Saturday, May 26, 2012


Features

U.S. Envoy Holbrooke Starts Three-Day Visit To Pakistan

Holbrooke is set to visit Peshawar in Pakistan's troubled northwest
x
Holbrooke is set to visit Peshawar in Pakistan's troubled northwest
TEXT SIZE - +
By Abubakar Siddique
Richard Holbrooke, President Barack Obama's special envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan, has arrived in Islamabad at the start of a three-day visit.

Pakistan's Foreign Ministry has said that Holbrooke will discuss with Pakistani leaders a "comprehensive strategy" to tackle militancy and extremism in the region.

Holbrooke told an international security conference in Munich on February 7 and 8 that to resolve the conflict in Afghanistan, a new approach is required that must involve all of Afghanistan's neighbors, and Pakistan in particular.

In meetings with Pakistani leaders, both sides are expected to grapple with the complex problems posed by an expanding Taliban and Al-Qaeda insurgency.

Tariq Fatmi, Pakistan's former ambassador in Washington and Brussels, told RFE/RL that Pakistani leaders have welcomed Holbrooke's appointment, but are likely to press him to take their perspective into account.

"Washington has to recognize that the war on terror as pursued by the Bush administration has not only failed to achieve its objective in Afghanistan, but has resulted in the problem assuming alarming proportions for Pakistan as well," Fatmi said in a telephone interview from the Islamabad.

"Secondly, Washington has to appreciate that Pakistan now has a democratically elected government for which it may not be possible to agree to some of those [demands] that were made on it regularly when we had an authoritarian regime," he said.

Visit To The Frontier

To see the situation firsthand and to better understand the dynamics of the Taliban and Al-Qaeda insurgency in Pakistan, Holbrooke is expected to visit Peshawar, according to Pakistani media reports. The capital of Pakistan's North West Frontier Province, Peshawar also serves as the administrative headquarters for the neighboring tribal areas that are directly controlled by Islamabad.

In Peshawar, regional analyst Khalid Aziz tells RFE/RL that recent attacks in the eastern Pakistani province of Punjab show that the insurgency has now expanded well beyond parts of the remote tribal regions on the Afghan border.

In relatively peaceful southern Punjab last week, some 30 people were killed in a suicide attack on a religious procession of Shi'ite Muslims.

In another attack over the weekend, seven policemen were killed as their security post was blown to pieces. Pakistani Taliban militants later accepted responsibility for both attacks.

Pakistani and U.S. officials have had sharply different perspectives in the past on the spread of militancy in Pakistan. Washington has complained about the lack of concerted Pakistani efforts to root out Taliban and Al-Qaeda sanctuaries on its soil and even questioned Pakistan's sincerity in fighting the extremists.

Pakistan, for its part, has seen U.S. drone attacks against alleged militant targets as "counterproductive," and warns that in some cases, those strikes push more people into the extremist fold.

Aziz said that Holbrooke's visit will give the United States and Pakistan an opportunity to reconcile such differences.

"Obviously this is an expanding insurgency; the militancy is ratcheting up," Aziz said. "The presence of Mr. Holbrooke will give an opportunity to the Pakistani and U.S. policy planners to get to grips with it."

Former Pakistani ambassador Fatmi says that Holbrooke is likely to hear from Pakistani leaders that he needs a broader regional effort to succeed in resolving the conflict now centered in Afghanistan and Pakistan.

He adds that Pakistan's arch-rival India and other regional powers must facilitate such an approach.

"I think it would be to the long-term advantage of India, Pakistan, [and] Afghanistan. I would even broaden it to Iran, China, [and] Russia...for all these countries to sit down together and look at the problem in a less nationalistic and more regional approach," Fatmi said.

As a former ambassador himself, he recommends that even a seasoned diplomat such as Holbrooke should begin by listening intently.

"I would tell him to be patient and to be a good listener. Because in South Asia, these things matter...and a bit of deference and a bit of humility can take you far," he said.
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Mumtaz Piracha from: Karachi
February 14, 2009 11:57
Good Governance Forum is the largest, most diversified and globally searched platform for exchange of views on key national and international issues amongst the concerned citizens of Pakistan belonging to all segments of the society.

Richard Holbrooke's visit to Pakistan lasted for just 3-4 days. He hardly had time to meet and exchange views with independent media, forums and public service organizations like the Good Governance Forum. His discussions with the government officials and selective political leaders remain hidden from the public view.

Governance is the KEY to all issues emanating in and out of Pakistan. Unless and until it is drastically reformed, Pakistan will remain plagued with domestic, regional and global issues. The epidemic of extremism, militancy,and terrorism is the outward manifestation of the outdated establishment methods and methodology, out of tune with the current and foreseeable challenges of phenomenal proportions.

The best option is to hold free, fair and transparent fresh elections in Pakistan as soon as possible and let all national, regional, ethnic and special interest representative parties and groups find a place in the federal and provincial legislatures. Any representative group outside the legislature will always remain a thaw in the neck.

Last general elections in Feb 2008 could hardly be called general elections. Many parties and groups either boycotted the elections or could not win seats owing to their size and outreach. It also cannot be ruled out that the elections were partly engineered to partly support vested interests. A detailed study of the election results can practically demonstrate the fine tuning of the election engineering.






by: M Saleem Chaudhry from: Karachi
February 16, 2009 17:21
If the restoration of pre-November,2007 judiciary was materialized as demanded by legal fraternity,political parties,wedded to fair principles and hard core nationalist organizations, the pseudo-democracy and a mockery of popular leadership could not dream of getting catapulted in the corridors of power.There would have been little scope for manipulation of all sorts by Machiavellian characters and current chaotic situation would have been managed much earlier.Thus Holbrooke could have talked in much more conducive environment with visionary and trustworthy leadership of Pakistan who would not have been hesitant to let Holbrooke have feedback from civic bodies to build a comprehensive evaluation of ground realities,enabling him to work out realistic and practical options.

by: Salil Niyogi from: Oak Ridge, TN,,USA
February 17, 2009 19:05
Mr. Holbrooke's visit is timely. He will
stress Pakistan's control of Al Quaida and Pakistan's role in the Mumbai attacks. With India, he should assure US support in India's border dispute with China. He should assure increased US-India trade. People in India like the USA!

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Chechen Leader Names New Premier

Latest Comment (2 total)

Gushing gush: Your Kadirov and his new minister look like Mongols, but blonde Mongols. Are ... More

Protests Haunt Baku Eurovision Final

Latest Comment (1 total)

super-sonic-Arab-rocket: may be these idiots will arrest all of Azerbaijan until Eurovision ends ! ... More

Last 10 Eurovision Finalists Picked

Latest Comment (5 total)

Camel Anaturk: Meine Liebling EuGenio,we heard and read all about that on radio the Voice ... More