Tuesday, September 02, 2014


In The Shadow Of Lenin, Two Ukraines Face Off In Kharkiv

Russian-speakers argue with Kharkiv's supporters of the anti-Yanukovych revolution outside the regional administration on February 25.
Russian-speakers argue with Kharkiv's supporters of the anti-Yanukovych revolution outside the regional administration on February 25.

Related Articles

As Manhunt Continues, What Are Yanukovych's Options?

As the manhunt for Viktor Yanukovych continues in Ukraine, rumors are flying about his whereabouts. One thing is clear: options are narrowing for the fugitive former president.

Havel Fellow Fishes Out Deposed President's Dirty Secrets

Twenty-one journalists are working to preserve and publicize documents seized from ousted Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych's residence.

For Putin, Ukraine Is Too Important To 'Lose'

With crowds of jubilant Ukrainians milling through the palace of ousted President Viktor Yanukovych, many have been speculating that Ukraine's days in Moscow's political and economic orbit may be numbered.

Explainer: Why Kyiv Needs Western Economic Aid

Ukraine's crisis is not just political, it also desperately needs economic support and hopes to get it from the West. What does Ukraine need, and where might the money might come from?

Who Might Lead Ukraine?

Who will fill the power vacuum in Ukraine in the wake of President Viktor Yanukovych's ouster?
By Tom Balmforth
KHARKIV, Ukraine -- Wielding batons and riot shields, masked Euromaidan supporters have occupied the regional administration building in the eastern city of Kharkiv for several days. They vow to remain until "corrupt" officials resign.

Across the city's main square, a few hundred pro-Russia demonstrators shout insults like "scum" and deride them as "fascists." They have also set up an encampment under a towering statue of Soviet founder Vladimir Lenin, which they claim to be guarding against vandalism from Euromaidan supporters. Russian flags flutter in the wind as pop anthems from Vladimir Vysotsky and the Perestroika-era rock band Kino boom out of speakers.

To get a sense of how Ukraine's Russian-speaking eastern provinces are reacting to the dizzying overthrow of ousted President Viktor Yanukovych's regime, Kharkiv is a good place to start. In this industrial city, the first in Ukraine to recognize the Bolshevik authorities in 1917, Stalinist architecture is ubiquitous and the Russian language is omnipresent.

Once the capital of Soviet Ukraine, Kharkiv is decidedly pro-Moscow and many here have watched uneasily as a bloody street uprising in the capital ushered in a new, pro-Western leadership.

LIVE BLOG: Ukraine Crisis

Many, like Valentina Morder, 68, a pensioner in a wooly hat, worry that the parliament, now in the hands of the opposition, will now restrict the rights of Russian speakers.

"Everyone should be able to speak in the language that their mother sang to them as a child. My mother sang in Russian. She worked here before the war and after the war. I've worked [here] for over 40 years," Morder says. "Why should someone tell me that I have to live a certain way."

The parliament has already scrapped a law that gave minority languages in select regions official status, a move that touched a nerve in predominantly Russian-speaking cities like Kharkiv.

Against The Old, Corrupt Order

But even in Kharkiv, the Euromaidan and the new government in Kyiv have their supporters.

Artyom, a 33-year-old manager at an eco-friendly fuel company who declined to give his last name, says he is fed up with widespread corruption. He has demonstrated against Yanukovych, supports the new authorities, and says it is only a matter of time before others here do too.

"I'm feeling positive. These people sooner or later will understand it all. It's not even that important that every single person understand," Artyom explains. "It's important that most of the people here in Kharkiv unite and come to understand what happened -- especially in Kharkiv."

Likewise, Roman, a 28-year-old scientific researcher, says he never supported Yanukovych and agreed with the pro-Western protesters in Kyiv who ousted him. But he also expressed concern about what he called the revolution's "violent" methods.

Noisy Standoff

As night fell on February 25, tension rose as numbers swelled on both sides of the barricades. Police in riot gear stood on alert as anti-Maidan activists lined up in crowds across the street from the regional administration.

The crowd chanted "Russia, Russia!" and "Berkut!" -- the latter a supportive reference to the riot police disgraced in many parts of the country for their association with the brutal crackdown in the capital that claimed scores of lives.

They made rude gestures and shone green laser pens at the pro-Maidan activists guarding the administration building -- and who roared back "Ukraine, Ukraine!"

ALSO READ: As Pace Of Political Change Picks Up, Eastern Ukraine Balks

Standoffs like these have been nightly occurrences since the Self-Defense Maidan security brigade occupied the regional administration on February 22 and blockaded the office of Kharkiv Oblast Governor Mykhaylo Dobkin with a black sofa.

They have pledged that the building will not be looted or vandalized on their vigil, but refuse to leave until Dobkin and Kharkiv Mayor Hennadiy Kernes, both allies of Yanukovych, leave their posts.

While Dobkin can be dismissed by authorities in Kyiv under the 2004 constitution, Kernes is an elected mayor -- and is in power until 2015.

Police are stationed outside the regional administration, but appear to be maintaining their neutrality.

A Way Forward?

Meanwhile, the ultranationalist Right Sector group, which rose to prominence during three months of anti-Yanukovych protests, has established a presence on the ground floor of the administration building.

Vitaliy, a 30-year-old man wearing a balaclava, is perched on a windowsill and looks out over gathering crowds of angry residents. He says his mobile-phone-repair business is being crushed by an institutionalized culture of bribery, and vows to fight on until the local authorities are removed.

"When they've all left, then we will vacate the building. They gave it to us officially," Vitaliy says. "We didn't seize this building. We didn't burst in here fighting. We were allowed in here from the first day. And from the first day there have been attacks on us."
Pro-Maidan security guards sit on a black sofa blocking Kharkiv Governor Mykhaylo Dobkin's office in the regional administration building.
Pro-Maidan security guards sit on a black sofa blocking Kharkiv Governor Mykhaylo Dobkin's office in the regional administration building.

Others complain that virtually all basic bureaucratic procedures require a bribe in Kharkiv. Getting a drivers license, for instance, requires a $200 payoff.

For Russian-speakers like Morder, however, there is apprehension at the ascendancy of parties associated with the west. She confesses she only voted for Yanukovych in the 2010 election as a viable option against his rivals.

"I'm not to blame for what Yanukovych did. I'm not to blame for what someone else did. When we elected Yanukovych, we didn't vote for him -- we were voting against them, the western part of the country. We just didn't want this violence," she says.

"And now it turns out that we were right. Neither me, nor you, nor this woman traveled over there with batons."
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
by: Mamuka
February 26, 2014 15:31
What is Rinat Akhmetov doing all this time? Biding his time and wating to swoop in and somehow profit from the chaos?

by: Mamuka
February 26, 2014 17:08
Regarding my earlier post about Akhmetov, there was a good article on the UK Telegraph on 26 Feb about the activities of Akhmetov and other oligarchs, many of whom have their economic base in eastern Ukraine-- and their expensive mansions in London.

by: eric d from: IF ID USA
February 27, 2014 00:18
What's really at stake in the current stand-off? Here's an article that puts it on the news-line:

MOSCOW — President Vladimir V. Putin ordered a surprise exercise of ground and air forces on Ukraine’s doorstep Wednesday, intending to demonstrate his country’s military preparedness at a time of heightened tensions with Europe and the United States over the turmoil gripping Russia’s western neighbor. The Obama administration said any Russian military intervention in Ukraine would be a costly and “grave mistake.”

What will the White House do if Putin does decide to invade? claiming he's defending "ethnic Russians" & they're begging him to "save them!" From those Ukrainean "terrorists"! or something...

Will this be another "red line" in the sand? Where Obama's words mean nothing? Because he's not ready & willing to back them up? And Putin can one-up him again. Just like Syria...

Will the American left ("The Nation" et al.) wash its hands of guilt in the ensuing bloodshed? claiming (like Vladimir Putin) the Ukraineans are "right wing extremists" or "terrorists"? or something... Forgetting that the real terror is always that waged by governments against their own (or somebody else's) citizens?

I'm really afraid "the West" is going to have to be prepared to walk the talk. To the point of sending UN military police or some kind of US/EU cops, if necessary, to defend the Ukraineans against "Greater Russian" aggression.

I don't look forward to it. I don't want it. I hope further bloodshed can be averted. But whoever knows Putin's record knows he won't hesitate to send the troops. And they won't hesitate to shoot real bullets. Just like at Euromaidan, before the shooting stopped...

Anyway, worth keeping on watch on it. Just in case...

by: Jack from: US
February 27, 2014 04:52
this mess in the Ukraine is part of a devilish plan by evil dictator Putin to offload Ukraine from the shoulders of Russian taxpayers onto EU taxpayers. And it worked! EU and US are already scrambling their rear ends to find billions of $$$ to prop up collapsing Ukrainian economy

by: Eugenio from: Vienna
February 27, 2014 21:02
Now you realized that there were two Ukraines :-). Y little bit too late: the Crimean Peninsula has successfully started separating from Ukraine. Odessa, Kharkov, Donetsk and the entire South-East will follow soon - and will join Russia.
Whereas the rump Ukraine will become a failed state and all those who have been yelling on the Maidan so much will have to go to Frankfurt and London to clean toilets there. It is called the international division of labor or "democracy in action" :-).

by: Anonymous
February 28, 2014 17:47
language is not the right dividing line
In fact, there are many Ukrainians who speak Russian

and there are many Ukrainians who speak Ukrainian
but who are pro russia

and then
in Ukraine there aren't only 2 languages
but 3
tipical for the cultural mix of Ukraine
which is called in Ukrainian Suržik (суржик) = "mixed meal"
spoken mostly in the center of Ukraine
and which is made with Russian words
but with Ukrainian grammar and pronunciation
A lot of people speak Suržik

by: American Tolerast
March 01, 2014 05:28
Two identical tribes killing each other? How East European of them.

Most Popular