Visas, Sanctions, Money: How The EU Plans To Prolong Bans On Russian Athletes

A protest at the International Olympic Committee headquarters in Lausanne, Switzerland, in March 2023

BRUSSELS -- The European Union is drawing up new measures to prevent Russian and Belarusian athletes from competing under their national flags and symbols within the bloc, as international sports bodies have chipped away at bans imposed due to Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022.

Discussions in Brussels have been given added urgency by the sporting calendar, with several international events due to be hosted in EU nations over the coming months. Six European countries have even threatened to boycott next year's ice hockey world championship in Germany if Russia plays.

"We reject the return of Russian national teams to international ice hockey tournaments," German ice hockey federation chief Frank Lutz said earlier this month.

How Did We Get Here?

This year has seen key developments that may rehabilitate sportsmen and sportswomen from Russia and Belarus.

SEE ALSO:

Cold Play: Nations Line Up To Boycott Ice Hockey Games Against Russia

First was the decision of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) in the summer to provisionally lift the suspension of the Russian Olympic Committee (ROC) -- a move that could lead to athletes representing Russia at the 2028 Los Angeles Summer Olympics instead of participating as neutrals.

The same decision was taken in the spring for athletes from Belarus, which has been included in the bans after serving as a springboard for Russian tanks in 2022.

This has prompted some sport federations to welcome back athletes of the two countries to compete with national colors and anthems. This move, in turn, has forced some European and other Western nations to take matters into their own hands, especially when it comes to sporting events taking place on their soil.

Only in recent weeks Finland announced that it will restrict short-term work visas for Russian athletes and sports professionals. Sweden is actively looking into blocking Russian athletes from coming to the Swedish city of Falun for February's Nordic World Ski Championships and Estonia has already decided to do the same for the junior version held in the Baltic state in January.

That same month, the Czech Republic has banned Russian athletes from entering and participating in the women's under-18 ice hockey world championship.

"There are government directives, government statements, which de facto ban issuing visas to enable Russian athletes to take part in the championship," Czech Interior Minister Lubomir Metnar said on November 18.

It still remains to be seen what happens with the senior men’s ice-hockey tournament hosted by Germany in May next year as several key European nations have announced that they refuse to play the Russian team.

The main sponsor, the Czech automotive company Skoda (owned by Germany's Volkswagen), has threatened to pull funding in case of Russian participation.

SEE ALSO:

Ukrainian Olympian Urges US To Bar Russian Athletes From 2028 Games

The problem with all this is that it’s done on a national case-by-case basis, and several EU members have asked Brussels to come up with a more coherent bloc-wide response.

This is deemed necessary as some of them risk losing the right to host various sports tournaments in the future. A more robust legal framework backing them up, drawn up by Brussels, would help the case of many countries wanting to block a full rehabilitation of Russian athletes and sports teams.

This response is now taking shape and covers three strands of work: visa rules, sanctions, and funding.

Visas

On visas, it is important to note that this is largely the responsibility of each EU capital. What Brussels has done is to issue EU-wide visa guidelines on Russian citizens, but these do not -- so far -- contain specific language explicitly addressing athletes.

This could change in the coming weeks, as the European Commission is looking over its guidelines. But these only are guidelines and they aren’t binding.

So far, countries in the Baltics and Nordics are denying entry based on rules stating that visas only can be issued for essential travel for categories of Russian citizens such as opposition figures, people in need of protection, and for specific medical needs and treatment. Athletes can hardly qualify here.

Another legal avenue is to use the EU Visa Code which states that a visa must be refused and entry denied if an applicant is considered a "threat to the international relations of any of the member states.”

The EU visa code is binding for all members of the bloc, and there will also be a proposed update early next year. But it needs a qualified majority of member states to be changed and that discussion will not happen quickly enough to deal with sporting events taking place this winter.

It is also unclear whether the measure will be updated to specifically ban athletes from representing a country waging a war of aggression, or whether it will remain more general and therefore open to legal interpretation.

Sanctions

Then there are sanctions. The possibility to slap visa bans and asset freezes on Russian and Belarusian athletes are there. But the rules require proof that their actions in some ways have contributed to the “undermining of the territorial integrity of Ukraine” or that they have been active in destabilizing the EU via hybrid threats.

SEE ALSO:

EU To Add Wildberries CEO, Other Business Chiefs To Russia Sanctions Blacklist

All that can be a bit of a stretch to find evidence for, and there is a reluctance in Brussels corridors for penalizing sportspeople, as the focus very much is to go after politicians and other decision-makers.

What the EU is looking into, and what could be included in the bloc’s new sanctions package that will go to member states this week, is to have sectoral sanctions on Russian and Belarusian sportspeople competing with national symbols, not just individual blacklistings.

This would mean a sort of blanket ban similar to what the bloc already has imposed on other Russian activities such as transport services, engineering, or even access to Russian media.

The issue here, however, is unanimity. Will all 27 EU member states really reach agreement on such a move any time soon?

Money

Finally, there is the financing, in particular via Erasmus+ Sport -- an EU program that finances European sports organizations and federations often at grassroots level. With an annual budget of roughly 80 million euros ($88 million) a year it normally hands out grants up to 1.5 million euros. And while that doesn’t sound too much, it can be a crucial lifeline for smaller sports, clubs, and municipalities that build or maintain facilities.

The guidelines for Erasmus+ were recently updated by the European Commission.

The text now states international sport governing bodies that “authorize Russian athletes to compete in sport events under full national representation, including the use of the national flag, anthem, and other symbols” as well as entities that organize such sports events when such action takes place, are no longer eligible for such funds.

This is, according to the document, “in order to avoid granting legitimacy or reputational benefit through sport to Russia, which is responsible for the war of aggression against Ukraine, and to ensure that the objective of the action of promoting integrity and values in sport is not compromised.”