map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

'Berlin Wall's Lessons For Today'

In an op-ed for "USA Today," Jeffrey Gedmin discusses RFE and the role of free media in societies living under repressive regimes. More
More Articles

Commentary

Two Anniversaries, Two Legacies -- Which Will Bosnia Choose?

A cemetery for those who died in the siege of Sarajevo, built on a football pitch in front of the Zetra Olympic hall in Sarajevo (file photo)

February 11, 2009
By Gordana Knezevic
In Sarajevo, February is not the shortest month. At least it doesn't seem that way. There are simply too many anniversaries to honor, mourn, or celebrate.

It's been 25 years since the 1984 Winter Olympics, when for a fleeting moment the entire city was transformed into the world's sports capital. That February, every citizen of Sarajevo seemingly believed he or she had personally contributed to each medal won in the giant slalom, bobsled, or ski jump, or simply felt immeasurable pride at being a perfect host.

Eight years later, Sarajevo was back in the world's headlines when it was attacked by Serbian artillery forces. One of the worst massacres of the war that ensued took place on February 5, 1994, when a single shell killed more than 60 people and severely wounded 200 more in what came to be known as the Markale market massacre. February 5 was declared a day of remembrance for victims of the war, including 12,000 Sarajevans, many of whom are buried at former Olympic sites hastily converted to graveyards during the conflict.

The defense of Sarajevo was heroic. People of different ethnic backgrounds fought side by side to protect their right to live together -- only to see their country divided, once the war was over, into an ethnically identified Serb Republic (Republika Srpska) and a Muslim-Croat Federation.

Undoing Dayton?

The U.S.-brokered Dayton peace agreement in 1995 was praised for forcing all sides to the table to end nearly 3 1/2 years of fighting. But it was a shotgun wedding that failed to deliver the constitutional framework needed for Bosnia's future.

A Sarajevan family mourns a victim of the city's February 1994 marketplace massacre. The shelling, which killed 68 people, did not discriminate between Bosniaks, Serbs, and Croats.
One of Dayton's legacies is the Office of the High Representative, an international post established to supervise the postwar normalization. Since December 1995, the world has sent six of its most prominent diplomats to babysit the fragile Bosnian peace. The post came with almost unlimited powers. But each time, the high representative left Bosnia frustrated at his inability to move the country forward, toward real stability.

The latest such case is High Representative Miroslav Lajcak, who is leaving in favor of a post as Slovak foreign minister. Lajcak signaled his intention to leave in late January; his successor has yet to be named. Local political leaders, reasoning that Lajcak is unlikely to use his final weeks in office to play disciplinarian, have seized on this window of opportunity, using the current power vacuum to propose that Bosnia be divided into four separate regions.

Despite the locals' protestations that the plan would create "sustainable economic units," this is hardly regionalism as it is understood in Europe. Rather, it is a throwback to the early 1990s, when Bosnian Serb leader Radovan Karadzic presented a scheme to divide Bosnia into four cantons -- one Serb, one Croat, and one Muslim, with Sarajevo thrown in as a separate entity to convince the international community the division was truly administrative in nature, and not a split along ethnic lines.

In the months leading up to the war, the leaders of Bosnia's three national parties secretly drew and redrew the maps in an attempt to formalize Karadzic's proposal. Many of those maps ended up in the dustbin; but psychologically they laid the groundwork for the ethnic cleansing that followed.

Old Goals

Once again, the maps are being privately redrawn. History does not repeat itself, and the current four-unit proposal does not mean Bosnia is once again teetering on the brink of war. If anything, the leaders of the three major national parties believe the time has come to achieve their wartime goals -- albeit through peaceful means.

Even Dayton, the treaty that brought peace to Bosnia, has become a weapon in the mounting tensions. It has been nearly 14 years since the ink dried in Paris, but Bosnia's national leaders have yet to comply with one of its basic demands -- that they sit together and produce an official constitution. Without that step, Bosnia cannot move ahead on European integration or NATO membership.

But attempts to introduce a new constitution have failed repeatedly. When a preliminary document was finally cobbled together in 2007, Haris Silajdzic, the Bosniak member of the country's tripartite presidency, blocked the deal, saying it didn't go far enough. In truth, he has called for the dissolution of Republika Srpska, and has no inherent interest in carrying out Dayton to the letter. (Silajdzic was one of the key Bosniak negotiators in the Dayton talks but is now its chief critic inside the Muslim-Croat Federation.)

What has been completely lost in Bosnia is a sense of reality. Each ethnic group clings to its own narrative of the recent past.
Similarly, Milorad Dodik, the prime minister of Republika Srpska, have no personal stake in seeing a constitution approved. Officials in Banja Luka, the capital of Republika Srpska, are pushing for secession from the Muslim-Croat Federation, and have traditionally refused to countenance the three-party negotiations prescribed by Dayton.

Dodik has hired an American law firm to advise his government on any further negotiations with the international community and on other legal issues. As Russia's money and Belgrade's influence in the region grow, Dodik is increasingly flexing his muscles. He is ready to use any legal loophole or marketing trick to block constitutional changes.

In Dodik's view, the future of Republika Srpska is safe -- it is Bosnia that will not last. His arrogance is not simply poor manners. It is an intentional jibe meant to annoy his political partners and force Muslim and Croat leaders to ask for an ethnic "divorce" -- a division of the country along ethnic lines.

New Element

To add to the turmoil, the religious head of Bosnia's Islamic community, Mustafa Ceric, last week defended the country's Wahabbist movement during Friday prayers. He rejected any division between "old" and "new" Muslims, invoking specters of "Islamophobia" and "genocide" that haunt all of Bosnia's Muslims.

The appearance of religion in an already tumultuous ethnic debate is a bad sign. And as long as politicians hold the people of Bosnia hostage to their ethnic or religious identities, no one will be asking the questions that really matter: Why are more than 40 percent of Bosnians unemployed? What is the average salary still below $600? What has happened to the millions of dollars and foreign aid that has poured into the country since the end of the war? Why have reforms aimed at European integration not been introduced?

What has been completely lost in Bosnia is a sense of reality. Each ethnic group clings to its own narrative of the recent past. Most Muslims consider Republika Srpska an entity created through genocide. Many inhabitants of Republika Srpska, meanwhile, deny that events like the Markale massacre ever happened.

Nationalism in Bosnia is a strong drug that keeps the country deeply divided.

Independent voices are not being heard.

Where is the global city of Sarajevo that hosted the Olympic Games?

Gordana Knezevic is director of RFE/RL's South Slavic and Albanian Languages Services. The views expressed in this commentary are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect those of RFE/RL.
This forum has been closed.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 5
by: Abdulmajid
February 28, 2009 23:55
So Milos objects to me calling him and the likes of him, and all those who took part in the anti-Muslim crusade fascist morons. But that's what they are, and I call them what they are not because it pleases me, but because of their actions, because of what they did. And their constant saying "The Muslims committed war crimes too" does not exonerate the Serb war criminals, and to use what the Turks did hundreds of years ago as a justification for mass murder, rape etc, is a very base, vile and rotten way of thinking: And Milos, to say that rape is a normal thing in war, that it was perfectly legitimate for the Chetniks to do against Muslim women and girls, that's beyond good and evil. So the American soldiers raped Iraqi women? unfortunately, some did, but they did it against standing orders and consequently were tried and punished for it, the Chetniks did that on orders from the top, bah, it is impossible to talk some sense into you, you feel comfortable in your evil stupidity. The day will come when a Serb President or prime minister will have to apologize to the Bosniaks and the Kosovars for what Serbs did to them, just as France had recently to apologize to the Jews for the Petain colabo regime handing over the French Jews to the Nazis. And just like in today's Germany people shake their heads in disbelief whentold about the savagery and brutality of the Thirty Years' war, so one day Bosnian schoolchildren will shake their heads in disbelief when told about the savagery the Serb aggressors did in 1992-1995. And some incorrigible Serbofascist morons will continueto dream about the cross chasing the Crescent from the Balkans but they will have as much power to stop it as they might stop the Moon.
Serbofascist morons!

by: Abdul Majid
February 28, 2009 18:03
Bah that simpleton Milos. And all the other chauvinist simpletons out there. They resent my saying that I hate them. See if I care. Serbs did hateful things all over the Balkans,and their leaders are evil little chauvinists, and all the little Karadzics out there are as bad as their heroes, what is there to discuss with them, it would be like discussing with Nazis, and Fascism is not an opinion, it's a crime, and I will for as long as I live call all those who think that the Serbs have a God-given right to rule over most or all of the former Yugoslavia, and who think that they have a God-given mission to kill, expel or christianize the Muslims by their name: Fascist genocidal barbaric MORONS!!!
And unless the Serbs removbe from their political agendas all and any claims on other countries and peoples and forever renounce military aggression as a political means, and ask the Bosniaks and Kosovars' forgiveness for the genocidal crusade they attempted on them, I will NOT consider this accursed wretched nation as civilized, and that's my last, final and only word on this issue!!!

by: Abdulmajid
February 28, 2009 01:02
Well, most certainly all those Serbs who speak out for Milosevic and Karadzic, and who believe that Serbs have a God-given right to establish Greater serbia, and to kill, expel or christianize the Bosnian Muslims, to destroy the Ottoman and Austrohungarian cultural heritage in BiH, the non-Orthodox houses of worship (that is especially vile and uncivilized), rape little girls, shoot prisoners in the back (because the filthy cowards could not look them in the eyes) are certainly barbarian genocidal fascist MORONS, and these ugly, stupid evil creatures do 100% deserve my hate and contempt, and I really ask myself if they are not suffering from some kind of collective paranoia. The Bosnian Croats who share these execrable ideas are the same. They too are fascist morons, the scum of the Earth. And I will repeat it to my last breath!
But I do have to admit that it will be very difficult to stand up to these Fascists. Because if as I have just read it is true that a rather high percentage of the Serbs have notions of suicide (btw. I read this the first time several years ago) - well, who has no respect for his own life certainly has less respect for the lives of others. So it would be difficult, but nevertheless the Muslims will not be led like lambs to the slaughter. They know what to expect from the enemy: humiliation, torture, rape, destructioon, exile, death.
So they will have to act accordingly.

by: Abdul Majid
February 27, 2009 22:55
bJust those who claim to be (or who were) victims of Fascism are often the worst Fascists. Just look at Palestine. And the "Serbs" try to do the same thing in Bosnia: to turn the Bosniaks into the Palestinians of Europe. Yes, all those who stand for this idea, or who are apologists of Milosevic, Karadzic, Mladic, etc. ARE fascist morons! They show it because they always come up with the same old stuff as a justification for their latest anti-Muslim crusade: the Turks, Austrohungaria, the Nazis, the Ustase blah blah blah. What a vile , rotten way of thinking, even if we admit that in the past Serbs really were victims of aggression BUT NOT LAST TIME AROUND! To say "in the war the Serbs were the victims, not the perpetrators", or "well, all that was terrible but in war terible things always happen" is thoroughly vile and rotten. So what will they say when next time around they get the wrong end of the stick? Then I will say to them: In war terrible things always happen, so what are you crying about?
I call all those who still think that Serbs have a God-given right to rule the Balkans and a God-given mission to exterminate, expel or rechristianize the Muslims FASCISTS,and if it's the last thing I do! And if I were living in BiH anytime the mood strikes them to attack the Muslims again, I'm firmly determined not to let these pig-faced, pig-mannered sons of swine who call themselves Cetniks, Arkanovci, VRS, Serb Eagles, Skorpioni or whatever, run me out of my house, rob me of my belongings, rape my wife and daughter before my eyes etc etc etc. No: if it comes to that, I swear that before they kill me I will kill as much of them as I can. And all Bosniaks should be prepared to do the same: Why? Because we may lose next time around, but we are determined to defend ourselves, for you it will be a bitter victory. As bitter as we can make it.
But since the Bosniaks are a majority in BiH, they can soon take what's legitimately theirs. Of course Dodik and his cronies will not let go of it graciously because they are very afraid of the Muslims, for the day the Muslims will be the absolute majority in BiH these Serbs will be called to account. So someday they will lose their nerves and try to start war again, and for that day the Bosniaks should better be prepared. They should not give themselves to illusiona as to what they can expect from the Serbofascists: Humiliation,destruction, death. And if there is anything I can do to help them, I will.
To my last breath, I'm proud to be a Muslim and not even under the threat of death or torture I am willing to give it up. I try my best to respect peoples of all religious backgrounds, but I absolutely refuse my respect to those who won't accord me the same. And for those who look down on, despise and hate my religion and portray it as the greatest evil in the world, I have nothing but contempt! I feel personally insulted by them. And if this includes every Serb Fascist and Islamophobe who bad-mouths Islam and the Muslims, or worse, who participated in Karadzic's crusade and can't wait for the next, then so be it! Let them suffer the fate they have accorded us! Did you get that you Islamophoboic Serbofascist Morons?
You are the "HUNS" of today!
So you have "inat".
Well, I have "inat" too!

by: carlos from: porto
February 27, 2009 17:25
what a perfect summary of Serbs' paranoid fantasies, Milos! ooooh, even "professors will admit this"! wow, it must be true then. the "30 villages" claim has been debunked by The Hague tribunal, it is a pathetic lie. Serbs committed genocide in Bosnia, admit it and move on.

by: Milos from: Canada
February 27, 2009 15:54
Well your comments really portray your so intelligence. From all I've read in your comment is words of hate. You try and preach the word of reason but every other word is Serbs are fascist morons. Honestly listen to yourself, Serbs are not fascist; Serbs were the first ones to stand up to fascism and one of the first to fall victim to genocide in death camps (Jasenovac) led by Croatian Fascists the Ustase led by Ante Pavelic. Never again make that claim Serbs are fascists. Secondly as I stated before Yugoslavia was systematically broken up by the West. Professors openly admit this in Universities. In the late 1980's the West offered Yugoslavia a structural adjustment policy to switch its style of economy and to open it up. Something very similar that they implemented in Iraq recently. Why because Yugoslavia was a European power and the only worthwhile communist one left in Europe. This policy brought about extremely high inflation and so the economy waned. Then it wasn't hard to split the country up, they didn't do it by ethnic lines because there's one ethnicity (except the Slovenians) they did it through religious divides because that was the only way they could distinguish one group from the other. What did they do then they rallied up some ultra nationalist leaders to lead revolts Izetbegovic and Tudjman promised them arms and money and the possibility of a new country of their own. VRS and was just the counter force of this oppression led by the West and the Muslims same concept in Krajina in Croatia. NATO has even brought this same concept literally to Iraq, you see fighting between the Kurds, the Sunnis , and the Shiites. Same concept. Rape, its a fear tactic commonly used in war, look at what NATO's done in Iraq look at their jails, If Srebrenica was a "genocide" then what about the 30 Serbian villages that were burned to the ground in Srebrenica area by Naser Oric's troops who were where? In Srebrenica, Srebrenica was a UN safe haven and Izetbegovic used it as a military operation ground. In those supposed 8000 dead they identified 1200 mujahedine and Naser Oric's soldiers. So much for a safe haven. And don't try and say the common thing you always say oh what are you pulling these facts out of your ass no these facts are from UN archives that they opened and disputed. Ask any politics prof in university why they don't talk about the break up of Yugoslavia and they'll all say, "Because it worked"

by: Bosnali Abdul Majid
February 25, 2009 21:35
Bah look at that poor benighted soul Milos saying that Serbs were victims too. Well, "IN war terrible things happen" I mean, that's what I hear the justifiers of genocide say all the time. Now I'm giving it back to you.
Argue with the likes of you? Who hate the Muslims? Who despise them?
How can one discuss anything with people who refuse to talk reasonably? And who see all others as stupid? Or else why would they come up with the same old stories always?
The JNA in Bosnia just put on these Cetnik shakos on their heads and "VRS" badges on their sleeves.
80% of war victims were Bosniaks. 80% of war crimes were committed by "Serbs", and the campaign to exterminate the Bosniaks was premedidtated. All Milos and the likes of him come up with as an answer is "Aw c'mon...exterminate...such an ugly word"!
Rape camps that's unique. Some chetniks bragged about how they raped 11-year old girls, one of them (Milan Lukic)told a bereaved mother "Well be thankful that I return one of your daughters, ha ha ha!" That's the Serbs for me. That's how I will always see them.
Yugoslavia broke up because it was BANKRUPT, and the war was initiated by the pitiful, bankrupt dictators Milosevic and Tudjman. What interest would Europe have to create such a black hole of violence and brutality in their own backyard. What really happened is known. Yet there are always some fools who have to present their own twisted version of it, despite knowing it's not true.
What about the story of the refrigerated truck full of bodies of murdered Kosova Albanians which was pulled out of Perucica Lake in 1999? And the Serb TV interviewed a man who was bathing in that lake. And what did that simpleton say? "To be honest I don't believe anything of it".
The number of simpletons among the Serbs is still astonishingly high. As are those who still believe that it is their God-given right to rule the Balkans, or who feel superior to all othes because they are (even if mostly just vaguely) Orthodox Christian. Well, all that is just another way of being a simpleton.
And let me tell you this: If I see them as genocidal murderers rapists barbarian and savages then it is not because I have an ingrained hate against them (I don't have an ingrained hate against any nation in particular) but because of their actions. And your "stop accusing us of wrongdoing and try to see our side" will not exonerate them, not by a bit. So why continue saying it? It does not exonerate the serbs from the crimes they committed.
And I have tried to see your side. The Serbs know that their numbers in Bosnia are shrinking while the number of Bosniaks is increasing. Until 2025 or 28, they will be >67%, and then they can do as they please. Karadzic's attempt at destroying them was nothing but a pathetic try to stave off the inevitable.
So hang your head and cry you Serbofascist morons!

by: Milos from: Canada
February 25, 2009 16:21
Well, I think people should really stop bringing up rape when it comes to war because there were atrocities on both sides, and there always are atrocities on both sides. Another thing Vukovar and Krajina were very Serbian dominated areas.
Yes Serbs lost the war and nobody ever wants to listen to us see our view because it is much easier to demonise another than to actually rationally argue them. Media cannot talk about the atrocities that were brought upon the Serbs by the muslims and the Croatians because that would completely undermine the fact that they won a war that was completely provoked and funded by Western powers. Another thing muslims and Croatians didn't grasp the idea of Yugoslavia as well as the Serbs did because to this day there are people in Serbia that call themselves Yugoslavs and not Serbs. During that war Serbia proper was called Yugoslavia, and many people considered themselves Yugoslavs and not Serbs hence why Serbia's influence in the war really wasn't all that great. Because as we all know if the JNA went into Croatia and Bosnia the war would have been won by the Serbs or many more NATO and EU soldiers would have been brought in to help. Anyways aside from what could have happened because what ifs are very useless Al down there just claimed he wasn't racist but he just completely went on a big tangent of racial slurs against Serbs. I never said I don't like being called a Chetnik, truthfully my grandpa was a Chetnik and yes Chetniks were guerrillas because fighting an open war with a power like Nazi Germany really wasn't smart. And I mean honestly don't use the word in such a demeaning way how will somebody not be insulted by it, like if I called you a rapist balija (which there were) you're going to go on a big bloody rant about something that has nothing to do about it next time I go on this site. Personally I think we can live together, I actually think all the south Slavs (former Yugoslav countries) can live together and it would be better for them to do so because together we were strong and we can be strong, but that's too much optimism when you have people like buddy down there raging about things that commonly happen in times of war.

by: D from: Michigan
February 24, 2009 19:48
This is a very biased paper...it is very easy to see that this author did not know what is was talking about from their very primitive and biased facts. You should be ashamed of yourself.

by: Abdulmajid from: Berlin
February 20, 2009 12:19
Mirza,
that's what I'm saying: Where no one isdiscriminated against and all people are accorded the respect they wish for themelves. And the children to be taught that genocide was only caused by some very evil men, but that man ist good at heart. I know, becasuse at their best, these good, kind, generous, industrious people deserve better than they have now.
But there can be no place in Bih for Fascists of all kinds, and that means not for Wahabis either.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 5
TEXT SIZE - +
Video
Sarajevo's Brightest Days

For a fleeting moment 25 years ago, the 1984 Winter Olympics in Sarajevo transformed the city into the international sporting capital of the world.  Just a few years later, the region would be engulfed in war and Sarajevo would never be the same. Video courtesy of TV Liberty. Play

Editors' Picks

Arresting Images

Photos Of The Week Photogallery

President Van Rompuy

'How's That Again?!' Audio

Karzai Inauguration

The Anticipation Of Change Video

Follow Us On Twitter

Keep up-to-date on all the latest news from RFE/RL's broadcast region by following us on Twitter:
~ You can find our instant news feed at @RFE_RLNEWS.
~ An obsessive Kremlin watcher? Follow our blog at @PowerVertical.
~ Human rights abuses chronicled at @RightsWatchdog.
~ News, comment, and the odd silly dictator story at @TransmissionRFE.

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile