Saturday, May 26, 2012


Commentary

Mladic's Long Shadow

Bosnian Serb ex-military commander Ratko Mladic appearing before the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in the Hague
TEXT SIZE - +
By Gordana Knezevic
The day before his extradition to The Hague to face charges of war crimes and genocide, Ratko Mladic requested permission from the Serbian authorities to visit the grave of his daughter Ana.

She had committed suicide in 1994 at the height of the Bosnian conflict that had earned her father worldwide notoriety. Mladic wouldn’t take no for an answer: let me go, or bring her coffin to my cell was the message to his captors.

The final image of himself that Mladic wanted to project to the Serbian public was that of a grieving father desperate to pay homage to the memory of a beloved daughter.

It was meant to generate some empathy for a man accused of directing the worst massacres committed in Europe since World War II.

But the tone and manner in which he phrased his request was a flashback to the old Mladic, the bullish wartime commander of the Bosnian Serb Army, remembered with terror and rage by the survivors of Srebrenica, Sarajevo, and many other places in Bosnia-Herzegovina.

Mladic's Daughter Also A Victim Of His Mania

Ana, a medical student at the time, was distraught over the war in Bosnia and her father's role in the torture and killing of civilians, according to reports in some opposition media not loyal to the Milosevic regime.

Her death is inseparable from thousands of others who died during those years (1992-95), victims of a concerted campaign against Bosnia's civilian (and above all, Muslim) population.

She, too, was a victim of her father's mania. Yet Mladic did not request a visit to the gravesites of Sarajevo or Srebrenica, where unmarked mass graves are still being identified and catalogued, 16 years later.

No trace of remorse or sorrow was visible on his face, haggard and significantly paler than the last time he appeared on our TV screens. Facing the cameras in The Hague courtroom, Mladic was reminiscent of Nazi war criminal Adolf Eichmann, as portrayed by Hannah Arendt in her book "Eichmann in Jerusalem," when he described the charges against him as "obnoxious," and insisted that he had only been defending his people.

Eichmann, too, was only doing his duty. Speaking in Serbian, Mladic exclaimed, "I am Ratko Mladic, the general, and the whole world knows about me!" After 16 years behind the scenes, it’s his time to play the hero again. However, this time he may not have the final word.

Sarajevo residents dive for cover during a Serbian mortar attack on the besieged city in 1992. Bosnian Serb forces led by Ratko Mladic kept the city under siege for 44 months.

Having in mind the serious health problems he's been struggling with in recent years, including alleged hospital visits, it is very hard to imagine that the Serbian authorities were unaware of his whereabouts.

Nevertheless, even if we assume a certain level of negligence, or worse, complicity, between the alleged war criminal and those claiming to be on his trail, the fact that he was finally apprehended by Serbian security forces carries some weight.

Culture Of Criminal Impunity

It was a bold move, especially if we keep in mind that former Serbian Prime Minister Zoran Djindjic was assassinated not least for handing over Slobodan Milosevic to The Hague tribunal.

Djindjic believed that cooperating with The Hague was not only a formal obligation, but that it was in his country's best interests to break with its violent past, and its culture of criminal impunity -- and therefore to bring all suspected war criminals to justice.

The current Serbian leadership is more pragmatic than Djindjic. They are less inclined to dwell on the past, and more concerned with Mladic's worth in furthering Serbia's present interests abroad -- including hoped-for concessions over Kosovo, as well as throwing open the doors to Serbia's EU accession.

Serbian President Tadic is being praised by world politicians for finally detaining Mladic and EU dignitaries are queuing up to salute Belgrade, predicting a "new era" in its relationship with the continent, and hastily turning a "new page" in relations with Serbia.

Uncomfortable Questions

The trial will take its course, but most have been reluctant to explore why arresting Mladic was so important. In the Serbian case, stirring the memories of the 1990s would only draw attention to those elements in Serbian society and political life that haven't changed their outlook or nationalist agenda.

For the European powers, the questions would be no less uncomfortable. Why did the UN fail to protect its designated "safe havens," one of which was Srebrenica, before it was overrun by Mladic's troops?

Why did the Dutch peacekeepers on the ground not even attempt to save the people there? Why did the siege of Sarajevo last 44 months, while its citizens were subjected to myriad daily humiliations as thousands were killed and wounded?

As one of those besieged in Sarajevo in 1992, I remember the first time I heard Mladic's voice. It was the second month of the war and the entire city was under Serbian bombardment.

Our telephone lines were cut off.  Bosnian ham-radio operators intercepted a command issued by Mladic, and they sent the audio recording to the city's main radio station.

Mladic was heard talking to his officers on the ground, in the hills surrounding Sarajevo: "Fire on Velusici, not too many Serbs there. Drive them crazy."

More than 20 people were killed that night alone. Many more homes were destroyed, but the following day the only topic of conversation was the fact that Mladic had mispronounced the name of Velesici, one of the suburbs of Sarajevo (he had pronounced it "Vel-oo-sici.").

"He is destroying a city he knows nothing about," angry Sarajevans commented while standing in a line to get water, buy a newspaper, or just share with neighbors the hope that "Europe will stop these crazy guys who're shooting at the city."

Waging A War Against Coexistence

Another part of his intercepted order has not been forgotten either: Serbs may be killed too if they get in the way or choose to stay with their Muslim and Croatian neighbors, friends, and family members.

Mladic's army was waging a war against coexistence, forging apartheid with shellfire and artillery. It was not a war to protect (a Serbian "people" in Bosnia), or even to create anything (a Serbian "republic" within the country's borders).

The first task was to destroy what was already there, to forcibly divide ethnically mixed communities, to break up families, and to destroy those lives and places that would not yield to a simpler, ethnically pure vision of Bosnian reality dreamt up by Mladic and Karadzic.

Serbs, Croats, and Muslims fought and died together against those who would deny them the right to live together.

The capture of Mladic marks a major step in a process of reconciliation begun, largely at the initiative of outsiders, nearly two decades ago.

In the winter of 1992-93 Aryeh Neier, president of the Open Society Foundation, came to Sarajevo determined to teach its people how to keep records of war crimes, to write down the times of detonations, to describe the damage, to find out the names of the victims.

He was the first one who pointed out that the war would be over one day, and the people who were then shooting at the city would have to face some international court. 

The Hague tribunal had not been established yet. Neier had to keep his winter coat on during the lectures, because there was no heating in the old Austro-Hungarian railway facility where he spoke, opposite the city's Presidency building in downtown Sarajevo that had been targeted by snipers and artillery.

Theater Of The Absurd In The City Of The Absurd

Today I wonder what sort of evidence would have remained without people like Neier, ready to risk his own life to make sure that war criminals would one day face justice.

Shortly after Neier's visit, Susan Sontag came to Sarajevo. Surprised that the intimate Kamerni Theater was still operating in the besieged city, she decided that staging a performance of Samuel Beckett's "Waiting for Godot" was perfect for the situation, and could have been written with Sarajevo in mind. The best home for the theater of the absurd was the city of the absurd.

In a sense, the entire city was "waiting for Godot," for something or someone, while Susan Sontag worked with local actors using an interpreter, and by the light of oil lamps.

The time of the play's opening was kept secret, to avoid targeted shelling. During those most desperate times, Sontag provided so much joy and so much laughter to people who refused to accept ethnic borders as the boundaries of their life -- as ordered by Mladic.  

When Sontag passed away in 2004, Bosnians paid her a special tribute and the square in front of the main theater in Sarajevo was renamed after her.

That may be considered as the territory she liberated when she decided to stage "Godot" in defiance of Mladic's artillery. 

Gordana Knezevic is director of RFE/RL's Balkan Service. The views expressed in this commentary are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect those of RFE/RL
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments page of 2
    Next 
by: John from: Chicago
June 16, 2011 19:22
More of the same anti-Serb propaganda to support the lies they've told for many years now. Fortunately, only the ignorant and the animal world are uninformed enough to believe this diatribe. This is the method used over and over, make comparisons to the Nazi's and convict via public opinion then kill him in prison like the other Serbs since they couldn't possibly find them guilty based on "evidence". Pathetic
In Response

by: NoPartition OfBosnia
June 16, 2011 20:51
Yeah, yeah the poor angelical and completely innocent Serbs, wronged by everybody but never did anybody wrong, of course. And as for him, why don't you nominate him for the Peace Nobel Prize? You serbofascists thugs are so pathetic. And you will never get your Greater Serbia!
In Response

by: Kenny S from: San Francisco
June 16, 2011 22:23
It's difficult for me to gather this as being "anti-Serb propaganda" when the author clearly heralds the multiethnic cooperation between serbs, croats, and muslims in Sarajevo. In fact, you could even say that she's making Mladic and the Milosevic/Karadzic regime look like bad apples in a state that is struggling to move on from its past, but can't due to people holding on to the image of those like Mladic and Karadzic as being national heroes.
In Response

by: Damir from: Canada
June 16, 2011 22:29
John, your previous post makes you sound uneducated, please pickup a Balkan history book and then repost.

Great reporting Gordana! Bosnia has been a country of all faiths for thousands of years and it will be for thousands more to come!

ZIVOT JE BOSNA
In Response

by: Emir from: 29 Palms, CA
June 17, 2011 00:12
John... your types are still in denial. I expect no change from you. Maybe, you'll see the truth in the hereafter.
In Response

by: Marijana from: Sydney
June 17, 2011 00:13
Well said John!
In Response

by: Mark from: Australia
June 17, 2011 02:48
John, can you please clarify what exactly are you disputing?

Are you saying that there was no shelling of Sarajevo that the Muslims shelled themselves for four years?

Or are you saying that the Serb shelling was militarily justified - I think the issues here are the international humanitarian law + laws of war and armed conflict principles of distinction and proportionality.

Did the Bosnian Serb troops which Mladic allegedly had control over make an effort to distinguish between military and civilian targets in the city? Where the aim was military targets, was it militarily justified given the level of property damage and civilian casualties that that would entail - what alternative measures did the Bosnian Serbs pursue in Sarajevo. What military threat did the Bosnian Muslims and Croats pose, given that the Bosnian Army was the old JNA rebadged and inherited most of the weaponry.

From what I can gather, Mladic will be accused of ordering the shelling of Sarajevo beyond military necessity and with the intention of causing harm to civilians, against the laws of war and the Geneva protocols. His alleged order to send them crazy may add weight, depending on whether he was talking about soldiers or civilians.

My impression was that the shelling targetted the city as a whole and was used as leverage in negotiations. This is likely to contravene the Geneva protocols and customary international law.
In Response

by: Slava
June 21, 2011 01:22
The manner of armed Muslim nationalist goons in Sarajevo fits the description of violating the stated standards of conduct, that some pious blowhards hypocritically bring up.
In Response

by: mike levin from: ny usa
June 17, 2011 03:31
John from Chicago..you are an idiot... that is what they said about the Holocaust ! you want to say that no genocide happened iN Bosnia ? and what about those facts documented by Serb activists and human right groups ?

by: Vuk Mujovic from: Belgrade, Serbia
June 16, 2011 20:46
This , once again, proves the maxim: When you are unsure of history , write it for the winners.

This whole article is made in a bad tone with a lot of presumptions. Those presumptions harm , not only the people of Serbia who are now victims of prejudice, but also the people of Bosnia who are told for the last 18 years that they are victims and that they should feel like victims and act like victims, thus making even those who have no reason to feel this diminishing feeling victimized in their mind.

I hope for the families of those who are wrongfully harmed in the conflict to find some sort of closure in this arrest (and potential conviction), but fabricating the truth just dishonors those who were wronged and they are at least numerous.

Articles like the one above just make things worse, for everyone. If we were focused on how to make things better rather then where to cast blame we would live in a prosperous society... but than there wouldn't be much work for sensation journalists, would it?

by: obilic111 from: U.S.A
June 16, 2011 20:55
I guess Ms.Gordana has to lie otherwise she wouldn't have job at Radio liberty.
Yugoslavia was country of coexistence and liberty,Muslims were not fighting for coexistence they were fighting for religious rule.Read Islamic Declaration of their
war leader Alija Izetbegovi.He is very spesific what country he is fighting for. Srebrenica had 28th division of Bosnaian army that commited numerous crimes,and most of those killed were fighting man armed by NATO and ARABS.So much lies in your reporting.Do you have any shame?

by: draganm
June 16, 2011 21:40
"The current Serbian leadership is more pragmatic than Djindjic. They are less inclined to dwell on the past, and more concerned with Mladic's worth in furthering Serbia's present interests abroad -- including hoped-for concessions over Kosovo"
Tadic is a fool. Name one thing he or anyone else received as a "concession" for licking Unlce Sam's boot? Serbia will get nothing except more demands and humiliation. The only thing they will get is the loss of even more territory until the Serbian people have had enough.

by: obilic111 from: chicago
June 16, 2011 22:59
I've sent comment earlier not flataring i dont think it will see the day light.
No suprize we had same treatment from communists

by: Donovan from: PA
June 16, 2011 23:24
I don't care much what Mladic did or not, this is for the court do decide. But I hope EU doesn't get overexcited and admit Serbia now because they caught him. Admitting Serbia and Croatia to EU will not do any good in my opinion. What are they really bringing to the table? It will only make the adriatic coast beaches more expensive for EU tourists. What's the point of that? Can you imagine Serbia in the Eurozone?
I know Serbia has oil but you don't need to be in EU to sell it; I mean look at Russia and Saudi Arabia. Furthermore. Serbia has an unsolved territorial issue which will drag on forever as far as I can see. Then Serbs and Croats will constantly vote against each other in all EU forums. And I can only imagine the monstrous bailouts needed for these two in the future, if Greece's example is anything to go by.

by: Dragan Cetnik from: melbourne
June 17, 2011 01:16
Bravo srbine! this is just all ant serbian propaganda againts the serbs. They blames the serbs for everything and turned the whole world on the serbs cos we were too powerful in the region and Europe. another excuse for the west and american dogs to get there hands in somewhere where they are not wanted. Bosnians are a made up nation and people. they are either turks without a home or serbs who were made to cnver under the ottoman empire. what about all these attrocities committed by the muslims and croats no one is doing anything about this or the killings of thousands of serbs by albanians and the tafficking of organs - again nothing being done. they need to speak to serbs to find out the real truth. in one sense the only mistake we made during the war was not killing all the muslims and croats. zivela srbija
In Response

by: Abdulmajid
June 19, 2011 18:34
The same old serbofascist propaganda lies. I see you are by your own writ a serbofgascist thug thirsty for Bosniak blood. Bosniaks do have a home and it is called Bosnia-Herzegovina and it has existed for over 1000 years and will continue to do so despite all your Kyaradzic-Dobrica Cosic-Ilija Garasanain propaganda lies! And if you want to try and exterminate the Bosniaks once again, may you find all you wish for us balije. And just so you know feller, THE CROSS WILL NEVER CHASE THE CRESCENT OUT OF BONSIA! IN OTHER WORDS: YOU SERBS WILL NEVER EXPEL OR EXTERMINATE THE BOSNIAKS!! Dolje velika Srbija!Dolje repluka srpska! Zivjela Bosia i Hercegovina ujedinjena!
In Response

by: Abdulmajid
June 20, 2011 19:05
"Bosnians are a made up nation and people. they are either turks without a home or serbs who were made to cnver under the ottoman empire."
"in one sense the only mistake we made during the war was not killing all the muslims and croats. zivela srbija"
It is statememts by bloodthirsty anti-Bosniak thugs thirsty for Bosniak blood like you that give me the notion that those who say "SRBE NA VRBE" are right! Who wants to share a planet with you! I forbid my daughter to marry a Serbn and evben if he were teh nicest man in the world. People like you do not deserve to walk this Earth but even the Devil would not want to admit you in Hell! You will NEVER get your velika srbija! If you think it is your good right to take revenge on us for whatever the Ottomans allegedly did to your ancestors hundreds of years ago and call us "Turks without a home and traitors to the Serb race" , and thus pass judgent on us as prosecutor, judge and executor in one, and then whine that Serbs are demoinized...You yourselvesw fdo that much better with statements liek yours than anybody who genuinely hates the Serbs ever could! We will make you PAY and with INTEREST for what you did to us! Next time around the boot will be on the other foot. Come to Bosnia if you want to "complete the job" and you will meet the fate you so burningly wish for us balije. It is our good right to live as Muslims in our own country and THE CROSS WILL NEVER CHASE THE CRESCENT OUT OF BOSNIA! The Serbs will NEVER LIQUIDATE US BALIJE! The boot will be on the other foot and if you insist on your evil anti-Bosniak attitude your descendants will have to PAY and with INTERESTS for your sins! Statements like yours give me the notion that your accursed nation and people should be reduced to the living standard they had in the 17th century!
Balija,Muslim, and PROUD OF IT!!!

by: obilic111 from: chicago
June 17, 2011 02:25
Radio Liberty should have motto free to say what we like.

by: Jim from: Australia
June 17, 2011 03:43
What an absolutely disgusting article of pure hate and propaganda. I just wonder how much you were paid to write such criminal lies. You should be ashamed of yourself.
In Response

by: Slava
June 17, 2011 08:01
Note the sleaze who approve of such garbage.

by: Jelena from: Munich
June 17, 2011 06:52
Mladic is a HERO!
Without him, there would be no Serbia.
In Response

by: Abdulmajid
June 19, 2011 18:43
Serbofascist thug bloodthirsty for Bosnkiak blood, may you get all you want for us balije , poturi, Turks or whatever you want to call us. ANd may Mladic die all 100.000 seaths he caused. Each and every single one of them.
In Response

by: Jelena from: Jagodina
June 20, 2011 06:52
Dragi boze, molim te lepo jel vidis kakvih jih ima na ovom svetu. We know the truth. No one can take that away from us.
In Response

by: Abdulmajid
June 20, 2011 11:03
Yes we know the truth and nobody can take it away from us. In Ratko Mladic and his thousands of willing executioners I see embodied everything that is hateful about the Serbs and should be consigned to Hades like Pol Pot or Stalin. And be so kind and keep your "truth", or better said, your propaganda lies for yourselves. You people still want thne liquidation of Bosdiaks, you are not interested in peace and reconciliation, you only see us with the same olds monstrous hate and viscveral rage and disdain, so why should we come and kiss your b, er, hems of yoru shirts???
You ahev alkre43ady maded up your mind about Bosnia and Bosniaks: iot must be erased from the map and tehy must perish. That is your judgment, and you are prosecutor, judge and executioner in one person. But we are not afraid of you. Come with what you want and with whom you want, but do come. You can't do to us no less and no more than what God decides. Mladic said to te people of Srerenica before he had them murdered "Not even your Allah can help ypou". But who are we to decide what God wants? if it was His will that they should be killed by Mladic's hand and be martyrs what was there for them to do anyway but to resign themselves to their fate and at least die with their heads held up? And God has decided that the Bosniak people should not be liquidated, for they are still there. And do you know something, you xenophobic genocidal serbofascist anti-Muslim thugs? They will remain! Even in thousand years they will be there to spite you! And the day will come when they will finally shake off your shameful yoke!
Comments page of 2
    Next 

Latest Commentary

No records found for this widget:963

More Commentary

Most Popular

               
 
 
 
 
Being Discussed Now

Chechen Leader Names New Premier

Latest Comment (5 total)

M: Ingush human rights defender Magomed Khazbiev: "Kremlin needs slaves in the Caucasus":
http://pik.tv/ru/shows/vasha-pravda/video/86/4437 More

Kingsley As Karzai?

Latest Comment (1 total)

M: they put the dictators in power and they make fun of them More

Moldova Sentences 3 On Uranium Charge

Latest Comment (1 total)

Ionas Aurelian Rus:
One should not only salute the capture of these officials by the Moldovan ... More