Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

Tashkent Mayor Jahongir Ortiqhojaev (file photo)
Tashkent Mayor Jahongir Ortiqhojaev (file photo)

TASHKENT -- A court in Tashkent has found the Uzbek capital's mayor, Jahongir Ortiqhojaev, guilty of breaking the law over decisions to hand city land to a company affiliated with the president's son-in-law.

The Chilonzor district court on January 27 ruled that two decisions made in 2018 and 2019 by Ortiqhojaev were unlawful.

According to the 2018 decision, more than 6 hectares of land in Yunusobod, one of Tashkent's most expensive districts with some 100 private businesses based there, was to be placed in the city's land reserve.

Then, on the last day of 2019, Ortiqhojaev issued another order giving that land to the Urban Developers construction company.

Business owners and entrepreneurs in Yunusobod filed a lawsuit against the decisions, saying the plan to develop the area would harm their businesses and that several regulations and laws had been violated since the land, worth at least $11.5 million, was placed under the control of Urban Developers.

Urban Developers, which planned to develop a trade and entertainment complex in the Yunusobod district, appeared to be associated with Oibek Tursunov, the husband of President Shavkat Mirziyoev's elder daughter, Saida. The company was established a month before the mayor's 2019 decision was announced.

Ansor Naberaev, officially listed as the owner of Urban Developers, has rejected any connection with Tursunov. He was not immediately available for comment on the court's January 27 ruling.

According to official registration and tax documents, 97 percent of Urban Developers' shares are owned by a company called Odoratus Business LLP, which is registered in the United Kingdom and operated by B2B Consultants Limited in the Central American country of Belize.

The company's assets are officially shown as having a value of 100 pounds ($130).

According to the documents, obtained by RFE/RL, Odoratus Business also co-owns shares of several other companies in Uzbekistan, including more than 60 percent of shares of the Milk House company, which is co-owned by the Pro Milk Technology company.

More than 95 percent of Pro Milk Technology's shares are controlled by Promadik Invest, which is owned by Tursunov.

Protesters gather during a rally in Sarajevo on May 30, 2020, to protest against the allegedly high level of corruption in the Bosnian government.
Protesters gather during a rally in Sarajevo on May 30, 2020, to protest against the allegedly high level of corruption in the Bosnian government.

Transparency International (TI) says in an annual report that the coronavirus pandemic has highlighted "widespread corruption" in countries across Eastern Europe and Central Asia, where it says "corrupt and authoritarian" leaders have reduced oversight of government spending and curtailed civil liberties.

Some political leaders in the region "used the crisis to increase their power, add restrictions to already limited access to information, eliminate transparency requirements from public procurement rules, and renounce public accountability mechanisms," the Berlin-based corruption watchdog said in its 2020 Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI), published on January 28.

As a result, the report added, transparency of foreign-aid spending has decreased, "making it difficult to track funds and ensure appropriate distribution to the intended recipients."

The CPI ranks 180 countries and territories by their perceived levels of public-sector corruption, based on 13 expert assessments and surveys of business executives. The lower the number on its 0-100 scale, the more corrupt a country is perceived to be.

TI said that countries performing well on the CPI "invest more in health care, are better able to provide universal health coverage, and are less likely to violate democratic norms and institutions or the rule of law."

But persistent corruption has undermined health-care systems in many countries and contributed to "democratic backsliding" amid the coronavirus pandemic.

"COVID-19 is not just a health and economic crisis. It is a corruption crisis. And one that we are currently failing to manage," TI Chairwoman Delia Ferreira Rubio said.

"The past year has tested governments like no other in memory, and those with higher levels of corruption have been less able to meet the challenge," Rubio said, adding that even countries at the top of the index "must urgently address their role in perpetuating corruption at home and abroad."

Denmark and New Zealand retained their places at the top of the CPI, followed by Singapore and seven Western and Northern European countries.

Eastern Europe and Central Asia remained the second-lowest performing regions in the ranking, with an average score of 36.

Georgia (56), Armenia (49), Belarus (47), and Montenegro (45) scored above the global average of 43, while Uzbekistan (26), Tajikistan (25), and Turkmenistan (19) ranked at the bottom of the region.

Belarus, where the authorities have cracked down on mass protests triggered by a contested presidential election in August, has jumped 16 points since 2012.

Corruption remains a problem in the country, where "the president's office has exercised authoritative power with little to no legislative or judicial checks and balances while the economy has mostly been controlled by the state," TI said.

Kyrgyzstan (31) jumped seven points since 2012, but the watchdog said that "widespread corruption and a lack of transparency and accountability have undermined an adequate response to COVID-19."

Bosnia-Herzegovina (35) dropped seven points over the same period, with the Balkan country experiencing "numerous violations" of human and labor rights during the pandemic, as well as "discrimination in economic aid distribution and alleged unlawful procurement of medical equipment."

Serbia (38), which earned its lowest score on the CPI in nine years, faced "serious rule-of law issues, continued democratic erosion, and efforts to silence critical voices."

TI cited several controversial steps taken by the government in response to COVID-19, including suspending parliament, implementing extensive curfews, and "inciting violence against protesters."

The government also "restricted access to information on the procurement of medical equipment, and retaliated against health-care workers who criticized its response to the public health crisis."

Kazakhstan also scored 38, Kosovo 36, North Macedonia 35, Moldova 34, and Ukraine 33.

Azerbaijan and Russia were ranked 129th, each with a score of 30.

With a score of 44, Bulgaria, Hungary, and Romania were well below the average regional score of 66 and remained the lowest performers from the Western Europe and European Union region.

Afghanistan (19) came last in RFE/RL's broadcast region despite jumping 11 points since 2012.

Afghanistan "instituted significant legal and institutional reforms and recently announced plans to establish a new anti-corruption commission," TI noted.

Pakistan ranked 124th with a score of 31, while Iran scored 25, putting the country in 149th place.

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG