Wednesday, August 24, 2016


Five Years After Nazran, Ingushetia Still Plagued By Militant Violence

Ingushetia has surpassed Chechnya as the most violent of the North Caucasus republics
Ingushetia has surpassed Chechnya as the most violent of the North Caucasus republics
By Claire Bigg
On the night of June 21, 2004, in one of the best-planned attacks by Chechen separatist rebels, hundreds of armed men stormed the southern Russian city of Nazran, leaving a trail of destruction and death in their wake.

The raid alarmed the Kremlin, which had boasted of bringing stability to the North Caucasus after a decade of war with Chechen separatists.

Led by Chechen warlord Shamil Basayev, the heavily armed assailants targeted 15 official buildings in Ingushetia's main city as well as several towns and villages in the republic, which borders war-battered Chechnya.

They caught Nazran off-guard, wreaking destruction for one night before withdrawing with two truckloads of seized weapons and only minimal losses on their side.

"It was already dark when the shooting suddenly started. I went to the center of Nazran and heard that shots were being fired throughout the city. The border guards' building was on fire," recalls Akhmed Sultanov, a correspondent for RFE/RL's North Caucasus Service.

Sultanov says the streets of Nazran were littered with dead bodies and charred vehicles.

"The center of Nazran was a terrifying sight. There were burned-out, bullet-ridden cars everywhere. There were dead people in cars, people who had been shot," Sultanov says.

"Many of them wore army fatigues; many policemen had been shot dead. I saw that some of them had been pulled out of their cars, thrown onto the ground, and shot from behind."

Nazran's Interior Ministry building and train station were burned to the ground. More than 60 police, security officers, prosecutors, investigators, and border guards were killed -- many of them caught in their sleep and slain in front of their relatives.

Ingushetia is still plagued by violence and insurgency.
The republic's acting interior minister, Abukar Kostoyev, his deputy Ziyaudin Kotiyev, and Nazran's prosecutor-general, Mukharbek Buzurtanov, were among the victims.

About 25 civilians, including a local United Nations worker, died in the crossfire.

North Caucasus Not 'Pacified'

Underscoring the gravity of the attack, then-Russian President Vladimir Putin flew to Nazran to hold talks with Ingushetia's president at the time, Murat Zyazikov.

Putin ordered the deployment of federal troops to bolster security in Ingushetia and vowed to "find and destroy" the militants.

The Nazran raid was a huge embarrassment for the Kremlin, one that undermined its claims that Chechen rebels were too battered by a decade of war with Moscow to mount any significant offensive.

It came at a very inconvenient time for the Russian government, which was preparing for an election to replace Kremlin-backed Chechen President Akhmed-hadji Kadyrov, killed just six weeks before in a bombing attack.

It was also a departure from previous attacks and hostage takings, since the militants in Nazran didn't put forward any specific political demands.

Their main goal, besides capturing a huge cache of weapons, was to showcase the insurgency's capabilities and undermine Moscow's claims that rebels had been reduced to mere "pockets of resistance."

Chechen political analyst Timur Muzayev describes the attack as a "show of force," and "defining moment in the battle waged by opponents of Russian rule in the North Caucasus."

Muzayev adds that the Nazran raid was "an exceptional attack. It was a show of force that didn't yield any result for the militants; they didn't make any political demands, they didn't seek to negotiate or pressure. They just wanted to show that it's possible to shake the regime in the North Caucasus."

'Too Much To Carry'

Adding insult to injury, a Chechen rebel website just days after the raid posted what it said was footage of Basayev and other rebels seizing weapons from the Ingush Interior Ministry during the attack.

Shamil Basayev Footagei
|| 0:00:00
June 19, 2009
Just days after the raid on Nazran on June 21-22, 2004, a Chechen rebel website posted what it claimed was footage of Chechen warlord Shamil Basayev during the attack.

In the video, the man purported to be Basayev is seen listing weapons and complaining that the rebels don't have enough vehicles to carry them away.

"We are now in the Interior Ministry's weapons warehouse," the man says in the video. "We've seized about 700 submachine guns, more than 800 pistols, about 1 million rounds of various calibers, equipment, and uniforms. Our only problem is the lack of transport."

The man in the video adds that the Nazran raid was conducted jointly by Chechen and Ingush rebels. A number of witnesses have confirmed that some of the militants were native Ingush.

Increasing Public Support

This was not the first time Chechen separatist fighters conducted forays into neighboring provinces.

In 1995, rebels led by Basayev stormed a hospital in the southern Russian town of Budyonnovsk, killing some 166 hostages. And in 1999, some 2,000 Chechen militants entered Daghestan and battled Russian troops for 10 days before retreating to Chechnya.

What the Nazran raid made clear, however, was that the Chechen conflict had not only spilled out of Chechnya; militants were also developing support bases outside their republic.

Critics say Moscow inadvertently encouraged young men in Ingushetia and other North Caucasus regions to join the insurgency by closing its eyes to the brutal methods employed by federal forces in the region.

In the poor, chiefly Muslim republic of Ingushetia, heavy-handed police tactics, combined with official corruption, rampant poverty, and a 75 percent unemployment rate provided Chechen militants with wide public support and a ready pool of recruits.

RFE/RL's Sultanov says he saw many residents come out of their homes during the Nazran raid to cheer the militants.

Timur Izmailov, an Ingush journalist, says Ingushetia's descent into violence began with the presidency of the Kremlin-anointed Zyazikov.

"Within months after Zyazikov became president, terror began in the republic. People were kidnapped and killed. Neither officials nor ordinary people respected the law," Izmailov says.

"Many were against the authorities because they killed innocent people in front of their mothers, brothers, and sisters. Basayev enjoyed strong support among the Ingush population due to the pervasive lawlessness."

Basayev was killed in a Russian special operation in Ingushetia in 2006.

And with Ingushetia teetering on the verge of civil war, Russian authorities finally dismissed Zyazikov last year -- news that was greeted with singing and dancing in the streets.

New Ingush President Yunus-Bek Yevkurov, a respected former paratroop commander, has spared no effort to restore trust in local authorities and stem the rebellion. In an unprecedented move just weeks after his appointment, he ordered the prosecution of several security officers on kidnapping charges.

But it will take more to bring peace to Ingushetia, the new hot spot of the North Caucasus.

"After Ingushetia's new president took office, a great number of people, even in the opposition, were convinced that the situation would improve," Sultanov says.

"But illegal arrests and extrajudicial killings continue, there are armed raids, and people continue to be killed every day."

RFE/RL's North Caucasus Service contributed to this report

Claire Bigg

Claire Bigg covers Russia, Ukraine, and the post-Soviet world, with a focus on human rights, civil society, and social issues. Send story tips to​


This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
by: Konstanti n from: Los Angeles
June 20, 2009 07:03
What?<br />Russian military and &quot;intelligence&quot; (what a horrible word that is an insult for any intelligent and honest individual) appointing their &quot;Gauliters&quot; and ministers from Russian Spetcnaz, the war criminals and subversives, and Ingushetia nation is saddenly become &quot;terroruists&quot;, by Putin, to be &quot;peacefied&quot; by Russia?<br />What are we all here, idiots?<br />Ingushetia for a wile was left out of immediate Russian genocide and repopulation by Russkiys , but when Ingushetia declared years ago they had resources to build two hidroelectric plant and shy out of Russian provocations, Russia immediatly pushed to Ingushettia Russian military and Spetcnaz pseudo-Muslim terrorists and started destroy and annex Ingushetia...<br /><br />For similar reasons, little willingness of Dzasohov's Northern Osetia to annex Georgian territory and small Georgian wine bottling plant in Beslan, generated Russian annexation of Northern Osetia by Gauliters from Russia and murder of children in Beslan...<br /><br />Today Russia is a condamnation for frieedom, dignity and very life of nations arround Russian borders and inside Russia - tommorow condamnation for whole Europe and USA... <br /><br />Konstantin.

by: rkka from: usa
June 20, 2009 20:33
Wow, not a single mention of the sharp decline of violence in Chechnya in the whole article!<br /><br />But what can you expect of a Russophobe propaganda shop like RFE/RL.

by: Konstantin from: Los Angeles
June 22, 2009 07:05
rkka?<br /><br />Is &quot;rkka&quot; an abreviation for &quot;Revolutionary Kommity&quot; of the Lenin's red terror in Russia, where &quot;A&quot; at the end stands for &quot;America&quot;?<br /> <br />RKKA mistaken Russophobia for his Russofillia, as the rest of the World evaluates Russia, again - &quot;RattenForBand&quot;.<br /><br />It wasn't any violence in former USSR or CIS beside Russian secret shape-shifters of Russian Army and Intelligence, plotting since 1954 again to kill non-Russian people and to justify invasions of Russian Army and Spetcnaz - for more annexations and repopulating non-Russian countries by Russkis, trying create a larger Russian Empire.<br />All &quot;terrorist&quot; acts, since Russian Spetcnaz gased nerve gas Cheremushka in Tbilisi, done by order of Russia that <br />correlates all too well with Russian propaganda, destruction of any attempt of improvement in non-Russian nations, politics of crimes of Russia, its timing and Russian expansion.<br /><br />Russia like to be scarry and induce<br /> &quot;Russophobia&quot; in the World. <br /><br />Dreem Russian terrorists from RKK!<br /><br />Konstantin.

by: Maksim from: Tallinn
June 24, 2009 22:03
Quality anti-Russian propaganda, as usual.

by: Ron from: Atlanta
June 27, 2009 20:55
Just curious why neither of the recent reports on the Nazran raid fails to cite Moscow's claim that weapons stolen in Nazran were used in the raid on Beslan - whose fifth anniversary is also just around the corner.<br />Also, wasn't a demand of the Beslan raiders that suspects, rounded-up in the aftermath of the Nazran raid, be released?<br />Just curious - it will be September before you know it.

Most Popular

Editor's Picks