Thursday, July 31, 2014


The Power Vertical

Behind Closed Doors

Does anybody seriously think that a politically connected oligarch of Mikhail Prokhorov's stature would agree to lead a liberal political party -- even a highly domesticated one like Right Cause -- without official sanction?

Prokhorov's surprise announcement on Monday that he would take the reigns of Right Cause ended that party's months-long search for an influential leader who would lead them into the State Duma and political relevance. The party had previously tried, unsuccessfully, to recruit Finance Minister Aleksei Kudrin, Kremlin advisor Arkady Dvorkovich, and Deputy Prime Minister Igor Shuvalov.

Prokhorov is Russia's third richest citizen with an estimated fortune of $22.7 billion and his deep pockets could conceivably turn Right Cause into a player overnight.

He is also be the first top business mogul to enter politics in such a high-profile way since Mikhail Khodorkovsky's ill-fated attempt to finance opposition parties in the 2003 Duma election.

But 2011 is not 2003, when Vladimir Putin was just getting started in consolidating his vice grip on Russia's political system and would tolerate no serious dissent. Today, the political landscape is markedly different, with a sharply divided elite and a widespread belief that Putin's top heavy power vertical is stifling economic development and growth.

And Prokhorov is not Khodorkovsky, who was challenging the Kremlin's priorities consistently prior to his October 2003 arrest. In contrast, Prokhorov has kept his nose clean in Putin's Russia, amassing his fortune and abiding by the unwritten rule forbidding business leaders from engaging in unsanctioned political advocacy.

No, I don't think Prokhorov is going rogue here. So what is going on?

Prokhorov's move came on the heels of Putin's announcement that he was forming a new political grouping called the All-Russian Popular Front, which many analysts see as a vehicle for Putin to return to the Kremlin following the 2012 elections. Putin made his announcement at a conference of United Russia in Volgograd and the details of how the ruling party and the new group will work together are not entirely clear yet.

Right Cause, meanwhile, has endorsed President Dmitry Medvedev's reelection.

So one theory out there is that the groundwork is being laid for some form of managed competition between Putin and Medvedev in 2012. The assumption here is that Putin would return to the presidency, but the election would have a veneer of respectability and legitimacy.

This could be what's going on, but I am far from convinced.

The more likely scenario is that a decision about 2012 has not been reached yet and the elite is setting up the political infrastructure to keep all their options open. The rest is political theater.

In a widely discussed report published online today, Kremlin-connected political analyst Dmitry Orlov, director general of Agency for Political and Economic Communications, argues that decision about who will be president in 2012 is being decided by "the most influential 25-30 Russian politicians and businessmen" behind closed doors:

But whatever this select group decides, Orlov says the alliance between Putin and Medvedev will endure beyond the election:

It can be assumed with a high degree of probability that the tandem will last until the end of the 2012 presidential election and then grow into a lasting political alliance between Putin and Medvedev. The tandem's obvious primary function during the election period, which actually has already begun, is to ensure the unity of the ruling elite -- primarily about a single candidate for the presidency.

The formation of the Popular Front, which will purportedly bring together various Kremlin-friendly political parties and social organizations, is one vehicle to consolidate the elite. Beefing up Right Cause, which will give disgruntled liberals in the elite a (limited) voice, is another.

In all likelihood, a final decision on 2012 will not be made before the elections to the State Duma in December of this year.

Meanwhile, a new set of tea leaves will be available for reading following Medvedev's much-anticipated press conference on Wednesday.

-- Brian Whitmore

Tags: Putin-Medvedev tandem

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Anonymous from: USA
May 18, 2011 06:03
Maybe those 25-30 influential Russian politicians and businessmen behind closed doors should start calling themselves an ELECTORAL COLLEGE, since they ultimately decide who will be Russia's new leaders in 2012. Seriously, is the USA any different?
How much political theater do we Americans have to witness every couple of years? Sarah Palin? Donald Trump? Gone are the days when U.S. Presidents wrote their own speeches and read them in front of gathering crowds on the White House lawn. This is the 21st century, everything is scripted. Speech writers write the speeches and campaign advisors make sure a candidate wins. The candidate alone does very little.

About This Blog

The Power Vertical is a blog written especially for Russia wonks and obsessive Kremlin watchers by Brian Whitmore. It covers emerging and developing trends in Russian politics, shining a spotlight on the high-stakes power struggles, machinations, and clashing interests that shape Kremlin policy today. Check out The Power Vertical Facebook page or

Listen