KYIV -- One man said his morning commute had taken three or four hours. Another predicted misery, but was trying to be optimistic. A woman said she had to wake a lot earlier to deal with the traffic congestion and public transit delays
Split in two by the mighty Dnieper River, Ukraine’s capital is welded together by seven road and rail bridges that allow Kyiv’s 3 million inhabitants to live, work, and function -- even in wartime.
Since the beginning of October, Russia has pummeled those bridges with increasing ferocity, adding a new dimension of anxiety to a city already bracing for a stressful winter -- the result of Russia’s targeting Ukraine’s power grid and heating plants.
This week has been particularly fierce, and bridge traffic has been restricted to public transportation only -- buses and subway trains. On November 20, a new barrage damaged two of the bridges, prompting Mayor Vitali Klitschko to close one entirely. At least eight people were killed.
City and national authorities are scrambling to come up with alternatives in case one or more of the bridges is completely taken out by missiles or drones.
"Due to systematic attacks on bridges, we are creating alternative routes for people, community supplies, emergency services, and defense needs. A total of 21 combined water crossings are planned, Mykola Kalashnyk, the national transport and infrastructure minister, said in a post to Telegram on October 30. “Work has already begun in the capital."
There are no easy fixes, however.
Some Kyiv residents, who have grappled with nearly five years of all-out war, are frustrated that city authorities did not do more to anticipate potential problems with river crossings.
“In a time of war, they didn't even anticipate that a situation like this could arise,” one woman, who declined to give her name, told RFE/RL’s Ukrainian Service. “It's very sad, and it's a black mark against our mayor.
“We don’t need [new] parks during a war; what we need is more infrastructure so people can get to work without problems,” she said. “Because in the morning, it's a quest, and in the evening, it's a quest too.”
Utility workers repair a bridge in Kyiv closed to traffic following Russian missile attacks.
A River Runs Through It
Wide, but not especially deep, the Dnieper regularly freezes over when Ukraine’s winters turn arctic, which adds to engineering problems. Also, while bridges over the river are numerous, access to the banks themselves, by road and public transit, is limited.
One proposal calls for erecting floating pontoon bridges to carry traffic across the water.
The problem with that is the need to build waterside embankments, to anchor the bridges to the shore. Some of the initial work has begun in at least one place, but river currents have already washed some of the sand and rockwork away, said Anna Minyukova, a bridge and transport tunnel engineer.
SEE ALSO:
Ukraine Wrecked Putin's Bridge. Now It Can Choke Russian Supplies To Crimea“This is because the work is being carried out without formal design --following a simplified procedure -- in an effort to speed things up,” she said. “The stated timelines -- two to three months, with the latest suggestion that operations would begin in February -- are unrealistic, especially since some of the required materials are being sourced from abroad.”
Officials have also considered bringing in a fleet of high-speed hydrofoils to ferry people across the river.
Like with the pontoons, however, that plan would require building new infrastructure -- piers and access roads, for example. The vessels would only be able to handle a small fraction of the current bridge traffic; about 80 passengers each.
The Soviet-designed hydrofoils are also notorious gas-guzzlers. And they only move quickly when they rise out of the water, on their underwater “wings,” said Dmytro Bespalov, an expert on transportation mobility.
“While these vessels are capable of rising onto their foils and picking up speed, the fuel consumption becomes so high that the economics go through the roof,” he said. “I might be mistaken, but I recall hearing a figure of around 120 liters of diesel fuel per hour.”
Cars stuck in a traffic jam on a Kyiv bridge caused by the overnight Russian jet-drone attack.
Over Or Under?
And then there is the tunnel.
Officials have floated the idea of building one or more tunnels under the Dnieper. The city’s extensive Soviet-built subway system has two lines that cross to the left, or east , bank, where more than half of its residents live.
But subway trains on those lines run only on bridges, over the Dnieper.
Already five potential locations for tunnels have been identified, and an unspecified American company has expressed interest to Ukrainian officials.
SEE ALSO:
A Quiet Ukrainian Counteroffensive, A 'Rout' For Russian ForcesAside from the cost, the other problem with a tunnel: the design, engineering, and construction work would require years before it would be operational.
“Under the best possible conditions, construction would take anywhere from three to six years -- and that assumes consistent, well-planned funding and a stable security situation,” said Vitaliy Selyk, co-founder of Smilyvi Vidnovlyuvaty, a charitable organization that helps to rebuild war-ravaged communities.
“Building a tunnel would require two massive construction sites -- large enough to be seen from space -- on both the right and left banks of the Dnieper. Would any civilian construction worker want to work at a site that’s constantly under fire?” he said.
“Maybe it’s a military ploy, to confuse the enemy,” Bespalov said. “But a tunnel project has nothing to do with solving the problems we face here and now. In Central Europe, the typical timeframe for tunnel construction is five to 10 years.”
A Russian jet-powered drone strikes one of Kyiv's bridges in early October.
Discouraged by snarled traffic and overcrowded subway trains and buses, many Kyiv residents have started simply walking across the bridges -- and saving time in some cases.
One man, who gave his name as Serhiy, said he was looking for new work in the eastern bank districts so he wouldn’t have to deal with crossing the river.
“I don't want to say bad words, but I am thinking about Putin,” he said, referring to the Russian president.
Another man walking home after work said if the winter was cold enough, he was ready for an even more creative way of commuting:
“I'll just get two huskies from a shelter and find a sled harness,” he said, without giving his name. “I'll take them to cross the Dnieper.”