Features

Tide Of Protest Engulfs More Russian Cities

As many as 10,000 people rallied in Kaliningrad in January.

As many as 10,000 people rallied in Kaliningrad in January.

March 10, 2010
By Claire Bigg
Like millions of Russians, Tatyana had been bracing for the annual hike in utility tariffs that comes with the new year.

But her bill for January exceeded her worst nightmares. It had jumped 25 percent from the previous month, eating up as much as two-thirds of her salary.

"I have great difficulties in paying for my flat," she says. "Salaries here are low and tariffs for utilities are very high. I grew up in Soviet times, and we didn't have such problems. I'm really scared for my children."

Tatyana, a 50-year-old preschool teacher in the central Russian city of Penza, must now spend 5,000 rubles ($168) per month on water, gas, and electricity. This leaves her with just 2,300 rubles ($77) to feed her two teenage children and her husband, an invalid whose health problems prevent him from working.

Panicked, Tatyana decided to take to the street. She joined a rally in Penza organized by the opposition this past weekend to protest worsening living conditions and call for the ouster of local leaders.

"I'm in a hopeless situation," says Tatyana, who was afraid to give her last name. "I can't bear it anymore. I need to do something about it and that's why I went to the protest. I saw that people had already been driven to despair."

Nervous authorities in Penza did their best to deter residents from attending the rally, offering free entrance to the local zoo, free city excursions, and public lectures on how to cut utility costs.

But to no avail. An estimated 2,000 protesters massed on March 7 in Penza's city center. The demonstration was peaceful but pointed: local residents are fed up with their sinking living standards, and ready to speak out about it.

Nationwide Rallies

The Penza rally was the latest in a string of street demonstrations that have rocked Russia in recent weeks. In places as varied as Samara, Irkutsk, and Archangelsk, disgruntled residents have been joining forces to protest low pay, mounting unemployment, police abuse, and what increasing numbers of Russians see as a corrupt government on both the local and federal level.

The rich are becoming even richer, the poor even poorer. Corruption is total, everyone is stealing.
The largest demonstration, held last month in the Baltic city of Kaliningrad, drew as many as 10,000 people.

The demonstration will be repeated on a nationwide scale when Kaliningrad becomes one of at least 15 cities to stage coordinated protests on March 20.

And the protest is not limited to banners and slogans shouted on cold city squares; some prominent Russians, too, are voicing their resentment at the regime built by Vladimir Putin over the past decade.

"The rich are becoming even richer, the poor even poorer. Corruption is total, everyone is stealing," veteran rock star Yury Shevchuk told his fans at a March 7 concert in Moscow. "The system has built a brutal, cruel, and inhumane government in our country. People are suffering, not only in prisons and camps, but in orphanages and hospitals as well."

The recent protests are a notable shift from the public passivity of the early and mid-2000s, when the country was enjoying an unprecedented wave of stability and economic prosperity.

Political analyst Dmitry Oreshkin says much of the roiling discontent now is due to the economic crisis, which has hit Russia particularly hard after almost a decade of oil-fueled growth.

"Unemployment is on the rise, prices are soaring, livings standards are worsening," he says. "Television tells us tales that we are rising from our knees, but this no longer reassures people."

Nervous Kremlin?

Curiously, authorities are allowing the opposition rallies and police so far have largely refrained from arresting or beating protesters.

Oreshkin says Russia's political leaders understand that using force to stem such a wave of discontent could turn against them.

"Authorities are rational enough not to follow the Chinese path," he says. "They would happily break the arms of protesters, but when these protesters number 1,500 or even 10,000, it's better to find a compromise with them. This signals an evolution of society's political culture, a very slow evolution that is taking place with the change in generation."

The Kremlin's reaction to the season of protests has been muted, but betrays concern.

President Dmitry Medvedev sent his envoy to Kaliningrad following the February rally, and a Kremlin advisor for the region, Oleg Matveychev, resigned under pressure following the protests.

Medvedev also fired the chief of police in Tomsk following a public outcry over the murder of a local journalist by police.

The demonstrations are also notable for uniting the country's usually fractious political opposition.

Communists and other marginal political parties have been responsible for organizing many of the rallies, and the sight of Russia's opposition forces standing side by side after years of infighting likely adds to the Kremlin's uneasiness.

'Authorities Need Not Worry'

But analysts say the protests bear no real threat to the political system.

"It has been able to quench the protests," says sociologist Aleksei Grazhdankin, the deputy head of Russia's independent Levada polling center. "Besides, there is currently no political force that could lead these rallies and transform them from separate local outbursts into a massive protest. So authorities need not worry."

In fact, despite growing coverage of the rallies in the Russian and international press, studies by the Levada center show that the number of political protests have not increased significantly since the mid-2000s.

Grazhdankin says Medvedev and his mentor, Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, remain hugely popular despite a slump in polls following the economic crisis. The current wave of protests, he says, is nothing more than a seasonal phenomenon.

"People always display their discontent more actively in spring," he says. "But if we compare the current situation with data from previous years, there is no real increase."

There is no doubt that anger is mounting in Russia over enduring hardship and corruption. Many are desperate for change. But even among the thousands of Russians who took to the streets in recent months, far from all believe the protests will lead to genuine improvements.

"Keep the local government or change it? I think someone else will arrive and nothing will change," says Tatyana in Penza. "I've long given up hope that things will get better."

RFE/RL's Russian Service contributed to this report
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
     
Comments
by: Vlad from: Moldova - US
March 10, 2010 19:36
10,000 is many people. I love Shevchuk and his songs. Respect him for talking honestly.

Russia is badly corrupted and bureaucracy is worse then in Moldova. Police and officials are uncontrollable.

Oil prices going up but Russia must build some economy besides natural resources. Russia needs democracy and freedom. And Russia needs to drop imperial ideas and have good relations with the West. The US and EU do not wish elimination of Russia and they bring good. Freedom does not hurt and capitalism is the best working system.
In Response

by: gimba from: Not the local
March 12, 2010 12:56
10000 it is not enough.
Shevchyuk - was on sale with giblets to oligarch Chubays.
Russia itself will solve that it should, and that is not present. ОК?
If in Moldova so it is good, why third of Moldavians on earnings in Russia, rather the reverse?

by: Johann from: USA
March 10, 2010 23:38
Vlad from Moldova says" Capitalism is the best working system"
What a noncence: A lot of my friends here in USA are out of work and are loosing their houses or businesses. They can't pay their creditcard bills.
Banks had to be saved by the "Big Government" ( That is not a capitalism)
In Russia and socialist EU it is called "State Capitalism" !!!
Vlad says Moldova is better of then Russia.
Russia controls their borders, and even expands them into Georgia.
Moldova doesn't control its border. There is a seperatist government in Transnistra, that has even business intrest in USA. European companies are doing business in Transnsitra without autorization from the central government in Chisnau. The city of Tiraspol is hosting international soccer games ( thery have much better stadium, then Chisnau).
So Moldova is not controling their borders.
Moldova can't even elect a president.
At least Putin saved Russia from anarchy and gave Russians some pride.
In Response

by: Alex from: California
March 12, 2010 00:11
You should move to Russian then if you like it so much. See how people on the street will judge you.
In Response

by: gimba from: Not the local
March 12, 2010 13:06
People in streets will not judge hee. The overwhelming majority of the population thinks as hee.
It is democracy.

by: Hryhoriy from: New York
March 11, 2010 02:50
No surprises here! The russian federation will completely implode within the next 3-4 years...no doubt about it.

by: Anthony from: Canada
March 11, 2010 13:51
I feel so sad and angry for all these poor hard working and honest Russian people. When will this government of corruption and lies come to an end? I wish all these wonderful honest Russian people could move to Canada.

by: Henry from: USA
March 11, 2010 19:49
Johann says, "What a noncence: A lot of my friends here in USA are out of work and are loosing their houses or businesses." Although, capitalism does slip up every once in a while, it does provide room for fixing its problems when it crashes. In Russia, the economy is heavily worked by Putin's government, and isn't as flexible as the Western free marker. And plus, in America, when you go out of business, you aren't starving in the cold.
In Response

by: gimba from: Not the local
March 12, 2010 13:03
You will laugh, but in Russia bankrupts too do not starve in a cold

by: rosie from: france
March 12, 2010 12:49
This is an opportunity for me to say two things that I've been itching to say on some forum.

I feel very much for Russian people who can't have a good opposition and get real democracy and freedom and a nice president. I suspect it's because they have never had that freedom so they always need a dictator like figure to control everything.

And to Johann in usa, you say 'socialist eu', that always makes me smile how right wing americans think democrats are socialist and all europe is even 'communist' LOL. There are few socialist gvts at the moment in eu, and even if in UK it's called 'labour party', they are more liberal than our conservative gvt in France. And considering all the discussions about your health care, for us, it's a joke. Every single person in France or other eu countries would hate to have a system like american for social services. We are very happy with good pensions, unemployment, family, health benefits. We have long holidays, women equality, no religion stuffed down our throats. This is a compromise between socialist pure state controlled systems and ultra liberal economies. In fact in EU, there are very few state controlled companies, even the post is getting private and energy. The problems today in the crisis is because of american ultra liberal mistakes and you have damaged the whole world.

by: Konstantin from: Los Angeles
March 15, 2010 16:43
Theafery smarties always label away theft as plossible deny-ability.
One steals in a name of Capitalisma, another in name of Socialisma.
It reminds me old French "atheists" - common sence against theafebility,
"We believe in God, not in cleargy-theafs" - but Lenin said "it is Vulgarizma".

French system of reason and the "Liberte, Dignite, Egalite" - is still working
With so called "Capitalists" and "Socialists" parties checks and ballances.
It depends also on degree of Caucasian Civilization. If no Dignity is left,
If Russia inslave or sale as slaves and plagiarize, dreams only of theft,
They look for labels to lie and expand, kill again and breed again chances.
But then again - big Barbarians say big Superpowers cannot be Frenching.

Konstantin.



by: rosie from: paris
March 17, 2010 01:27
euh, Konstantin

didn't understand a work, was that english french or russian ?
     
TEXT SIZE - +

Editors' Picks

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile