Friday, August 26, 2016

The Power Vertical

Meet Russia's Political Entrepreneurs

Former Finance Minister Aleksei Kudrin
Former Finance Minister Aleksei Kudrin
What is Mikhail Prokhorov up to? In an interview with on January 31, the billionaire Kremlin-connected oligarch insisted again that his presidential campaign is the real deal, not some ploy to divide the opposition vote and ease Vladimir Putin's re-reelection. The opposition is, quite naturally, more than a little suspicious.
During our conversation for the last Power Vertical podcast, I put this question to NYU professor and longtime Russia-watcher Mark Galeotti, author of the blog "In Moscow's Shadows." Mark's thoughtful answer is worth reproducing here in full:
I would suspect that Prokhorov, like so many actors within the current Russian elite is at once telling the Kremlin that he is playing the Kremlin game while keeping one eye on potential endgames, potential other outcomes, ways of actually maximizing and leveraging his own power. 
I don't think that he has rolled in -- as he himself has proclaimed -- as an anti-Kremlin candidate with no connections to the Putin circle. There is some degree of connectivity there. But on the other hand, simply to write Prokhorov off as a complete Kremlin stooge would be a mistake.
The point is that everyone is a political entrepreneur in their own right in the current situation because nobody knows what is going to happen.
I think this is pretty much dead-on accurate -- and, as Mark suggests, not just in the case of Prokhorov. The same thing can be said about former Finance Minister Aleksei Kudrin and former Federation Council Speaker Sergei Mironov. Depending on how things develop, more high-profile names could be added to this list quite soon.
A particularly interesting new species that has appeared on Russia's landscape in the wake of the disputed December 4 parliamentary elections is the political entrepreneur. These longtime insiders are now hedging their bets and hoping to secure a safe landing regardless of how the current political crisis is resolved.
There is a bit of cynicism at work here, to be sure (we are, of course, talking about bureaucrats and politicians). But as is the case whenever there is the potential for rapid political change, there are also some principles at stake -- and for some, perhaps a political epiphany or two.
Prokhorov's first attempt to enter politics was -- when he agreed to head up the Right Cause party as a Kremlin-loyal pseudo-opposition force -- purely an insider game that ultimately fell apart amid noisy public acrimony in September.
He now says he is aligned with what he calls the liberal wing of the elite, which favors political reform and an end to Putin's system of "managed democracy."
“I think that the liberal part of the elite is bigger and bigger from day to day, because I have a lot of calls from different levels, and they really express their support for my candidacy," Prokhorov told Chrystia Freeland, global editor at large at Reuters, in a recent interview.
Meanwhile Mironov, who is also running in the March 4 presidential election, appears to be making some headway with the opposition and the emerging Russian Street.
The former Federation Council speaker is a longtime Putin loyalist going back to his time in the St. Petersburg Legislative Assembly in the 1990s. His center-left A Just Russia party -- which until recently was staunchly loyal to the regime -- was a Kremlin-backed project to siphon votes from the Communists. 
But Mironov was nevertheless forced out of his speaker's post following a bitter dispute with the ruling United Russia party. He also backed Dmitry Medvedev for a second term in the Kremlin and drew fire for saying that his party would not support Putin's return to the presidency in 2012 if he were nominated by United Russia.
Running as an opposition party, A Just Russia won 64 mandates in the 450-seat State Duma in December, a marked improvement over the 38 it won as a pro-Kremlin party in 2007.
In an interview with RFE/RL's Russian Service today, veteran opposition figure Boris Nemtsov gave his seal of approval to Mironov's presidential bid, calling him the best of the registered candidates.
"For people taking to the streets, Mironov is preferable because he did not only heed our demands, but he included them in his program," Nemtsov said.
The political entrepreneur who has the most capital to work with, however, is Kudrin. The former finance minister is a good bet to end up being Russia's prime minister regardless of how the current crisis is resolved.
Kudrin is personally very close to Putin but has nevertheless been vocal about the need for political reform. He has said that December's parliamentary elections were a fraud and called for their results to be annulled. He has offered to act as a mediator between the opposition and the Kremlin. And he spoke at the massive street demonstrations in Moscow on December 24.
Despite this, Putin has repeatedly said that Kudrin is a valued member of his team and is widely believed to be planning on making him his premier should he win in March. 
Prokhorov has likewise said that he would name Kudrin as his prime minister should he win the presidency.
Kudrin's ability to maneuver owes a lot to his friendship with Putin. But it also stems from the fact that as finance minister he was very good at his job -- stabilizing Russia's public finances and paying off its debt despite a breathtakingly corrupt environment ("Euromoney" magazine named him Finance Minister of the Year in 2010).
These new entrepreneurs don't by any means want to burn their bridges with Team Putin -- at least not yet. But they also want to be on the right side of the barricades. Their dance will continue at least until March 4 -- and perhaps longer.
-- Brian Whitmore

Tags: Mikhail Prokhorov,Sergei Mironov,2012 presidential election,Aleksei Kudrin

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
by: La Russophobe from: USA
January 31, 2012 22:59
"nobody knows what is going to happen" -- HA!!

Maybe you and Mark don't know, Brian, but I do. And so does Prokhorov. Putin will easily sweep back into power and then crush his opposition. But before crushing, he will bribe. And those with the most chips, like someone who shows he can be an electoral force, will cash in most. Prokhorov is simply building up chips he can use to benefit himself, the same as Zhirinovsky is doing. Likely Zyuganov is doing the same, but the only serious question about someone being interested in presidential power is about Zhyuganov, the only person in the race who might actually want to win. And, who knows, with Navalny's help he might make quite a decent showing.

by: Nina Ivanovna
February 01, 2012 00:58
It was interesting to see how the "liberal" elites at Davos were at once trying to distance themselves from the government, and praising it at the same time.

by: Vakhtang from: Moscow
February 01, 2012 06:11
Everyone knows that Volodya believes in political technology аnd it should be noted that they often work.
Direct anger of the people in the right direction-- against the enemies of Volodya by various promises, of political plays, rumors and speculation.

A massive preparations for the elections started:
Military and various special forces seriously increased wages...with that kind of money it is clear that they will protect Volodya.
Organized clowning with Prokhorov and Kudrin- playing the role of political prostitutes as a true long ago remarked Lenin.
And what they're thinking about something inside their heads
as they say --secondary thing.

You, too, my "dea"r Mr.Whitmorе often say one thing, doing another, agree to do something, but just in case are considering escape route..
To lie, hide, dodge-a part of behavior in society for better adaptation and career...
Scoundrels and cynics are powerful people in the modern world while kind-hearted despised and destroyed...have any objections ?

by: Ben
February 04, 2012 10:57
Both figures embody the Putin`s economic policy of the mineral empire that brought the income growth of Russians,who are most hated for it. Russians who demand the resources industry nationalization and state-sponsored modernization doesn`t understand that they whish to return to USSR in the deminished size.

Latest Podcasts

About This Blog

The Power Vertical is a blog written especially for Russia wonks and obsessive Kremlin watchers by Brian Whitmore. It offers Brian's personal take on emerging and developing trends in Russian politics, shining a spotlight on the high-stakes power struggles, machinations, and clashing interests that shape Kremlin policy today. Check out The Power Vertical Facebook page or