Wednesday, November 26, 2014


Features

No Love Lost: Afghan Woman Exposes Corrupt Judge's Unusual Offer

"I raised my voice because I wanted to stand up against and get rid of corruption," Dewa says. (file photo)
"I raised my voice because I wanted to stand up against and get rid of corruption," Dewa says. (file photo)

Related Articles

Karzai Blames Foreigners For Corruption

Afghan President Hamid Karzai says foreign governments are to blame for widespread corruption in Afghanistan and are undermining his efforts to establish the rule of law.
By RFE/RL's Radio Free Afghanistan and Frud Bezhan
A senior judge has been convicted of bribery and fired from his position after a perversion of justice exposed the invasiveness of corruption within Afghan society.

Zahoruddin, a 65-year-old judge in the country's eastern Nangarhar Province, who like many Afghans goes only by one name, was convicted on December 19 of bribery and corruption charges stemming from a young woman's divorce case.

Zahoruddin and another judge apparently became aware that Dewa, a 22-year-old freelance journalist, had filed for divorce and conspired to extort bribes from her in exchange for ensuring her request was granted.

Zahoruddin contacted Dewa, offering to help. But upon meeting with the young woman, he demanded more than $2,000 in bribes. When his offer was refused, he offered an alternative -- entering a life of wealthy matrimony with none other than the judge himself.

Unknown to the judge was that Dewa had come to the meeting armed with a hidden recording device. She recorded the entire 15-minute exchange. Dewa sent the recording of their conversation to the Supreme Court in Kabul and a criminal investigation ensued.

Second Judge Investigated

Zahoruddin strenuously denied the allegations against him, insisting that his marriage proposal was merely a "joke." Upon being confronted with the evidence, the judge accused Dewa of fabricating the evidence as part of a conspiracy to discredit him.
He said I wouldn't be alive to enjoy my freedom.

Despite his pleas, Zahoruddin was convicted on December 19 of bribery and corruption by a court in Nangarhar's capital, Jalalabad. It was not immediately clear whether he received a jail sentence.

Fazil Hadi Fazil, the chief justice of the appeals court in Nangarhar, said police are also investigating another judge, Tahir Rohani, who was presiding over Dewa's divorce case. In his testimony, Zahoruddin said he and Rohani had hatched a plan to split the bribe money.

"Our superiors are very serious about these kinds of allegations," Fazil says. "Judge Tahir Rohani, who is a senior judge at the family court in Nangarhar, is being investigated and questioned by the Supreme Court. The court will soon reach a verdict in that case."

Dewa, who has spent the last few weeks in hiding in Kabul, has welcomed the verdict. Her divorce case, however, has yet to be resolved.

Dewa claims that, after revealing the secret recording of her conversation with Zahoruddin, she received a death threat from the judge. Out of concerns for her safety, police put her in a safe house in Kabul, where she remained during the police investigation and subsequent trial.

"When my story became public, I received a phone call not long after," Dewa says. "[Zahoruddin] told me 'You got what you wanted, and now you have dishonored me in front of everyone.' He said I wouldn't be alive to enjoy my freedom."

'Shower Her With Gold'

Dewa says her ordeal began last month when she filed her divorce papers at a courthouse in Jalalabad. Within days, Dewa says, she received Zahoruddin's offer to help and set up a meeting.

After refusing his bribe request, Dewa says, the marital offer came. Zahoruddin boasted about how his standing as a judge could protect her and offered her a solid financial future. In the course of the 15-minute recording, Zahoruddin can be heard saying he would "shower her with gold." The judge is also heard repeating his marriage proposal some 15 times.

His marital advances spurned, the judge left and swore he would ensure Dewa's divorce papers would never be formalized.

Despite Zahoruddin's conviction, Dewa says the media attention surrounding the case has exposed her to possible retaliation. Even so, Dewa says she has no regrets about doing her part to expose rampant corruption in the country.

"I raised my voice because I wanted to stand up against and get rid of corruption," she says. "I want the government to help me with my security so that my life is not in danger. I've left my hometown in Nangarhar Province and I can't go back."

Integrity Watch Afghanistan, a local nongovernmental organization, estimates that Afghans, who have consistently identified corruption as among their biggest concerns, collectively pay bribes amounting to $1 billion a year, about 5 percent of the country's entire annual gross domestic product.

Zahoruddin's conviction is a rare success story. Despite President Hamid Karzai's repeated promises to clean up corruption, analysts say there have been few results from his initiatives, citing the government's failure to prosecute a single high-level corruption case.

Written by Frud Bezhan, based on reporting by RFE/RL's Afghan Service

Frud Bezhan

Frud Bezhan covers Afghanistan and the broader South Asia and Middle East region. Send story tips to bezhanf@rferl.org. 

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Anonymous
December 22, 2012 14:38
is this the sophisticated hegelian or rather slightly corrupted and misguided "pseudo-sharia" "logic of an afghan judge"?:

"[...] now you have dishonored me in front of everyone."

this guy blackmails and threatens her and she (!) has "dishonoured" him. (?)

not much self-reflexivity and self-criticism in some parts of the world.

wow!

the recording, great idea though!
Dewa for a ministry on corruption! (just kidding, of course)

finally, something positive from the region!
(let's wait though, whether she is still alive in few months time.)
In Response

by: Anonymous
December 26, 2012 17:22
um,
You do know that's a standard reaction, by crooks everywhere, to exposure, right? It's not even limited to misogynists, though popular among the group. "How dare you show me up", frequently paired with "everybody does it": totally global.
In Response

by: Anonymous
December 27, 2012 13:41
"totally global"? -
according to transparency indices (transparency international) some places are verifiably more prone to the transgressions of law than others. this of course doesn't imply that certain phenomena could not be discernible elsewhere.
to deduce though that blackmailing a young woman to marry her on an institutional level is global. quite daring.
Maybe - as you might claim inherently - there is a global tendency; several countries come to mind when addressing abuse of power and harassment, violence against.
yet, I guess that this kind of misdemeanour and the implicit, tacit acceptance of such phenomena in certain societies are not that widespread in some parts of the world where certain indices are relatively low. well, just a guess.
No offense! have a great day!

by: Bill Webb from: Phoenix Arizona USA
December 23, 2012 00:18
All public officials should behave as if they were on video all of the time, then corruption would be no more, even if, according to muslin men, it's "just a woman."

by: Ahamad Ali from: Malaysia
December 28, 2012 15:04
in my opinion, it is the right time to publish all about this wild man (biography, video). he can not be called judge. I big to Afghan goverment to bring him to jail because we don't want others to do such a bad and foolish thing in the future.
I appreciat you Dewa! you are the only strongest women who have the right job. but we or the people want to know more about this nonhumanbeing that who and where is he from?

Most Popular