map
Our Affiliates
Listen In 28 LanguagesRFE/RL Radio
In 28 Languages

'Berlin Wall's Lessons For Today'

In an op-ed for "USA Today," Jeffrey Gedmin discusses RFE and the role of free media in societies living under repressive regimes. More
More Articles

Features

With Pale School Opening, Serb Leader Sends Message To Bosnia

A child shows the traditional Serb three-finger salute in Pale, in Bosnia's Republika Srpska, on September 8. He's waving the Serbian flag.

September 09, 2009
By Gordana Knezevic
It is unusual for a president of one country to travel to another to celebrate the opening of an ordinary elementary school.

It's even more unusual when that president does so without informing key officials in the country he's visiting.

But that's just what Serbian President Boris Tadic did on September 8, when he traveled to the town of Pale in Bosnia-Herzegovina to attend a ribbon-cutting ceremony at its freshly built red-brick school, where classes for 600 first- through eighth-graders have already begun.

Neither the Croatian nor Muslim members of Bosnia's tripartite Presidency were consulted about Tadic's trip. The reason for that may have become clear when the Serbian leader, in a speech before hundreds of local officials, schoolchildren, and Orthodox clergy, explained the reason for his visit.

"By opening this school, we're contributing to a great thing: education for our people," Tadic said. "I want to tell you that Serbia, of which I am president, has a responsibility to Serbs wherever they are. Serbia is not responsible for the citizens of Serbia alone; Serbia is responsible for all the people who belong to our nation."

Funding for the school -- provocatively named "Serbia" -- came not from Serbia but from the local government of Bosnia's Serbian entity, Republika Srpska.

But critics say everything from Tadic's presence, to the historically loaded site of Pale, to even the school's provocative name -- "Serbia" -- speaks of a wider plan crafted with Belgrade's approval.

Milenko Dereta, an analyst based in the Serbian capital, says the ribbon-cutting is just the latest salvo in the ongoing Serbian campaign to shatter Bosnian sovereignty and build a unified Serbian nation.

"A real achievement [in tolerance], for me, would be the opening of a school named 'Serbia' in the Muslim-Croat half of Bosnia," Dereta says. "But when it's in Republika Srpska, it's like a cherry on top of a cake or a flag being raised to mark territorial gains."

'Special Relations'

Pale, a sleepy mountain town in a region known to local Serbs as East Sarajevo, was the stronghold of Bosnian Serb leader Radovan Karadzic during the Bosnian war.

Nearly 20 kilometers to the east of Sarajevo, it was a key launching point for the Serbian artillery barrages, under Karadzic's supervision, that killed more than 10,000 Sarajevans during the 1992-95 siege of the city.

Plaque bears the name of the "Serbia" elementary school in Pale.
The internationally brokered Dayton agreement that ended the war kept Pale, and the rest of Bosnia's Serb-majority territory, as part of Republika Srpska, which together with the Muslim-Croat Federation formed Bosnia-Herzegovina.

Dayton also granted Serbia the right to "special relations" with the Republika Srpska.

But critics say that doesn't extend to building schools named "Serbia" in a town notorious for its tactical contribution to the slaughter of Bosnians in Sarajevo.

Sacir Filandra, a professor at Sarajevo University, notes that Dayton intended to empower Serbia as a peacemaker, not a spoiler.

"The problem is that 'special' and 'parallel' relations [as defined by Dayton] is subject to political manipulation," Filandra says.

The development is particularly worrying at a time when Milorad Dodik, the voluble prime minister of Republika Srpska, is threatening to secede from the state.

At the September 8 opening, children gathered outside the school waved both Serbian and Republika Srpska flags, occasionally flashing the three-fingered salute favored by Serbian soldiers during the war.

Dodik, playing the ebullient host during the school opening, praised the Serbian president as his own.

"It's a wonderful occasion to be here today among the good people of Pale of East Sarajevo, among our people and students, with our guests and with our dear President Tadic," Dodik told the crowd.

A Blind Eye?

For Bosnia's Muslims and Croats, Dodik's antics are nothing new. More upsetting may be the muted reaction of the international community to provocations like the Tadic visit and the "Serbia" school.

Austrian diplomat Valentin Inzko, the high representative for Bosnia and Herzegovina -- whose task, as outlined by Dayton, is to monitor the country's fragile peace -- offered no statement about the Serbian president's trip.

Serbian President Boris Tadic (left) with Republika Srpska's prime minister, Milorad Dodik, in Pale on September 8
Aleksandar Popov, an analyst based in Belgrade, suggests that the West, by turning a blind eye to such events, may be trying to appease Serbia for the loss of Kosovo, a former Serbian province that declared independence last year with the backing of the United States and a majority of EU countries.

"The idea that Serbia could make up for the loss of Kosovo by acquiring Republika Srpska is poisoning us," Popov says. "Serbia could gain much more respect if it would contribute to stability in Bosnia -- if it would cooperate not just with Republika Srpska, but with other parts of Bosnia as well."

Few of Popov's fellow Serbs share his view, however. "Why shouldn't we build a school in Pale?" says one passerby in Belgrade. "I see it as an expression of Serbian unity."

Marija Arnautovic from Sarajevo, Ljudmila Cvetkovic from Belgrade, and Ivan Katavic from Pale contributed to this story
This forum has been closed.
    Next 
Comments page 1 of 4
by: Abdul Majid
September 21, 2009 01:05
to Girl
yes, that's true. I know. After all, during 1992-95 my girlfriend was a Bosniak refugee from Zvornik. The nicest person I have ever known and pretty as the bright day to boot. And all Bosniaks I have known since then, and all the people I met in Bosnia are the kindest and most sympathetic people in the world. Only when someone starts bad-mouthing the Bosniaks, slandering them as "jihadists" or saying "We won't be ruled by Muslims" or to justify or deny or belittle Srebrenica or some such, then I only apply to them what my father taught me: "With a gentleman (or a lady), behave like a gentleman, and with a scoundrel, like a scoundrel, all else is bunk."
See the diatribe by that Greek fascist. He only shows his ignorance and evil. Bosniaks are Bosniaks. They have theri own nationality and their own hostory fro over 1000 years, and they have for mopst embraced Islam since 500 years. They have had more than enoughtime to develop a national identity, and even if some are descended from serbs or Croats who took up Islam, that was hundreds of years ago. Now they are all Bosniaks, and proud of being Muslims. They are NOT crypto-Christians, and they are NOT traitors to their own. But the Greeks, Serbs and Bulgarians did commit genocide against the Balkan Muslims after 1878, just to rob them and to chase them from the land, just like the Serbs did in 1992-95, and it is only in imitation of them that the Turks later had no qualms to commit genocide against the Armenians (and by then the Turks only imitated the fascistoid ultranationalist political model the Balkan countries had introduced in the 19th century, that's why they did it.) And so I tell you, I don't know how many Greeks there are, but I do know that many do not support fascism! And those who do, let them know that there are over one billion Muslims in the world. And even if you murdered 11.000 people at Srebrenica and nearly 100.000 all over Bosnia, I tell you: The orthodox cross will NEVER chase the Crescent from the Balkans, and you will NEVER turn the Bosniaks into a folkloric, underprivileged minority as in Greece!
The Banner of Islam will NEVER be lowered in Bosnia!
ANd if you pride yourself in being a good Christian, if THAT is what Christianism is, then I am glad that I am a Muslim, and I tell you I'd rather face a firing squad than to be baptized in your faith! And ALL Muslims who are marginalized and oppressed everywhere in the world, be it in Palestine or in Kashmir or in Turkestan I see as brothers and sisters! And that counts for my Bosniak brothers and sisters too! (and of course I could think of a better and more constructive way to help them prevail against their enemies, but I am just one man and therefore of little consequence. I can only encourage and suggest; it is up to the Bosniaks themselves to decide about their future. If my help is requested I am gladly willing to give it.)

by: Christ Anastopolis from: Athens, Greece
September 20, 2009 05:16
Why does Abdul keep referring to his ethnic group as Bosniaks? You can't give a religion and ethnic group!!

You are either Serb Muslim or Croat Muslim, that is historic fact! We Greek's support Serbia and our orthodox brothers to the north in there unitry and brotherhood. I wouldn't even be bothered if they named every school in the Serb Republic "Serbia". Good for them, stand up to the west and muslim majority! :)

by: Brazilian Man from: São Paulo - SP, Brazil
September 19, 2009 20:33
And just to complement: the people from the Serbian power circles that propose the expansion of Serbia into Bosnian lands is the same people who violently oppose European tolerance… and the Gay Pride March in Belgrade:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/8264514.stm

by: girl
September 19, 2009 17:18
my mother is bosnian serb and she lost her father, her home and many family and friends in the '92 war, yet she still raised me to respect and love all nations, whatever their religion or background may be. Maybe if there were more people like her, people wouldn't waste time spreading hostility and hatred in the world. Don't you have more important things to do in life then read articles like this one and then precede to spit on other nationalities and religions. Shame on you. Most of you have probably never even been to Bosnia. It's a magnificent country with beautiful traditions and warm, open and friendly people: serbs, muslims and croatians alike.

by: Brazilian Man from: São Paulo - SP, Brazil
September 18, 2009 17:26
Abdul Majid, I understand your feeling.

by: Abdul Majid
September 17, 2009 17:58
Emire: whose side are you on, anyway?

Brazilian Man, you are surely right on the three-fingered salute; now to me it represents the same as the Nazi salute. Which in turn is actually the ancient Roman salute. But no matter what it once was, today it stands for racism, xenophobia and genocide. That's why I can't feel much sympathy for those who make such gestures. sorry but that's how it is.

by: Emir from: Omercajic
September 17, 2009 15:10
i'm bosnian,stop talking about something u don't now!

by: Brazilian Man from: São Paulo - SP, Brazil
September 17, 2009 06:07
Other thing to consider about the picture of the Bosnian boy with the flag of Serbia: the three-finger gesture as a “Serb salute” is a clear manipulation of an symbol to current nationalist-expansionist policies.

First, the gesture is not “Serb”, since the Greeks used it during their insurrection against the Ottoman Empire:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Epanastasi.jpg

And second, the gesture, as a reference to the Holy Trinity, is not only an “Orthodox symbol”, since it was used as a Christian symbol by Catholics… like Pope Pius IX:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pio91856.jpg

That’s it!

by: Abdul Majid
September 17, 2009 02:02
The statements by such subjects as Michael Averko and other defenders of Serbofascism and of Russian impersialism or other hypocrite pseudomarxists or pseudo- leftists or pseudo-anti-imperialists who in the name of their convoluted ideologies defend monstrous leaders such as Milosevic or Radovan Karadzic and their followers only show that the capacity for human beings to do evil and that human depravity are boundless.
People who defend and justify the greatest evil in the world should not be allowed to have any say. freedom of opinion is one thing, but to propagate racism, xenophobia and bigotry, to defend genocide and barbarity is beyond good and evil.

by: Mike Averko
September 16, 2009 11:06
The repeatedly crankish outbursts of the pro-Bosnain Muslim nationalist fanatic posting at this and other RFE/RL threads reveal his/her human shortcomings.

The post-WW I Yugoslav monarchy was Serb based. It made an attempt to reach out to others.

However, there were extremistrs like the soon to be created Ustasha and Hanschar who chose a different path along with some others.

The post WW II Yugoslav state consisted of non-Serb Communists. Serbs were the most numerous of peoples in Yugoslavia. It's therefore absurd to suggest that their role should be less that of others.

Like other parts of Bosnia, Srebrenica involved killing on all sides. The manner of the casualties ranged from collateral damage, killed in combat and the war crime of summary execution.

In the last few years, the fallacy of 200,000 or more Bosnian Civil War fatalities has (for the most part) been put to rest.

There's valid reason to question the figure of 7,000 or more Muslim males summarily executed at Srebrenica.

Finally, the likes of Kucan, Tudjman, Izetbegovic and the KLA greatly contributed to the wars of the last deacde in former Yugoslavia.


    Next 
Comments page 1 of 4
TEXT SIZE - +

Editors' Picks

Arresting Images

Photos Of The Week Photogallery

President Van Rompuy

'How's That Again?!' Audio

Karzai Inauguration

The Anticipation Of Change Video

Follow Us On Twitter

Keep up-to-date on all the latest news from RFE/RL's broadcast region by following us on Twitter:
~ You can find our instant news feed at @RFE_RLNEWS.
~ An obsessive Kremlin watcher? Follow our blog at @PowerVertical.
~ Human rights abuses chronicled at @RightsWatchdog.
~ News, comment, and the odd silly dictator story at @TransmissionRFE.

Products and services:

RSSMail SubscriptionMobile