Sunday, May 19, 2013


The Power Vertical

The Big Chill: Is Russia's Mini-Thaw Over?

A man in front of a Moscow court protests the prosecution of entrepreneur Aleksei Kozlov.
A man in front of a Moscow court protests the prosecution of entrepreneur Aleksei Kozlov.
TEXT SIZE - +
Andrei Kolomoisky thought he'd have a little fun.

After seeing an edited video on YouTube mocking Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's address to the nation ahead of the December 4 parliamentary elections, the journalist for "Vyborgskiye vedomosti" posted the link to his blog on the newspaper's website.

He now faces a possible five years in prison for inciting extremism, according to the St. Petersburg-based news site Fontanka.ru.

The video, which has since been removed from Kolomoisky's blog but is still available on YouTube, has attracted more than 600,000 views. It edits Putin's speech to make it appear that he is saying Russia is entering a period of "empty promises" and increased poverty.

WATCH THE VIDEO HERE:
 

 
 
Soon we will hold elections to the State Duma that will undoubtedly set the tone for the election of a new president. Our country is already now entering a period of empty promises. Dear friends, we have accomplished much together. Poverty, although moving slowly, is nonetheless experiencing stable growth, and in this case it is very important to guarantee we continue this course. That is why I decided to return to the times of humiliation, dependence and destruction to redraw plans for the development of Russia.
 
According to prosecutors in the Leningrad Oblast city of Vyborg, by posting the link, Kolomoisky violated a provision in the Russian Criminal Code against using the media to incite hatred or enmity as well as one prohibiting the humiliation of a person or group.

It's not clear where -- if anywhere -- this case is going. Nor is it clear whether Vyborg prosecutors are acting on their own or on instructions from Moscow.

But it does seem to fit into a pattern of politicized prosecutions that has been visible since the March 4 presidential election.

Among the most high-profile of these was the re-prosecution and re-conviction of former businessman Aleksei Kozlov, the husband of opposition journalist Olga Romanova.

Entrepreneur Aleksei Kozlov is escorted out of a court session in Moscow on March 15.
Entrepreneur Aleksei Kozlov is escorted out of a court session in Moscow on March 15.

In 2008, a court convicted Kozlov of stealing money from a leather-production company he owned together with former Federation Council deputy Vladimir Slutzker. The conviction came after Romanova wrote an article critical of one of Slutzker’s associates. Romanova claims Slutzker threatened Kozlov with legal problems if he failed to denounce his wife's story.

The Supreme Court struck down Kozlov's conviction. But in his retrial, completed shortly after the presidential election, he was convicted again and sentenced to five years in prison. The case was widely seen as a litmus test of how Russia's justice system would function with Putin back (formally) in charge.  

Billionaire businessman and presidential candidate Mikhail Prokhorov said the verdict would stoke distrust in the judicial system. Opposition figure Garry Kasparov said that "the authorities are sending the latest signal" of how things will be under Putin 2.0.

Another high-profile case, of course, involves the feminist punk-rock group Pussy Riot over their now-infamous "Prayer for Putin" concert/protest at Moscow's Christ the Savior Cathedral. Three members of the band are in prison awaiting trial on charges of hooliganism and inciting religious hatred. They face seven years in prison if convicted.

More than 2,000 people have signed an open letter to Patriarch Kirill, asking him to press for the charges to be dropped. But Kirill told Russian Television this weekend that he was sickened by Pussy Riot's actions and saddened that Russian Orthodox believers would defend them.

A case that has attracted less attention involves opposition figures Ilya Yashin and Boris Nemtsov, socialite and journalist Ksenia Sobchak, and Anton Krasovsky, an aide to Prokhorov. Prosecutors have opened a criminal case into an incident in a Moscow restaurant in which some members of the group got into a fight with a camera team from the Kremlin-friendly website LifeNews.ru, who were filming their conversation against their will.

LifeNews, of course, had previously published recordings of Nemtsov's private telephone conversations.

"We're used to this sort of thing, and all of this is political in nature," Yashin told Interfax. "If the process starts, we'll use our rich experience of defending [ourselves] within the walls of the court."

Does all this add up to a full-blown crackdown? It's probably too early to tell. But as Kasparov suggested, the authorities seem to be sending a signal that they want to put an end to the atmosphere of (relative) tolerance for dissent that prevailed throughout the election season.

Kolomoisky, for one, says he has no illusions. "As long as things are moving along the same vector as in the case of Pussy Riot. I wouldn't be surprised if I got a real prison term," he told Fontanka.ru.

-- Brian Whitmore

Tags: Andrei Kolomoisky, Aleksei Kozlov, justice system, political prosecutions

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Eugenio from: Vienna
March 26, 2012 18:49
Here we just have a gringo media pouncing on Russia. can we trust this gringo "journalist"? Give me a break. I find more truth in a scrap of ex-lax.
In Response

by: Ilya
March 27, 2012 03:35
You're getting lazy comrade. The FSB needs to trim your wages, maybe even cancel your vodka allowance. Are you saying that Kolomoisky is not being prosecuted for linking to a humorous video? Or are you saying that he was actually 'inciting extremism' by displaying a possible dislike for Putin?
In Response

by: Eugenio from: Vienna
March 27, 2012 16:53
Ilya, the comment posted above in my name has not been posted by myself - some joker just borrowed my name: you will never find in my postings such words as "pouncing" and "scrap of ex-lax". I don't even know what an ex-lax is. So, please do not trim my wage :-))).

by: vytautasba from: vilnius
March 27, 2012 07:02
Reviewing what happened in Russia since 2000 the "mini" thaw if there ever was one was a very "mini" one indeed. I suspect that during one of the major ice ages the sun would occasionally come out and "mini thaw" a small piece of ice. By evening the puddle surely turned back to ice.

by: eric d from: ABQ NM USA
March 28, 2012 00:12
Do Russians really just love their Czars? Their Stalins? Their Putins? Do Russians love being stomped on & censored by the FSB? Do Russians love the constant terrorism/counter-terrorism farce staged managed in the North Caucasus? Or is there some rational explanation for Putin's 'victory"? Please, oh you Euros of greater wisdom. Explain to us poor ignorant gringos...
In Response

by: Eugenio from: Vienna
March 28, 2012 06:36
Hi, Eric D., first of all - congratulations, you are the first gringo who actually realized how ignorant he is and - instead of coming up with his smart opinions concerning a place that s/he will not even find on the world map - are asking others for explanations. I hope you become the President of the US one of these days (seriously)!!!
Second, Eric, as such participants of this Forum as JACK (from the US) never get tired to point it out - most of the stuff that you see on your gringo TV-channels - is just a carefully prepared cheap propaganda aimed at brainwashing you with the only goal: to make you feel like you live in a paradise, whereas everybody else (i.e. people in Iran, Russia, Venezuela, Cuba, China, N. Korea etc etc etc) live in a hell.
The reasons for brainwashing you in this specific way are cristally clear, Eric: (a) you have just been kicked out of Iraq, (b) you are getting defeated in Afghanistan - and the heinous crimes constantly committed by your toops in this country provoke only disgust in everyone who get info on those, (c) your economic situation is pretty bad too: your sovereign debt has exceded 100 per cent of your GDP, your economic growth is sluggish, your unemployment rate is the highest since the times of Pres. Carter (late 1970s), (d) all of the above leads to spontaneous outcry by a segment of your own population (we have all seen the desperation of the members of the Occupy movt - even if some people on this Forum try to pretend like nothin' is happening there).
So obviously, the undeniable decline of your country in the global economics and politics - combined with just as undeniable rise of the new emerging powers (such as Brasil, Russia, India and China) - makes it necessary for the Wall-Street oligarchy that is driving your country directly into a wall to come up with some "EXPLANATIONS" that would somehow help you, guys, get some orientation in a rapidly changing world. The explanatory strategy they (through their media) have chosen is to present everything else like a nightmare, so that your own misery would somehow step back in your minds leaving the place in your consciousness to some more "positive" pictures - those of someone else supposedly living much worse than you do.
IF you really want to know how people in Russia or Ukraine really live, I can recommend doing what I did last year. (a) In the Summer get a plane to Odessa on the seaside in Ukraine (you don't need a visa for this and it will cost you several hundred dolloars - depending on where exactly "ABQ NM" is situated). (b) Once you arrive, go to the railway station and get from people who offer housing there a room or an appartment in the barrio called ARCADIA (right next to the beach) - and don't pay more than $ 20 for a room or $ 30 for an appt!!!. (c) Go to the beach (not to the paid one! - go to the one which is for free and accessible to anyone!) and have a look at how people are spending time there; go to the city itself too and have a look around. And there you have it: you can very easily make your own impression of what the life there is like what the extent to which the majority of people are "suffering" there is.
Cheers from Vienna, Eric, and have a nice Summer!
In Response

by: Ilya
March 28, 2012 07:04
It's so generous of you and Jack to stick it out in your miserable, capitalist countries instead of emigrating to workers' paradises like Iran and N Korea.
In Response

by: Eugenio from: Vienna
March 28, 2012 13:55
Hi, Ilya, thank you for the comment. The fact that Jack and myself are not migrating to Iran or N. Korea YET can most probably be attributed to the fact that my own (and probably Jack's also) personal economic situation is FOR NOW kind of ok. But if you take such a highly economically developed and democratic florishing country as SPAIN, for example, FYI, Ilya, 2011 has been the first year since the Civil War of the 1930s (!!!) in which this wonderful country LOST POPULATION due to high rates of outmigration. And I don't know what the situation in such countries as Portugal, Ireland or Greece is, but - from a few articles I read in the press - it looks like many people are migrating out of these countries - from Portugal to Angola or to Brasil, for example. So, who know when the turn of Jack or my own is going to come.
In Response

by: Ilya
March 30, 2012 03:11
Let me know when you do decide to move to N Korea or Iran. I'd love to read about your fabulous socialist lifestyles over there.

About This Blog

The Power Vertical is a blog written especially for Russia wonks and obsessive Kremlin watchers by Brian Whitmore. It covers emerging and developing trends in Russian politics, shining a spotlight on the high-stakes power struggles, machinations, and clashing interests that shape Kremlin policy today. Check out The Power Vertical Facebook page or

Listen

Partner Media