Thursday, April 24, 2014


Transmission

Who Killed The Kazakh Border Guards?

A Kazakh border guard closes a barrier at the Korgas crossing point, the largest on the 1,500-kilometer-long Kazakh-Chinese border.
A Kazakh border guard closes a barrier at the Korgas crossing point, the largest on the 1,500-kilometer-long Kazakh-Chinese border.
TEXT SIZE - +
Fifteen bodies -- 14 of them border guards -- were found on May 30 on the Kazakh-Chinese frontier but there are still no clear answers as to how they died.
 
The facts, as they stand, are sketchy. What is known is that there was a fire at a remote outpost at Sary Bokter, in Almaty Oblast on the Kazakh-Chinese border. The fire burned down a soldiers' barracks and an officer's house and investigators found the bodies of the 14 border guards among the debris. The body of a civilian forest ranger was found shot to death in a nearby house. Officials have said that a 15th border guard, who was posted at the base, remains missing.
 
Several theories about the deaths have been aired in the Kazakh press: an accidental fire, an attack, or an incident connected to hazing.
 
The accidental fire theory has been called into some doubt, as investigators were quoted in the media as saying that the guards were already dead by the time the fire started.
 
The authorities have launched an investigation and the bodies have been taken to the Kazakh city of Astana for DNA identification and forensic tests. Officials have only said that preliminary tests show that none of the men had alcohol in their blood.
 
Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbaev wasted no time in saying on June 1 that the apparent killings were “a terrorist act,” without specifying who might be behind it. His comments come during the trial of 37 people accused of organizing the mass unrest that led to deadly violence in the western Kazakh town of Zhanaozen last year.

If the deaths were the result of an attack, it is unclear who the perpetrators might be. The border, which is 1,520 kilometers long and entirely within China's Xin Jiang province, is relatively calm. As Nathan Hamm points out at "Registan":
 
If for no other reason, this incident is odd for having happened on the border with China. Violent incidents have not been uncommon along borders between Central Asian states or along Tajikistan’s border with Afghanistan. The Chinese border has been fairly quiet since independence.
 
The Sary Bokter border post is not permanent, but a temporary construction put up in the summer reportedly to clamp down on the scores of Chinese who cross the border to collect herbs and plants which are used in Chinese medicine. Despite that, it is not a region particularly blighted by ethnic or political tensions. (The fact that a border post was set up there to counter herb-pickers is testament to the relative low stakes.)
 
While no officials have gone on the record to accuse the Chinese, there have been mutterings in the press and on Internet forums about ethnic Chinese or Uyghur separatists being the likely culprits. This makes sense given the historical enmity and suspicion many Kazakhs hold for the Chinese. A Soviet-era proverb, loosely translated, reads: "If hordes of Chinese come, the red Russian will be like a father."
 
In recent years, there has been a rise in popular anti-China sentiment, after reports of official plans to lease Kazakh farmland to China. The presence of Chinese migrant laborers or market traders (both ethnic Uyghur and Han) across Kazakhstan has also stoked some resentments.
 
A Chinese hand here would seem far-fetched, considering the decent state of Kazakh-Chinese bilateral relations. And a remote outpost -- rather than, say, a crowded shopping mall -- would seem an unlikely target for domestic terrorism.
 
Skullduggery among smugglers is another possibility. Along some parts of the border, smugglers have operated freely. In 2011, there were reports that over 100 members of a criminal group had been arrested for illegally trafficking goods across the border.  
 
The key to unraveling the mystery may well lie with the 15th border guard, who still has not been found -- along with a few missing horses. There has been speculation in the Kazakh press that it is the missing guard who is responsible for the killings, possibly as a revenge for hazing.

The sheer remoteness of the outpost (it is off the cellular grid) has just added to the confusion and speculation. But the Kazakh authorities are clearly taking the incident seriously. Border forces have been strengthened and on the highway between Almaty and Oskemen, military checkpoints have been put in place and cars have been stopped and searched. According to RFE/RL's Kazakh Service, local residents learned about the deaths from the press and many were scared to talk openly about the deaths.
 
President Nazarbaev has announced that June 5 will be a national day of mourning in Kazakhstan in honor of the slain border guards.

-- Luke Allnutt
This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Dervish Uyghur from: America
June 04, 2012 15:37
Thank you Mr. Hamm for writing this important article. Uyghur communities both in Kazakhstan and around the world are closely watching the investigation into the killing of Kazakh border guards. We Uyghurs, as ethnic brethren of Kazakhs, feel deeply saddened by this tragedy. We hope the Kazakhstan government fully investigate the killing and bring the culprits to justice. But before the conclusion of the full investigation, we expect both the Kazakh government and media not to point fingers at Uyghurs and speculate that it was the work of "Uyghur separatists". The immature Kazakh media should investigate the truth instead of finding a scapegoat for this tragedy with sensational speculations. Uyghurs have no beef with the Kazakhs. Uyghurs are happy for Kazakhs to have an independence state and freedom yet denied to them by the Chinese government on a daily basis. There is no reason for the Uyghurs to target Kazakh border guards. If they wanted, and were capable to, they would have targeted the Chinese border guards. In fact, the so-called Uyghur separatists do NOT have the capability to carry out any such attacks. They do not have the training or weapons. The so-called Uyghur separatist threat is cooked up by the Chinese government to justify its brutal policies against the Uyghurs' yearning for independence just as the Soviet Union did to the Kazakhs before the Kazakhstan became independent in 1991. Therefore, the Kazakh people should understand the pain and suffering of Uyghurs and sympathize with and support their struggle for freedom and independence. It is better the Uyghurs are the neighbors of Kazakhs than the Chinese. Any rational Kazakh will agree with this proposition. Thanks.
In Response

by: Kazakh from: Almaty
June 05, 2012 17:07
Hi Dervish,
I agree that Uygurs has no benefits out of this situation and there is no need for them as many Uygurs live in Almaty and Kazakhstan.
Do you have any ideas on who did this?
Thanks

About This Blog

Written by RFE/RL editors and correspondents, Transmission serves up news, comment, and the odd silly dictator story. While our primary concern is with foreign policy, Transmission is also a place for the ideas -- some serious, some irreverent -- that bubble up from our bureaus. The name recognizes RFE/RL's role as a surrogate broadcaster to places without free media. You can write us at transmission+rferl.org

Most Popular