Tuesday, September 02, 2014


The Power Vertical

'Take This Law And Shove It!'

Riot police detain human rights activist Lev Ponomaryov during an unsanctioned protest in Moscow on May 7.
Riot police detain human rights activist Lev Ponomaryov during an unsanctioned protest in Moscow on May 7.
Lev Ponomaryov has decided to just say no -- and he's not alone.
 
The head of the advocacy group For Human Rights announced this weekend that it would refuse to comply with a new law signed by President Vladimir Putin requiring NGOs receiving funds from abroad to register as "foreign agents" and subject themselves to extensive state scrutiny.
 
"We are declaring a campaign of civil disobedience to laws that have been passed in violation of the Russian Constitution, the European Convention on Human Rights, and other conventions that Russia has signed," Ponomaryov told Interfax.
 
"We will never be [foreign] agents and will not obey this law. We are agents of Russian citizens. We will continue to receive foreign grants and will speak about this openly."
 
And Ponomaryov indicated that he has no illusions about what such defiance might mean.
 
"The government will take measures against us, and we will oppose this by using legal methods, like going to courts, including the Constitutional Court. Then the government will somehow close us down, but this will be the government's decision," he said.
 
Speaking to "Nezavisimaya gazeta," Ponomaryov said he was undeterred by the stiff fines and potential prison time that noncompliance could mean.
 
"We are continuing in the tradition of the Soviet dissident movement, whose members were not afraid of much harsher punishments," he said.
 
And the civil disobedience campaign appears to be gaining momentum.
 
Svetlana Gannushkina, head of the group Civil Assistance, also said it would defy the law.

"We will take to court each attempt to force us to voluntarily go to the guillotine, and we hope to win. If we lose at our courts, we will appeal to the Constitutional Court, and then we will appeal to the European Court of Human Rights," she told Interfax.

Arseny Roginsky, a former prisoner in the Soviet gulag and the founder of Russia's largest human rights group, Memorial, says it will decide at a meeting in the autumn whether or not to comply with the law, which goes into effect in November. "But Memorial consists of many structures, and each has the right to make its own decision," he said.
 
Speaking to the RIA-Novosti news agency, Memorial Chairman Oleg Orlov suggested that he was leaning toward civil disobedience.

"It's humiliating and it would be foolish to go and register yourself as a foreign agent,"  Orlov said, adding that Memorial will "take all possible legal steps against discriminatory practices" established by the new law.
 
Thus far, Moscow Helsinki Group head Lyudmila Alekseyeva is the biggest name to resist the civil disobedience tactic. She told Interfax that she would stop taking foreign funding, seek Russian financing, cut back on programs, and auction off some of her belongings -- including her collection of Gzhel ceramics -- to keep the group afloat.

Ponomaryov said he still hoped to persuade Alekseyeva to continue taking foreign funding.

The civil disobedience campaign comes at a time when the opposition has been openly mocking and ridiculing the authorities' attempts to crack down on them.
 
It is still unclear how far the rights groups will take this campaign of disobedience. And it won't be clear how much the Kremlin will crack down on them until the law actually comes into effect in November.
 
But if they stick to their guns until then, they will add to what is already shaping up to be a very difficult autumn for Putin and his ruling circle.
 
The Kremlin already has to deal with what looks to be tough and complicated regional elections in October. The authorities have long planned, after the summer recess, to enact painful reforms of Russia's creaking social-welfare bureaucracy, which are bound to be unpopular.

Moreover, economic uncertainty remains high amid fears of contagion from the eurozone and volatile energy prices.
 
If you throw in the prospect of an open civil disobedience campaign, it may not add up to a perfect storm -- but it is certainly a recipe for a very hot autumn.
 
-- Brian Whitmore

Tags: Lev Ponomaryov,Svetlana Gannushkina,Arseny Roginsky,Oleg Orlov

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Twatmore from: Morescow
July 24, 2012 11:57
Why don't they try not taking foreign grants first? That way they won't have to register.
In Response

by: Duh
July 24, 2012 17:11
Because then they can't operate?
In Response

by: Jack from: US
July 25, 2012 12:58
also because Russians will not give these clowns money. They can only live off CIA budget
In Response

by: roger from: nyc
July 27, 2012 01:27
What's your name, Jack?

by: Mark from: Victoria
July 28, 2012 04:10
Let me preview for you what the European Court of Human Rights is going to say when they get around to reviewing Ponomarev's complaint.

ECHR: "Ummm....Mr. Ponomarev...isn't this law almost exactly the same as the USA's Foreign Agents Registration Act?"

LP: "Why, yes; yes, it is. And what of it?"

ECHR: "Well, surely you see it's....ummmm....kind of hard for this court to condemn the Russian law without also....you know....condemning the American law also as unfair and discriminatory?"

LP: "I'm afraid I don't see the problem. Everything the American government does is good for democracy and freedom. Everything the Russian government does is bad for that stuff. Can't you just write that?"

About This Blog

The Power Vertical is a blog written especially for Russia wonks and obsessive Kremlin watchers by Brian Whitmore. It covers emerging and developing trends in Russian politics, shining a spotlight on the high-stakes power struggles, machinations, and clashing interests that shape Kremlin policy today. Check out The Power Vertical Facebook page or

Latest Podcasts