Thursday, June 20, 2013


Afghanistan

Top U.S. Officials Condemn Afghan Corpse Abuse Video

A Pentagon spokesman calls the video deeply troubling.
A Pentagon spokesman calls the video deeply troubling.
TEXT SIZE - +
By RFE/RL
Top U.S. officials have condemned as "deplorable" a video depicting what appears to be U.S. Marines urinating on the corpses of Taliban fighters.

In a statement, Defense Secretary Leon Panetta said he has ordered an investigation into the video, which threatens to deepen anti-American sentiment in Afghanistan.

Panetta promised that the soldiers who took part in the incident will be held accountable “to the fullest extent.”

Officials said the investigation would likely consider whether the Marines violated laws of war, which include a ban on photographing bodies and a range of other rules.

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton joined Panetta condemning what she described as "deplorable behavior."

"It is absolutely inconsistent with American values," she said, "[and] with the standards of behavior that we expect from our military personnel and that the vast, vast majority of our military personnel -- particularly our marines -- hold themselves to."

A spokesman for NATO's coalition forces in Afghanistan told reporters from Kabul that the International Security Assistance Forces (ISAF) would support the U.S. investigation.

German Brigadier General Carsten Jacobson also described the video as "very much working against our cause."

"Any sort of [video], any sort of activity of this kind that is grossly against all the moral values that the coalition forces are standing for... and that we are here for," he said.

Meanwhile in Kabul, Afghan President Hamid Karzai called the incident "completely inhumane," while the Afghan Defense Ministry called it "shocking."

According to the White House, Panetta called Karzai today discuss the matter.

Marc Grossman, the U.S. envoy on Afghanistan and Pakistan, is due to meet Karzai in Kabul this weekend.

The video, which was uploaded to YouTube and others sites, shows four men with U.S. military uniforms, military rifles, and Kevlar helmets. Speaking with American accents, they laugh as they urinate on the bodies of three bearded men stretched out on the ground near a mud-brick wall.

One of the men laughs and says "in the heart" as he urinates on the chest of one of the corpses. "Have a great day, buddy," another says sarcastically.

Senior Marine and military officials who requested anonymity told news agencies that at least two of the four men seen in the video had been identified.
 
The officials said the men were from a Marine unit based at Camp Lejeune in the state of North Carolina. The unit returned from Afghanistan late last year.

Taliban: 'Barbaric' Footage

The video comes at a sensitive moment, with Washington trying to promote Afghan reconciliation just as U.S. troops gradually withdraw from the country. The Taliban earlier this month agreed to set up a political office in Qatar for negotiations with the international community, but also demanded the release of its prisoners from the U.S. detention facility in Guantanamo Bay as a form of prisoner exchange.

Afghan Taliban spokesman Zabihullah Mujahid today denounced the footage as "barbaric." But Reuters quotes Mujahid as saying "the video will not harm our talks and prisoner exchange" because the political process is in the preliminary stages. He said Taliban fighters will, in the meantime, continue their armed struggle.

The footage has outraged many Afghans, regardless of their views on the Taliban. Kandahar resident Amanullah says it damages prospects for peace talks.

"We condemn this action by U.S. soldiers who have urinated on the dead bodies of Taliban fighters. It will harm the peace talks," Amanullah said. "It seems that the United States never wants peace talks to happen in Afghanistan, and this action will increase misery in the country."

In Washington, Clinton today pledged to continue to support Afghan-led efforts to reconcile with the Taliban.

One Kabul resident, Feda Mohammad, says anti-American sentiments in Afghanistan have been aggravated.

"The U.S. soldiers who urinated on the dead bodies of Muslims have committed a crime," Mohammad said. "Since they have committed such a crime, we don't want them anymore on our soil. We don't like foreign soldiers to be on our soil. They have to leave."

Another Kandahar resident, Tawab Khan, says the perpetrators should be identified and put on trial.

"All of us Muslims condemn this action by foreign soldiers, who have urinated on the bodies of Taliban fighters. It is against Islam and the international community's role," Khan said. "We want the Human Rights Commission to prosecute this brutal action and arrest the criminals of this incident."

Anti-American feelings have boiled over into violence several times in Afghanistan in recent years. Protests over reports of the desecration of the Koran have twice sparked deadly riots.

written by Ron Synovitz and Richard Solash, with agency reports
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Ray F. from: Lawrence, KS
January 12, 2012 18:45
Would it have helped if they had first cut off the heads of these 'rebels'? A military reflects the values of the society it purports to defend. Hate to say it, but most Americans have about as much regard toward the people of Afghanistan as these soldiers. Bring these hapless soldiers home now! They are doing more harm than good.
In Response

by: Jack from: US
January 12, 2012 21:21
weren't u among millions of Americans who enthusiastically supported invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan, along with bombing and killing of Christians in Serbia and Kosovo? so what has changed your mind? The fact that glorious US army which was happily bombing Belgrade and killing journalists, women, and children there, only to flee with the tail between the legs from Iraq and Afghanistan, begging Taliban for peace and paying reparations to Wahhabi Sunni al queda terrorists?
In Response

by: Ray F. from: Lawrence, KS
January 12, 2012 22:05
Nope, that wasn’t me, but as an American, I suppose I must share in the guilt of my more belligerent countrymen. Or should I? More and more I sense, from my humble abode in the Midwest, that our ‘elected’ officials within the Washington beltway no longer represent the interests of the majority of hard-working Americans. There would appear to be a different dynamic driving American foreign policy, and I have a strong suspicion that it is connected (for want of a better term) with the ‘military-industrial-political-entertainment’ complex. In their calculation, war is good business, and the US has an obligation to play the role of the global policeman.

I’m hoping that this video might galvanize the people in this country against this armed madness. Alas, it will likely take a strategic defeat before the American people understand that killing Afghan peasants and then urinating on them is NOT in our national interest.
In Response

by: Russian
January 12, 2012 23:23
Dear American Nazi,
Remind me who created wahhabi al-quaeda terrorists? It was you American Nazis and you alone. Islam is the religion of peace. They do not invade anyone until they are being invaded and provoked.
In Response

by: Russian
January 12, 2012 23:20
Dear American Nazi,
Could you please provide me with some internet sources about Taliban "cut off the heads" of dead soldiers or "urinating" on dead bodies of the US troops or any other western troops? The only source I found was a Royal British Gurkha beheading a dead Taliban.
From Russia with love:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFGpNqjezTw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KVFEqazDSHU

by: Konstantin from: Los Angeles
January 13, 2012 06:33
In history of Russia were many serf's uprizing against Feudals.
They were so scared of Feudals that before they burned all,
They had an urge urinate or incrimate on mentions floors.
In doing so, some would turn it into a victorious ritual.

American soldiers are not mailnutritioned and weak,
As Russian serfs, that starved for months or weeks.
They are brave and trained and professionally strong
As they come, but after stress one can't hold for long
Without a leek. Why did they act as old Russia pigs?

The were some bushes behind their back to be used.
Is culture of George Balanchini and Alexandr Kartvely
Once helped USA "post Stalin" Russian lies abused?
Lost in Russia-boys made media, press and movies?
Lost in "World Order" of Russia's friend Bechtel-blue?

Or is it one of Russian insurgency to take Afghanistan
After USA gone, as they did before invading Georgians
In 2008, method - use telepaths to make by their plans
Intended victims leek, to help Russian propagandistan?
Whell they immobilized in USSR by it all non-Russians.

Most Popular