Wednesday, May 22, 2013


News

Vote On Russian Language Bill Sparks Ukraine Crisis

Loading
12:00:00 / -:--:--

Police scuffled with angry lawmakers and protesters who oppose the Russian language bill outside the Kyiv building where President Viktor Yanukovych planned to discuss the recent Euro 2012 football championships.

TEXT SIZE - +
By RFE/RL
A political crisis has erupted in Ukraine after ruling party deputies pushed a bill that dramatically increases the official status of the Russian language through the parliament.

The speaker of Ukraine's parliament, Volodymyr Lytvyn, tendered his resignation one day after the vote, which took place late on July 3.

Police used tear gas, batons, and other forceful methods to disperse protesters in downtown Kyiv the day after the vote.

Opposition politicians are calling it a full-blown crisis and vowing to continue to battle the ruling party of President Viktor Yanukovych over the bill's fate and the way they believe it was bulldozed through parliament.

In a bid to defuse tensions, Yanukovych postponed a planned briefing on Ukraine's co-hosting of the recently completed Euro 2012 soccer tournament on July 4 to meet with Lytvyn and leaders of major factions.

"A full-fledged political crisis has started in Ukraine," opposition leader and former parliament speaker Arseniy Yatsenyuk told a press conference after that meeting. "The so-called stability of Yanukovych has definitively collapsed. There is no more a myth about stability. There is a weak president, a deficient parliament, absent state institutions, a destroyed constitution, and a complete collapse of honesty, morality, and political responsibility of a so-called political elite of Ukraine."

Lightning-Quick Vote

The bill was rushed through a second and final reading by deputies of the majority Party of Regions, which is led by Yanukovich.

Opposition lawmakers tried and failed to physically stop the speaker from calling the vote, provoking scuffles with members of the ruling party. When that failed, they walked out of the intensely divided chamber in protest.

"I ask you to consider my resignation and take a decision on it," Lytvyn told his fellow lawmakers.

Mykola Tomenko, a deputy parliament speaker, reportedly offered to step down along with Lytvyn.

The parliament's speaker and the president must each sign off on legislation before it becomes law.

Yatsenyuk insists the vote is inadmissible.

"Yesterday, the parliament approved a decision to vote on a bill to ban the Ukrainian language in an unconstitutional, unlawful, and inhumane way," he said, adding, "There was no law adopted yesterday. There is no new law on the state language policy."

Public Anger

Two hundred and forty-eight legislators out of 364 present approved the bill in the lightning-quick vote on July 3.

Opposition activists the next day clashed with police outside parliament as they protested the bill's adoption and the ruling party's methods.

Some of the roughly 2,000 protesters hurled bottles of water and sticks at the police, and both sides used pepper-spray against each other.

Riot police fired tear gas and used batons to disperse the demonstrators.

"The people of Ukraine protest against the dictatorship of President Yanukovych," Ukrainian opposition leader and former parliament speaker Arseniy Yatsenyuk said of the protesters' demands. "He created a handmade Ukrainian parliament, which is not actually a parliament, it resembles a joint-stock company, and the key shareholder of this company is actually President Yanukovych. And he believes that the country is his personal property and we believe that the country is the property of the people of Ukraine. So we defend our country, we defend our constitution, and we defend our language."

Many protesters had stayed out on the streets overnight to express anger at the legislative maneuver.

PHOTO GALLERY: Tension was evident in the Ukrainian capital, Kyiv, on July 4 as protesters opposed to the Russian language bill gathered outside the site of President Yanukovych's abortive press conference on the recent Euro 2012 soccer championships. (Photos by RFE/RL's Ukrainian Service)



Whose Crisis?

Yanukovich described the situation as a crisis in the legislature following the speaker's resignation.

National elections for a new parliament are scheduled for October 28.

Language policy is an emotive subject in the former Soviet republic of 45 million people whose state language is Ukrainian but where a significant number of people speak Russian as their mother tongue.

The leader of the opposition Udar party, heavyweight world champion boxer Vitali Klitschko, told Reuters at the scene of the protests in Kyiv on July 4 that "politicians are dividing our society."

"They themselves do their best, all they can, to divide the people," Klitschko said. "There is no such issue as a language issue today, and we all know very well the names of the politicians responsible for this."

Supporters of the bill argue it will make life easier for the country's Russian-speakers by allowing their children to receive schooling in their mother tongue.

The bill would give Russian language equal status with Ukrainian across much of the country for use in legal discourse, business, and education.

It would recognize Russian as a "regional" language in predominantly Russian-speaking areas and enable its use in the public service.

Threat To Sovereignty?

Critics say this would undermine the Ukrainian language and threaten Ukrainian sovereignty.

Opposition parties have condemned the proposal as an attempt by the Party of the Regions to woo disillusioned Russian-speaking voters ahead of the parliamentary voting.

Russian speakers are more common in Ukraine's south and east, and in large cities. Ukrainian speakers are more common in Ukraine's west and north, and in rural regions.

* CORRECTION: An earlier version of this story erroneously stated the date of the vote as July 4. It was July 3.

Based on reporting by RFE/RL's Ukraine Service, Reuters, AFP, Interfax, and ITAR-TASS
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments page of 2
    Next 
by: Vladimir from: Zaporozhye
July 04, 2012 04:38
The Russian speakers were denied not only the right to their language and culture, but to their name too, On the 13th of June I applied to the authorities to be provided with a foreign passport. I did not get it because they insisted on my name to be transliterated into Latin as Volodimir (the Ukranian equivqlent of my name).I won't have it. Iam Vladimir.
I wrote a few books in which the issue is looked into.
In Response

by: RICK from: MILAN
July 04, 2012 15:22
DO YOU KNOW HOW IS ....

WHEN SOMETHING IS AGAINST RUSSIAN
EVERYTHING IS PERMITTED !

YOU NEVER LISTEN SOMETHING FROM EU
IN DEFENCE OF RUSSIAN LANGUAGE ?

NO , NEVER ! ! !

EU PREFER TO DEFENCE ALBANIAN IN MACEDONIA

ALSO IF ALBANIAN AREN'T EU CITIZENZS

AND TO IGNORE RUSSIAN SPEAKING PEOPLE
IN UKRAINE , IN MOLDOVA , IN BALTICS REPUBLICS ...

ALSO IF NOT LESS THAN 3 MILIONS OF EU CITIZENS

ARE RUSSIAN SPEAKING !

(3 MILION THAT YOU CAN FIND IN 3 BALTIC REPUBLICS POLONIA FINLAND AND ROMANIA )

RUSSIAN SHOULD BE AN OFFICIAL LANGUAGE ALSO IN EU

BUT EU PREFER TO GIVE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE STATUS
TO IRISH
A LANGUAGE THAT NO ONE SPEAKS !
In Response

by: Deaglán from: Éire
July 10, 2012 16:52
Labhraítear Gaeilge. Ní láidríonn sé do chas tíortha agus teangacha eile a mhaslú.
In Response

by: Frank
July 04, 2012 19:24
In the above RFE/RL piece, the comments attributed to Yatseniuk are inaccurate nationalist babble.
In Response

by: William from: Aragon
July 05, 2012 00:21
Given that your name originated from the original Viking name Vladmar, then your's is the most correct pronounciation and spelling compared to Volodimir.
In Response

by: Anonymous
July 05, 2012 09:03
You are wrong. You are Volodimir, nor Vladimir!

by: Eugenio from: Vienna
July 04, 2012 04:54
Finally the European standards in minority language protection have been met!

by: ahmed41 from: HP
July 04, 2012 10:37
The parliament has passed the bill with a clear majority !!!

If voters do not agree to this, then will it be a referendum issue ?
In Response

by: Eugenio from: Vienna
July 04, 2012 18:23
Dear Ahmed, I would strongly disagree with your point on that the minority language issue should be a "referendum issue" for the simple reason that an ethnic/linguistic majority just can not be authorized to deny a minority their right to use their own MINORITY language in their native country.
And minority language protection exists not only in many European countries (Belgium, Italy, Spain, even here in Austria), but also in many other countries in the world (India being probably the best known example of respect for minority languages).
Those who are interested in seein how those Ukrainian nationalists who can only lose and who represent the NATO-imposed world which is disappearing in front of our eyes, can have a look here at some videos of nationalist protests in the Ukrainian capital Kiev caused by the adoption of the new language law: http://www.pravda.com.ua/rus/news/2012/07/4/6967991/

by: Jack from: US
July 04, 2012 14:35
most Ukrainians prefer to speak Russian anyway whether the Ukrainian parlament approves it or not. Ukrainian language is regarded by most as a village tongue spoken by uneducated and poor
In Response

by: Jack from: US
July 04, 2012 16:05
That was not me but a swarthy RFE/RL staffer. US is biggest sponsor of Zionist terror.
In Response

by: CJ from: Saskatoon, Canada
July 04, 2012 18:44
This is a strange comment. While I speak Russian my wife speaks Ukrainian. Here home city is Lviv and she holds a masters degree from a prominant Canadian university. She is not from a village or uneducated. Near where my grandparents or the thounds of highly educated Ukrainian-Canadians who choose to speak Ukrainian. If this comment was made in Western Ukraine or Western Canada I would suggest you have running shoes on.
In Response

by: Ben
July 04, 2012 19:31
Jack,how do you come to know about the Ukrainians` preferences?
Oh,I understand! Your name in Russia was Yasha,and you strongly prefer Russian by your old tradition of Hmelnitsky` memory.
In Response

by: Victor from: USA
July 04, 2012 22:07
If you want to speak russian then go to russia. In Ukraine the language is "Ukrainian".

Get used to it katsaps
In Response

by: Vladimir from: Zaporozhye
July 06, 2012 06:02
And if you live in Switzerland your language following your logic, must be Swiss?
Victor, are you familiar with the rules of the forum? "katsaps" is a taboo epithet. If you are using it you humiliate other people and your claim to being an adequate communicator on the forum is null and void.

by: RICK from: MILAN
July 04, 2012 15:11
this isn't a """ Russian Language Bill """

BUT

MINORITY LANGUAGE BILL ! ! !

by: Jack from: US
July 04, 2012 16:00
"orange revolutionaries" were quick to bend over to please US government and its NATO minions. They tried to force Ukrainian language on everybody and drove the Ukraine into economic devastation comparable to the damage from WWII. Now the Ukraine is managed by Russian PM Azarov who does not speak Ukrainian. Unlike pro-Western orange revolutionaries Azarov got solid 7% growth rate for the Ukraine. Finally most Ukrainians got food on the table and they are not starving like they were under pro-NATO minion government of Yuschenko and his cronies

by: Mart from: Estonia
July 04, 2012 19:59
This bill aims, in fact, at complete elimination of the Ukrainian language off the face of the earth, and therefore it constitutes agression against the Ukrainian people. May they consolidate against this move. As for Russian speakers on Ukraine, they know best that nobody has ever limited their use of Russian.
In Response

by: Frank
July 06, 2012 00:41
Mart,

Whatt you just said is a flat ot lie along the lines of the comments attributed to Yatseniuk in the above RFE/RL piece.

by: Natalie from: Kiew
July 04, 2012 20:42
So far, the only comprehensive analysis of the problem I managed to find:
http://www.opendemocracy.net/od-russia/mykola-riabchuk/playing-with-ambiguities-ukraine%E2%80%99s-language-law
In Response

by: Frank
July 06, 2012 00:42
Natalie,

Riabchuk is an extreme nationalist with ignorant views like the ones evident in that crappy openDemocracy piece you gave.

by: François from: Versailles
July 04, 2012 20:50
I love the handfull of protesters. Looks like there are 100 or so of them. Headline news ! RFE would do better to cover NYC police brutality.

by: American Troll
July 04, 2012 20:55
The wise choice would be bilingual English and Mandarin, given that no one in the 22nd century will speak Russian, Ukrainian, or probably any other Slavic language anyway, unless Slavs unexpectedly revive the lost art of procreation.
In Response

by: Anonymous
July 06, 2012 18:00
and you start studing Spanish !
In Response

by: American Troll
July 07, 2012 22:09
Estoy totalmente de acuerdo, amigo. Es una lengua hermosa y muy similar a inglés :) El más importantemente, esto tiene un futuro, a diferencia de las lenguas eslavas. No escuchar los rednecks y Republicanos sólo porque son más fuertes. Mayoría de nosotros somos agradecida por nuestra siga americanos al sur. ¡Viva bilingüismo!
Comments page of 2
    Next 

Most Popular