Saturday, May 26, 2012


News

U.S. Congressional Panel Backs Recognition Of Armenian 'Genocide'

People lay flowers in April 2009 at a memorial in Yerevan to the victims of the World War I-era killings.
TEXT SIZE - +
WASHINGTON -- A U.S. congressional committee has voted to approve a nonbinding resolution recognizing as "genocide" the mass killing of Armenians by Turkish forces at the end of World War I.

The vote by the House Foreign Affairs Committee was 23-22 in favor of the resolution, ignoring objections by the administration of President Barack Obama and the government of Turkey.

Turkey responded immediately, recalling its ambassador to Washington.

Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan said in a statement that he was seriously concerned that the resolution would harm relations between Ankara and Washington. He also expressed concern that the move might threaten efforts by Turkish and Armenian officials to turn the page on a century of mutual mistrust and hostility.

Armenian officials described the vote as a boost for human rights.

The resolution now goes to the full House, where it is unclear whether it will pass.

White House spokesman Mike Hammer said that one day before the vote, Obama called Turkish President Abdullah Gul to express his appreciation for Turkey's efforts to normalize relations with Armenia.

Hammer said Obama urged Turkey to rapidly ratify a deal reached in October with Armenia that would open the border between the two countries. The deal still must be approved by the Turkish parliament, and Turkish lawmakers have warned that the committee's vote could stall progress.

Meanwhile, the White House urged the Foreign Affairs Committee not to pass the resolution, saying it would offend Turkey at a time when relations with Ankara are crucial for U.S. Middle East policy.

A White House statement said that on March 3, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton spoke with the committee's chairman, Howard Berman, a Democrat from California, urging him to let Turkey and Armenia resolve the issue between themselves. The two countries are now in talks on improving their relations.

Chief executives from the U.S. aerospace and defense industries also had warned passage of the resolution could lead to a "rupture in U.S.-Turkey relations" and put American jobs at risk.

Before the vote, members of the committee debated the issue vigorously. In opening the hearing, Berman noted that historians and experts on international law agree that the deaths constituted genocide.

"As crimes of genocide continue to plague the world, Turkey's policy of denying the Armenian genocide gives license to those who perpetrate genocide everywhere," stated Berman.

Berman acknowledged that Turkey has for decades been a vital and loyal NATO ally of the United States, but said any souring in bilateral relations over a U.S. recognition of the Armenian genocide would pass quickly because Turks understand the importance of their link to the United States.

He also noted that nearly two dozen other countries and the European Parliament already have recognized the Armenian genocide. Berman said it's important that the United States, which views itself as a beacon of human rights around the world, should do the same.

Some members of the committee who opposed the resolution countered that the United States shouldn't be risking any bad feelings with a predominantly Muslim state at a time when Washington is trying to bolster its standing with the Islamic world.

One of them was Representative Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, a Republican from the southern state of Florida.

"We need to ensure that our decisions and our actions concerning the resolution before us do not have unintended consequences that could place at risk critical U.S. security interests, our operations in Afghanistan and Iraq, and our troops serving in harm's way."

Representative Dan Burton, a Republican from the midwestern state of Indiana, reminded the committee of the talks between Armenia and Turkey. He said the United States shouldn't intrude but leave the issue for them to resolve.

"But the question is: Is it the right thing to pass this kind of resolution? What good is it going to do? I don't see that it is going to help anything. Now, the two countries in question are trying to negotiate a settlement, to bring in international experts to look at all the historical facts and come up with some kind of a conclusion. It seems to me that's the best way to let this thing be solved," said Burton.

Despite such objections, Berman urged the committee to vote in favor of the resolution. He said he doubted that Turkey would allow its ties with the United States to suffer too much.

The committee chairman said he believed that just as the United States values good relations with Turkey, so must Ankara value its relations with Washington.

written by Andrew Tully based on RFE/RL and wire reports
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments page of 3
    Next 
by: Alex from: Fort Lauderdale, FL
March 05, 2010 08:07
Despite the paradoxical statement that America is a "beacon of human rights", this is great in regard that Turkey must understand that any hard-headed stunts it pulls in retaliation will fail. France recognized the genocide despite near-identical threats from Ankara. Italy, Greece, the Netherlands, Belgium, Canada, Poland - all NATO allies, have not suffered from any impositions Turkey may or may not have placed on them. So good luck, Turkey. Good luck on your hot-headed rampage.

by: vlad from: USA - Moldova
March 05, 2010 16:46
I have written a petition to our congressman and singed one to Obama to pass recognition of the Armenian genocide. It is sad that Obama promised to recognize Armenian genocide but failed to do that so far.

All peoples from South-Eastern Europe remember Ottoman Empire rule very well. I would not doubt it was a genocide.

by: MSO from: MSO
March 05, 2010 19:33
Does any one know the meaning of Genocide? This must be a government decision to exterminate a nation. Is there any evidence this was a government decision? Years passes but there are only tv programs, all kind of press articles, but there is no evidence. Turkey does not deny the massacres but denies the the government plan to destroy a nation. Withour adding any value to this contradiction in views, people only repeats to me what they were educated by the public relations of Armenian side.

by: MSO from: USA
March 05, 2010 19:36
With a similar argument, the World War 1 and 1980's Turkish immigrants from south eastern Europe also remembers what happened over there. There is no doubt of your hatred against Turks and muslims.

by: Victor from: California, USA
March 07, 2010 00:19
"Does any one know the meaning of Genocide?"

Yes, the word "genocide" was coined by Raphael Lemkin - actually GIVING WHAT HAPPENED TO ARMENIANS AS A PRIME EXAMPLE OF THE GENOCIDE

So the definition of the word itself is based on the Armenian mass murder.

by: Taxpayer from: USA
March 07, 2010 00:31
MSO said: "There is no doubt of your hatred against Turks and muslims."

This is a very interesting way of thinking - I guess projecting Turkish mentality on other groups is the only way they can explain the world around them.

Who says Armenians or Americans hate Turks and Muslims? In fact, the recognition of Armenian Genocide by Turkey would benefit Turkish people more then anybody. This will help Turkey to realize that the future is not in protecting its murderous past but with developing future together with other ethnic groups of this country. To this day despite all the genocides and assimilation efforts Turks (descendants of the nomadic Turkic tribes that came from what is now Altay region in Russia) are a minority in Turkey.

One day all people in Turkey will realize that they were brainwashed by their government just like people in Soviet Union were. These believes in the great past of Ottoman Empire and greatness of Mustafa Kemal (aka ataturk god) lead nowhere.

Turkey's out-of-wedlock child Azerbaijan where Turkic population committed genocide against Armenians in 1980-90s suffers from the same genocide amnesia disorder (must be genetic) while monuments to their late president Heydar Aliyev are erected by his son and current president in every poor village. All these monuments will be thrown down one day by the same people who worship them now just like monuments to Lenin, Stalin and Saddam Hussein were.

by: MiddleEastMan from: UK
March 07, 2010 02:34
The US will not take the fake genocide any further, Turkey is not weak as before. In world war 1 when the soldiers went to war to fight the brits, greeks, russians, frenchs and many more it was the armenian tribesmen killing innocent turkish women and children and turks have all the proof of this, what the turks are saying to armenians is, come face to face and open your archives and we will open are archives and lets call all the prefessors and historians and see if its a genocide, if it is then turks are happy to pay the penalty, but if you make a comedy show and vote its a genocide then the turks wont take it.
Turkey will not lose in this game but the US and armenians will.
p.s it wasnt 1.5 million its impossible.

by: MiddleEast from: UK
March 07, 2010 02:37
US recognition of a bogus genocide and thus legislating falsified version of history into law, to appease well-oiled Armenian lobby and to secure future votes and dollars from Armenians, while expedient, would be a travesty of justice, fairness, honesty, scholarship, critical thinking, and free speech. But just as gravely, it would make a mockery of the U.S. Congress’ own records, as the following among many other such documents, clearly refute Armenian claims once and for all:
a- “American Military Mission to Armenia” (General Harbord) Report 1920 and the Annex Report Nat. Archives 184.021/175 –which does not mention any “race extermination” but, on the contrary, refers to “…refinements of cruelty by Armenians to Muslims…”
b- Joint U.S. CONGRESS RESOLUTION NO. 192, APRIL 22, 1922 relative to the activities of Near East Relief ending 31 December 1921 which has unanimously resolved that a total of 1,414,000 Armenians were alive (which makes killing of 1.5 million Armenians an impossibility, since the total Armenian population was around 1.5 million at the time.)
c- George Montgomery, a member of the U.S. delegation at the Paris Conference, had presented a detailed tabulation in 1919, showing a total of 1,104,000 Armenians alive, apart from those who had already immigrated to other countries.
d- 29 March 1919 report of the Paris Conference subcommittee on atrocities, chaired by the U.S. secretary of State Lansing, lists Armenian losses as “…more than 200,000…” Even this number is exaggerated as they got their information from the Armenian church, not exactly an impartial source. The Turkish Historical Society documented the deaths of 53,000 Armenians using Ottoman police reports field on site, of which number only about 8,400 are reported as victims of massacres. The paragraphs a, b, and c jointly point to the THS number being closer to reality.
Who, then may have jacked this number of Armenian casualties from the original 54,000 first to 200,000 in March 1919, 600,000 in May 1919 (in a poster created by Armenians) to the current 1.5 million?

by: RD
March 07, 2010 02:59
MSO, let me educate you a little. You are looking for proof that the Turkish Government planned and executed the Armenian Genocide. Here is a little bit of proof for you, but you will have to ask yourself the question; what happened to more than 2 million Armenians that lived in Eastern Turkey? They all just decided one day to pick up only the clothes on their back and leave Turkey? Yes, the Turkish Government thinks it can fool the world by saying it was not aware of what was happening to the Armenians, much like Hitler had no idea that atrocities were being committed against Jews.

by: jean valjean from: france
March 07, 2010 10:03
Why do you bracket the word genocide ?? There is no doubt at all about this historical fact and the only relevant point is the unbearable Turksih denial policy. Radio "Free" Europe should know this !
Comments page of 3
    Next 

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Chechen Leader Names New Premier

Latest Comment (2 total)

Gushing gush: Your Kadirov and his new minister look like Mongols, but blonde Mongols. Are ... More

Protests Haunt Baku Eurovision Final

Latest Comment (1 total)

super-sonic-Arab-rocket: may be these idiots will arrest all of Azerbaijan until Eurovision ends ! ... More

Last 10 Eurovision Finalists Picked

Latest Comment (5 total)

Camel Anaturk: Meine Liebling EuGenio,we heard and read all about that on radio the Voice ... More