Saturday, May 26, 2012


Commentary

The Biggest Hypocrite Of All

Iranian President Mahmud Ahmadinejad speaks to UN representatives on September 22.
TEXT SIZE - +
By Hossein Aryan
A leopard can't change its spots. Nor, apparently, can Iranian President Mahmud Ahmadinejad when it's time for his annual address at the UN General Assembly.

Ahmadinejad is back in Tehran now, after traveling to New York last week to deliver his seventh speech to the UN, which, like all those before it, was full of sentiments about which Iranians can only dream. One can only imagine what they were thinking as they listened to Ahmadinejad deliver a lecture on ethical leadership.

The man who took the podium is a weakened and isolated figure at home. But you wouldn't know it by the way he treated the speaker's platform as a mosque pulpit and delivered a speech that sounded like a Friday Prayer sermon.

Like a mullah who reminds worshipers of their responsibilities toward Allah and prescribes behavior in religious, social, economic, and political affairs, Ahmadinejad preached the need for an underlying "faith in God," "compassion," "justice," "dignity," and "freedom." He called for world leaders to have "integrity in both words and deeds" and a "defiance of oppression."

This from the head of a government that has killed and jailed untold numbers of its citizens for their beliefs.

Ahmadinejad accused the West of hypocrisy and berated the United States for a long list of sins -- from slavery to colonialism, participation in two world wars, use of nuclear weapons, and military involvement in Vietnam and Korea. He again questioned the existence of the Holocaust and the "mysterious" forces behind the 9/11 terror attacks. In messianic language, he ended by offering the world glad tidings for a beautiful future built under the leadership of the hidden Twelfth Imam, accompanied by Jesus Christ.

With his call for liberty, compassion, and justice, many Iranians had to be asking why he doesn't want the same for them. In the spotlight on the UN stage, Ahmadinejad endorsed a society that couldn't be more different from the beatings, torture, repression, executions, and imprisonment he presides over at home.

During his six years in power, life in Iran has been miserable for people hoping for even a modicum of political freedom. The peaceful democracy protests that followed his 2009 "reelection" marked the start of a brutal state response that continues even now.

Hundreds of Iranian activists who participated in peaceful protests have been put under house arrest and jailed for their political views, including two of Ahmadinejad's opponents: Mir Hossein Musavi and Mehdi Karrubi. They would certainly like to feel some of the justice about which Ahmadinedjad so enthusiastically spoke at the UN.

Sunnis Muslims in Iran who cannot practice their faith freely would probably also like to taste the freedom he urged world leaders to grant their citizens. Religious and ethnic minorities across Iran would like nothing more than to see some demonstration of the tolerance and absence of discrimination that he preached.

Iranians of all backgrounds would like Ahmadinejad to root out the pervasive corruption in his own regime, not just call for its end everywhere else. And the equal distribution of wealth and the eradication of poverty that he embraced? Millions of Iranians who live in poverty want the same thing.

And when he spoke of "the shared and collective management of the world," Iranians must have wondered when they would also be able to participate. For in Iran, under the concept of velayat-e faqih ("guardianship of the jurisprudent"), the authority of Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei -- as the "the Guardian of Muslims" and representative of the Twelfth Imam -- cannot be questioned. Doing so can lead to long imprisonment or even execution.

But the flowery phrases that rang out in the hall of the UN General Assembly might as well have ended with "except in Iran." Because the fact of the matter is that when Ahmadinejad talks about hypocrites, he's talking about himself.

Hossein Aryan is an RFE/RL correspondent. The views expressed in this commentary are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect those of RFE/RL
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: UKR FAN from: Canada
September 27, 2011 22:03
Someone should give Mr. Ahmadinejad a Thesaurus so he can look up the meaning of the words he is presenting. He obviously doesn't know what they mean. I actually thought he was smarter than that to not know the meaning of a simple word like "dignity." Poor chap, I feel sorry for him; and to think he has a prominent role in the Iranian government and he doesn't even know what he is saying.

by: Andrew from: US
September 28, 2011 07:36
These shallow "analysis" by Iranian exiles who when go to Iran stay just in North Tehran and get their data from the same exile community in the US I does not reflect any reality on the ground.

Startfor Intelligence just published a much more realistic assessment by its analyst who just came from Iran called Geopolitical Journey: Iran at Crossroads, suggest you all read it and the one who wrote this primitive sloganeering "analysis" reads it too.




by: Michael from: Moscow
September 28, 2011 11:25
Can anybody then explain to me why, then, western leaders have run out of the room as soon as the Iranian president begins to pursue his claims and facts? If the western diplomats, who claim to be democrats, be honest and "innocent", they would have sat fearlessly and gave a rebuff to the Iranian president. The very fact that they run out of the room every time, clearly demonstrates their weakness and deceitfulness in the front of the bitter Truth, expressed by the Iranian president. At least, for that I respect president Ahmadinejat.
In Response

by: Seidkazi from: Ma Wara An-Nahr
September 29, 2011 14:55
"Can anybody then explain to me why, then, western leaders have run out of the room as soon as the Iranian president begins to pursue his claims and facts?"

Exactly, THEY are the biggest hypocrites, not Ahmadinejad. For a start, you don't see the Western diplotwats leave the room when a thug like Karimov comes.

by: RD
September 28, 2011 14:41
The Iranian President is undoubtedly a dictator and is sure not winning any points with anyone in the world. However, you have to admit the West is a tad hypocritical also. No one walk out when the Turkish PM is delivering his speech at teh UN even though he and his nation deny one of the biggest crimes against humanity (i.e. The Armenian Genocide). Double standards? You bet.
In Response

by: Michael from: Torino
September 30, 2011 15:51
get over it.. events that happened 100 years ago aren't a issue really. according to your opinion then 90% of the world leaders shouldn't speak there because of the genocides done by the US (in the Philippians, Vietnam, Iraq, native Americans etc.), Spain, France, British etc are much worse. many more that aren't recognized.

You should care more about the Armenians of now, who are living in a oppressed and impoverished Armenia under a dictatorship

by: manna
September 28, 2011 15:53
One cannot write about this man without a bitter sense of humor -- what the author of this piece has skillfully done!
In Response

by: Seidkazi from: Ma Wara An-Nahr
September 29, 2011 14:58
Ahmadinjead is a brilliant provocator who manages to expose the double standards of that so-called 'international community' that only represents, BTW, a self-serving, parasitic cosmopolitan caste.

by: Logan from: UK
September 28, 2011 18:20
These are some of the questions he asked.

Obviously they have no courage to answer that's why they ran away. When liars hear the truth they run.

"How can the crimes of the occupiers against defenseless women and children and destruction of their homes, farms, hospitals and schools be supported unconditionally by certain governments, and at the same time, the oppressed men and women be subject to genocide and heaviest economic blockade being denied of their basic needs, food, water and medicine....

It is no longer acceptable that a small minority would dominate the politics, economy and culture of major parts of the world by its complicated networks, and establish a new form of slavery, and harm the reputation of other nations, even European nations and the U.S., to attain its racist ambitions."

by: Pitocco from: Italy
October 01, 2011 07:32
The author of this article, I think, takes his feed from Usa. Is then objectives?

by: Lovemore Kaseke from: Harare
October 04, 2011 07:41
Iranian President is not a hypocrite. Remember that when germany wanted to attack a country they always prepared a pretext, including killing their own soldiers at the border with the country they wanted to atteck in order to spark the war. are we very sure that the CIA and the US government, eveil as they are do not have a hand in the bombing of the wtin towers. Ahmadinejad is rioght to ask the questions that baffle all of us. Bush said either you are with us or you are against us soon before the war. What does this mean.

by: Bill Webb from: Phoenix AZ
October 06, 2011 20:36
Ahmadinejad needs to just look at the demonstrations in New York. There are not groups of thugs terrorizing the crowds on motorbikes like happened in Tehran. He just talks the talk but can't walk the walk.

Latest Commentary

No records found for this widget:963

More Commentary

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Loophole Offers Legal Out For Doctor Convicted In Bin Laden Case

Latest Comment (9 total)

F*ALL: No the US can go to hell. This was blood money earned by ... More

Afghan Parliament OKs Security Pact

Latest Comment (1 total)

donky kong: No surprise. Both candidates support this too. Choosing between Obama or Romney is ... More

No Saturday Night Fever, As Armenia Mulls Eurovision Blackout

Latest Comment (24 total)

Rafi: There's no need to bring in a straw man, and make me say ... More