Saturday, May 26, 2012


The Power Vertical

Citizen Tsivinyuk

People pass by an election poster of the United Russia ruling party in Moscow.
TEXT SIZE - +
Russia's latest YouTube political sensation is a Siberian teenager.

Matvei Tsivinyuk, a 15-year-old student at Krasnoyarsk's Gymnasium No. 3, captured the imaginations of oppositionists when he defaced United Russia campaign placards in his high school's lobby -- and then posted a secretly recorded video of his confrontation with the headmaster.

According to press reports, Tsivinyuk tore some of the posters and wrote the inscription: "The party of thieves and scoundrels."

He was promptly summoned to the principal's office where the clandestinely recorded argument with headmaster Aleksandra Pronina took place. The video is jumpy and poorly centered --  for obvious reasons -- but the dialogue is crystal clear.

WATCH THE VIDEO HERE:


Aleksandra Pronina: If there is something you disagree with then go to a demonstration. But not in school.

Matvei Tsivinyuk: According to Article 9, Point 5 of the law of the Russian Federation....

Aleksandra Pronina: Enough, Matvei! I don't care about any article. Article 9, Article 10, or whatever.... Does your family have a lot of money? Your parents may have to pay a fine for your hooliganism.

Matvei Tsivinyuk: A fine over a piece of paper?

Aleksandra Pronina: For hooliganism! Do you understand!? It's not just paper! It's a political placard!

Matvei Tsivinyuk: It should not be in the school because political parties are forbidden from agitating in educational institutions, including spreading propaganda.

Aleksandra Pronina: It's not propaganda.

Matvei Tsivinyuk: What is it, then?

Aleksandra Pronina: It's not propaganda. It is there so you can read the biographies of these people. I am telling you now, categorically, that if you deface any more placards I will turn you over to the police.

Matvei Tsivinyuk: And what will they do?

Aleksandra Pronina: I don't know. It's another sphere. My sphere is education. But I have warned you. If you read the biography of Vladimir Ilyich Lenin....

Matvei Tsivinyuk: I don't respect him....

Aleksandra Pronina: I'm just telling you that he was expelled from gymnasium and he was expelled from Kazan University when he studied there. I don't know if you want the same fate.

Tsivinyuk, who is an excellent student according to press reports, now joins the ranks of police officer Aleksei Dymovsky, courtroom whistle-blower Natalya Vasilyeva, and other Russians who have taken their grievances online. It's still not clear what will happen to Tsivinyuk, who, as a minor, may not face the harassment other YouTube whistle-blowers have faced.

Tsivinyuk does have his supporters and his actions have been getting some positive press coverage and supportive comments in online forums.

"I believe that if we had more such high-school students, then the political system would be more free and democratic. In general, this situation is standard for an election, when you just use the administrative resources in favor of the party in power, limiting political competition," Andrei Seleznyov, a city council deputy in Krasnoyarsk, told RFE/RL's Russian Service.

Other officials have been less supportive. Krasnoyarsk Krai's deputy governor, Sergei Ponomarenko, accused him of "militant ignorance and meanness."

United Russia officials deny that placing election placards in schools violates the law, as long as the director consents. (One has to wonder whether Pronina would have approved Yabloko placards in the school.)

Nevertheless, the incident comes as United Russia is coming under increased scrutiny in the media over the use of administrative resources in advance of the December elections to the State Duma.

-- Brian Whitmore

Tags: United Russia , 2011 State Duma elections , Matvei Tsivinyuk , Administrative Resources

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: La Russophobe from: USA
November 17, 2011 00:09
There are things far more horrifying going on in Russian schools invovling United Russia, and with children who are far younger and more defenseless.

http://oleg-kozyrev.livejournal.com/3817223.html
In Response

by: Steve
November 17, 2011 15:16
Child rights!?

Not like situations such as the one concerning Jerry Sandusky - inclusive of an extended mass coverup.

by: Douglas Clayton from: Canada
November 19, 2011 17:51
RFERL as usual scraping the barrel for negative stories about Russia. The USA could never stand up to the kind of scrutiny Russia gets from RFERL: you have a sclerotic and corrupt political system, graft and corruption on an enormous sale (just in the defence sector alone), media manipulation of a passive electorate by private media barons pursuing their own corrupt or fanatical agendas . And you have the barefaced gall to criticize Russia, which has made huge strides since Communism. Hypocrites!!!
In Response

by: Anonymous from: USA
November 20, 2011 20:02
Yes, we do have the gall to criticize Russia. When in US (or Canadian) history has there ever been a Secret Police system like Gestapo or NKVD? I, as an American, do not live in fear of the State. My own government might be incompetent, but at least it is not looking for ways to silence me. Russia is sliding backwards toward a police state like the USSR once was. One of the few good things Yeltsin did was split up the KGB monstrosity. Putin is looking more toward rebuilding it in order to keep himself in power for life.

by: Douglas Clayton from: Canada
November 21, 2011 12:05
Here is my reply to Mr Anonymous (who is so unafraid he prefers not to give his name). He clearly does not know the history of the United States, and has not heard of the McCarthy era, when hundreds of thousands of Americans who did speak their minds were hounded, driven from the country, or otherwise persecuted. I have also not heard any evidence that Russia secretly ships people from country to country in order to have them tortured, unlike the US. Americans who dare to speak out and think differently have every reason to fear their government. The closest recent analogy to the USSR is the USA under the previous president (whose father was head of the CIA - an institution no less sinister than the KGB).
In Response

by: Sergio Meira from: Netherlands
November 21, 2011 14:35
And here is a reply to you, Mr Clayton, from Canada, whose familiarity with American history is also quite limited and cherry-picked. That you have not heard evidence of atrocities and disrespect to both public opinion and human rights in Russia, not only of journalists, but of the common people; that you are not appalled at the state control of the media; that you do not see influence in what the Russian government delights in calling its "near abroad"; none of that speaks well for your capacity to understand what is going on there.

Which is not to say that the US are not guilty of all the things you've accused it of. They are. But if you think you can use one countries' crimes to exhonerate another; if you think the 'strides' Russia has taken are sufficient for the memory and consequence of current corruption (a structural flaw so pervasive, and at the same time so inherently necessray to the current power structures in the Russian Federation), then I must pronounce you unfair.

Oh, the US are certainly not perfect, and did terrible things. I am not going to engage in the game of comparing it to the Russian Federation, though. If you can't see the terrible Russian problems for what they are; if all you can say is 'but my neighbor is also baaad'.... then I think you really having nothing to contribute.

Good day, sir.
In Response

by: Joe
November 22, 2011 01:59
Your pompous blather might be impressive to yourself and misguided others.

In real terms it's lacking in substance.
In Response

by: Anonymous from: USA
November 22, 2011 03:23
Well said Sergio!
I don't know what form of government Mr. Clayton thinks is supposed to be best, but top-down, vertical, power structures NEVER last. They only lead to instability and revolution. The McCarthy era was a very short period of American history that was more of a knee-jerk reaction to the spread of Communism in the world. Russia doesn't need to use extraordinary rendition in order to torture people, they simply do it behind closed doors and then deny it. How many Chechens have to come forth describing horrific torture by Russian soldiers before Mr. Clayton accepts that it is occurring? 1000? 10,000? 100,000? I fully expect Mr. Clayton to respond with all sorts of "yeah, but" 's. Bleating on about Iraq, Vietnam, Korea, etc.

BTW: I have always used "Anonymous" to post comments on this website. My real name is not important. I fear hackers, scammers, and even marketers more than my own government.

About This Blog

The Power Vertical is a blog written especially for Russia wonks and obsessive Kremlin watchers by Brian Whitmore. It covers emerging and developing trends in Russian politics, shining a spotlight on the high-stakes power struggles, machinations, and clashing interests that shape Kremlin policy today. Check out The Power Vertical Facebook page or

Listen

​​