Sunday, May 26, 2013


Afghanistan

Khomeini Commemorations Met With Resistance By Afghan Youth

A large billboard in Kabul, erected by the Islamic Shura of Kabul, to mark the anniversary of the death of former Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khomeini
A large billboard in Kabul, erected by the Islamic Shura of Kabul, to mark the anniversary of the death of former Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khomeini

Related Articles

Video Opponents Look To Put Dogfighting On Tight Leash In Afghanistan

Dogfighting, although illegal, has long been a lucrative and popular sport in Afghanistan. But the blood sport is being given a tight leash as opponents call on authorities to enforce animal-protection laws.
TEXT SIZE - +
By Frud Bezhan
Young people swept through the streets of Kabul this week, defacing and tearing down posters of Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini plastered throughout the city.

Meant to commemorate the anniversary of the death of the former Iranian supreme leader, the posters and large billboards have offended many in Afghanistan, a Sunni-majority country whose relations with its western neighbor have recently soured.

Demonstrations including both Sunni and Shi'a have been staged daily in the Afghan capital ahead of the June 3 anniversary.

Scores of young people gathered on June 1 in front of a looming billboard of Khomeini, some carrying placards reading: "This is Kabul not Tehran."

"Why are we celebrating Khomeini's day here?" asked Kabul University student Ahmad Jan Kandahari. "He is an Iranian figure. Why do we need to celebrate him here in Afghanistan? Here we have our own cultural icons and jihadi figures. They should be the ones celebrated in Afghanistan."

'Direct Attack'

During a rally on May 31, a Kabul high-school student named Arash described efforts to honor Khomeini as a grave injustice to the Afghan nation.

"As you see, posters of Ayatollah Khomeini are hanging in the intersections," he said. "This is a direct attack against Afghan culture and own national heroes."

Young people demonstrate against Khomeini in Kabul on May 30.
Young people demonstrate against Khomeini in Kabul on May 30.
The social-networking site Facebook was abuzz with comments and photos after the posters were put up. And while many were critical of the move, some defended Khomeini as a great leader of the Islamic faith.

"Khomeini is one of the leaders of the Islamic faith," wrote Ashraf Frugh. "He doesn't just belong to Iran but to all countries where he has followers."

Such supporters of Khomeini are the ones the Islamic Shura of Kabul, the Shi'ite council that put up the posters, intended to bring on to the streets on June 1. The posters, which the council put up with the permission of local authorities, feature a large image of Khomenei and announce a "big gathering" in large letters. All comers are invited to celebrate the 23rd anniversary of the "Great Leader...saying goodbye to this world."

The religious council expects hundreds to pour through the Mazari Mosque in a mass prayer to pay their respects.

Fierce Political Debate

Coming amid increased tensions between Tehran and Kabul, with some Afghan lawmakers accusing Iran of meddling in Afghanistan's internal affairs, the issue has become fodder for a fierce political debate.

"Iranian leaders are not the leaders of Afghanistan!" wrote Kabul University student Rohullah Elham in one Afghan forum. "The policies of Iran do not favor Afghanistan. The Islamic regime in Iran is not our government. Those of you who have sold your souls, wake up!"

Ahmad Saeedi, a Kabul-based political analyst, says the marking of Khomeini's death in Afghanistan is a worrying indication of Iran's growing influence in the country.

"The cultural, economic, and political influence of Iran starts from the presidential office and spreads throughout the country," Saeedi says. "This is ensuring that the rules and traditions of Iran are overriding those in Afghanistan."

Observers say the main source of recent Afghan-Iran tensions is Kabul's signing of a long-term strategic agreement with United States on May 1, which raised Iranian fears of an extended U.S. presence in Afghanistan.

Some Afghan lawmakers and officials have accused Tehran of launching a campaign aimed at derailing the U.S.-Afghan partnership, notably through bribing influential Afghan lawmakers and by inciting anti-American and antigovernment sentiment through media outlets it funds.

Written and reported by Frud Bezhan, with additional reporting by RFE/RL's Radio Free Afghanistan

* This article has been amended since it was originally posted
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments page of 2
    Next 
by: Davood from: Kabul
June 01, 2012 19:40
It is a matter of profound disappointment that the RFERL is being used as a tool to inflame ethnic/sectarian tension in Afghanistan. Contrary to the report's implicit message, the demonstrators come mainly from Hazara/Shia communities as well as from other communities. This report and some recent reports on Afghanistan by both RFERL and local services (Dari/Pashtu) demonstrate the unprofessional conduct on part of some Afghan journalists who cannot disassociate their work from their ethnic politics as well as the RFERL's management' s failure not to acquainted with the growing ethnic tension in Afghanistan.
In Response

by: Moderator
June 02, 2012 13:18
This report has since been amended.
In Response

by: kabulistani from: Kabul
June 03, 2012 03:06
when Karzai and his team commemorate from some Pakistani Pashton by the money of Afghanistan people why nobody object it? few months ago there was a big gathering/conference on Achakzai Pakistani, Karzai is paying Afgjhanistan's money for Pakistan tribal people, why nobody did demonstrate? Khomini is Iranian I accept this but Achkzai and Ghafar khan is also Pakistani for us! I am not Hazara neither Shie and I don't see it necessary that we commemorate the death of Khomini here as it doesn't solve the problem of our people but if some body did it we should tolerate it as a principle of democracy we should respect the others' rights! unfortunately in VOA/ Radio liberty/sdaie Azadi there some fascist pashton anchors who have discrimination with other ethnic groups in Afghanistan, their reports are always based on their fascism believes and interests, they are even against Farsi/Dari language but they are working in Radio liberty Dari section and the same with VOA, I am wondering how these VOA and Radio Liberty don't know that these people are discrediting the channels.
In Response

by: Latif Logagare from: Kabul
June 03, 2012 13:11
I totally agree that When Mr. Karzai commemorate death anniversary of a Pakistani Pashtoon just because he is speaking the same language as Mr. Karzai then every other tribe in Afghanistan has the right to do the same.
Mr. Karzai laid down the base for Racism as his other (Afghan Millat) group used to do in the past.
In Response

by: wali from: kabul
June 05, 2012 09:38
dear karzai commemorated afghan achakzai and ghaffar khan...they are not pakistani but afghans like u and me...ghaffar khan is not buried at his native town but prefferd afghanistan jalalabad and achakzai and his forefathers participated in every war of afgans.. he died for afghans and untill now his family and his followers are struggling for peace in afghanistan, they didn,t support pak but afghanistan..on other hand iran is destabalising afghanistan and they r not afghans but our enemy..so there is hell of difference between khomeni and achakzai..karzai is right commemorate all afghan personalities

by: ali from: sydney
June 02, 2012 05:14
Hazaras Number one enemy is Iran . down with to those who sold their souls to iran . wake up guys . we are always blamed slaves of iran . i think it is time to say no to such iranian activities inside our country

by: jawad from: Kabul
June 02, 2012 09:06
This report is written based on widespread discrimination against Hazara people. Reporter has tried to discriminate Hazara people. He has tried to show that just Hazara people are under influence of Iran and to justify his unfair claim, he has lied. And has tried to show that Hazara people did nothing just celebrating Khomain's death anniversary, while the youth who resisted and protested were Hazara youth and they carried placards reading "Here is Kabul, not Tehran" and these Hazara youth were the people who didn't let Iranian ambassador to get out of his embassy. The reporter has written that it was managed to celebrate Khomaini's death in Mazari Mosque, while we don't have any mosque named Mazari Mosque. We have Mazari Square which was the ground of our protest against Khomain's ( who we call him Iranian Religious Evil) death anniversary. WE hope, before hiring such reporters teach them ethics of Journalism and Honesty in their career. I was one of the protesters against Khomaini and Iran's interferences in Afghanistan. I was hoping that your radio will have a fair report on our protest. But when I read this report It deeply made me fell annoyed. Your reporter has tried to ignore our work because we are Hazara.
In Response

by: Moderator
June 02, 2012 13:18
This report has since been amended.
In Response

by: Ashraf from: Australia
June 03, 2012 00:07
All I can say is that put the facts mentioned in this report upside down, then you will get the truth. The report doesn't reflect the truth about what happened and whether Hazaras are the ones supporting Iran meddling into Afghanistan's internal affairs. And Majority of Hazara's young and old generation don't have a favourable look towards Iran and it's polititian. You can't tell lies anymore! Wake up! The world has changed!
In Response

by: Saman from: Mazar
June 02, 2012 18:15
Being under the influence of the USA (and Jewish lobby) is worse!!! Afghan "journalists" paid by the CIA to write bogus stories about Iran is worse. Either people of Afghanistan have to wake up or be under their Imperial US masters and drug lords.

by: Anonymous
June 02, 2012 14:22
dear rferl!
I am really shocked! it's the second or third time in a time frame of just less than a moth that I have read comments about very different regions precisely highlighting that some journalists in rferl both distort and manipulate facts and instrumentalize their jounalistic function.

As some readers and listenerns put it:
Please dear rferl Management! check, re-check, double check
what is published on your site. assess the intentions of your journalists.
eventually, it would be turn out to be rather difficult to restore a damaged reputation.
hope you continue with professionalism!

by: Hadi Mufid from: Kabul
June 02, 2012 19:36
I don't think the Afghan-Iran tensions all come from Kabul's signing of a long-term strategic agreement with United States. It's rather a matter of awareness of when/how Afghans get to know that Iran has been having its negative influence in Afghanistan, particularly on Hazaras. To many in Afghanistan, Iran is apparently known to be helping the Hazaras for sharing religion with them, while it's a ridiculous idea to Iranian turbaned-headed politicians. For instance, not many know that 60% of the Hazaras killed by Abdul Rahman was mainly caused by Iran. They were killed basically for being Shias, and always, the Shia-Sunni fire is lit by Iranian cleric extremists.
Not many know that in pre-9/11 Afghanistan, Iran directly supported the Norther allies-who fought against the Hazaras-only to light up the fire higher.

And partially, yes, tension has become more intense since May 1st, when the Afghan-U.S. Strategic Partnership was signed. And it is obviously understandable that Iran gives a leg and an arm to stop the West from staying around.
Not mentioned here, but this protest was organized by young Hazars who have always tried to prevent such commemorations from happening. Iran should understand that these voices will be heard sooner or later.

by: Azad from: London
June 02, 2012 20:22
Iran has destroyed the Hazaras in name of the religion. Today Hazaras have realised that Iran in fact their number one enemy.

Today Hazaras are more educated and do not make that mistake again.

by: Fahim Parsi from: Balkh
June 02, 2012 20:44
What is different between celebrating Khomaini's death and Khan Abdul Samad Khan's? One a religious fanatic leader another an ethnic nationalist leader? Both have unhealthy influence upon our country. First of all, RFRL needs to stop this hypocrisy. If we opposite Shias for celebrating Iranian leaders then we must stand against Karzai and his other ethnocentric officials celebrating Pakistani nationalist Pashtun leaders in Kabul.

by: Amir from: Kabul
June 03, 2012 03:56
This is really a great disappointment that a prestigious medium like RFERL manipulate the fact. The picture from demonestration shows that the demonestrators mainly come from Hazara ethnic group and happening in Mazari Square, west of Kabul.
the most helarious thing is that the reporter has reported that commemoration of Khomeini was held in Mazari Mosque which is an absolute manipulation!!! contrary to the report, commemoration was held in Al-Zahra Mosque, which is different from Mazari Mosque.
The reporter quoted Ahmad Jan Kandahari to manipulate the fact that demonestrators are other than Hazaras, while he/she could quote another one from participants of demonestration.
I strongly suggest please revise the report again, based on the points I mentioned in my comment.
RFERL should have deep knowledge of Afghanistan context, otherwise such mistake by its unprofessional and biased reporter will be repeated more and more, which costs reputation of medium.

by: Mohsin from: Kabul
June 03, 2012 04:46
Thanks for the amendment, but as a protest organizer I have to say that somethings are still wrong in this report. The protest we organized and took part in was completely peaceful, without tearing posters, ... suggesting violence, while this report contains things like what I mentioned. This means you don't observe journalism rules & principles and misinform the world of our peaceful protest. Yesterday also I asked if u needed details about the protest, I would send u since I was an organizer there. Please rectify it again.

by: Amir from: Kabul
June 03, 2012 06:25
It was really disappointing when I found that RFE/RL manipulated the facts. I strongly suggest please again amend the report and it is still full of mistakes and manipulations.
in report you mentioned the commemoration was held at Mazari Mosque, but contrary to the report, the commemoration was held at AL-Zahra Mosque and the demonestration was held in Mazari Square, west of Kabul, as you see in the picture.
Secondly, the demonestrators came mainly from Hazara ethnic group.
thirdly, the reporter quoted Ahmad Jan Kandahari, a fake name, to manipulate the fact to show demonestrators are not Hazaras while he/she could quote from demonestrators in Mazari Square.
I hope RFE/RL will observe the principle of impartiality and journalism ethics, otherwise it will cost reputation of RFE/RL in Afghanistan.
Comments page of 2
    Next 

Most Popular