez having denied making a statement about the cause of the quake in Haiti. What Chavez said (and he's not denying it) is that the U.S. are using the Haiti earthquake... Will you comment on that?

But why would anyone at Russia Today put words in Chavez's mouth? Who knows? Perhaps an editor at Russia Today strongly dislikes the president of Venezuela? Perhaps this story is part of a conspiracy to discredit the Russian agency, or perhaps somebody at Russia Today just hates their boss? Perhaps the Russians and the Iranians wanted to see if other agencies would repeat a silly report without checking the facts?

By the way, I followed the link given by bandidito in a comment. It took me to the opinion published by ABS.es on January 24, "Un terremoto made in USA", by Francisco Robles. I can't read Spanish, but the google-translation seemed enough to convince me of Roble's great sense of subjectivity.

by: Robert from: Eastern U.S.
February 02, 2010 00:49
Senator Sam Nunn at the Conference on Terrorism, Weapons of Mass Destruction, and U.S. Strategy at the Georgia Center, Mahler Auditorium, University of Georgia, Athens, Ga.

Senator Nunn responding to a question:
"...Others are engaging even in an eco- type of terrorism whereby they can alter the climate, set off earthquakes, volcanoes remotely through the use of electromagnetic waves.
So there are plenty of ingenious minds out there that are at work finding ways in which they can wreak terror upon other nations.
It's real, and that's the reason why we have to intensify our efforts, and that's why this is so important..."

Notice the interesting identification of eco-terrorism, climate alteration, artificially induced earthquakes, etc.
And notice the Senator says it is real.

http://www.defense.gov/transcripts/transcript.aspx?transcriptid=674

Now this interview occurred in April 1997, almost 12 years ago, which means the work was going on many years before that.
And who do you think was doing the work?
Ha - now that is the fun part for your research.

So while Hugo is seemingly an interesting character, what he is saying is not outside the realm of possibility at all.

So Brian from Colorado, you might want to start working on "your education." lol
Comments page of 2
    Next 

About This Blog

Written by RFE/RL editors and correspondents, Transmission serves up news, comment, and the odd silly dictator story. While our primary concern is with foreign policy, Transmission is also a place for the ideas -- some serious, some irreverent -- that bubble up from our bureaus. The name recognizes RFE/RL's role as a surrogate broadcaster to places without free media. You can write us at transmission+rferl.org