map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

CNN: RFE/RL is "World Changing Radio"

CNN International reports on RFE/RL's role in Czechoslovakia's Velvet Revolution, and its continuing mission to spread free media More
More Articles

Iran Election Diary

Khatami's Azeri Joke Backfires

May 27, 2009

Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.



In the last two weeks, a video showing Iran’s former President Mohammad Khatami telling a joke about Iran’s Azeri minority has led to protests by Iranian Azeris and students in several cities including Tehran, Orumyeh, and Tabriz. (The video above is from a protest in Tabriz on May 25.)

The protests have drawn scores of people, many of them calling for a public apology from Khatami; others have said he should be defrocked. It is not clear when the video was made, but it appears to come from a private meeting.

The video, which is of poor quality, shows Khatami sitting in a room with several others, including some clerics, telling a joke.

“There was a preacher from Ardabil whose expertise was telling the story of how Fatemeh Zahra [the daughter of the Prophet Muhammad] got married," he says. "[The preacher] said that the night she became a bride, she was being taken to the house [of the groom] and the Prophet was walking in front of her, while Imam Hassan and Imam Hossein [both the sons of Fatemeh Zahra] were walking with her.”

Jokes about Azeris in Iran tend to focus on the idea that Azeris are slow, with the implication here that the preacher couldn't even get the story right.

What's interesting is the timing of the video's appearance and the possible motives for its release.

The head of the Azeri lawyers association in Tabriz, Hossein Farhudinia, told RFE/RL's Radio Farda earlier this week that he believes the posting of the video is a calculated move ahead of the June 12 election.

He also said that telling jokes is a tradition among Iranians and that those who tell jokes generally do not mean to show disrespect or insult others.

Mohammad Ali Abtahi, who served as one of Khatami’s vice presidents, gave a similar explanation to an Azerbaijani website Day.az. He said that the video is “a pre-election provocation by the forces who are in power.”

Khatami, who withdrew his presidential candidacy, is now backing former Prime Minister Mir Hossein Musavi, who is seen as President Mahmud Ahmadinejad’s main challenger.

Musavi is from Iran’s Azeri minority and is expected to garner a good deal of Azeri voters. The minority is actually huge, making up at least 25 percent of the country's population. A speech Musavi gave on May 25 in Tabriz reportedly attracted a crowd of some 30,000.

According to former Vice President Abtahi: “By provoking Khatami, the conservatives are trying to get Azeris to turn away from their 'native candidate.'” He added that both Khatami and Musavi have great respect for the Azeris.

-- Golnaz Esfandiari
This forum has been closed.
     
Comments
by: Elyar
June 09, 2009 18:59
problem is not just the jokes but some Azerbaijanis are desensetized about it. Racism in in iran is so well accepted by both victims and racist persians that they don't even second doubt it. If Persians in US were called donkeys woudl they still think that is not racist comment? This is a disease which will bring Iran down and will divide it.

by: Aydin
June 08, 2009 17:40
It is really unbelievable that how one can justify such racist jokes about other nationalities! Prince Harry faced a formal Army inquiry over a video in which he called a high-flying Pakistani officer cadet a "Paki" and formally apologized for that. He had not even told any jokes about Pakistanis but he had only called him "Paki" and that was enough to condemn his racist comments all over the UK. Please see the video of Prince Harry and compare it with Mr. Khatami's racist joke and judge yourself that which one was more offensive?!

Prince Harry's shame video:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/theroyalfamily/4218159/Prince-Harry-Paki-row-MoD-launches-formal-inquiry-over-video-gaffe.html

Khatami's shame video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AFazZ2iR96Y&feature=related



by: Urmu.News
May 30, 2009 19:59
PRESS RELEASE: FORMER PRESIDENT OF IRAN INSULTS AZERBAIJANI MINORITY
http://www.adapp.info/press-release-former-president-iran-insults-azerbaijani-minority

by: Aydin from: Seattle, USA
May 30, 2009 08:19
It is shame to be ignorant. I also wonder what happen to the journalist attics. Radio Farda gives tribune for those who is trying to cover up, the shame and racism in Iran. I have seen over and over the free media has been given either to pro Persian groups or pro Islamic Persian. I have to ask myself where my tax moneys are going. We can’t change the fascist government in Iran, but we can change unethical journalism.

by: Elnaz from: USA
May 30, 2009 07:14
In most of racist jokes in Iran, Azerbaijani Turks are called idiots, dump, donkey, and cockroach and ….. Mr.Farhudinia thinks that calling Azerbaijani Turks Khars (donkey) is a tradition? wow, interesting traditions, we have in Iran!!! and those who call Azerbaijanis donkeys, do not mean to show disrespect or insult Azerbaijanis? This, so called the head of the Azeri lawyers association, does find degrading words such as ‘ Donkey Turk” a tradition which does not mean to disrespect others. This is like someone saying that we have tradition of calling African Americans such and such and we really don’t mean to insult them. I am very impressed with intelligent sources rferl is interviewing to inform us? Someone using such an insulting word to call an ethnic group, is trying to do what? Persian services of VOA and rferl often use this type of individuals who are unable to make a decent statement but now you are dragging these comments to spoil your English section. It is a shame. I am finishing this to write a formal complain to your head editors.

P.S don't make up titles for people, we don't have an Azeri Lawyer's Association in Tabriz so there is no such a tile as "" the head of the Azeri lawyers association""

by: Urmu.News
May 29, 2009 07:57
"Azeri lawyers association in Tabriz"!!??
There is not any association with this name. There is an association with the name: "Eastern Azerbaijan Bar Association" and it has very close relationship with Iranian government like all Bar Associations in all provinces of Iran. Azerbaijanian lawyers in Iran who talk about the language rights of Azerbaijan have many problems with government. They can be arrested like Saleh Kamrani and some of them are not allowed to work as a lawyer.
This is not the first time that Radio Farda is trying to hide the reacial act against Azerbaijani Turks of Iran.
     
TEXT SIZE - +

About This Diary

Controversy continues to swirl around Iran's June 12 presidential election. Three candidates, all current or former senior officials, were looking to unseat incumbent Mahmud Ahmadinejad, who was deemed the outright winner within hours of the polls closing. RFE/RL correspondents follow the Iranian public's saga through dispatches of their own, as well as by highlighting some of the viewpoints emerging from Iran through Facebook, Twitter, and other online resources (in orange).

RFE/RL In Persian

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile