Thursday, September 01, 2016


Iraqi Foreign Minister Says Camp Ashraf Must Go, And That Iraq Admired As Arab Revolutions Unfold

Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari: "Iraq has passed the test."
Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari: "Iraq has passed the test."
On April 8, 2011, the Iraqi military launched a raid on Camp Ashraf, 60 kilometers north of Baghdad. The camp is the headquarters of the Mujahedin-e Khalq Organization (aka People's Mujahedin of Iran), an organization opposed to the current government of Iran. According to the United Nations, some 34 people were killed in the raid and hundreds more injured.

The group was founded as a Marxist terrorist organization and was given sanctuary in Saddam Hussein's Iraq in the 1980s. Today, Camp Ashraf is home to 3,500 members of the organization and their families.

During a visit to RFE/RL's Prague headquarters, Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari spoke to correspondent Joseph Hammond about Camp Ashraf, the pending U.S. military withdraw from the country, the tense situation around the ethnically mixed city of Kirkuk, and the transformative politics sweeping the Arab world.

RFER/RL: The United States is scheduled to withdraw its troops from Iraq by the end of this year. But U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates recently said that the United States could extend its role beyond that date. Does Iraq want U.S. troops to remain and, if so, in what role?

Hoshyar Zebari:
Well, first of all, I think the agreement for the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq ends at the end of 2011. And there are no plans to extend that agreement or to postpone the withdrawal. This is an issue that both the United States and the government of Iraq are committed to implement.

But it doesn't mean that [the] American presence in Iraq will end. There will be a presence through the embassy, through the consulate, and also through the implementation of the Strategic Framework Agreement for Cooperation and Friendship between Iraq and the United States, which was concurrently signed with the [Status of Forces] agreement.

So we need some implementing tools for that agreement, in terms of training, in terms of advisers, in terms of capacity-building. But this would not be through a new agreement. This would be done bilaterally between the Iraqi ministers and [their] counterpart in the United States on various issues. This is how we approach the time beyond 2011.

RFE/RL: Will the Iraqi military and the Kurdish peshmerga militia be able maintain security in these tense regions after the United States withdraws?

Well, the U.S. troops currently are not only in the north, actually. They are in different parts of the country. This is first. Secondly, I think that Iraqi security forces are capable of standing on [their] own. Of course, they will still need backup and support, but they are capable of maintaining law and order and internal security. That's why, yes, after the withdrawal I think there has been plans to fill that vacuum, led by the United States forces. And the Iraqi military forces have some working mechanisms with the peshmerga forces in the north in order to avoid any misunderstandings or clashes in the disputed territories.

RFE/RL: What is the likelihood that the status of Kirkuk will be determined in the near future?

This is a constitutional matter. Despite all the skeptics, all the people who raised the alarms that Kirkuk is the powder keg, it will blow up Iraq, since 2003 up to now it has not gone off. OK? Yes, there are disputed areas, claims, problems, but it has not led, really, to any all-out conflict or violence whatsoever.

This is a constitutional matter. There are procedures to address [and] resolve these issues. The new government was voted into power to implement this constitutional article, which is 140, which calls for the normalization of the situation in Kirkuk and other disputed territories. So it's an obligation on this government.

Camp Ashraf

RFE/RL: Earlier this month, the Iraqi Army raided Camp Ashraf, home of the People's Mujahedin Organization of Iran, which seeks to overthrow Iran's clerical leaders. The United Nations says 34 people were killed in this raid. The Iraqi government denies this and accuses guards in the camp of being responsible.

The Iraqi Constitution prohibits the presence of mujahedin or any other militia groups from neighboring countries, whether it's the PKK [Kurdistan Workers Party], whether it's the PJAK [Party for a Free Life in Kurdistan], or whoever to have presence on Iraqi territory and to launch attacks against our neighbors. Constitutionally, this is not allowed and the mujahedin or the MEK [Mujahedin-e Khalq] member of the Ashraf camp have to respect the Iraqi law.

Iraq has a commitment not to extradite any of its members to Iran. Iraq has a commitment also to observe international humanitarian law and to have access by international organizations to them, like the United Nation missions, ICRC [International Committee of the Red Cross], and so on. Yes, what happened was very unfortunate, really, but the aim was not to expel the members of the Ashraf camp to Iran.

This was a military operation intended to take control of part of the territory. Ashraf camp is not a small camp; it is 50 [square] kilometers large. The Iraqi military extended its authority over about 20 kilometers of the camp.

No country in the world will tolerate any organization to undermine its sovereignty, to defy its authority, and to act as if this is a liberated territory or a state within a state. So they have to abide by the Iraqi rules and regulations, and also we have called on European countries and others to resettle these people in their countries, for them to go on and continue their struggle. In Iraq, their presence is unacceptable.

WATCH: Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari on Camp Ashraf:

Iraq Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari On Camp Ashrafi
April 19, 2011
Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari speaks about the recent deadly raid on Camp Ashraf, the status of Kirkuk, and the Arab revolts in an exclusive interview at RFE/RL's broadcast headquarters in Prague on April 18.

RFE/RL: The U.S. government originally controlled Camp Ashraf following the 2003 invasion of Iraq. They disarmed the Mujahedin-e Khalq and transferred control of the camp to the Iraqi government in 2009. Has the United States government been kept abreast of developments at Camp Ashraf? The Iraqi government has called for the expulsion of this group and set a deadline of the end of the year.

This is an Iraqi decision. This group is branded  in the United States as a terrorist group, by the Department of State list, and it was in Europe up to very recently, when it was lifted. Those countries who care about the fate and human rights of this group, actually, they should welcome them and they should resettle them in their countries. My government has requested such a thing from European countries and from other countries, to resettle members of the Ashraf camp in their countries.

RFE/RL: Where do you see the Iranians going?

Wherever. Any country -- in the northern countries, in Australia, in New Zealand, Canada, the United States, wherever.

RFE/RL: Right now, we're seeing tremendous upheaval across the Arab world -- revolutions in Tunisia, in Egypt, and uprisings in Yemen and elsewhere. What can other Arab countries learn from Iraq's political experience?

I think what the people of these Arab countries are calling for [is] basic rights, basic democratic rights, basic freedoms, representative government, elections, and being part of the decision-making. Iraq has done this through the hard way, through a difficult, arduous road to building democracy. It hasn't been easy with the foreign occupation, with the sectarian war, with the terrorism, with the regional interventions. But Iraq has passed the test.

Now, the Iraqi political system feels more comfortable in the region, because what the Arab peoples in all these countries are demanding is what we have achieved. We don't want to be the crown or the example, but I think Iraq draws a great deal of admiration [from] many, many people on the streets of Sanaa or Tripoli or Damascus or Cairo.
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
by: Anonymous
April 20, 2011 16:45
" The group was founded as a Marxist terrorist organization"
that is very poor definition of this group it's better to read little bit more about them or ask your friends in Radio Farda for "general info".

by: shahram from: dc
April 20, 2011 18:21
NCRI - While the Iranian Resistance on Tuesday revealed a top-secret operational command document regarding the massacre of Camp Ashraf residents on the order of Nuri al-Maliki signed by the Commander of Iraq's 5th Division in various capitals of the world, Iraq's Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari in an interview with BBC News ''Hardtalk'' tried to wash the blood off al-Maliki's hands by repeating the preposterous claims of the Iranian regime and Maliki's spokespersons that the PMOI members killed themselves. He said: "This is a very suspicious incident actually. We are willing to investigate because the way these people have been killed, they have been killed in a certain specific way, not by the Iraqi security forces as such..."

Zebari's preposterous claim comes while US forces and US embassy representatives in Baghdad as well as a UN team and their medical teams in their visit to the camp on 10 and 13 April examined all the dead and took photographs and films and issued official positions on the Iraqi forces' crimes.

Following the international attention to this great crime against humanity, the al-Maliki government, which initially denied killing Ashraf residents, accepted that three people had been killed in accidental collisions with vehicles. (Ali Gheydan, commander of Iraq's ground forces, Alhurra television, 9 April 2011)

Following statements issued by the US State Department, European Union, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Amnesty International, Senator John Kerry, Senator Carl Levin and many other Congressmen and Senators in the US as well as Members of Parliament in the UK and Europe, al-Maliki's spokespersons in a brazen lie claimed that a further 31 other people killed in Ashraf "were shot execution-style". (Saad al-Matalabi, political adviser to al-Maliki, Christian Science Monitor, 17 April 2011)

On the other hand, over the past 28 months, Zebari and his ministry have not issued a single visa for journalists, lawyers, Parliamentarians, and relatives of Ashraf residents from five continents who wish to go to Iraq to visit Camp Ashraf. This is while Zebari is clearly aware that agents of the terrorist Qods Force and the Iranian regime's Ministry of Intelligence and Security are continuously travelling between Tehran and Baghdad and have installed 240 loudspeakers around the perimeter of the camp.

The Iranian Resistance condemns Zebari's false claims and the inhumane attitude of his ministry in preventing visits by relatives, lawyers and Parliamentarians to Iraq and Camp Ashraf and advises Zebari not to further involve himself in this great crime against humanity and crime against the international community in Ashraf and its legal consequences.

We urge Zebari to personally visit Camp Ashraf along with a delegation of UK Parliamentarians and a specialist team from Doctors Without Borders to see up close the corpses of the 34 martyred residents and talk directly with 225 others who were shot or targeted with grenades.

Hossein Abedini
UK representative office of the National Council of Resistance of Iran
20 April 2011

by: Anonymous
April 21, 2011 10:23
Very courageous statement and the only one from Arab leadership supporting call for change and protest in Arab world. Yes Iraq went through such process. Yes Iraq is becoming a democracy although regional interferences whether from Iran and their proxy’s Syria Hezbollah but also GCC were an obstacle to peace and reconstruction of Iraq as they supported warlords and mafia gangs that fragmented Iraqi society under the motto of political participation and democracy. Iraq is rebuilding and strengthening its ranks and central authority. Maleki and Allawi had difficult task but were behaving more responsible comparing to other warlords using whether the ethnical agenda or the religious agenda to subjugate populations and destroy Iraq unity and soul that refused sectarian divide and foreign interferences starting by interferences from neighboring countries. Warlords sold their souls and Iraqi soil, hopefully Iraqi soul was much bigger and aware than dirty limited minds running behind money and privileges. Surprising the actual warlords during Sadam era were benefiting generously from the hospitality of the countries that are manipulating them now under the motto that they were opposition groups in exile in reality they were warlords in the making. The ones who remained in Iraq and were slaughtered by the Sadam’s regime were forgotten, the ones still in live including their kids and families have no reward no say on what is going on in post Sadam decade. During the post Sadam decade Iraq got the spoiled pseudo leadership in Exile as reward and they started filling their pockets even slaughtering their co- citizens for foreign interests. Sad but Iraq went thorough all those nightmares and now recovering progressively. We are all prying for you may god help us in our endeavors and spare us what Iraq went trough.

Most Popular

Editor's Picks